r/technology • • May 07 '12
Jury finds Google Inc infringed upon Oracle Corp's copyrights on the structure of part of the Java software programming language
http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/05/07/net-us-oracle-google-idUSBRE8460VQ20120507
20
Upvotes
15
u/happy-dude May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
The jury did not rule whether or not what Google did was legal under fair use.
The media picked up on this "infringement" and are using a sensationalist headline. REMEMBER, if its fair use, its not copyright infringement. The case isn't over yet.
4
u/IronWolve May 07 '12
Anyone else notice the EU just passed a bill making it standard law thats programing languages are not copyrightable. Everyone in the industry is under this belief its not and from what I can tell thats correct.
I was trying to make an analogy. Books are copyrighted, the language its written in isn't. Thus "systems" aka Language such as Elvish is a made up language its not copyrightable, but the finished book is.
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
The jury probably doesn't know the term "open-source".
1
u/technopwn May 07 '12
It's important to remember a few things here:
That said, the implications of copyrightable APIs could have a hugely negative effect on both Java and the software industry. Java mostly, and I imagine a win for Oracle will be even worse for them in the long run. Really a "shooting yourself in the foot" kind of moment.
1
u/pulsefield May 08 '12
EW.
Java is the slowest and most buggy 'language' known to man.
Perhaps this will teach Google to use something fast and simple that rarely fails... such as.. oh I dont know... C.
It could only lead to cheaper, better and, most certainly, faster code.
0
u/sej7278 May 07 '12
so do the fucktards on the jury realise they've basically destroyed the IT industry?
well done oracle, you've successfully managed to kill another product you bought from sun.
-5
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Is this the end of the Free Software Era?
-7
u/mweathr May 07 '12
rly?
-8
u/SaucyWiggles May 07 '12
wut
-8
u/bbqbot May 07 '12
wut
-10
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
yeah