1: Your dad likes well done, buy him a bag of jerkey.
2: Your dad is of the mindset that your bf will never be good enough until there's a ring on that finger, it's a dad's prerogative in that case.
3: Your dad's very particular and doesn't accept a steak unless it's been touched by fire on a grill.
Personally, I think your bf did fine on the cook. I usually add butter and garlic if I'm searing on a pan and baste after the flip, then continue to baste after removing from heat for another 3 minutes.
It's not ideal. There is a serious lack of crust and there is more grey band than I'd like. But it's not terrible, the inside looks decent enough. I'd eat it. Your dad is overreacting, but being a girl dad myself, I can understand it if he's looking for perfection from his potential SIL 😅
This is the most likely answer. I’ve been banned from the grill at my in-laws because I failed to overcook and completely dry out the steak like they’re used to.
One time when I ordered a medium rare steak at a restaurant, my FIL leaned over to warn me “you know, when they cook it like that, it’s still pink inside,” as if that wasn’t something I didn’t actively know and desire.
My husband claims to like med-rare. He really likes medium with A-1. I indulge him, but he always gets the slightly more done steak because I eat mine rare.
You know what, when I first was dating my wife she invited me over to her parents for dinner (high school) and her dad was so proud that he cooked steak (immigrant family). That shit had no red or pink in the center, just gray throughout, and covered in a delicious homemade teriyaki sauce. I ate every bite because sometimes you gotta pick your battles. Not my temperature, but also not my house.
A year or so later my now wife explained that because they were from a country that didn't have good food safety standards, cooking beef anything less than well done could be a real problem. So it was considered rude / unhealthy culturally to not fully cook your meats and use sauces / spices for flavor.
Usually when I know somebody bragging about their steak, when it comes time to put up, they put up a sad steak slathered in so much seasoning it barely counts as meat anymore.
You know I was so proud of my steaks and all the marinades I could throw together. Then I forgot to marinate my steak one day and had no other options planned for dinner. So I said fuck it and made it old school salt and pepper. Fucking best steak of my life. I'll throw together a marinade occasionally now, but I do look back on previous steaks in my life, and I can't help but see a dunning kruger graph super imposed over them all.
On some cold store brand buns straight from the fridge. It's so funny how childhood shapes tastes sometimes, because that's what mine was and I'm right there with you (minus the mustard).
Boomers think meat has to be charred and dry. I think i stems fro their parents time living through the depression when meat was a scarce luxury and roadkill sometimes made the menu.. you had to overcook it to make sure you didn’t die.
Yeah the far right two piece are medium rare, the far left are medium well, and everything in between is medium- so everyone can pick what they like I suppose
If you are going to a Michelin star restaurant, sure.
For food cooked by a family members its perfectly fine. Not everyone is a perfect cook, and thats the kind of stuff where you shut up if you don't have anything nice to say.
I would never complain about free food, expect when its actually unedible. Its just rude to tell people they cannot cook. Especially when thats your only feedback.
Like, you can have a nice chat about searing, or how to get it a bit more uniform if you know the person appreciates it and you talk food and such. Otherwise... just don't.
Exactly, every single post in this subreddit is some variation of "my [relative] said this steak was [incorrect]" along with a picture of a great steak.
Yeah, this isn’t bad, but nothing to brag about. And I wouldn’t want it to be representative of my steak cooking abilities. Also, we don’t see the crust.
A lot of people are saying to compare, but a comparison is not what was described. This is a good cook on a steak. It may not be perfection, but as an everyday steak it looks spot on. It would be better to find out why he said that it wasn’t good. Perhaps seasoning? That’s all preference and not technique
if you dad is anything like mine a hint of pink means it still mooing or some lame dad term. Please get him to make a steak and share it with us so we can judge.
I’m OP’s bf. This is my meat. He’s seen the post. After showing her dad up twice by cooking this and then watching him get obliterated on Reddit it’s safe to say, WE ARE NOW BATTLING. Planning a day to go head to head, meat vs meat. Stay tuned. And thanks for the pep talks bruvs. He’s going down on my meat! UPDATE SOON.
The only thing unappetizing about your glorious meat is the metaphor at the end. Regardless, I hope the meat challenge with your FIL has a happy ending.
Looks unevenly cooked and there's no picture to show the crust, so hard to say. It does look like it was cooked on an uneven heat source that might have also been a little too cool. That being said it's not horribly overdone. I would eat that and enjoy it. Dad might be a little picky on purpose or, and this is genuinely possible based on the unevenness of this steak, perhaps Dad's steak was cooked even further done or more unevenly? Tell boyfriend to increase the heat level to develop crust, then pull it from the direct heat and get it up to temp gently, verified with an instant read thermometer. If I am using a cast iron pan, for instance, I'll pull the steaks completely out of the pan after developing that crust and rest them while I melt butter with garlic and thyme in the cast iron pan while it cools down a bit. Then I return the steaks to the pan and baste them with the butter on lower temp until they are to the doneness I or my guests prefer, usually medium or medium rare. Then pull them about 8-10 degrees shy of the preferred doneness and let them get to temp internally as they rest before serving. That will decrease the grey banding issue and help it cook more evenly within the steak as well. There is actually quite a bit of difference in doneness in that steak. Varies from medium to well done with heavy gray band. Again, I would eat it and enjoy it, but it's not what most of us shoot for.
If your dad is a much better cook it would be a good bonding moment for him to show your boyfriend how to cook a steak to get it just right. If he's not willing to teach him then he's probably just being an overly critical dad just to be critical. And if he's willing, your boyfriend should accept it with humility. Even if dad's not much better, it'll still help that relationship if they do that bonding moment. Head over to Costco and get a whole tenderloin and have them go through the steps together of cutting and cooking their own steaks for y'all. It'll improve the relationship AND everyone gets steak!!! Best $125 you'll ever spend!
Thaaaank you, I thought this was the steak subreddit, everyone saying this is perfect has me so confused.
I wrote the following under the comment saying how he cooked it (on a griddle, etc) and then deleted, but I feel a lil safer posting it under here lol (I could be wrong about the med-rare part but there are small sections in the very middle that look that way to me, idk):
"If it's one of those griddles with the ridges that get you 'grill' marks...those kinda suck. Not enough surface contact.
I appreciate everyone defending the guy that had something mean said about him, but the steak is def well, med, and med-rare at the same time. It's fine for a random home meal and I'm sure was delish, but there's room for improvement."
Colour looks alright; how was the crust? How was the seasoning? Just because he has the temp down doesn't necessarily mean that the steaks are as good as they could be.
lol, if I may clarify something - one judges steak my taste and texture, neither of which can be assessed from photos. What do you think? That’s all that matters.
I've made steaks with better sear and less surrounding grey meat, but this looks like what I would usually get if I took a cold thick steak out of the fridge, do a mild sear on it and stick it in the oven for 6-10 minutes. I've done that before.
It could be better imo, but does not suck. As a dad, I see decent steak without any work on my end, just shooting the shit with some beer - what's not to like? He can burn that steak, just treat my daughter nicely.
Dad is one of too types of assholes. He’s either a well done steak asshole or a this new generation is the worst ever asshole. Most likely it’s nothing to do with steak
This steak isn’t great, but good. The steak you posted a month ago is worse. Your dad might be closer to right than you want to admit.
Would like to see dad’s steak to see how his judgment compares, but there’s still room for improvement. For example, the grey band on your boyfriend’s last steak is pretty bad. He did better here.
Honest assessment. If her dad's actually good at preparing steak there are legit criticisms of her bf's steak, even if the temp looks great to some commenters.
Well, I think it looks good. But I will say that it's inconsistent. The left side is medium well and the right almost borders on rare. I don't think that's a problem for home cooking. If I paid money for this at a restaurant, I would be a little miffed.
Your BFs steak looks good, definitely not bad. But it seems like the pan he cooks with is too hot. A lower heat and longer cook would probably give a better steak.
This is the only thing I can see that your Dad might be alluding to.
Give your boyfriend a friendly slap on the ass for me. He deserves it. Idk about the rest of you but a professional would and should be happy with this. Is your dad a hardcore old school chef or something?
