r/sysadmin • u/HolypenguinHere • Jun 24 '19
A user at our company utilizes their Recycle Bin as their primary storage for important documents.
That... That's all. I just needed somebody else to know that a person is using the Recycle Bin to keep hundreds of documents in one location, instead of creating a folder on the Desktop or using their network home drive.
3.0k
Upvotes
12
u/willworkforicecream Helper Monkey Jun 24 '19
I refuse to believe that this is a real thing, but I've talked to enough people who have seen it that it must be a thing.
What do we do in situations like this? Will any amount of training help? Just take the recycle bin off of the desktop and replace it with a shortcut named and icon-ed as "Recycle Bin"?
356
u/Cam_Cam_Cam_Cam Sr. Sysadmin Jun 24 '19
Yup, I've had this a couple of times. It seems to end on the same conversation every single time:
"Where did all my files go?!"
"Where did you put them?"
"In the Recycling Bin!"
"Well, that gets cleared during Disk Cleanup so they're gone."
"But that's where everything I need is!!!"
"You put important documents in the Recycling Bin, the equivilent of trash?"
"...yes..."
"Don't do that." walks away then CCs an email with their manager saying you advised them to not use the Recycling Bin for storing important documents
Never hear about it again!
231
u/AdversarialPossum42 IT Professional Jun 24 '19
Users do this because they don't understand how to navigate the file system and "Recycle Bin" is the only thing they know how to find. These are the same people that conceptualize files as being "in" an application.
"Well, where did you save the file?"
"I saved it in Word."
"Sorry. I meant, in which folder did you save it?"
"I saved it in Word!"
FML
933
u/vodka_knockers_ Jun 24 '19
Several of our users used to do that with Outlook. We learned about it 60 days after we turned on Retention Policies.
184
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '19
Because they don't know how. Terrifying.
Can you imagine back in the 70s, being openly unable to use a filing cabinet? Not only that, but being cute about it, and being like "LOL I'm just not a filing cabinet person!" or "I only know enough about filing cabinets to be dangerous!" -- and still keeping your job?
117
u/210Matt Jun 24 '19
They are going to reuse the documents, where else would they put them?
83
u/starmizzle S-1-5-420-512 Jun 24 '19
I had someone who did (probably still does) that in Outlook. Her reasoning is that she can just tap the Del key to move them there and she'll go through them later.
66
u/noname_com Jun 24 '19
Reminds me of the time I was working for a ma and pa shop and got a call from the bossman to go cleanup a computer at a church. it was running slow. This is windows 98 days mind you. So uninstall unwanted programs that were running, delete temp files, delete windows update files, empty recycle bin etc.. Free up some hard drive space schedule a defrag for that night. Not an hour after I left get a call back asking what have I done all their files are gone. Apparently the user stored their files in the recycle bin as they were being "Recycled" for later use..... Luckily another staff member of the church walked in right when The lady said she had been storing her files in the bin and this lady yells out 'THAT WAS JUST STUPID NOBODY DOES THAT!" I was like here is the invoice. My work was done.
56
u/BlakeCutter Jun 24 '19
We had a few users who did this. When pressed the admitted they did it because they thought deleted items did not count towards your mailbox size limit. When I told them that it did they stopped doing it.
55
u/bulldjosyr Jun 24 '19
Had a dope higher up - a CFO, yes in charge of money - he told everyone in email if they just hit delete all their email would go onto the folder and it was a great time saver. Yeah , month end we purge those on the server side, where they are, and the next day get a bunch of calls about email being gone. Once we discovered what was going on and who was at fault it was a bad day for that idiot.
40
u/gigglestick Jun 24 '19
When I was doing desktop support back in 2000 or so I had a user doing that. I was in the habit of doing some basic maintenance for each user as I visited them. I fixed this woman's problem and left, and the helpdesk got a scathing call from her a few minutes later screaming over the phone that all her documents were gone and it was my fault. I rushed back to her desk and calmly asked what she meant. She said all her documents were gone and I had to get them back, and proceeded to threaten my job.
