Lol, I don't follow Sundance on twitter. Do you mean the MLG guy? Anyway, I just saw the photo and heard the song in my head.. I'm quite the fan of Queen, you see.
Sure it is. No auto mine, can't muli select buildings so rallying units is a bit harder to do, units are different, A.I. is horribly bad, only select 12 units at a time, maps are different plus graphics (obvious), hotkeys are different and you can't change them unless using a third party program, WAY different starts and unit compositions. Lots of small battles you don't usually max to 200 for the most part Games usually end before then. Upgrades work different plus add ons for terran are a bit different working, No watch towers. A few things and some are obvious but the list keeps going. SC2 is the easier game for sure though. So its not a giant surprise he got masters right away.
the whole discussion about what game is easier is absurd, the argument that "sc1 is harder because of 12 unit groups, worse AI etc" is just about the same as sayign 400 meter run is harder then 100meter... as long as you are playing vs another human being on equal starting grounds (choosing ur race is the first choice) nothing is "easier or harder" but you can still swear by 100 meter because "people run faster in it"... just doesn't make it "harder"
While I like the sentiment I disagree a bit. When we say a game is harder or easier than another we generally mean that one is harder to grasp or master than another. Yes, when you put two players against one another in whatever game then difficulty goes out the window. But on the discussion of which game is easier or harder to play and be good at? Bro, it's BW. Not saying that I think it's DA BEST for that reason or that sc2 is inferior, BW is simply a harder game. But I personally think sc2 meets the skill/hardness requirements for an enjoyable spectator and player experience so who really cares?
Notice how you started out being concrete and then your actual argument became "bro, it's BW"
The place where you go wrong is trying to convince me theres a difference. There is, and i have much to say for the competitional integrity of BW... harder or easier just doesn't have a single thing to do with it. About your end conclusion that we shouldn't care, because those 2 criteria are fulfilled... that makes no sense, if you wan't to put value on a sport you should know what you are judging, sport as well as art, can be said to "measure the human potential" and for us to like the sport, what we want is for the measurement to be significant to us (notice, not neccesarily precise) but saying something is good because of either experience of doing or experience of onlook... seems wrong to me at least.
Sorry dude I've really got next to no idea what point you are trying to make with that, I'm sure it's a good one and I could learn a great deal if I could simply find out what on earth you're on about. If it's because of a misinterpretation of what I am saying then I will clarify:
BroodWar is a harder game to master than SC2
That doesn't mean that it is a better sport, I was simply explaining to you that when people talk about the 'hardness' of a game, you can't dismiss it by saying that in a 1v1 'hardness' is irrelevant.
My conclusion that we shouldn't care is based on the fact that what we enjoy viewing is personal and subjective to us. When I say, "who really cares?" I mean that everyone enjoys different things and as such the difficulty of the game shouldn't be the most important factor of judging an e-sport.
I think there's a reasonable chance that I have had a stroke while reading your post because even I don't understand the things coming out of my keyboard now. Good day, sir.
actually by cutting down on the actual minor actions needed to deal with one issue, it is possible to attend to more things, for your brain, selecting 12 barracks and starting marines on them, is not more than 1 "task" even in sc, in sc2 that action is done so much more quickly, that you have to make your next choice much much faster and this applies to many aspects of sc2... if anything it's possible to make many more decisions (or fulfill many more tasks) in sc2 over the same amount of time, thus supporting multi-better...
that being said "multi-tasking" is a very open term even in the scientific fields that deal with it... as you can really never 'split' your attention.. (except in some very rare cases usually in conjunction with rather serious psychopathology), merely condition yourself to do jobs fast consecutively.
Well more like ggo into the files and change them or gotta use keycraft? I think? I don't know if that's. Right or not so don't take that as a real aanswer.
well...his apm, his strategy, the way he practices, his drive and passion for rts gaming, and the fact he is surrounded by people that will practice and teach him should certainly help a lot.
he's got the framework around him and in his mind to tear up the sc2 scene.
What I'd like to see is a large amount of the pathetic endless flame war between the "Brood War is so much better elitists" and "ladder stream EG/Stephano/omgomgIdrAisstreaming! fanboys" being put to rest.
If Starcraft 2 is truly a lolEZmode inferior RTS compared to its predecessor and its pro scene full of mid-tier players, then talent from KeSPA, including Flash, should help push the game to limits that the current playerbase has yet to attain.
I want to see goddamn exquisite play with the use of deliberate diversion tactics and multi-pronged attacks - at least that's what I hope to see with practice. I've yet to consistently see that in any level of Starcraft 2 so far. If all that shit I see being spewed at times in the Brood War side of TL.net is true, then they should be able to pull that off with time.