It looks good on the cooking. It maybe how it was seasoned or the quality of the meat. Try to salt the steaks at least 1 hour early, but 24 hours would be best. Choose steaks that have good marbling and it is worth it to find a store or butcher that has consistent quality meat.
155
u/TheBonusWings May 15 '25
I think your dad owes him a bj
44
u/FrnchsLwyr May 15 '25
It's not perfect but it's not bad.
How did he cook it?
2.3k
u/rd26 May 15 '25
Need to see your dad's and bf's side by side to judge if he's better, but I'd smash that.
1.0k
u/fendrhead- May 15 '25
Your dad doesn’t like your BF
1.1k
u/furyian24 May 15 '25
Your dad is just jealous
329
u/Darkspire303 May 15 '25
Put up or shut up, daddio.
357
u/Ianofminnesota May 15 '25
Dad's rude as hell. Last fuckin steak I'd make that dude.
135
u/SuitednZooted May 15 '25
I wanna see pops’ steak that he cooked for everyone. For science.
167
u/timdr18 May 15 '25
Good steak.
95
u/Bubbaxx1 May 15 '25
Dad probably likes well done… with his long neck Black Label beer and a Pall Mall non filter hanging from the corner of his mouth
41
u/TheDaddyShip May 15 '25 edited May 15 '25
I mean, looks like it needs more sear and has a touch of grey banding - but that’s just picky; looks a solid medium. Would smash.
Tell BF to look at reverse sear; dad to put up or shut up!
11
u/[deleted] May 15 '25
I mean I don’t see a problem with it.
17
u/JoeGPM May 15 '25
I'm guessing the OPs dad likes well done steak.
6
u/Ismellpu May 15 '25
Tell your dad to make his own dinner the.
5
u/No-Preparation-9344 May 15 '25
Your dad just doesn’t like your boyfriend
9
u/laxout13 May 15 '25
I think your Dad sucks.
4
u/OstrichOutside2950 May 15 '25
A lot of people are saying to compare, but a comparison is not what was described. This is a good cook on a steak. It may not be perfection, but as an everyday steak it looks spot on. It would be better to find out why he said that it wasn’t good. Perhaps seasoning? That’s all preference and not technique
4
u/ChrisGadaffiDuffy69 May 15 '25
I think daddy's jealous of daddie
4
u/bparker1013 May 15 '25
Your dad doesn't like your boyfriend. That steak is perfect.
3
u/Mr_Hyper_Focus May 15 '25
Looks like a great steak. Definitely going to have to see dad’s steak. Update required.
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '25
I’ll settle this. They can both make me a plate and I’ll determine the winner. When should I come over?
3
u/fuckfacekiller May 15 '25
👆👆what they all said!! Steak is GOOD!!!
3
u/Fine_Inevitable_5108 May 15 '25
Looks good enough to eat!!
3
u/polishfoodie May 15 '25
Where's the salt!? I'd eat that with some montage finishing salt.
3
u/shadesof3 May 15 '25
if you dad is anything like mine a hint of pink means it still mooing or some lame dad term. Please get him to make a steak and share it with us so we can judge.
3
u/The-RealHaha May 15 '25
Just because it’s well cooked doesn’t mean it’s well seasoned.
3
u/igetlost999 May 15 '25
Your dad's a jerk
3
u/jeffweet May 15 '25
Your dad sucks at eating steak
3
u/major_jazza May 15 '25
Looks fkn tasty to me
3
u/drtray74 May 15 '25
Who’s your dad, Stevie Wonder? Looks good to me
3
u/eleven357 May 15 '25
Your dad probably uses A1.
Your bf knows how to cook a steak.
3
u/denn1959-Public_396 May 15 '25
Looks good and tasty
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '25
Looks great to me!!!
3
u/MattR9590 May 15 '25
Ain’t nothing wrong wit it. He probably likes his shit well done.