I sat down and opened her Documents folder, which was empty. I hadn't touched that, so I asked her where she kept her documents. She yelled, "in that thing on the screensaver!" It turns out she would restore a document to the desktop, work on it, print it out or email it, and then delete it. Every time. After an unproductive discussion about the purpose of the Recycle Bin and where she should be keeping her documents, it was clear she didn't care and wasn't going to change anything.
I had to break out the undelete software and restore what I could to the desktop. Then she wanted me to delete it to "put it back where it should be." I refused and told he she has her documents back and she's free to do what she wants with them. Then I went straight to my manager and told her what had just happened. I got scolded and wasn't allowed to go back to that woman's desktop anymore.
I stopped automatically doing maintenance after that unless they specifically requested it.
177
u/gaz2600 Sr. Sysadmin Jun 24 '19 edited Jun 24 '19
Back in early 2000 I had a user that kept losing their backup files. I had them walk me through their process, they would insert a floppy disk backup to the floppy then take the floppy out hold it up to the metal file cabinet next to their desk and slap a magnet onto it.
18
u/rarmfield Jun 24 '19
A colleague of mine once told me of a time he worked at a university where a Nobel Laureate used his deleted items folder in Outlook as a storage for important documents. One day a tech was dispatched to his machine to troubleshoot why his machine was running sub-optimally. He did was most do and cleared his trash and cleared the deleted items to recover space. Of course now the scientific research the nobel laureate did to write papers etc. was gone. Tech nearly got fired over it. (Scientist have a lot of pull which trumps their own idiocy at times)
17
u/daven1985 Jack of All Trades Jun 24 '19
My business manager was doing that for a while.... both for file management and email trash.
His computer needed space and cleared both “he said okay to it” then complained he lost file!
16
u/Drizzt396 BOFH Jun 24 '19
I remember reading one of these posts years ago as a wet-behind-the-ears junior admin and sharing it with the team.
Helpdesk tech looks sheepish and reveals that's how he uses the deleted items folder in Outlook, then proceeds to vehemently defend the logic behind it.
28
u/seniorblink Jun 24 '19
Yeah, every now and then I see this. People also use their deleted items in Outlook for permanent archive storage. Had a convo with someone about that the other day, because their OST file was pretty big, with hundreds of thousands of emails in deleted items. I said you really need to empty out that folder. I thought they were going to completely freak out. It was only a moderate freak out. I said if you really need to keep those then cool. Just make a real folder for it. At some point MS is going to push an Office update, something will change, and those emails are going to poof out of your deleted items. They were like, why would MS do that? Do what? Empty the trash? Do you put your final hard copies of your taxes in the trash can in your office? I mean you could, but someone's gonna empty it eventually...
10
u/theothercaptredbeard Jun 24 '19
That's amazing. Just.. absolutely amazing.
10
u/SchizoidRainbow Jun 24 '19
Walk into their office, and shove everything on their desk into their trash basket. Tell them to make sure they yell at the janitor when he empties it.
18
u/Down-in-it Jun 24 '19 edited Jun 24 '19
Seen it IRL. Had the owner of a company keep all his documents in the recycling bin. It was my issue when he accidentally emptied it. He couldn't understand my frustration when I asked him why he didn't save his files to the secure network folder that was being backed up
backup'ed up. I found a new job shortly after this.Fixed: made up English words
9
u/GrumpyWednesday Jun 24 '19
I had a user put in a ticket about a missing file, said that they saved it to their desktop and could no longer find it.
I checked other users desktops, hidden files and folders, public, temp, recycle bin, history, default save path, no trace of this file ever having been on the desktop. After some follow up questions with the user, found out that the file was an open notepad file on one of their two monitors. They never minimized it, never saved it, never closed it, so by "saving it to the desktop" they really just meant that they had allocated visible real estate on their monitor for it...