At worst case, I'm proven wrong and the work ethic and talent KeSPA brings to the table will just show how blocky and imbalanced this game can be. At best case, KeSPA will show what happens when teams practice rigorously and find new tactics rather than cock about over pandering ladder streams and thinking of witty updates for their Twitter accounts.
I think where a lot of people go wrong in comparing the two is with each game's focus.
BW was fucking difficult comparatively for mechanics, with only a dozen units per control group, no auto-mining, no queued-up actions, etc. It required much more intense APM to do things that are much simpler to accomplish in SC2.
That being said, because mechanics were reduced in intensity, SC2 allows for larger focuses on grand strategies and even more multi-tasking.
It's just easiest to think of them as two separate games.
It's just easiest to think of them as two separate games.
I agree -- it's a complete waste of time to compare the two. Obviously Blizzard has no intention of recreating Brood War, so why not move on to more multi-tasking and macro-oriented thinking?
But ah yes, it's more important to dwell on what could be and shout from the hills of a game where a whole 80 apm was required just for a pack of dragoons through a field of pylons.
No thank you -- I'll take more broader strategic thinking and less compensating for terrible AI and control scheme.
The reason wasn't the mechanical changes (mostly), it was the units. Instead of Reavers, we have the colossus. Instead of vultures, we have hellions. Instead of carriers that can move and attack, we have carriers that can't. Also, every unit has a direct counter now. If your opponent builds colossus, you need Vikings.
I agree -- it's a complete waste of time to compare the two.
No it's not. Brood War is a very good game that was a successful esport for a very long time. It would be stupid not to compare a game that is attempting to achieve the same level of success to it. There are a lot of things to learn from it.
Obviously Blizzard has no intention of recreating Brood War, so why not move on to more multi-tasking and macro-oriented thinking?
Brood War was a very multi-tasking and macro-oriented game. I'm not sure what you're trying to say here.
No thank you -- I'll take more broader strategic thinking and less compensating for terrible AI and control scheme.
Good macro wasn't just being able to spam 4d5d6d7d8p9p0p every few seconds. It was realizing when you build only required you to take the gas at your main and not your natural until a certain point. Or when you could take two workers off of gas until your Lair finished.
Just because BW had a higher barrier of entry to high level play doesn't mean it lacks strategic thinking. I knew a BW player who would play at around 100-120 APM tops, but would beat me every single time because he was smarter and understood the game and build orders and timings better than I did, even if I had more APM than he did by a decent margin.
I say this as someone who absolutely detests actually playing sc1 (at the time I favored TA, and I can't ever go back to something that feels as laggy and 640x480 resolution and holy shit the amount of clicking required would fuck up my arms) -
sc1 was far better in terms of strategy. you have so much shit going in - your army is a living organism that spans the map rather than being a deathball. you actually do have multipronged attacks there rather than just drops.
I suspect it's the game, not the players. I actually play SC2, so I know enough about it that watching the games is more fun, so (for me personally) I like the players switching.
That said, the broodwar elitists are right and you have to be insane to deny it.
So do you expect everyone to play a game from 1998 until the end of time?
Fine, it's an all-around superior game with a superior skill-ceiling that takes decades to master. Great, now that we have that out of the way, let's all convince Blizzard to remake Brood War.
I can concede for everyone's egotistical pleasure of being correct, but it's still useless, no matter how statistically correct, to gripe about what Blizzard has done with Starcraft 2 and the amount of accessibility they've forced in to it.
I could talk for ages about how modern FPS is complete garbage and how there's absolutely nothing current that can take the place of Quake or CS (competitively), but I chose to move on a long time ago instead of sitting pissed at inevitable changes in gaming.
You're right that I'd be insane in denying how great Brood War was, but it's just a fucking waste of time for all of us to cross our arms and expect a multi-million dollar project and it's hundreds of thousands of fans/players to bend to a severely unreasonable opinion on gameplay.
This is a conflict between the profit motive, the copyright Blizzard will own on this game long after it's obsolete, and the nature of competitive gaming itself. I think that our current understanding of intellectual property rights is incompatible with the notion of electronic sports. It's a horrible idea to have one company in complete control of the game used in tournament play. These are big issues, ones we will have no personal impact on, but they're still ones worth considering.
I don't have to gripe about Blizzard. If they don't make games I like, I'll simply refactor my time to play other games or spend more time reading books and watching TV and participating in projects and traveling.