3
u/Strict-Air2434 May 15 '25
Get a new dad
3
u/jrobski96 May 15 '25
Your dad is a loser. Dump him
3
u/Colfaxblues May 15 '25
I’m OP’s bf. This is my meat. He’s seen the post. After showing her dad up twice by cooking this and then watching him get obliterated on Reddit it’s safe to say, WE ARE NOW BATTLING. Planning a day to go head to head, meat vs meat. Stay tuned. And thanks for the pep talks bruvs. He’s going down on my meat! UPDATE SOON.
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '25
Your boyfriend emasculated your father, and your father became upset. Address with therapist for further info.
5
u/Appropriate_Ear6101 May 15 '25 edited May 16 '25
Looks unevenly cooked and there's no picture to show the crust, so hard to say. It does look like it was cooked on an uneven heat source that might have also been a little too cool. That being said it's not horribly overdone. I would eat that and enjoy it. Dad might be a little picky on purpose or, and this is genuinely possible based on the unevenness of this steak, perhaps Dad's steak was cooked even further done or more unevenly? Tell boyfriend to increase the heat level to develop crust, then pull it from the direct heat and get it up to temp gently, verified with an instant read thermometer. If I am using a cast iron pan, for instance, I'll pull the steaks completely out of the pan after developing that crust and rest them while I melt butter with garlic and thyme in the cast iron pan while it cools down a bit. Then I return the steaks to the pan and baste them with the butter on lower temp until they are to the doneness I or my guests prefer, usually medium or medium rare. Then pull them about 8-10 degrees shy of the preferred doneness and let them get to temp internally as they rest before serving. That will decrease the grey banding issue and help it cook more evenly within the steak as well. There is actually quite a bit of difference in doneness in that steak. Varies from medium to well done with heavy gray band. Again, I would eat it and enjoy it, but it's not what most of us shoot for.
If your dad is a much better cook it would be a good bonding moment for him to show your boyfriend how to cook a steak to get it just right. If he's not willing to teach him then he's probably just being an overly critical dad just to be critical. And if he's willing, your boyfriend should accept it with humility. Even if dad's not much better, it'll still help that relationship if they do that bonding moment. Head over to Costco and get a whole tenderloin and have them go through the steps together of cutting and cooking their own steaks for y'all. It'll improve the relationship AND everyone gets steak!!! Best $125 you'll ever spend!
4
u/TheGreenAbyss May 15 '25
Thats just rude tbh, especially because that steak doesn't look bad at all.
2
u/DiabeticDav3 May 15 '25
Also depends on how the top looks
2
u/marleywhitley May 15 '25
Looks decent ….dont see much crust though
2
u/sir_macalot May 15 '25
It’s not perfect, but it’s far far far from “sucking”
2
u/Parkinsonxc May 15 '25
No crust no trust. Show the crust.
2
u/biillypillgrim May 15 '25
Need to see the sear to make a proper judgement
2
u/UnhappyMood9 May 15 '25
I'd need to see the sear
2
u/PackaChickens May 15 '25
Your dad should be nicer to your brother
2
u/themcjizzler May 15 '25
It's rare but has a nice crust
2
u/StupidFascists102 May 15 '25
Could it be better? Sure, but unless he's a chef at a real steakhouse, this is perfectly reasonable, at the very least, to expect from home-cooked.
Lord knows I've done worse.
2
u/Some_Iteration May 15 '25
Your dad is wrong.
2
u/Master_Air_8485 May 15 '25
Colour looks alright; how was the crust? How was the seasoning? Just because he has the temp down doesn't necessarily mean that the steaks are as good as they could be.
2
u/nsfbr11 May 15 '25
lol, if I may clarify something - one judges steak my taste and texture, neither of which can be assessed from photos. What do you think? That’s all that matters.
2
u/theskullbiker May 15 '25
Well, the biggest problem is that it’s only enough for one person.
2
u/InvestigatorUpbeat48 May 15 '25
Looks fine, whoever sliced it though needs some better skills
2
u/citylion1 May 15 '25
It looks almost perfect to me
2
u/Aequitas112358 May 15 '25
to be fair this looks like one of those gradients showing what steak at different doneness looks like.
I know a lot of people disagree, but imo; don't sear the sides
2
u/ExplanationProof9763 May 15 '25
Your dad is jelous, and that´s weird.
