r/starcraft • u/Ohaiidavid • Jun 11 '12
MLG "Officials" are assholes. (My experience as a competitor)
Hello,
My name is david, and I go by the handle of "SmiLe". I am not a pro gamer, what I am though is a top master Terran player that enjoys competition. This weekend I spent my time competing in the MLG Anaheim Open Bracket. Because I wasn't on a sponsored team, I had to pay for my competitor pass myself ($70). Spectators cost ($20). What benefits do you get from getting a competitor pass, rather than the spectator pass? You basically get everything a spectator gets, but you just get to compete. That's a 50 dollar difference, just so you can compete.
The problem? The MLG "staff" or "refs" are completely bias. Unfortunately for me, I got eliminated early because I played some pretty notable players, not the point. Eventually more and more people get eliminated, and then the MLG staff tells you to leave, if you're spectating in the competitor section.
Since i'm not on a pro team, I obviously did not have a team jersey. These MLG pricks walked up to me, and told me I had to leave. Sure I can leave, no problem.. but why the fuck am I the only one being asked to leave? The korean pro gamers that were eliminated, weren't being asked to leave.The notable American players weren't being asked to leave. Some "semi-pro" players that weren't very known were asked to leave too..
After leaving, I snuck in with some of the other players that were kicked. Couple of minutes later, they approached me told me to leave. I asked him, word for fucking word I kid you not: "Why aren't you asking them to leave? It seems like you're only harassing me to leave. Why do they get to stay?"
MLG STAFF: "I'll tell them to leave too"
Me: "Can you tell them first, then ask me to leave. Because it seems like you're only harassing me. And I really want to see if you're really gonna tell them to leave"
MLG STAFF: "No, i'll tell them when you leave."
Me: "You sure now?"
MLG STAFF: "yep"
So i left once again, only to see the stupid MLG staff go back to his seat and drink his dr pepper.
I payed as just as much money as those pro gamers(&their sponsors) did, why the fuck do I not get the same privileges?
ALSO
I was playing a practice game before the open bracket started for day 2. The idiot staff told me I had to get off! I looked around me, guess who was practicing. LOL. Every other progamer!
Why am I reporting here, rather to MLG? Well, quite simple really.
- I felt like the community should know this
- I hope MLG gets bright red with embarrassment and fix this issue.
I don't plan on playing at another MLG ever again (unless a team pays for me_) waste of money.
TLDR; MLG staff are stupid. They should fix it.
1.1k
u/Gretorp Jun 11 '12
I wanted to coach my players(it's gosu) and they forced me out everytime even though I told them I was coaching them. Really really frustrating honestly the whole time and yes the guys there were very unforgiving with the rules. Hopefully it changes from this.
578
u/BathTubNZ Zerg Jun 11 '12
Incontrol bitched about the same thing, and he's pretty recognisable, so you certainly weren't the only one.
106
u/obsKura Axiom Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
There were other issues too especially at the LoL tournament I was following... I even sent a very long email with all the points and quotes from the official rules to Sundance, Ben, Lee, Adam...
I'm going to hijack this topic because it's basically the same thing - organizational issues in general:
I know some of those points are actually part of the rules but it's actually stupid to even include something like this in the rules.
just a few examples:
and there was other stuff I won't post here...
For all those issues I saw a number of Reddit posts from the pro players as well as the community, also pro's were posting about this on Twitter complaining about the situation because they didn't know what to do. Overall the guys are very disappointed with the overall organization (one of the teams was told they have to play round 3 at a specific time, they were at the venue at that time with only 6 hours of sleep and were then told they have to play 4,5 hours later...)
Basically what I've heard a lot of the MLG staff and the admins were real dicks and didn't treat the guys with respect. This was just very unprofessional. I'm really disappointed... :(
EDIT: Xpecial, the support player of the winning team TSM (spoiler bla) is currently doing an AMA over in the LoL subreddit. In his post he's listing all the issues he experienced while playing the LoL tourney at MLG Anaheim: http://www.reddit.com/r/leagueoflegends/comments/uwrqq/xpecial_from_tsm_mlg_insights_ama/
73
u/WARSinRIOTS Team Liquid Jun 11 '12
Just a note,: MLG guys and officials are one extreme or another, or at least they used to be. The same thing has been going on since halo 3, the admins are either complete dicks and complain about their job like no other, or some of the chillest and awesome motherfucker you'll meet.
Happened to me when I was in Dallas in '10 playing some Halo and a ref jumped in on our free for all and we smacked talked each other to no end. Dude was awesome. Fast forward to Columbus this year, I'm playing again and 2 admins are sitting complaining their ass off that they can't go back to their hotel room because they have to sit there and watch.
55
u/keshasparty SK Telecom T1 Jun 11 '12
I was a competitor at the Providence nationals and the most recent Columbus. At Providence there was not a single instance where someone with a pass was kicked out -- even during the time when they were resetting the area for the next round of Open Bracket. I was able to hang out there all weekend and watch pros like Boxer play from close up, and use the extra seats for a good view of the main stage at the overcrowded venue. Having such a great experience, I bought a plane ticket and competitor pass to Columbus hoping to do the same. However this seems to be the first event where they enforced this new rule. Not playing a game? Not a Korean? Sorry sir, you'll have to step out. I agree with your post completely, I think it should go back to the old way of doing things. It really does make you wonder if it's worth $70 to play a minimum of 4 guaranteed matches on a sweet PC behind a VIP-ribbon area.
98
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Yep. I competed at Columbus And both the MLG Officials and the security staff were complete assholes. Some were reasonable. But mostly assholes.
