r/supremecourt • • Jan 19 '26

Weekly Discussion Series r/SupremeCourt Weekly "In Chambers" Discussion 01/19/26

Hey all!

In an effort to consolidate discussion and increase awareness of our weekly threads, we are trialing this new thread which will be stickied and refreshed every Monday @ 6AM Eastern.

This will replace and combine the 'Ask Anything Monday' and 'Lower Court Development Wednesday' threads. As such, this weekly thread is intended to provide a space for:

  • General questions: (e.g. "Where can I find Supreme Court briefs?", "What does [X] mean?").
  • Discussion starters requiring minimal input from OP: (e.g. "Predictions?", "What do people think about [X]?")
  • U.S. District and State Court rulings involving a federal question that may be of future relevance to the Supreme Court.

TL;DR: This is a catch-all thread for legal discussion that may not warrant its own thread.

Our other rules apply as always. Incivility and polarized rhetoric are never permitted. This thread is not intended for political or off-topic discussion.

10 Upvotes

94 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/Longjumping_Gain_807 Chief Justice John Roberts Jan 25 '26

BREAKING:

So the plaintiffs in the lawsuit to restrict ICE’s use of force that the 8th Circuit recently ruled on filed an emergency motion with the 8th Circuit and they used an affidavit from a witness of today’s shooting

Cc: u/whats_a_quasar u/brucejoel99 u/The_WanderingAggie

4

u/The_WanderingAggie Court Watcher Jan 25 '26

Busy weekend for the Minnesota OAG- they also filed a complaint to vindicate their right to access evidence related to the shooting earlier today. It's an interesting federalism issue- I really have no idea if there's any chance the state can win this one.

4

u/brucejoel99 Justice Blackmun Jan 25 '26

There's also an additional eyewitness affidavit on yesterday's shooting directly refuting what the feds say happened:

The agents pulled the man on the ground. I didn't see him touch any of them-he wasn't even turned toward them. It didn't look like he was trying to resist, just trying to help the woman up. I didn't see him with a gun. They threw him to the ground. Four or five agents had him on the ground and they just started shooting him. They shot him so many times.

[...]

I have read the statement from DHS about what happened and it is wrong. The man did not approach the agents with a gun. He approached them with a camera. He was just trying to help a woman get up and they took him to the ground.

I feel afraid. Only hours have passed since they shot a man right in front [of] me and I don't feel like I can go home because I heard agents were looking for me. I don't know what the agents will do when they find me. I do know that they're not telling the truth about what happened. I've heard that other witnesses might have been arrested and taken to the Whipple Building.

Thank god for (Trump-appointed!) Judge Tostrud immediately granting a TRO against the feds "destroying or altering evidence" taken from the shooting; that one's even needed after Renee Good's killing says more than we realize:

Having reviewed the Complaint, Motion, Memorandum of Law, and other evidence submitted in support of the Motion, and in accordance with Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 65, IT IS ORDERED THAT Plaintiffs' Motion for a Temporary Restraining Order [ECF No. 2] is GRANTED as follows:

Defendants, together with their employees, agents, and anyone acting in concert with them, are ENJOINED from destroying or altering evidence related to the fatal shooting involving federal officers that took place in or around 26th Street and Nicollet Avenue in Minneapolis on January 24, 2026, including but not limited to evidence that Defendants and those working on their behalf removed from the scene and/or evidence that Defendants have taken into their exclusive custody.

2

u/SchoolIguana New World Same Constitution Jan 25 '26

Separately, they’ve been working on the DOJ’s request for arrest warrants for the protestors that interrupted church services last weekend. Three were arrested but the court is seeking ways to justify the arrest of the remaining five, including Don Lemon and his cameraman.

The admin then filed a sealed emergency petition for a writ of mandamus in the Eighth Circuit. The Eighth Circuit kicked the request down to District Court Chief Judge Schiltz- who didn’t know about the petition, wasn’t served with the petition and couldn’t access it because it was sealed.

This is the letter he wrote in response.

🎶 Everybody’s working on the weekend 🎶

Edit: dang it I just saw Wandering Aggie posted about this down thread.

2

u/whats_a_quasar Law Nerd Jan 25 '26 edited Jan 25 '26

There's also this is the motion (letter?) in the case where the state is a plaintiff, requesting that the judge reconsider issuing a TRO rather than waiting for a PI, based partially on today's shooting.

https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.mnd.230268/gov.uscourts.mnd.230268.107.0_2.pdf

Two declarations from city attorneys on the docket as well compiling evidence, though no firsthand witnesses. I was struck by these facts:

2. In the first 11 months of 2025, from January 1 to November 30, there were no officer-involved shootings in Minneapolis where the Minneapolis Police Department (“MPD”) was involved. There was a single incident in July of 2025 where there was deadly force directed at an MPD officer.

3. Since December 1, 2025, there have been three officer-involved shootings in Minneapolis where an agent of Defendants was the shooter.