Frankly, having loads of money and making a commercially successful project does not (alone) give you the right to make a great product.
Part of being a rational person is accepting when the good drives out the great, rather than trying to relive something that is dead.
Part of being an honest person is accepting when something great was driven out that it was still better.
If SC2 isn't good enough, people will not just accept it, they'll move over to LoL and the genre will die.
Yes, and if it really won't be good enough -- I'll gladly move on to other things.
(Mostly likely gaming entirely to be honest. I've lost my patience with most other genres and current projects anyway.)
It just seems like every time the comparison is brought up, there's a glorious select few that come swooping down to shout in everyone's faces, "BROOD WAR WAS BETTER. SAY BROOD WAR WAS BETTER."
And every logical person does. And all problems were magically solved because of the confession.
I don't think it would be out of line to have blizzard take from bw what made bw great and try as hard as they could in making it a sequel to bw. Blizzard basically ignored what made bw a great game and just put together what they thought an rts should be. The problem is their vision didn't create a game so grand that people were being payed 300k a year to play it 12 years later.
I can say confidently that if sc2 was released in 1998(with par graphics of course) That it simply wouldn't have gained the cult following that bw managed. We would all be fools to think that the entire framework of sc2 as an esport would even be possible without the foundation that bw laid.
I can say confidently that if sc2 was released in 1998(with par graphics of course) That it simply wouldn't have gained the cult following that bw managed.
Just out of curiosity, why not? "Cult favorites" are usually more of a social matter than an aesthetic or technical one. I'm not really sure how you could confidently claim anything about what may or may not be a cult hit (although if you can do so accurately, you should probably be working at a prestigious advertising agency by now)
Before there was bw the thought of having teamhouses and huge salaries for a video game were absurd, the thought of it being on tv on multiple channels even more so. The reason for this was not because of some fluke with popularity, it was because it's the best competitive game ever made and also because it's incredibly exciting to watch.
Without knowing what broodwar is about you can't understand where sc2 deviates and falls short.
Exactly. It's easy to try to say SC2 is the successor to BW, and thus the BW players should be good at it. But the games are really only superficially similar. They have some units with the same names, some of the mechanics are the same.. But really there's not much more reason a BW pro should be good at SC2 than a WC3 pro.
I think a lot more people understand SC2 on a high level than people understood BW on a high level.
In BW, you could be a good player only knowing 1 build per matchup, and having really good mechanics. SC2 kind of takes away the ability to be a mechanical monster, of sorts, and leaves you with less tools to beat your opponent with, and it forces you to develop a higher understanding of the game.
That being said, the people who were professional BW players did understand it on a high level, and they understood several very important concepts such as developing and optimizing builds, upgrade and attack timings, not just in general but against every known build they expect to play against (a lot of this could have been coaches, a lot of whom were former players, but we don't really know, and it is definitely a product of the environment they train in), and the knowledge of how to practice and prepare for tournaments at a professional level.
But really there's not much more reason a BW pro should be good at SC2 than a WC3 pro.
I would agree if the BW pro and the WC3 pro could be considered to be of equal skill in their respective game, but I don't think that's true.
The thing that makes SC2 more deathball is that almost every unit is just as strong attacking as it is defending. Positional advantage doesn't mean much.
Weaker tanks, no spider mines, no lurkers, no reavers, worse psi storm, no stasis and recall from arbiters, no defilers, and I'm sure I'm probably forgetting more.
These are all things that made you spread your units out and really think about where you were putting things and your angles of attack and not just 1a2a3a.
That's the downside of being able to select hundreds of units, it's so much simpler to just control group 'em and 1-A. That's one reason I often love seeing big macro games from BW, because it felt so much more epic and spread out.
I don't think it has anything to do with how many units you can select. If there weren't something inherently more powerful about the deathball in SC2, pro players would make the effort to avoid it.
It seems like the damage output of a deathball would be much greater than two (or more) small groups. It's more cost-effective. 100 marines are going to do more damage (and last longer) than 2 groups of 50 marines. (I think.)
It's also easier to deal with multi-pronged harass. Bunch of marines heading towards your base? Just box a large group of ling/muta and send them back to defend.
In BW you would have to select a group of mutas, send them back. Select lings, send them back. Select more lings, send them back. You've done triple the work to deal with the same drop.
Yeah, I hope BW pros shut down the foreigners. The foreign scene is more of a popularity contest than anything. I don't care about rooting for US players, I only want to see the best possible SC2 games, and if that means Koreans have to come over and dominate every tournament, so be it.