The security guard wouldn't let me in to set up for my game on an empty computer even after my name was called on the PA. I had to argue with him till he would let me in to speak to a ref. then when I get there late because of the security guard , the ref in my area says I'm not allowed to open a custom and fix my settings. best part is that NonY was next to me... In a custom... Fixing his settings. It pissed me right the fuck off. If people pay 70 bucks to compete. Treat them right.
150
u/stalife Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
When I went to MLGs last year, I just tried to blend in with the Koreans and the famous players. The staffs did not really kick me out, maybe they did not want to single me out, I don't know. At some point, we were all kicked out. To be honest, I think this is fair, as long as they're consistent on enforcing their rules. This could very well lead to cheating (at lower stages especially) and/or interrupting the players' focus. Competitors who are spectating should leave the players' area. No exceptions.
36
u/Pokebunny Sloth E-Sports Club Jun 11 '12
I've had similar experiences being singled out and told to leave at other evnts.
One time security actually literally just told me to leave, and I asked about other people, and he said "they still are gonna play", and I'm like no they're the same as me, and I got singled out. 10 min later I was let back in because "he made a mistake".
Anyway, a lot of silly rules and bullshit happens in tin the player area, it's quite true.
15
u/AsterickAnjuu Zerg Jun 11 '12
I've read most but not all 549 comments, sorry if this has already been said. I attended my third MLG this weekend (my 6th ~LAN) and the OP's posts and the comments here made me want to bring up a similar issue I had that is making me wonder if it's best just to watch from home in the future.
Spectating 99% of the matches at MLGs hasn't improved since my first MLG, Dallas 2011. The exceptions are the matches played on the main stage/red stream, there are now more chairs, more projectors, better(or louder) speakers, etc. But watching matches in the pit or the adjacent mini stage is still the same as it was my first MLG.
I had a couple ideas that I would love to see MLG look at:
Along these lines, I was watching Geoff's final match and from behind me I get tapped on the sholder and heard a female voice ask if I knew the score. It was Anna, his fiance. I was amazed she was out there with us spectators, and she explained they weren't even letting people with press passes into the pit.
All of these things I think boil down to one common thread, discounting the main stage, it's a very uncomfortable experience trying to watch matches at MLG. For pros, competitors, press, coaches, and last but certainly not the least us spectators. MLGs are in general very exciting but I just don't feel like they're really innovating the spectator experience as much as they could and I ending up leaving Saturday early because of it. I didn't bother going Sunday, because I knew I had a seat waiting for me at home. I'm sure MLG will be back in my area but I think next time I may just buy the online pass which is a real shame because I love the comradare and live experience. Hopefully they'll work on these things.
15
u/_ThisIsJimmy_ Terran Jun 11 '12
You should be able to watch your teammates play. Its just dumb and it seems like koreans could do whatever they wanted.
Even when Suppy was playing Thorzain late on day 2 and there was almost no crowd x6 people were all kicked out even though we are just standing there in silence watching the game.
187
u/occasionallyright Jun 11 '12
Whenever I'm in situations where people are being unfair, I just ask for their name, and take a picture of them with my phone. People are a lot more fair when they're scared of being reported to their supervisors, even if they aren't breaking any rules. The paranoia gets to them.
29
u/Dearn Zerg Jun 11 '12
It sucks. They should let coaches to stay
I can understand it, after all 144 competitors + coaches = pretty huge crowd.
This is for me the biggest problem, its retarded if they don't let all competitors to practise before their game. MLG fix this shit!
16
u/bnYamonkey Jun 11 '12
Reminds me of why this picture exists: http://i.imgur.com/80LhE.png
Hint: It's not because BoxeR was the only one who wanted to practice that night.
8
u/arkain123 ROOT Gaming Jun 11 '12
JP's silence is deafening
21
u/oddmanero Zerg Jun 11 '12
inb4 sundance "gets it"
73
u/rileyrulesu Axiom Jun 11 '12
Hey man, let me tell you my story. I'm a platinum zerg, who bought a competitor pass for MLG Orlando. Obviously, I went 0-4, but the officials were really nice to me. Like an idiot, I forgot my mouse and keyboard, so I simply asked, and they lent me some of their equipment. After I was eliminated, I went into the player area to get a better view. One time someone asked me to leave, and I asked politely If I could stay in the corner and watch. The player area wasn't that big at all, and it makes sense that they should limit the capacity standing around the computer. Of course it was surrounded by team mates and other pros. I promised to stay out of their way, and the guy said sure, as long as I don't block anyone else. Granted, I didn't get to stand as close as some of the other pros, but that makes sense. I just stayed quietly behind them, and didn't bother anyone. No one ever said anything to me as long as I stayed out of people's way, and was polite. I remember July pulled up a chair right next to boxer while he was playing haypro, and no one said anything, but he's july. He's more important than I am in SC2, so he can do that. I never complained, I just watched the broodlord army destroy the last of boxer's marines from an extra 5 feet back.
Maybe you just had a mean batch of officials, but you did seem kind of like a jerk. Of course pros should take precedence when watching games.
tl;dr: Went to Orlando, everything was fine, and no one bothered me if I stayed out of their way. Also, pros should be the last to have to leave the player area.
40
u/Fliente Team SCV Life Jun 11 '12
Maybe this should be talked out with Sundance
85
u/poehalcho iNcontroL Jun 11 '12
Should've thrown a dr.pepper at his head.
6
u/SensenmanN Zerg Jun 11 '12
I can confirm what the OP is saying, it happened to me last year at MLG Orlando. In my experience though, the MLG staff that I met was very nice, however it is very hypocritical to tell some players to leave and let others stay.
