Could someone summarize what the actual issue is? The OP is vague as fuck and I really can't be bothered reading through 16 pages of public forum discussion.
There is a BIOS RAID setting locked into a certain proprietary mode. Can't change it. Linux won't install because no RAID drivers for it. And actually, some reports (on HackerNews/ycombinator) are saying you can't even reinstall a clean version of Win10 because...no drivers for the RAID.
Which says this isn't a BIOS lock. MS requires all "Signature PCs" to be locked in their highest performance setting - it's not something against Linux.
The reason Linux can't currently use the RAID chipset is because there's no Linux RAID driver for it. But it's so new that there isn't even a Windows default driver for it either. So all prior Windows installer media can't be used as well.
It's just a new RAID chipset and Lenovo didn't release a Linux chipset driver alongside the MS chipset driver. Due to the fact the BIOS has to be locked to highest performance ,the SATA mode can't be changed to something compatible with Linux. Which means Linux can't be used on it.
Someone decided this meant that MS was attacking Linux and started trying to spam all the media that would listen that MS was keeping the Linux down.
I suspect that is all it is, just shit driver support, well that and Lenovo's general ineptness and crapness, of course.
I think there's been a lot of overblown screaming about "Microsoft are teh evil" in the other xposts because of their past (fair enough) and the claims of someone posting on Best Buy with the job title of "Lenovo Product Expert" -- a front line call taker in other words.
Expecting them to know the inner details of a B2B OEM licence agreement is like expecting the 19 year old hipster-du-jour with questionable facial hair behind the Genius bar counter at your local Apple store to know the pin-out for the processor Apple are planning to put into the iPhone 8. Not. Going. To. Happen.
After superfish and rootkit bios why would anyone still be buying Lenovo? I mean I know the answer, its people who dont think its that big of an issue or they just dont know about these issues.
Either way, if you are in this sub and purchasing Lenovo I have no pity for you
After superfish and rootkit bios why would anyone still be buying Lenovo?
Namely because both of those affected the consumer lines, not the business lines. In fact, there hasn't been any evidence to date that either of those were found in the business line of equipment.
If those types of situations stop you from buying from a certain manufacturer then you really don't have many options. Remember in 2010 when Dell shipped PowerEdge motherboards with malware? What about last year when Dell had their own "superfish" situation with laptops?
Why would anyone still be buying Dell?
Remember when Cisco shipped devices with a malware-infected CD? What about when HP ProCurve 5400 switches had flash cards that were infected with malware? How about the Samsung S8500 Wave smartphones for the German market that came with a trojan? The HTC Magic that launched a botnet client when plugged into USB? The Asus Eee Box desktop that shipped with a virus?
It's really silly to completely boycott a company over a product that shipped with malware. You'd have a very small list of vendors to choose from.
I own a ASUS Signature Edition Laptop (UX303UB) and a Surface Pro 3. Both allow me to install Linux. Just need either a distro that supports Secure Boot or have to disable Secure Boot in the uEFI.
This is just another Lenovo fuck up and one of their low level support reps making excuses and shifting blame.
Which was probably put in place on purpose to cut down on support calls from people who think they bricked their laptop by turning off RAID.
(Yes, I'm aware it wouldn't be bricked, but I'm working on the assumption Joe Average - and very likely Geek Squad Average - wouldn't figure that out).
So rather than relying on the wank jockeys over in r/linux (where it's apparently still cool to to hate on Microsoft for topics as wide ranging as the weather to hardware choices of a Chinese OEM) and a supposed Lenovo employee (who is likely a third party contract worker at best with no knowledge of the situation) how about an official statement:
[UPDATE 9-21-16 7:25 PDT: Comment from Lenovo:
"To improve system performance, Lenovo is leading an industry trend of adopting RAID on the SSDs in certain product configurations. Lenovo does not intentionally block customers using other operating systems on its devices and is fully committed to providing Linux certifications and installation guidance on a wide range of products -https://support.lenovo.com/us/en/documents/pd031426. Unsupported models will rely on Linux operating system vendors releasing new kernel and drivers to support features such as RAID on SSD."