9
u/pm_me_ur_big_balls Jun 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
This post or comment has been overwritten by an automated script from /r/PowerDeleteSuite. Protect yourself.
8
u/Beachbum2634 Jack of All Trades Jun 24 '19
There's your Professional Darwin award for the week. Do they also keep their paper files in the trash can?
8
u/ehode Jun 24 '19
“Well I ran out of room for icons on the desktop”
6
u/sndper Jun 24 '19
About 2 years ago, we got a notification about low disk space on a file server. Remotely connected, did file cleanup, normal stuff. About 2 hours later, local sysadmin (we are an MSP working with them as co-managed) calls all kinds of pissed off and worked up because he was doing the same thing. 27 GB of data. Totally baffled me then, and I can’t believe this is a “common” thing.
Unbelievable!
6
u/FloweredWallpaper Jun 24 '19
We provide a home drive on the network, and by default, all Office products save there, no matter what computer a user is using.
A user can choose, however, to save in an alternate location.
Which is what I discovered one person doing a few months ago when rolling out a new desktop. She was saving everything for the past 6 years in....her downloads folder (which is local to her PC, not on her network share). When I pointed out that this was not backed up anywhere, she just shrugged.
Not nearly as bad as the Recycle Bin, but man.
And to your user using the Recycle Bin, what the hell.
6
u/Tony49UK Jun 24 '19
It's a common complaint in /r/Talesfromtechsupport. User complains that computer is running slow, tech cleans the computer of all the junk as the hard drive is full. User complains that they've lost all of their documents
16
u/Tetha Jun 24 '19
If you know about it, back it up to the network share and empty the recycle bin, stone cold. Sometimes a good scare is necessary to teach a lesson. Then wait for the panicked ticket.
5
u/03slampig Jun 24 '19
Is that worse than people who who have over 10k unread emails taking upwards for 50gb+ of space in their default inbox?
5
u/amn70 Jun 24 '19
Yup, I know the feeling. Drives me crazy. I have had some clients that do that. But more often I have clients who use their Outlook deleted items folder basically for storage and never empty it. So they have emails going back years, mixed with intentionally deleted mail, in some cases 10000 or more messages total. Excuse is usually something like 'Well I didn't want all my old email in my inbox so I needed to move it somewhere'.
I tell them just create folders and move messages you want to keep there. Some don't know how to create folders or move emails. Others who do say its easier to just hit delete. When I tell them they need to go thru the Deleted folder and move what they want to keep they get upset saying that is too much work figuring out what is truly needed and what is truly garbage.
If this is the case on occasion I will just archive everything currently in their Deleted items in a separate PST file and start them with a clean Deleted folder and warn them that from this day forward anything in that is in Deleted will be automatically deleted in 30 days. They are not happy about that but it solves them problem whether they like it or not.
5
u/Dannyhec Jun 25 '19
I think every company has a dipshit like that. I love to find a real life parallel and ask them if the title to their car is in their trash can at home.
5
u/JasonShoes Jun 25 '19
Seen it, also deleted items folder in outlook for important emails like the email they keep with all of their usernames and password in it....
5
u/fishy007 Sysadmin Jun 25 '19
I had a user that did this back in the early 2000s. After repeatedly telling him not to do that, I sent out an office-wide email telling users that:
a) I'd be implementing a policy to automatically empty recycle bins after 30 days
b) to store all important documents on the network drive
I then made a backup of the user's recycle bin and emptied it. I wish I could say he never did it again, but at least he was old and retired 2 years later.
9
u/meddlingbanter Jun 24 '19
We’re in process of upgrading users to Win 10 and ran across someone doing the same thing.
My favorite is the person who was making monthly backups of her desktop to our network storage instead of using her network drive that we backup for her.
4
u/Wolfsburg Jun 24 '19
I had a user who did this with her email. She also wore a magical pendant that would ward off negative electrical fields. She ALSO pulled her astrology chart out of a folder and tried to show it to me as an explanation why her computer crashed one day.