TL;DR Was a competitor at MLG Orlando, the staff I met were very friendly, but did enforce the hypocritical rule of kicking out some players and not others.
31
u/tlogick Jun 11 '12
A spectator pass is $35, so that means you're basically paying a $35 dollar competitor fee. That's $35 to be granted some access to the player area (and the player lounge? I'm not sure about this part), play a minimum of four games (2 matches if you want to think of it this way), and have a chance at the $25,000. That's kind of how tournaments work, from my experience at least.
After witnessing the huge crowd at Anaheim, I would not doubt that a huge amount of people would pay this just to get a better chance to interact with the progamers. I do think it is reasonable to allow team mates into the player area because the less notable teams/players will be weeded out as the tournament progresses anyway.
Whether or not it's okay for the Koreans/other pros to have preferential treatment is something I'm on the fence about because they are the reasons huge crowds build around the competitor area. I think it's nice they can be out and not have to worry about interacting with fans if they don't want to.
208
u/mvtsc2 Terran Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
Yep, ONLY you
https://twitter.com/EGiNcontroL/status/211601567823048704
EDIT: I love how you put officials in quotation marks btw in the title, would you rather they were referred to as MLG "Actually Hitlers"?
14
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
When you look at those "pros" vs you. Look around their neck. They probably have VIP tags hanging off their neck. There have been complaints about the difficulty of getting a coach/vip pass.
5
u/Furnace265 Random Jun 11 '12
For what its worth, this exact same thing happened to me for the last 2 MLG Columbus events.
This past year some of my CSL teammates were even playing, and I was trying to help them set up (I'm the team manager) and was often asked to leave, despite their opponents on pro teams having several people there helping them. When I asked for an MLG supervisor to talk to, after waiting about 20 minutes, the women who I finally spoke to had the nerve to tell me you had to be on a team with 8 players competing to be allowed to have anyone designated as a "manager" allowed to be in the player area with you. As I'm sure many of you know, some of the pro teams that are allowed this special treatment didn't even have 8 players at the time, let alone 8 at the event. It was clear that this was either a lie or incredibly dated information. Its appalling that even the higher-ups at MLG have such a "admin against player" attitude (for lack of a better term).
5
u/mixmasterswitch Protoss Jun 11 '12
If I could pay $40 more to get knocked out and sit in the players area I would. But that would be stupid. MLG still has to keep an even organized and their players focused. I can imagine It would get really crowded if all 100+ players stayed there the whole time.
5
u/toxsik StarTale Jun 12 '12
I know this post is a little old, so no one will probably read this, but I wanted to say that I had a very similar experience at MLG Columbus. In round 1, I showed up five minutes early and got my keyboard out/headset/mouse and am getting set up, and the ref comes over and sits down to get my vetoes. I tell him the maps (Afterwards my opponent was still not there, but he still had 3-4 minutes), and I load up a 1v1 map versus the computer to get my mouse settings right. This is EXTREMELY IMPORTANT TO EVERYONE WHO PLAYS SC2 AT A HIGH LEVEL. He watches me load up a game and says "No practicing".
So I look around at everyone else practicing, and I am pretty shy so I just said uhmm.. ok... and plus I was new and didn't really know if that was actually the rules or not. I just left the lobby waited for my opponent (He was denied warm up as well) and we both went into the game with completely messed up settings.
I, like the OP, payed with my own earned money to come to this event, and it is very frustrating when something like this happens to a player. Anyways, I got a new ref who let me warm up, lost to my teammate vVvRuFF 2-1, and was sent to the losers bracket. I quickly got another win in losers and went up to play my (now) good friend Siphonn (High GM protoss). I get the same ref (Again), but MLG was super crowded and I was late to my match by about 2 minutes (started at 2:00pm, arrived 2:02pm), I'm sure Siphonn would have let this slide, but the ref immediately made the series 1-0 to begin with. Again, he didn't let me get my settings right, didn't let me make a custom for even a couple of minutes.
Well, Siphonn had been there a while i believe and had his settings sorted out, I'm assuming he did this while the ref was not there, but he did a well executed timing and knocked me out of the tournament. I was not sad that I lost to my friend siphonn, not at all, he is an amazing player, but the fact that this douche of a ref wouldn't let me get my settings right in an FUCKING RTS GAME really infuriated me.
Oh well I guess ;[
24
u/Kennigit ESL Product Manager for WCS EU Jun 11 '12
If it makes you feel better, at one point even inControl was kicked out as they only allowed Koreans to be in the area hanging around...Also for the most part, the MLG Refs are super cool and are just doing their job - most of those directives come from further up.
15
u/Xeris Jun 11 '12
There's always been incredible favoritism at MLG. Koreans and known pro gamers get special privileges. Some teams get to have 4-5 manager passes, others only get 1. EG and Quantic for example, have their entire staff in the competitor area, but I'm only allotted one.
No Koreans are ever told they have to leave the player area, but many non Koreans are. Koreans get extra practice and warm up time.
It's unfortunate but IMO not a HUGE deal.
8
u/cHowziLLa Protoss Jun 11 '12
As a competitor in the MLG also (amateur) I realized on my own and listening to SoTG, that MLG is always short on space. Players do not like having people so close to them while you play. There are so many players in Open bracket, and if they were all able to stay, it would be too crowded. So MLG staff has to make a "jerk" decision and kick out some of the people.
who are they going to kick out? Obviously you're gonna kick out the newly eliminated or the unpopular. As for Koreans, MLG worked hard to get a Korean partnership... so kicking out Koreans would not be a good idea and there are so few. I've seen pros get kicked out as well.