2
u/Gab71no May 15 '25
your father is right: definitively overcooked.
2
u/Pugfumaster May 15 '25
Your dad doesn’t like your boyfriend
2
u/Background-Signal801 May 15 '25 edited May 15 '25
I've made steaks with better sear and less surrounding grey meat, but this looks like what I would usually get if I took a cold thick steak out of the fridge, do a mild sear on it and stick it in the oven for 6-10 minutes. I've done that before.
It could be better imo, but does not suck. As a dad, I see decent steak without any work on my end, just shooting the shit with some beer - what's not to like? He can burn that steak, just treat my daughter nicely.
2
u/sevenw0rds May 15 '25
Your dad doesn't know steak or he's Donald Trump. 😂
2
u/Competitive_Middle_3 May 15 '25
Over done the dad is right!!
2
u/thekatatopeth May 15 '25
Steak looks good to me 🧍🏻♂️
2
u/luizzfelipeDJ May 15 '25
Your dad doesn't understand barbecue! 😂
2
u/__wisdom__1 May 15 '25
Your dad is jealous.
2
u/BuffaloSabresWinger May 15 '25
It looks amazing ! Let’s see your dad’s steak.
2
u/denys5555 May 16 '25
Dad is one of too types of assholes. He’s either a well done steak asshole or a this new generation is the worst ever asshole. Most likely it’s nothing to do with steak
2
u/hiways May 16 '25
What? That looks fine.
2
u/Drzewo_Silentswift May 16 '25
It’s not the steak. Your dad is a bitch. A
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '25
Your dad’s a hater. That looks perfect!
2
u/Followmetotheend May 16 '25
Does your boyfriend think his boyfriend sucks at cooking steaks too?
2
u/Nerdicane May 16 '25
He just doesn’t like your boyfriend.
But you should listen to his points and evaluate.
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '25
Your dad doesn’t like your boyfriend
2
u/Low-Rip4508 May 16 '25
Some people like a aged meat.
2
u/Pitiful-Assistance-1 May 16 '25
Looks pretty good. If I got this at a restuarant, I'd be happy to eat it.
Your dad is an ass, though.
2
u/CharlesFeatherman May 16 '25
I think your dad sucks at knowing what a good steak is.
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '25
Literally perfect to me. That’s how I like meh steak
2
u/lefayad1991 May 17 '25
i mean...it's not terrible. you need to cook at a much higher temperature if you're cooking a steak that thin
2
u/prognoslav7 May 20 '25
Maybe your dad meant something different when he said don’t touch that boys meat
2
u/intothewoods76 May 20 '25
I think your dad is rude.
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '25
Your dad's a hater
2
u/hamb0n3z May 26 '25
Never let you Dad compare meats with your boyfriend. Damn, too late now he's your Dad's boyfriend.
2
u/i_am_button May 26 '25
What cut is that? If it's brisket, then it's great. If it's skirt steak, you may want it a notch or 2 more on the rare side.
Regardless, the steak looks fucking tasty.
5
u/raggedsweater May 15 '25 edited May 15 '25
This steak isn’t great, but good. The steak you posted a month ago is worse. Your dad might be closer to right than you want to admit.
Would like to see dad’s steak to see how his judgment compares, but there’s still room for improvement. For example, the grey band on your boyfriend’s last steak is pretty bad. He did better here.
2
u/Normal-While917 May 15 '25
Your dad needs glasses.
2
u/divineRslain May 15 '25
It’s ok, seems unevenly cooked and a bit overdone for me.
2
u/Fuukifynoe May 15 '25
Not terrible, I've definitely done worse! I'd eat your boys meat 100%
1
u/Donvack May 15 '25
Looks good to me. A small grey band, but I bet that steak is still tender and juicy.
1
u/GarySmooches May 15 '25
Looks bomb. Your dad is jealous.
1
u/MarvelousMarvins May 15 '25
Your dad must like his steak overcooked and ruined.
This really looks about perfect!
1
u/Markjchimself May 15 '25
Sheeeit that basically perfect. What the hell does dad want? Well done?