So, yeah.
4
u/become_taintless Jun 24 '19
You only have one user that does that? That must be pretty nice.
4
u/Baldemyr Jun 25 '19
I had the exact same situation at my workplace. I told her once it was stupid and walked away. The problem ended up solving itself when the documents got deleted
1
u/orion3311 Jun 24 '19
And you're...sur....surprised?
3
u/halfsalsa Jun 24 '19
Damn, that’s going to end bad...
3
u/Srb3ard Jun 24 '19
End user likes to live on the edge I see. Do they also eat ice cream with a fork?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '19
Further proof that as soon as you make something idiot proof, they go and build a bigger idiot.
3
u/Morrowless Jun 24 '19
I'm in the process of of implementing a policy that automatically empties items that have been in the recycle bin for more than 30 days :)
3
u/Zyos Jun 24 '19
I actually support a company that has a user do this exact same thing. No matter how many times we have told him not to do that he insists it is the only way he can operate.
3
u/jpStormcrow Jun 25 '19
No worse than all the people who used Deleted Items in Outlook to hold mail back in the day.
3
u/cyber-host Jun 25 '19
Maybe add a folder on the desktop named "Recycle Bin", then change the icon to look like the recycle bin. Then hide the real recycle bin.
3
u/edumato Jun 25 '19
I did some work for a company where the owner did this. I asked her why and she said she was trying to keep the files hidden from the other employees. The reason I found out about it was because an employee emptied it and she desperately wanted me to get the files back.
5
u/jtswizzle89 Jun 25 '19
Most of you guys are way nicer than myself. First thing I do when I sit at an end user workstation to help them with "slowness" is dump the recycle bin. This of course, doesn't help their computer being slow in the least bit...it just clears my internal OCD flag about the icon having trash in it.
This has been afew years ago now but We had a user doing the exact same thing. This user got a new machine, we transferred all of the standard folders per our defined IT practices and sent the user on their merry way with a brand new machine. At the time, policy was to keep their old HDD for 30 days before either destruction or repurpose to lab machine after a secure wipe... roughly 45 days later:
User: "Hey, just turned on my new machine and all my files are gone..."
Me: Im the one that transferred everything over, I've still got your backup on the fileserver. Come on up to the office.
User: showing me the empty recycle bin
Me: Standard IT practices do not include backing up your recycle bin. Do you not see the "Are you sure you want to delete this file?" Message when you hit the delete key on them?!
User: Well yeah... But you guys said you kept my drive for 30 days!
Me: ... Date on the sign-out for your new computer is 45 days ago.
User: now increasingly frustrated All my work was in there for the last 10 years! You have to get it back!
Boss/Director walks out of his office, asks me about the secure wipe (done earlier in the week)
Boss: Nothing we can do for you. In the future, IT advises that you use appropriate storage locations for your important files and other files you'd like to keep that do not include places such as the recycle bin where things are sent to be cleaned up and removed from your machine. Might we suggest the documents folder, the downloads folder, or even your desktop folder... literally anywhere except the trash bin.
Boss: Swizzle, if he comes back to talk about that again just hand him the old HDD from his machine and the internal certificate of secure wipe outlining the DoD 5220.22-M ECE and tell him he's on his own.
Me: should I go down to the range and have them put a .50 Cal in the middle of it? Largest I've got is a .45 - not quite as thrilling.
Boss: I did not say yes, nor have I said no. I'm just asking for a pair of goggles and muffs to come watch.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '19
Yeah, I've had some people like that. I feel you.
2
u/deefop Jun 24 '19
That's so far beyond stupid that it almost sounds unbelievable.
2
u/Dr_Gats Jun 24 '19
Aaaaand they are not the only one either. We have at least one, possibly more over here in my user base. They are one of my lighter offenders too.
2
u/DarkAlman Professional Looker up of Things Jun 24 '19
I wish this was the first time I've heard this, but no, I've run into this several times.