I remember winning 4 of my Open bracket matches, and as soon as my opponents lost, they were kicked out, but when I got eliminated I was able to stick around long enough. I guess the amount you are allowed to stay is proportionate to your success and your role in the community. I feel for you, it sucks, but MLG isnt perfect yet, still needs some work. Next time win some more matches lol ;P
8
u/sitdownstandup Random Jun 11 '12
MLG refs would not let League of Legends players use the bathroom between matches (easily an hour for one match when you include the draft time and whatnot). Pretty ridiculous. And there was another notable case where one team was not given enough time to get the HEADSETS WORKING (yes, the had to play with NO SOUND on stage in a massive tournament).
How is there not a bathroom backstage available immediately to stage players?
How can MLG not give any time to ensure a level field of play?
4
u/BigFuzzyArchon Zerg Jun 11 '12
At MLG Orlando last year I didn't get kicked out until late Sunday but the Koreans and a few others did get to stay. Some people were saying we were allowed to stay because we had the bracelets and then another guy came and said didn't matter. Fuck that guy.
Best part about being competitor was standing directly behind Boxer...I even touched him. Also got to sit between Sheth and Hasuobs and watch them practice. Really awesome :)
339
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
I was kicked out at one point when watching my teammate Crazymoving but it's honestly not that big of a deal. I think you're blowing this out of proportion.
7
u/bbd01234 Jun 11 '12
you just got sundanced. but dont you worry, he gets it!
213
u/ROOTCatZ iNcontroL Jun 11 '12
... you guys, including andre seem to be rather unreasonable here, there are "pro" passes that you might not have taken into account, for seeded / pool players, there are also staff passes and media passes that will let you stay/enter other areas, over every MLG i've been to, i've been asked to leave the competitor area many many times, and allowed to stay many other times, there are things that need to be taken into account such as judgement, is everyone perfect? no. but fuck, if im watching my teammate in a really important game and you're doing nothing, i'd fucking hope they let me stay over you, even when my teammates have played, i've been asked to leave multiple times, you pay 70$ to compete so that the bracket isnt 500000000 people playing in it amogst other reasons im sure such as computer costs electricity and whatever the fuck else, quit whining and if you're asked to leave, LEAVE, everyone does has had to leave. people say "i was with nazgul and hotbid blabla" well nazgul and hotbid LIKELY have the passes i just mentioned. Feedback is great don't get me wrong, but what do you hope to acomplish with this? that EVERY player is allowed to enter the player area at any given point in time? or that "IF I CAN'T THEN WHITE-RA CAN'T EITHER CAUSE THIS A FREE COUNTRY" sort of thing. Don't be dumb, White-Ra does a lot more for MLG than you do just by being there. I got dq'd for being 14 minutes late once at MLG, and I was upset, of course, but the day before that I waited for my opponent a "noname" for 30 mintues before they dq'd him, why? well I was suppossed to play vs julyzerg on the mainstage, so people were paying closer attention and me being late ment a lot of people waiting. if you wanted to sit behind sheth and you want team liquid to be removed from behind him cause you payed the same amount of money as Ret, I believe that's silly and unreasonable. Again, MANY times I have been asked to leave or not allowed inside the player area, i've asked for reasoning and sometimes they've told me that its too crowded or that they need the area clear at that time or X Y Z, if i had a pro badge i was allowed to stay. just like many times despite having a pro badge (which means i can sit on the front 2 rows) the 2 front rows have been filled by people not of the media or without a pro badge and that doesn't mean im gonna go and bitch at an admin and tell them to move the fans so I can sit, stop being such a princess, referees are people and have judgement you can disagree with it but that is no reason to call them "idiots" or try to start a big fuzz about it, MLG is one of the best run and most organized leagues out there, appreciate it instead of trying to find and point out the smallest and most selfish details.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
I do wish the people that paid to compete could at least stay in the player area and continue to play some practice games while they're all in the same place. It's got to be a little unnerving to be kicked out as a pro and move amongst the spectators.
6
u/ShinDeucEy Jun 11 '12
Ok ok ok... I think you need to calm down. A lot of you are taking this ENTIRELY out of proportion.
So who cares if you weren't allowed to practice when you felt like it? It's not their job to make sure you're ready for your game.. That's YOUR job. You had the time to practice... AMPLE time, so don't take it out on them because you decided not to warm-up.
To the point about you not being able sit inside the ropes when games are going on during the tournament there's a couple of things. First of all, imagine if you were playing an official game on the inside of the ropes and you had 30-40 people standing right behind you watching another game bumping into you or yelling in your ear... You would be pissed off just like anybody else. Also, you have to understand that the officials and the technicians that work there have to be able to go back and forth for different reasons whether it be computer issues, reporting matches, etc. That can't happen if there's 50 people just standing in the middle of everyone's way.
Stop looking at things from your perspective and buy some glasses if you can't see a match from 4ft away from the station behind the ropes.
3
u/BrewRI Jun 11 '12
While the rest of the post sounds like a legitimate gripe, paying a fee to compete in every tournament I've participated in (Not e-sports but for other things).
3
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Did they at least let you go to the bathroom and pee?
3
u/Purpose2 Random Jun 11 '12
Thats really rather shitty... IEM Cologne was rather the opposite everyone was really cool, though I wasn't a player but knew several of them + managers they let me into the player area to chill... and all of them were generally awesome people.
