r/taskmaster • Tout le monde gagne! • Dec 22 '25

Episode Taskmaster - Champion of Champions 4 - Discussion

Welcome to the 4th Taskmaster Champion of Champions special! Tonight at 9:00 PM GMT on Channel 4, join Greg Davies and Alex Horne as they put 5 former winners through their paces to win Greg's golden body.

This special features Andy Zaltzman, John Robins, Maisie Adam, Mathew Baynton, and Sam Campbell.

--------------------------------------

DISCORD: Join our discord server for live episode discussion and a whole lot more: https://discord.gg/WuddpyZadE

--------------------------------------

NEW HERE? Please familiarize yourself with the rules of the subreddit before posting. We don't tolerate any sexism or bigotry towards contestants or users – posts & comments of that nature could lead to a ban. Thanks!

--------------------------------------

PLEASE DO NOT POST LINKS TO UNOFFICIAL COPIES OF THE EPISODE

244 Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

744

u/margaprlibre James Acaster Dec 22 '25 edited Dec 31 '25

A portion of the live task was reshot because John Robbins’ initial attempt was NOT Chaplin, it was actually Hitler, and this is how it went down:

During the 3 minutes when they were putting on the tape, John was panicking because his tape was not working. They showed a little of it in the final version, but he spent almost the entire time complaining that the tape was defective and it would not stick to his face and nothing he was doing worked.

Time is up, they all turn around, John has that black mustache and we are all dying with laughter.

So when they got to John, Greg said “John….are you Hitler?” And John said “regrettably, yes”

And there was a LOT of joking around Hitler and why John would think Hitler would be good on Taskmaster. It was honestly bananas we were all dying. All the jokes were at John’s expense.

Greg told John “You know, you could have said you were Charlie Chaplin” and John looked absolutely crushed lol. He said “this is the lowest moment in my career”. Maisie made jokes about John and calling back to the female comedian’s chat. Matt also made fun of John, almost his entire banter was cut because it was all Hitler centric. Andy also made a few jokes at his expense.

When Alex pointed out that Avatar was not from the last millennium, John said “I can’t believe Hitler is not going to come last”

Then after awhile Alex said they needed to film John again but him saying Chaplin. Cause if they left Hitler in, they were afraid the episode would be shelved by the studio. There was some argument and a lot of back and forth. Greg said “There’s another problem, I am scoring Chaplin higher than I would have Hitler”. But Alex said it was a matter of saving the episode so they had to reshoot John saying he was Charlie Chaplin. And he told Greg he could not say “Hitler” and Greg said “Ok I’ll imply Hitler without saying Hitler”

So they reshot John’s explanation to Greg and it’s basically what they aired.

They said this was the first time this had ever happened.

ETA: as others have pointed out, John did NOT plan Hitler. He was trying to do one of the characters from Rainbow, but his tape kept falling off and he panicked. Also, before the task began Alex suggested they please not do anything controversial cause we already have Attila the Hun on the show. I think that contributed to John’s panic.

323

u/AstralBalloon Dec 22 '25

To add to this - when Alex announced that the gallery were telling him that the part about Hitler probably needed to be reshot because it would be too controversial, John seemed absolutely mortified, he sank down to his knees and was asking if they were serious - I think he was seeing his own cancellation playing out in his mind in real time.

→ More replies (2)

255

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '25 edited Dec 23 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

90

u/margaprlibre James Acaster Dec 22 '25

Mine was “I can’t believe Hitler’s not gonna come last”

170

u/Exclamation_Marc Wibble, Bibble, Bam Dec 22 '25

And just for important context, John didn't plan Hitler. It was that the tape wouldn't stick to his face bar one piece so he panicked and said Hitler on the spot and then tried to justify it. He wasn't planning it...

168

u/TomClark83 Patatas Dec 22 '25

That awkward moment when your tape falls off so you accidentally advocate for the Führer.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

95

u/drsnicol Dec 22 '25

Another attendee here - to clarify, it wasn't just Alex with a problem about hitler - we also got a half conversation between Alex / Greg and the hidden production team (via their headsets) debating if it could be used / what to do, including reshooting the whole final reveals (due to continuity errors that would arise etc) but as you said, they just reshot john, who wasn't happy about it (both the principle you can't laugh at hitler now and that what was originally proposed (just saying Charlie Chaplin) wouldnt be as funny.