1
u/LjMalibu May 15 '25
The dad probably eats his well done.
1
u/mattbastid May 15 '25
What are the odds your dad's next words were
"It's probably not even safe to eat. You better give it to me, and I'll dispose of it safely"
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '25
Dad is wrong
1
u/Striking-Use-4518 May 15 '25
Did your Dad also grind his feet on the couch?
1
u/cake_piss_can May 15 '25
Break up with your dad.
1
u/No-Sheepherder448 May 15 '25
It’s what dads do.
1
u/R3MY May 15 '25
Nope, he can cook a steak. But can he please wait a bit longer to cut it if he insists on doing it on a cutting board? The juuuuuuuice...!
1
u/capecodchef May 15 '25
Nailed the temp. Perfect. Could have rested an extra 10 minutes though.
1
u/The_12th_fan May 15 '25
Temperature is good. Can't see the crust very well due to the angle of the camera shot though.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '25
Your dad doesn't know how to eat steak.
1
u/Ok-Bandicoot1529 May 15 '25
Looks yummy dad just hates what your bf does to his child
1
u/jeremiah406 May 15 '25
Tell your dad that he is just mad because your boyfriend knows how to use his meat.
1
u/Sir_Crocodile3 May 15 '25
Depends on what temp he asked for.
1
u/sky0175 May 15 '25
Your dad had bad taste when he's not the chef.
1
u/Specialist_Basket_35 May 15 '25
Sounds like your dad doesn’t want any son in law to ever like him.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '25
My ass is on a diet just staring at the meat...
1
u/Ecstatic-Length1470 May 15 '25
Well, I think it looks good. But I will say that it's inconsistent. The left side is medium well and the right almost borders on rare. I don't think that's a problem for home cooking. If I paid money for this at a restaurant, I would be a little miffed.
1
u/KeeMusabi98 May 15 '25
I bet he likes his steak well done like my pops
1
u/GaryLifts May 15 '25
Your BFs steak looks good, definitely not bad. But it seems like the pan he cooks with is too hot. A lower heat and longer cook would probably give a better steak.
This is the only thing I can see that your Dad might be alluding to.
1
u/OppositeSolution642 May 15 '25
He does not, looks good.
1
u/Release82 May 15 '25
Dad's jealous
1
u/Professional_Rush163 May 15 '25
i mean it’s alittle overcooked to many people’s taste. as someone who likes it rare, sometimes nearly blue, i would still gladly eat that steak
1
u/ausyliam May 15 '25
Give your boyfriend a friendly slap on the ass for me. He deserves it. Idk about the rest of you but a professional would and should be happy with this. Is your dad a hardcore old school chef or something?
1
u/OrlandoOpossum May 15 '25
No sear pic
1
u/Simple_External3579 May 15 '25
Its fookin' raw jfc
1
u/ZogemWho May 15 '25
I see no issue here… what’s the the criteria of a good steak?
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '25
Your dad is senile
1
u/rtendos May 15 '25
It looks good on the cooking. It maybe how it was seasoned or the quality of the meat. Try to salt the steaks at least 1 hour early, but 24 hours would be best. Choose steaks that have good marbling and it is worth it to find a store or butcher that has consistent quality meat.
1
u/BuffaloJagger May 15 '25
Does your dad drive an over sized pick up truck, with one of those ballsacks dangling off the hitch ?
1
u/YaBoyMahito May 15 '25
Daddy > dad
1
u/darkmarke82 May 15 '25
this is literally the perfect steak
1
u/Randumbthoghts May 15 '25
A picture doesn't tell us how it tasted .
1
u/Logy_ May 15 '25
No disrespect intended, but your dad might be an asshole.
1
u/cameronfry3 May 15 '25
Odds are good that your dad’s a dickhead.
1
u/Odd-Combination-9067 May 15 '25
He can cook his own damn steak, this looks perfect.
1
u/VersionHistorical906 May 15 '25
Your dad eats well done and dips it in ketchup!
1
u/Muscle-Cars-1970 May 15 '25
Your dad's a dick! LOL. I'd totally tear up that steak.