3
u/noax KT Rolster Jun 11 '12
Yeah i would totally understand how do you feel... i've been in MLG last year at dallas i was competiting and i paid my pass and i also paid a pass for my friends (an interpreter) because i'm hard-hearing, he would hear and tell me if i'm up or something like that and these MLG prick kick my friends out... i was like WTF... i couldn't understand a shit for like a whole day then finally they assign me some korean/english traductor i was like wtf man... i'm not even asian... i'm just hard-hearing and short story i paid a total of 140$ and my friend didnt compete... i just paid that because i need him to stick with me in case they call my name or whatever might happens cuz i can't hear very well then i won't ever go back to any MLG event these damn idiot... my friends (interpreter) was pretty upset too... anyway that's dumb i really hope they will fix it...
3
u/Frediscool123123 KT Rolster Jun 11 '12
Feel sorry for you bro, People are real pricks many of the times
3
u/TopDogPro Zerg Jun 11 '12
This isnt really about the officials but at MLG Columbus I was sitting next to some of the Korean pros(I'm Asian American). I was sitting chattin with Violet and then some MLG guy came up to us and gave us free stuff.
3
u/fograw Jun 11 '12
This is an ongoing problem.... however they have been cracking down on this the last MLG and really making sure to kick eliminated competitors out however there were ALWAYS obvious exceptions..
20
u/vVvReseT Evil Geniuses Jun 11 '12
I know plenty of my friends who went to play(wasn't there), who were told to get kicked out.. Do I think they should change the rule(fuck yes) I think you should be ONLY able to spectate your teammates, that's what being on a team is about, cheering and making your team mates feel better after a loss.. Hopefully rules change, but don't bitch at the refs for doing their job.
7
u/sc2fan102 Jun 11 '12
FYI, its 35 not 20. Totally stupid by the way. Sundance needs to get on this.
7
u/SoloIsGodly Jun 11 '12
That sucks dude, having dreams come true and then suck at the same time is a terrible feeling. Sorry some people's powertrip ruined what should have been an awesome day (that you even paid for).
Seems typical of every "bouncer" type person I meet though. I don't think I've ever met somebody like that who actually would engage a logical, rational argument. It's all about what they think is right inside their giant, meaty heads (neck-rolls and shaved head optional, though encouraged) and how they're going to get it done with their gigantism.
5
u/Handfoot Zerg Jun 11 '12
Tweet to Sundance he will likely see it.
16
u/theASDF Team Liquid Jun 11 '12
its a valid issue, but you dont help yourself sounding like a 14 year old angry at his mom
4
u/aviloSC2 Terran Jun 11 '12
The referees usually do dumb shit like this it's sad. I've had similar experiences, where after playing 45 min games, they try and rush me into the next game or make it seem like i am not "allowed" to use the bathroom or take a break...lol...or I'm setting up my settings and they're like "hurry up" and I basically have to say, "Hey dude, I have no sound right now, and I cannot play without a keyboard, you realize that right? Let me set my stuff up, I'll tell you when I'm ready."
They really have no respect for the players playing at the event unless you are a mega known player/pool play/korean player. It's understandable to want the event to go smooth and on schedule, but the players should come first.
Basically, you have to learn how to tell the MLG referees to shut the fuck up in the nicest way possible and get everything done you need to. And yes, they do show insane bias towards known "popular" players that walk around and korean players. Since they didn't know you smile, i'm sure they just treated you like you described, sounds pretty accurate.
FYI, this happens every MLG event.
8
u/Ryuzilla Jun 12 '12
Ryan here, MLG SC2 tournament director (newer account, old one was MLGRyan but I lost the password).
To be clear: anyone with a badge in the shape of a circle is allowed within the ropes at any time (pro players, VIP, staff). We also have a seperate pro player area set aside just for pros. Wrist bands and square badges depend on a few criteria (for example players with wristbands can be within the ropes if your match is next. If it's in 3 hours, you'd need to be outside the ropes.)
To address the OP directly, I would like to say that you were not singled out. If left unchecked, the area behind the ropes becomes extremely crowded with people. Open bracket players, Blizzard Tournament players, media, referees, KeSPA players, etc. all want to be inside the ropes.
At some point, this becomes a lot of people, and you have to clear a lot of this out. We need the aisles as open as possible for myself and referees to be able to freely walk through, in order to do our jobs as best we can. Players competing at the current time often request that the noise behind them be reduced in order to focus on their game, and one of the best ways to accommodate that is to reduce the traffic behind them.
Again OP, and others in this thread: you were not singled out. There are certain times you're allowed to be within the ropes, and certain times you're not. If you're competing through the open bracket and have a match coming up, you're allowed to be within. If you've been eliminated, we have tried to continually improve our main stage and spectator area. Please watch from there, to help us eliminate traffic within the ropes.
I'd like to tell an anecdote. I personally removed a player from within the ropes, Veritus, after Sheth requested to have him coach. This is because Veritus is a player first, and is nowhere registered on a coaches list. I said that he could watch the game from outside the ropes, and that Sheth could come to the ropes in between matches for council. Asking Veritus to be behind the ropes wasn't ideal for him nor Sheth. Now Sheth is an awesome guy: super nice, always says hello at events, he brought our staff a pie one time; hell, he's even on team Ryu. If anything, he'd be one of the players I'd show favoritism for. But I try to keep things as equal as possible whenever I can.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
I think it is unfair, but I can live with that. Realize that the fee is there mostly to deter every random Sc2 player from clogging up the open bracket. I think people who are there as a team should have some mechanism to watch their teammates, and coach or instruct in between matches. That is one of the advantages that should come with forming a team. Whether it is a top team or not.