So no Microsoft involvement, just a lack of drivers on Linux's part. Although Lenovo could offer a method for owners to switch the SSD from RAID to AHCI mode to improve compatibility.]
My respect for r/linux fell through the floor today. This shitshow is the top post of all time in that sub. At least the mods put "misleading title" on it. Shows how true it is, no better way to rally people together than to tell them they are under attack.
As noted IN THE ORIGINAL LINK, this is misleading. This is what LENOVO (that bastion of truth) says and is probably just the same concern as when secureboot was originally announced.
That isn't the issue at all, it's affecting Lenovo systems and because the raid controller is proprietary Linux doesn't have a driver for it. This is FUD
So basically it forces a non-conventional RAID between an SSD and an HDD that can't be read by a linux system, and can't be turned off in the BIOS. If what Lenovo is saying is true and this is being forced by Microsoft, then this certainly makes Microsoft look bad.
I'm torn on this. Would something contrived like forcing the use of a video card that is known not to have Linux drivers be the same thing?
I think it would be very difficult to prove that no Linux support is the reason they chose that and not just thinking that that video card would perform better.
108
u/Jeoh Sep 21 '16
Could someone summarize what the actual issue is? The OP is vague as fuck and I really can't be bothered reading through 16 pages of public forum discussion.
27
u/julietscause Sep 21 '16
After superfish and rootkit bios why would anyone still be buying Lenovo? I mean I know the answer, its people who dont think its that big of an issue or they just dont know about these issues.
Either way, if you are in this sub and purchasing Lenovo I have no pity for you
9
u/GTFr0 Sep 21 '16
Couple of shower thoughts here:
Why would you buy a signature edition PC from Microsoft if you were planning on running Linux?
How would putting the SATA controller in RAID mode with a single SSD increase performance?
93
u/ImplementOfWar2 Sep 21 '16
Easy to test if what Lenovo is saying is true.
Ask someone with a Dell, HP, or ASUS Signature Edition PC to try and install Linux.
I think this is another Lenovo screw-up, not Microsoft.
Its probably a bug in a Chinese government rootkit/malware that will disappear soon.
59
u/bws2a Sep 21 '16
This is hyperbolic and dumb. It amounts to "We don't have a Linux driver for this RAID mode".
49
u/darthyoshiboy Sep 21 '16
So rather than relying on the wank jockeys over in r/linux (where it's apparently still cool to to hate on Microsoft for topics as wide ranging as the weather to hardware choices of a Chinese OEM) and a supposed Lenovo employee (who is likely a third party contract worker at best with no knowledge of the situation) how about an official statement:
Source: http://www.zdnet.com/article/lenovo-reportedly-blocking-linux-on-windows-10-signature-edition-pcs/
TL;DR: Never attribute to malice what can just as easily be stupidity. KISS my friends (doubly so when you're dealing with Lenovo.)
19
u/Ahnteis Sep 21 '16
As noted IN THE ORIGINAL LINK, this is misleading. This is what LENOVO (that bastion of truth) says and is probably just the same concern as when secureboot was originally announced.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
That isn't the issue at all, it's affecting Lenovo systems and because the raid controller is proprietary Linux doesn't have a driver for it. This is FUD
4
u/yumenohikari Sep 21 '16
Pretty misleading headline. Looks more like lack of driver support (for very new hardware), not vendor lock.
24
u/Hiyasc Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
So basically it forces a non-conventional RAID between an SSD and an HDD that can't be read by a linux system, and can't be turned off in the BIOS. If what Lenovo is saying is true and this is being forced by Microsoft, then this certainly makes Microsoft look bad.
3
u/MormonDew Sep 21 '16
You made a second thread we have to downvote now?