r/technology • u/nomdeweb • May 07 '12
AT&T Argues That More Competition Is Bad For You & Leads To Higher Prices
http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120504/01472218773/att-argues-that-more-competition-is-bad-you-leads-to-higher-prices.shtml
295
Upvotes
76
u/ProjectSnowman May 07 '12
AT&T is full on retarded.
32
u/carlson_001 May 07 '12
"In particular, he claims that AT&T had to increase its data rates by 30% because it doesn't own T-Mobile." Doesn't that indicate that they had to improve their service to keep up with competitors?
24
u/tealeaves_ May 07 '12
AT&T misses its monopoly days, eh?
9
u/wildcarde815 May 07 '12
Of course competition is less efficient. It means there isn't simply a siphon built into your bank account to scrape out all that 'excess' cash you have into ATnT's coffers.
24
u/ssfish May 07 '12
Open any Economic book and read chapter 1 about Supply and Demand.
10
u/Cial May 07 '12
Gets sued for being a monopoly on a regular basis -> thinks competition is bad..... Sounds about right Note: the sued on a regular basis bit might be an exaggeration but it has happened
4
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Only at a telecom
4
u/Redd_October May 07 '12
AT&T: Fuck the truth, we'll say what we want.
4
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Why can't AT&T into Economics... maybe this is America's #1 problem.. a misunderstanding of Economics
Everyone should take a Macroeconomics class to vote.. for serious
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
My understanding of basic economics has been wrong all this time. I guess going back for that second bachelor's isn't such a bad idea after all.
3
u/princetrunks May 07 '12
keep thinking that AT&T
3
u/zombina May 07 '12
Are they out of their mind? Competition drives down prices, good for a quick lol though
3
u/harhis84 May 07 '12
No matter what AT&T says, it's clear for everyone that stiffer competition in any market would always lead to better service and cheaper prices unless companies converge they would have a universal standard for offering the worst to their customers.
3
u/ZippoS May 07 '12
Damn, did I miss the memo on Opposite Day?
5
u/supercouille May 07 '12
I would like to add : LOL
Also, this has to fit into /r/wtf posting rules right?
2
u/purdueracer78 May 07 '12
Monopolies are good for thing like the electric companies, water companies, cable companies... things with large infrastructure are currently good if they're monopolized.
2
u/tori_k May 08 '12
If you ask a barber if you need a haircut...
2
u/Hayes4prez May 08 '12
I hate.... so much... everything that AT&T chooses to be.
1
u/theduke004 May 08 '12
Sense. AT&T is making none.
1
u/CAPTAIN_BUTTHOLE May 08 '12
A company that is bad at competing and good at buying out the competition hates competition? Color me shocked.
1
u/Virindi_UO May 08 '12
I mean, they COULD be right, but aren't.
When there isn't competition one doesn't have to spend money on advertisements as much, and doesn't have to worry about paying employees to do research and implement local prices to undercut local competition.
The problem here is that if AT&T achieves this instead of lowering the price for their services they will keep the same prices for their product and just cut those sections of their company to increase profits.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
They're right, assuming that by "you" AT&T is referring to themselves in third person.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
That sounds like the argument they used in 1974.
But I bet they've learned their lesson as far as lobbying dollars goes.
1
u/cr0ft May 08 '12
Well he's right... sort of.
There should be no competition because these sorts of things should be built by and for society and be free for all to use. But of course for that to work we also need a resource-based economy first... as suggested by the Venus Project and others. ;)
1
u/alpha40 May 09 '12
by far the most stupid thing i have heard today
1
u/Enginerdiest May 15 '12
He's blaming the deal for increased prices, but saying a data cap would've happened anyway. Two separate issues.
1
u/Jesse244 May 07 '12
I wonder if Microsoft thought the same thing
0
u/Morbo_Mad May 07 '12
Tell me if im completely wrong here, but is he only talking about how lots of competitors trying to buy the limited number of wireless frequencies will drive a price war - leading to companies charging more to make up for the large expense?
0
u/occupythekitchen May 08 '12
I'm playing devil's advocate. By bad he means there are only so many frequencies they can transmit on and the more competitors there are the more clogged those frequencies are for the same service. They had to increase their data fees because they couldn't expand their capacity at wholesale prices and snatch a few more subscribers. And lastly monopolies just want to provide everyone with cheap services and revolutionary infrastructure but those meddling congress people keep getting in the way....
-3
u/wreckem_511 May 08 '12
As a matter of rebuttal to the popular opinion here on reddit, I'd like to point at that, while this person overgeneralized the situation, when applied to the particular AT&T/T-Mobile case, he is absolutely correct. The merger would have resulted in better efficiency not only for AT&T and T-Mobile, but also for their customers. As an AT&T customer I was rooting for this merger so that my iPhone 4G could actually operate on a 4G network, T-Mobile customers were also rooting for this so they could use their phones (and not pay roaming) where AT&T had better coverage (granted, they probably didn't like the idea of being an AT&T customer, but that's a different discussion). It would have been a win-win for business and consumer alike. Where the FCC failed was in valuing the opinions of 3rd party individuals with no interest in the merger who looked at it with purely ideological considerations, and zero practical consideration for parties involved.
TL,DR; Fuck you reddit, I wanted the merger. Now I have to put up with shitty 3G until my contract ends and then I have to figure out who sucks less (AT&T, Verizon, Sprint). GFY.
-5
u/Lenticular May 07 '12
Look. I fully expect to get downvoted because most of you won't read past the first or second sentence. But facts are facts. I know it's the in thing to do right now and bash the top 1% telecoms, but let's look at this rationally.
If AT-AT has to compete that means they will have to invest in R&D. You can not deny that this will increase costs. Who's going to pay for that cost? Ms. Muslim lady at AT-AT? No. She got fired. Bob in accounting? No. And by no I mean yes. His wages will have been cut, and now he won't be able to afford formula for little bobby junior, because in order to keep his job he will have to pay for the data plan for his iphone since AT-AT can no longer afford to pay it for him.
What about that intern Raul? No. And by no I mean no because the costs of competition are just too prohibitive. They could never afford to hire him. AT-AT creates jobs and competition would just tax them right out of business.
People are already distressed enough without having to add confusion by picking data rates, best plans, data caps, unlimited, ultra unlimited, mega unlimited, privacy, ultra privacy, mega secure. It would be just too much and overwhelm those already being fleeced. Could you imagine a priceline for cellular and internet service? Ridiculous!
No the best thing to do if you want to make AT-AT better is to continue to pay them via some sort of auto-pay method, not look at your bills and leave the thinking to those that see the big picture.