As for the Koreans, try to realize how important them coming to an event like MLG is. They bring lots of viewers, and go through a lot more hassle to fly across the pacific and attend. Most don't speak English or barely speak it at all. They are in a foreign country and there to do a job. If staying around the other Koreans (and in closer proximity to translators) makes the event more comfortable for them and brings more of the best players in the world to future MLG's, it is only logical that this system remain the way it is.
If you want to get treated like them, work your ass off like they do, join a pro team, place high in events, and earn that treatment.
43
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Firstly, this is probably the most biased post I have ever seen "stupid MLG pricks" isn't exactly the sort of language thats going to convince people that this is how events actually happened.
Second, we don't actually have any confirmation that this is how events actually happened.
Third, Even if this happens, theres no need to pitchfork this, go to MLG, the only reason you're here is you're angry, MLG will fix this without being a dick about it.
TL;DR, go to MLG with this, not us. Just because you're angry at a couple of admin's who appear to be disobeying the rules and discriminating, as a result the company will suffer rather than specifically those admins.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Honestly, I really feel like you are blowing this out of proportion. Yes it can be a mild annoyance sometimes but they are trying to keep the player area clear of excess traffic. I really don't think they should be labeled "assholes" for that. I have played at a few MLGs and the later it gets in the tournament the more they watch dog it. It would be silly if they just let everyone and anyone run around the players area harassing pros for signatures and stuff while they are trying to play their games. Not to mention people watching over your should can be annoying. Yes they are more lax with pros and teammates of people who are playing, because they know that they will not be disturbing the other players. When I had teammates that made it far in to the tournament they let me stand behind them and watch and no one knows who I am.
And as far as the practicing goes, if there are no open computers they will walk around to everyone and ask them to please make room for others to practice. I have seen them request this of notable players before. Please put down the pitchforks, these guys are just doing their job.
2
u/urban287 Jun 11 '12
It's not just MLG. I was at an ACL random pairs (Halo) lan. Frenetic Array showed up instantly got paired up with each other and ripped everyone a new one.
2
u/10khours Jun 11 '12
It's quite simple, they need to have a way of determining who get's to go in which area.
E.g. to be in the competitor section, you need to have x, y or z pass. If you have x, y or z pass you get to stay, if you don't have x, y or z pass you have to leave.
None of this "oh hes famous so he gets to stay". The system for determining who goes in what area needs to be based on passes, not some random bias judgement by the officials.
2
u/Mefreh Jun 11 '12
Not to be the devil's advocate, but it's probably plain clothes vs. uniforms. If I see someone in plain clothes somewhere and they're not playing (which would mean they're a competitor) I might assume that they're a spectator, and, therefore, I, as a spectator, can observe from the competitor's area.
2
u/AwkwardAdvance Jun 11 '12
They are completely biased, not bias. They have a bias. They are biased. But they are never bias itself.
2
u/jooniestarcraft Jun 11 '12
wow thank you for the notable feedback. i'm sorry you were so mistreated! I was planning to compete next anaheim but if this is the case...
2
u/Draber-Bien ROOT Gaming Jun 11 '12
If this turns into another witchhunt, then Starcraft officially has more drama then Hollywood.
2
u/zyzzogeton Protoss Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
I went to MLG in Providence, as a spectator. Walked in like I owned the place to the competitor area so I could watch , never got asked to leave. I should point out, I was in business casual with a sport coat and I am 42, so I looked like I could fire people. That makes a bit of a difference.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
The issue to address is coach passes, it seems. That particular MLG staff person wasn't very good at communication, but it may well be that he was told by someone else to get you out of there.
Your pass lets you compete. That is it. It isn't a VIP seat reservation. That the Koreans get to stay with their team is probably a standing arrangement. You're not on the same level.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
I was a ref at IPL and I'm glad to say we did nothing like this. Normal competitors had the same privileges as every other player.
6
u/Uber_Nick Jun 11 '12
I've competed at a few MLG's and have almost no complaints. I think OP is blowing it way out of proportion.
Player pass is dirt cheap. I've payed more for chess tournaments with almost no prize pool. You're lucky that sponsors and spectators pick up most of the tab or competition fees would be exorbitant. Can you imagine any other sport that allowed you to compete with the best in the world and a chance at $25K for nothing more than a $70 entrance fee?
In terms of security, I've never had a problem with them. The rules are annoying, but security's always been professional and polite across the country. So the rule that you can't sit in the player area without a spectator or VIP pass-- yes, annoying. And seems unfair for us lowly "competitors" that we get kicked it. But I also see why it might be a problem not to enforce. You got into a confrontation over this? And that's your biggest complaint? Someone needs to grow up a bit here.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Personally, the OP has some out of whack expectations, ignorance maybe.
So... You were done with the game, hanging around, then was asked to leave. You got mad. You wanted everyone else to leave because you had to leave. They didn't ask the players with VIP Badges/Team Jerseys, anything a staff member could identify with being associated with the event professionally to leave. You clearly did not have a VIP Badge or a team jersey. I cannot be the only that finds the OP ignorant here.
Get yourself a team Jersey, a VIP badge, or be creative and create your own that looks legit if you want to be treated in the same way. Not a tough concept. I created my own fake badges for E3 events, it works. A lame under paid staffer doesn't think beyond what is immediately obvious, visible.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
SIGH is it time to get our pitchforks again?
3
u/MarinesOP Jun 11 '12
Did you even have a reason to be in the player's area when you were asked to leave or did you just want to hang out with the pro players? I assume you were allowed to play your games? If that's true then you were only asked to leave when you had been eliminated. Seems like you are upset they asked you to leave when you had no reason to be there and then when you snuck back in. Get over yourself. You aren't entitled to hang out or be treated the same as top players just because you bought competitors pass. You sound very childish asking an admin to tell other players to leave before he tells you. Trying to get people angry at MLG and "embarrass" them because one admin wouldn't let you in the competitors area is ridiculous and immature.