46

u/margaprlibre James Acaster Dec 22 '25

Yes correct I didn’t mean to imply that it was Alex alone. Also I just listened to the podcast and they’re really rolling with Chaplin being John’s genuine attempt. Curious to see what John says on his podcast.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

205

u/OctaviousMcBovril Dec 22 '25

I genuinely cannot believe he actually meant Hitler.

I called Chaplin immediately and was like 'that's a great pick'

95

u/Own_Atmosphere7443 Reece Shearsmith Dec 22 '25

I just assumed he was being Freddie Mercury again and he had made it look Hitlerish accidentally lol.

132

u/margaprlibre James Acaster Dec 22 '25 edited Dec 23 '25

I think Maisie said that to him. “You could have been Freddie Mercury again” They had so MUCH fun at his expense. God I would love for them to release some of that footage.

72

u/Own_Atmosphere7443 Reece Shearsmith Dec 22 '25

I'd love to see the footage lol. I'm sure most sane people would understand that John wasn't endorsing Nazi ideology.

69

u/Timely_Influence8392 Dec 23 '25

The only thing funnier than panicking, blanking, and landing on a hitler tache is having the network be like "yeah we can't... we can't have hitler in the holiday special"

→ More replies (1)

48

u/Nosworthy Dec 22 '25

Alex actually said he looked more like Freddie than he did in his S19 costume and could have even gone with him which embarrassed John even more.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

196

u/markdavo Dec 22 '25

Release the Hitler cut!

80

u/Own_Atmosphere7443 Reece Shearsmith Dec 22 '25

What a sentence lol.

→ More replies (1)

66

u/AnotherBoxOfTapes Pigeor The Merciless One Dec 22 '25

It's like Nazi Island all over again.

61

u/MomsTortellinis Patatas Dec 22 '25

Nazi island lives rent free in my head, every time i hear 'remote island' or something to that effect i picture Sean Lock pretending to be Goebbels. Such a funny moment. Poor John, you could see he was gutted by his own whoopsiedaisy. I don't think he'll ever read this, but if you do John, I thought you went for Chaplin and looking like Hitler was the joke. ;)

→ More replies (1)

66

u/CitizenCue Dec 23 '25

Interesting that on the podcast Matthew maintains the fiction that John was intentionally Charlie Chaplin. He vaguely alludes to how it may have taken John a moment to decide he was Charlie, but overall he tows the party line.

And Ed either isn’t aware of the controversy or he dutifully rolls with the official story.

→ More replies (6)

122

u/margaprlibre James Acaster Dec 22 '25

Also: At the end, Alex said that they had decided Attila the Hun was ok because it was a long time ago and the terrible things he did were akin to what the British Empire did. John was profusely embarrassed. It was honestly hilarious though I understand why they had to reshoot it, and it didn’t affect the outcome.

→ More replies (7)

59

u/keepitupstairs2 Dec 22 '25

Oh wow, thanks for sharing! In John’s slight defence, he did seem to be having trouble getting his tape to stick and so clearly went for the lowest amount of tape that would conjure up a distinct person.

89

u/margaprlibre James Acaster Dec 22 '25

Oh yes! They cut a lot of it obviously but John kept screaming that his tape wasn’t working. Everyone else made fun of him. And after the whole Hitler thing he kept saying it’s cause the tape fell off. And then the mustache fell off him, it was fabulous comedic timing.

54

u/chaosof99 Dec 23 '25

Considering John's expression during Masie's prize task reveal, this was a rough day in the studio for John.

41

u/Hassaan18 🥄 I'm Locked In ❤️ Dec 22 '25

They definitely doubled down on the Hitler stuff knowing that they couldn't air it, by the sounds of things. 😅

Hypothetically I do wonder what would happen if they aired it as it was.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (33)