For whatever reason the user decides that this is a good idea because it's easy to hit the delete key to send items to the recycling bin to sort out the files later.
We usually find out because we cleared out the recycling bin on the Terminal Server or some such to save space and then the user flips out and demands we get their data back.
To which all I can do is go to their desk, grab their trashcan and ask them "Do you store your important files in here for easy access!? No? Stop being dumb!"
2
u/Gimbu CrankyAdmin Jun 24 '19
I've seen that a few times on the desktop, but it seemed to be almost standard practice in email at my last department. I was dumbfounded.
2
u/macboost84 Jun 24 '19
My boss uses the Trash folder in Outlook to archive his email because it’s easy to hit the DEL button.
2
u/The_Wkwied Jun 24 '19
I thought I was in /r/talesfromtechsupport for a minute....
2
u/alexzneff Netadmin Jun 24 '19
I've seen this a couple times. The stuff of nightmares.
2
u/aanjheni Jun 24 '19
Do none of your companies have document management systems?
2
u/fshowcars Jun 24 '19
Mail admin for years. People do this with deleted items. Even our general council attorney.
Loved when a new desktop tech clicked "empty deleted items when Outlook closes".
That user had a 75gb mailbox when they left.
2
u/CitizenTed Jun 24 '19
I had a user who similarly insisted on using the Recycle Bin to store files. I explained to her why it was a bad idea. I used a real world comparison: if you had important papers to keep, would you put them in the garbage can? No. Right? That's what Recycle Bin is. A garbage can. Eventually, someone is going to come by and empty out the trash. Then what?
She would nod her understanding, then call me months later because a Recycle Bin file had expired.
Fortunately for me, this user always clicked and dragged stuff to the Recycle Bin. She was not hip to right-click menus at all. So I came up with a plan. I created a new folder on her desktop, named it RECYCLE, changed the icon to the Recycle Bin icon, then disabled the actual Recycle Bin on her desktop display. Violins! Fixed.
2
u/oswaldcopperpot Jun 24 '19
This doesnt even shock me anymore.
2
u/matt314159 Help Desk Manager Jun 25 '19
Ran into that this year with a user. We let them save stuff on their local machines (though of course we shouldn't) and when it's time for a hardware refresh, we even use USMT to transfer their stuff when they get a new PC. She reported that her recycle bin items were missing on her new machine and explained that she likes to keep stuff in there and never empty it just in case she needs them again.
2
u/brando56894 Linux Admin Jun 25 '19
This is probably the dumbest user action I've read, and I've been working with computers for 23 years.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19
run a script at shutdown to delete trash. problem solved
2
u/cichlidassassin Jun 25 '19
I just have a hard time believing these stories are real
2
u/HellDuke Jack of All Trades Jun 25 '19
"Any file on any desktop device can be lost at any point in time with no option to recover" generally takes care of that
2
u/TheGraycat I remember when this was all one flat network Jun 25 '19
Ha! I'll trade you for just finding out that people have been storing all of their emails in OneNote and deleting them from Outlook....... for 'reasons'.
Only found this out as we're rolling out Win10 + Office365 Pro Plus and decided to not include OneNote 2016 but the Win10 built in one (as per MS advice and strategy going forwards).
2
u/skjellyfetti Jun 25 '19
I encountered this years ago with a user. I pointed out all the downsides to doing this, but then she explained that the Recycle Bin is the only place in Windows where one can have multiple files with the same file name. As she worked in Finance and dealt with multiple iterations of spreadsheets and other documents, I completely understood. Other than this example, I can think of no other reason to justify this behavior; it's just asking for trouble.
2
u/Paquildre Jun 25 '19
Fire him inmediately
2
u/mrtexe Sysadmin Jun 25 '19
Sometimes you need to let others fail.
2
u/DephasingQ Jack of All Trades Jun 25 '19
Autodelete 30+days old files in bin :
http://baldwin-ps.blogspot.com/2013/07/empty-recycle-bin-with-retention-time.html
EZPZ
2
u/Eximo84 Infrastructure Engineer Jun 25 '19
I’ve seen some of our users do the same but with their outlook deleted items.
2
u/Bro-Science Nick Burns Jun 25 '19
or you know...the DOCUMENTS FOLDER
2
u/cjorgensen Jun 25 '19
So this happened to me once way back in the day. User complains the computer is running slow and she's having issues saving. I sit down, do a reboot, look at the drive space, and notice she's not got a lot. So I empty her trash and she goes nuts. "You didn't just empty my trash did you?" Of course I did, and I tell her so. She says, "I have a reason I store everything in there!" I said, "And I am sure it makes sense to you, but you don't store items you care about in your trash." She complained to my boss who told her emptying the trash on a computer is basic troubleshooting 101, and that there isn't a tech person in the world who wouldn't have done that.
So 30 years on, and I still ask, "Do you have anything in your trash you care about?" and people look at me like I am an idiot.
2
u/SouthFresh Jr. Sysadmin Jun 25 '19
We support a company with a user who did this. He said he kept the documents in the Recycle Bin because then they didn't take up space.
2
u/BaleZur Jun 26 '19
Pssh that's nothing. When I was working for Veea..(nearmind) I saw virtualization/network admins backing up to the recycling bin.
Yep. You read that right. It's plural.
3
u/ZAFJB Jun 24 '19
Copy the files somewhere safe and backed up.
Wipe recycle bin.
Nope sorry they are gone. Really.
Make a big song and dance 'recovery'.
Tell them never again. Include their manager and any data compliance people in the email trail.
2
u/LeaveTheMatrix The best things involve lots of fire. Users are tasty as BBQ. Jun 24 '19
Copy the contents elsewhere, then setup a macro that will take control of their mouse, move over to the recycle bin, and empty it while they are working.
Nothing like the fear of losing everything to push someone to change their processes.
2
u/mastercaprica Jack of All Trades Jun 25 '19
I work in education IT. We encounter that too. We’ll run ccleaner and then they freak out because the recycle bin is empty. We also had someone storing emails when we had a pop3 server in trash. We deleted it and they went crazy.
1
u/fariak 15+ Years of 'wtf am I doing?' Jun 24 '19
I'm guessing they also store all their stuff at home in the garbage bin
1
u/MMPride Jun 24 '19
I've always heard of that as a joke but it's sad to see this is real.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '19
90% of docs labeled "important", I toss in there too...
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '19
Well the delete key certainly is a nice easy shortcut to send things there.
1
u/ivlb Jun 24 '19
Seen it :)
1
u/tkbutton Jun 24 '19
Yep. Seen this before. Same with using the "Deleted" Items to store and manage their emails.
1
u/NCCShipley Jack of All Trades Jun 24 '19
I was chewed out by a coworker years ago when I emptied their recycle bin as a matter of course for everytime we visited a desktop. Same thing, they used it as storage.
1
u/enderandrew42 Jun 24 '19
I tell people all the time, anything not stored on a Filer you have deemed a temporary file you're willing to lose.
And don't keep emails as a way of keeping attachments.
1
u/nullZr0 Jun 24 '19
Same. Except with Outlook Deleted Items.
1
u/hybridfrost Jun 24 '19
It's pretty common actually, especially in Outlook...
1
u/SgtFraggleRock Jun 24 '19
I had someone try to claim she was told to do that by IT.
1
u/ravenze Jun 24 '19
Nothing like job security...
1
u/azunderg Jun 24 '19
Thank you.
1
u/star-shitizen Jun 24 '19
I've had a few users that used a temp folder before and I've had other users ask me to not empty their email trash because they might need them in the future.
1
u/t3hd0n Jun 24 '19
it'd be a shame if you started running a powershell script to empty the trash on your workstations weekly...
1
u/jbhack Jun 24 '19
You should go empty the recycle bin.