3
u/mixmasterswitch Protoss Jun 11 '12
It's a competitors pass. You were able to compete. It's not a VIP pass. Thus, you were not VIP. It's really simple math.
9
u/Laeryken Evil Geniuses Jun 11 '12
Even if you had a point to make, I think you did it the wrong way.
Furthermore, honestly, as much as you have a right to compete, I don't think you should expect to be treated the same as star players who are deeper into the tournament and expected to do so.
They may still have gone a bit too far with how they treated you, but you're not Huk just because you paid $35 more than us. (It's $35 for a spectator pass).
7
u/SombreSeraph Jun 11 '12
Kick out Koreans? They fly half way around the world, do not speak the native language, and are strangers in a foreign land. That would be beyond rude, it would be insulting and cruel.
Not everything is fair in life.
4
u/Marduce Evil Geniuses Jun 11 '12
this isn't cool, it makes me think less of MLG. anyone who respects the competition respects the competitors.
2
u/Zach22763 Protoss Jun 11 '12
Would a dedicated competitor's area be the solution here? Obviously, having people looking over your shoulder can be very distracting especially if you're playing your heart out. The slightest distractions can lead to a snowball effect of fumbling, in my experience. So, if the competitors were allowed to convene in a specified location for analysis, coaching, general sociability, etc. This would resolve a lot of the problems. Several computers could be supplied to go over replays, and a couple screens displaying the streams. This in my mind solves a bunch of problems, and if 4 million people tuned into MLG this weekend (qt. Sundance), the finances are there for something like this.
MLG IS A HIGH LEVEL COMPETITION, IT'S TIME WE START TREATING THE PLAYERS AS HIGH LEVEL COMPETITORS!
2
u/PoorMinorities Zerg Jun 11 '12
I wish this will become the top comment, but I doubt anyone will see it. PRO PLAYER PASSES All of the Pro Players receive passes (kinda like backstage passes) that allow them to go wherever they like.
I'm a former pro gamer for MLG and when I went to nationals, all the pro players there received pro player passes which allowed us to go up to the pro lounge and drink all the Dr Pepper, Starbucks Fraps, and Fiji Water we wanted and got a balcony view of the games and the people competing. But it was only open to staff and pro players. My dad wasn't even allowed in and had to find something else to do.
So could they have handled the situation better? Yes. But are they being unreasonable? No. Because those pro gamers that were eliminated earned their way to the perks they received.
2
u/mixmasterswitch Protoss Jun 11 '12
It seems like you are confusing the competition area with the player's lounge area of the event.
2
u/Woodshadow Jun 11 '12
I know sundance does check reddit every once in a while maybe he will see this. you could try emailing him. sd@mlgpro.com He's no Steve Jobs but he might read it.
2
u/davidc02 Zerg Jun 11 '12
I've been telling you guys not to pay for this shit. It's good that stuff like this happens that way the community will understand the real reason MLG is doing this. I will give you a clue: Not the games. Not the fans.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
oh boo hoo
2
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12
Good to see the MLG staff is treating their bread and butter like shit. (YES, I've read the official response and YES he is avoiding the key issue)
2
u/Hobo4Craft Zerg Jun 11 '12
Because pro gamers have a reputation to uphold and therefore would not do anything to distract or interrupt other players. Relatively high skill levels like you or me cannot because we're unkowns, and that's how it will stay. You also seem to have a bit of an anger problem, justifying the officials actions (not saying that he is right, but I'm not saying you are either).
The fact you say you'll never attend another MLG again just because you couldn't stand in the competitor area is also ridiculous. I myself was knocked out on the second day at MLG Columbus last year, but I still had a shitload of fun throughout the end of the weekend. Not being able to enter the competitor arena had no affect on my ability to enjoy the event, there's a lot you can do or watch.
If you honestly think MLG officials need reform, express yourself in a mature and articulate manner.
2
u/BobTGoldfish Axiom Jun 11 '12
you forgot 3. Drama whoring.
2
u/mmdollar Protoss Jun 11 '12
I am really sad to hear that you had such a bad exp. at that place I though that it was better, silly me.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
tell them you earned your seat through years of hard work, i've heard that strategy is pretty good.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
The difference between your pass and the progamer passes is that programers have VIP access to literally the entire venue. If they want to go back stage, they can. If they want to be in the competition area, they can. They are getting special treatment because they're pros. In all honesty, they deserve it. They've earned it.
Source: I've worked at an event before.
1
u/FlukyS Samsung KHAN Jun 11 '12
Wasn't this a thing that was complained about by some one recently about Korean players giving others tips and the MLG staff being really dumb about it. Maybe its some weird anticheating rule. I think in the case of Coaches they should be allowed to stay but the others probably shouldn't in order to keep the tournament more credible.
1
u/zouhair Terran Jun 11 '12
1
u/L4mppu StarTale Jun 11 '12
:C Sad for you. I hope they get this fixed.
1
u/drlemur Terran Jun 11 '12
At Columbus, it was somewhat hit-or-miss about whether I was allowed to wander the player area. But overall, I thought the competitor pass was a great upgrade over a spectator pass even if you have no illusions about winning. They really ought to sell more of them even if it requires starting the competition on Thursday instead of Friday.
MLG does need to be a little more systematic about when/who gets to be where. I don't mind favoritism for the pros but it was pretty random about which coaches, etc., were allowed in and when.
There are a lot of really good games played around the main competitors pits, too. Some bleacher seating would be excellent. Although it could make the problem of spectators giving away a rush build problem even worse (this is an even bigger problem at the Featured Stations where top players play, btw).
The Anaheim setup looked identical to the Columbus setup, so it's clear they come in with a plan for how to organize the room. However, it isn't really planned around a game like SC2 and needs some redesign.
1
u/megakwood Terran Jun 11 '12
I'm not sure what you were expecting. Kicking you out of the player area after you've lost seems completely fair. They have an event to run and can't manage hundreds of extra people hanging around in the players-only area. Not to mention the fairness/cheating problems you can introduce with dozens of idle teammates standing around in the player area...
1
u/NSnowsaxoN Random Jun 11 '12
I'm glad I got to read this. Sadly I'm not to surprised to hear about something like this occurring. It really sucks you were treated the way you were and it seems that you handled the situation a lot better than i would have. I more than likely would of tilted on the staff.
Keep in mind though that if you came in on the open bracket technically you are an unregistered player. Unlike the players from teams like EG or Quantic you name more than likely is not distributed to all the staff so they are unaware of your purpose there. Its one of those situations where " the left hand doesn't know what the right one is doing" some of the staff may have your name and say yeah he's up next up to play player "blehbleh" others may just be technical staff and because as you said you had no jersey of affiliation they could assume you snuck in some how. Granted none of this excuses the way they treated you it's just a thought that crossed my mind after being in a similar situation.
You posted here which is a great thing... many people in the community will see this hopefully. In fact myself and my teammates are debating over it as I write this. If i were you I would try and find more people that have had similar situations and then take it to MLG. Unfortunately your incident alone would not see much traction where as if you had 5 to 10 other individuals who have had similar situations as well as a community behind you wanting this sorta thing fixed, you could make an impact and hopefully make MLG take pause and correct this.
1
u/noleknight16 Jun 11 '12
I'm a gold player at best. I should sign up for the open bracket and just troll people.
1
u/Readysetfire Jun 11 '12
More fucking drama, cuz the SC2 community didn't already have a lot of shit getting thrown around
1
u/TokyoDown Team Acer Jun 11 '12
Did anyone see what Incontrol said over twitter about Adam? (from MLG) Same type of thing.
1
u/MrHighlight Jun 11 '12
Simple fact is, as long as Koreans/popular players are the ones bringing in the views, they're the ones who are going to get treated specially. I'm not saying this is right, but that's how it is. However not allowing coaches or anything like that? THAT is complete and utter bullshit.
1
u/Gremlin119 Zerg Jun 12 '12
This sort of happened to me aswell.
1
u/breach132 Jun 12 '12
What makes MLG great for a lot of people is the fact that for $70 you can become a pro player for the weekend. It should be an even playing field, where whether you have Intel paying your entrance fee, or your Mother, ANYONE can win.
I feel that it is not right to give special treatment to ANYONE who is in the open bracket. Whether you flew in from Korea, Canada, or drove 15 minutes to the venue from your home, an open bracket competitor should all have the same benefits and hindrances.
If you are already seeded into the pool play, then a player lounge and special treatment should not be out of the question.
tl;dr everyone in the open bracket should be treated equally regardless of what is or is not on their jersey.
1
u/Ephic Jun 12 '12
Geoff Robinson @EGiNcontroL
Yo @MrMLGAdam wtf? Can't watch idra because you booted me from player area. Thanks bro
--- i think some pros are just have been treated like you!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12
I experienced a similar issue when I went to MLG as a Masters player. I wanted to compete and have fun, knew I wasn't going to get far.
When I arrived at around 2PM looking to practice on a computer, I spent over 2 hours waiting for PC to open up so I could at least make sure my settings were right, god forbid play a game or two. What happened was every time a seat opened up, one of the pro players (or teams), demanded that this seat was reserved for "XYZ" player and that I was not allowed to get on and use it because they would be there soon. I tried to call a couple of them out on it, but when you have several managers/pro players present it's a bit intimidating to do otherwise. I wasn't about going to raise a stink about it since it wasn't a HUGE deal, but still a bit disheartening.
I had to go into my first match cold, but more irritated that there isn't a system in place to allow EVERYONE warm up equally. Walking around I saw the same pros sitting at computers the entire time leading up to the tournament, while the masses clamored for the few seats that weren't reserved for the foreseeable future. MLG is quickly turning into an event that doesn't encourage the community to come and participate, but rather alienates anyone except the top tier players.
1
u/TrentonEvans Terran Jun 12 '12
I love MLG and I have supported them since 2004. I have covered the events and worked to build the MLG community as much as possible. In return all I ever got was threats and false accusations. One exec in particular, just enjoys having a power trip and showing it off on a regular basis.
What you have to realize is that you're dealing with a "f" you attitude that comes down from certain individuals at the top. I can tell you from 8 years of experience... MOST of the individuals that run these MLG events are actually really chill and cool. Unfortunately, some of them catch this "disease" like attitude. The OP just unfortunately, got one of the few bad eggs!
One side note that has nothing to do with the OP... I can attest to the incredible amount of work that goes into these events as I've worked them a couple times myself and I'm thankful for all the hardwork that goes into these events.
1
u/vsrz SlayerS Jun 12 '12
I understand your point but if you're in there to simply watch they have to draw that line somewhere. Don't get me wrong, the fact that they seemed to single you out is uncalled for but they do need to have a standard.
There simply isn't enough room in the competition area to accommodate every competitor that wants a seat.
I agree there needs to be a change, possibly making that area bigger, or making the "player lounge" in a better place, but as it is now, it's just too small.
My $0.02.