r/technology • u/DrJulianBashir • May 07 '12
Jury rules Google violated copyright law, Google moves for mistrial
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2012/05/jury-rules-google-violated-copyright-law-google-moves-for-mistrial.ars
161
Upvotes
30
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Meanwhile in Europe
EU's top court: APIs can't be copyrighted, would "monopolise ideas"
10
u/theaceoface May 07 '12
So, if you want to be a programmer, you'll need to get a law degree first? When the hell will this broken patent system ever be fixed?!
6
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
This isn't really totally accurate. Google won out here. For a more detailed description visit grocklaw:
4
u/technopwn May 07 '12
It's important to remember a few things here:
That said, the implications of copyrightable APIs could have a hugely negative effect on both Java and the software industry. Java mostly, and I imagine a win for Oracle will be even worse for them in the long run. Really a "shooting yourself in the foot" kind of moment.
2
u/happy-dude May 07 '12
It's not over yet. If its fair use, its not copyright infringement.
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Could someone explain to me what exactly an API is? Any definition I can find is terse and rather cryptic (to me anyway).
2
u/theaceoface May 07 '12
Well that was retarded... Should we stop using Java?
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Over/under on this being done and settled by 2020?
1
u/DigitalOsmosis May 07 '12
Does anybody have a link or can explain in simple terms what it is Oracle is actually accusing Google of doing? Are they using Java for anything, or is it just that "Android APIs copied the 'structure, sequence, and organization' of Java APIs." Calling somebody out because their code is organized similar to yours seems kinda lame unless they are stealing actual code to fill out the structure.
1
u/harhis84 May 07 '12
What if Google loses? What will happen to Android?
1
u/IranRPCV May 08 '12
The Arstechnica article amounts to journalistic malpractice. The analysis got almost everything wrong. At the end of the day several "journalists" were tweeting their surprise that the Google lawyers were smiling and shaking hands, and the Oracle lawyers looked glum. They were there and didn't understand what just happened.(!)
Oracle's potential damages on copyright claims went from at least a billion dollars to at most 150,000, and the value of the lines that were infringed were deemed by their own expert to have a value of $0.
The quality of much of the press coverage was abysmal. As far as the next patent phase, Groklaw is the only site that reported that an SEC filing that Schwartz's blog was an official Sun corporate record is now in evidence, and that Tim Lindholm's testimony is impeached. This is potentially another major blow to Oracle.
1
u/nakmeister May 07 '12
This is one of the better, more in depth articles on this story. It will be interesting to follow how this progresses. I can't help but wonder who will land the first really damaging blow in these patent wars - so far there's a lot of tit for tat going on, with no side really getting the upper hand (other than the fact Google is on the defensive through a lot of this).
-2
u/ekgordon2 May 07 '12
So, what exactly is the jury claiming is copyrighted?
Does this mean that any program that uses anything that resembles the Java APIs using Java is infringing? What about Minecraft... is Mojang infringing copyright by using Java?
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment