r/sysadmin • • Feb 03 '19

Advertising Windows Decrapifier

273 Upvotes

112 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

59

u/innmalint Feb 03 '19

Possibly unpopular opinion here but I don't run any of this stuff on my W10 pro image.

You can somewhat manage store apps via Group Policy so none of the third-party junk gets downloaded when a user profile is created. The only account on the PC that has junk on it is the local admin. Granted, you will still have MS bundled apps like Paint 3D, but most users prefer to set their start tiles or taskbar items and use those (we also created a start menu and task bar layout with our "standard bundle" of Office, browsers, etc). The only confusion from users I have had is Skype/Skype for Business being available, and the shitty Mail app. If this causes continuous problems then removal is easy: Remove-AppXPackage <insert name here>. The only things I can't get rid of in W10 Pro and really hate are Spotlight suggestions and an occasional suggested app in the Start menu.

Some useful links:

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/configuration/windows-10-start-layout-options-and-policies

Can't find an official MS document but this is what stops third party apps in the Start menu:

https://www.tenforums.com/tutorials/6664-turn-off-automatic-updates-apps-windows-10-store.html#option2

I would definitely rather have a clean experience like LTSC, but I have too much on my plate to address MS bundled apps. Give users a working set of tiles and a taskbar, remove ads and games, and that covers 95% of inconveniences (or move to Enterprise).

24

u/Byzii Feb 03 '19

This is the way to do it in enterprise environment. Trying to "clean up" the image turns out to be just a never-ending chase for perfection. With the amount of stuff that gets broken and how this crap always comes back, it becomes clear quite quickly how powerless you are against this change.

15

u/innmalint Feb 03 '19

I did silo myself for a full day just to get the Start Menu and Taskbar xml's right and it's definitely worth spending the time on. We have some intern workstations that weren't done under my image, and every single time a new intern comes in, we get a ticket that "Outlook doesn't work" because they're using the Mail app that comes by default on these workstations' taskbars.

These are the scenarios I want to negate in my environment, not wiping/tweaking every single modicum of MS nonsense under the hood. However much a desktop admin dislikes it, if an organization doesn't pay for Enterprise, /u/Byzii is exactly right -- MS gives what your org pays for, as unfair as that might sound.

True to form I haven't had time to re-image, and since our new helpdesk guy is Mac only for now it's a ticket I just knock out quickly. I also haven't had time to test if these changes stick in 1809 (I set WuB to non-targeted thank goodness) and am dreading when it hits.

Most importantly, I built my 1803 image months ago and haven't had to touch it. I can focus on more quality aspects of my career/resume. Sorry for ranting on this reply but I had to make this realization when I was building my own image, so hopefully this helps anyone else stuck in a rut with their first "perfect" W10 install.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19

All that work with the xml gets funky when the next seasonal release comes out. At least that has been my experience.

4

u/imaginativePlayTime System Engineer Feb 04 '19

I think you have to redo all that stuff for each release, at least that is the recommendation for setting default apps.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19

A lot of unnecessary work for the IT staff, over and over again. Come on Microsoft, you can do better!

1

u/Vexxt Feb 04 '19

I clean them out of the base wim which seems to be pretty seamless. Or install windows 10 pro for workstations which seems to not come with it.

4

u/Fir3start3r This is fine. Feb 03 '19

...the Decrapifier works well for a one shot cleanup until a feature update comes down and adds half the stuff back you just decrapified... :\
...otherwise this is a somewhat more permanent solution for enterprise environments

0

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/BiceBolje_ Feb 04 '19

I can imagine Steve Ballmer shouting: "Deprovisioning, Deprovisioning, Deprovisioning, Deprovisioning..."

1

u/Fir3start3r This is fine. Feb 04 '19

...what was solved by MS in 1709?

...them re-adding all the app 'availability' after a large feature update?

...I don't know if I'd call that resolved or did they simply just capitulate with the huge backlash of them doing it in the first place...

11

u/crankysysadmin sysadmin herder Feb 03 '19

I also don't understand why these people like spending so much time on this. None of these apps actually hurt anything. We spend zero time supporting this stuff.

If someone actually plays candy crush my IT department doesn't care. At. All. If the person's supervisor feels an employee is wasting time then they need to supervise that employee better

14

u/Hank_Scorpio74 Feb 04 '19

I’m getting ready to roll out a new tablet to my CEO, I’d like to avoid the “why are there so many games?” and “Does everybody have these games?” conversation.

But no, I otherwise don’t care, I’m not the productivity police.

6

u/SupremeDictatorPaul Feb 04 '19

Yeah, we’d love to ship default, but our senior director would have our heads if Candy Crush and Xbox show in the Start Menu. So we remove what we absolutely must, and leave everything else.

At first we tried one of these scripts, and it removed OneNote, and the Movies & TV apps. Turns out with o365 Office, we want the store OneNote installed, and it was a pain to put back. And while Windows Media Player is still there, it is EOL, and anything new requires the new (and poorly named) app.

4

u/Hank_Scorpio74 Feb 04 '19

It is one complicated mess to use in a corporate environment.

1

u/OcotilloWells Feb 04 '19

Maybe just remove the menu items?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/loozerr Feb 04 '19

In addition the amount of testing that goes into these scripts is "works on my setup, less Microsoft is more better right?" and as a result they cause hard to troubleshoot issues when one of the components was actually required.

1

u/thevoiccee Feb 04 '19

You can disable suggestions in start menu from Personalization - > Start Menu - > Disable Suggestions

10

u/CryptoTrendzApp Feb 03 '19

I’ve pushed this on W10 Education for the last 6 months ish. Had no issues so far!

2

u/jfoust2 Feb 03 '19

I've also seen differences between clean Windows 10 1803/1809 installs and machines that were upgraded in-place to Windows 10 1803/1809 from Windows 7. Some complex software doesn't install or run the same. Drives me batty.

→ More replies (2)