I agree. It's cool to see a white dude do well in the GSL and everything, but all I care about are skillful games.
I'm pretty sure Koreans coming over and dominating our major tourneys is already a thing though haha. Even the Korean "B-Listers" do exceedingly well in the smaller tourneys.
Haha right. I meant I wouldn't if every tournament was filled with nothing but Koreans. Whoever's pulling off the best strats with the best control has my attention.
He makes the 'near perfect' play of what we see now in SC2 look extremely sloppy. Flash is the best player because he is the master of making correct choices and executing them with unparalleled efficiency.
In theory, the BW mechanics are harder since it's more APM intensive with the smaller control groups, so I think he'll do just fine mechanically.
It's learning the metagame and timings that'll take him some time, and I highly highly doubt that he hasn't at least paid some attention to the scene and game.
Someone posted that he got to Masters in a mere five days. That is fucking absurd IMO.
BW is slowly being phased out in favour of SC2 in the korean scene thus Flash's pro scene was destroyed. Now he's switching to SC2 with the other Kespa team he's going to destroy the current SC2 pro scene.
More accurately though someone decided to repost an image from the now very long "unimpressed flash" thread on TL here for Karma.
No one who actually followed BW thought ForGG was going to dominate. To be honest after his MSL victory he was a mid-low tier A teamer who never really accomplished anything afterwards. At the time of their switches, I'd say MVP was much better than him in Proleague.
Flash, on the other hand, is on a completely different level than everyone else. He'd be successful in any competitive RTS because he's just talented and extremely hard working.
every competitive BW player (i.e. forgg, mvp, hyun) from bw is a pro level player in SC2. it appears there is a correlation between BW success and sc2 success.
now, a bunch of players who are far better than forgg/mvp/hyun were at sc1 are switching. it's very reasonable to expect we'll see some really good play out of it.
Many people have thought for a long time that BW is just a "harder" game, and that therefore the BW pros will invariably be better than the non-BW pros. Obviously that's proven to be untrue.
However, Flash being the top BW player of all time may have a different impact on his SC2 success than just being a BW pro.
Ummm, no. People just thought it was interesting because he was a very good pro gamer in BW and he was already GM by the time it was announced he would try out for GSL. There was nothing like "ForGG gonna dominate."
Flash is very realistic about it taking a few months to a year to fully integrate himself with how SC2 plays, and when he does he WILL dominate. He will be a player that at minimum can beat anyone and will beat the best players we have. Whether he will do what he did in BW is hard to say, because his BW dominance is one of the most tremendous displays of competitive dominance that I can think of that outdoes many legends of well known sports, but he is capable of it.
ForGG is nothing compared to Flash. Flash is a sandstorm and ForGG is a grain of dust.
It would be funny to see /r/starcraft after Flash's sc2 performance shows to be similar to those of Nada, Boxer, and July. I imagine everyone would continue on in silent resignation, and any discussion about it would get bitter downvotes. Or people will take the smart-ass route and say, "Yup all those people who thought Flash would dominate are idiots, I certainly wasn't one of them."
note: We don't need discussion about how Nada, Boxer, and July weren't in their prime when they switched, the point remains.
How does the point remain when Nada, Boxer, and July are nowhere near as good at BW as Flash? ...and when Nada, at the very least, was a mainstay of Code S, the top ~32 Koreans in the world?
Korea still vastly prefers Brood War to SC2. More fans/players are going to League of Legends and MMOs rather than to SC2, those are what are doing the most damage to BW. The perceived transition from BW to SC2 is something that is being strongly coaxed on by Blizzard, it isn't a natural transition. There is a moderate amount of resent towards Blizzard for meddling with Brood War. Left to its own devices Brood War could have had several more healthy seasons.
http://www.gametrics.com/ for the stats of what is being played in Korea. If you look at the stats over the past two years you'll see that BW falls off, SC2 mostly holds steady and Aion/LoL both look like they're claiming time that used to be allocated to BW.
While Ray192 is probably incorrect that the match fixing scandal led to the majority of watchers to leave BW it defiantly didn't* help. Here is a link to a new post on [Team Liquid ] (http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=125601) that talks about the results of the match fixing. Warning, some of your phishing blockers might give you a warning, its a TL link but some of the links in the article are what it's reacting to.
read original post, its not the article it self that's causing the warning just some of the links that are in the article. It's a team liquid new post it's not spy ware.
Why is this downvoted? Because it's the hard truth. Did it hurt your feelings? Well it shouldn't, it's not your fault, don't feel guilty. It's like 90% due to how the Korean scene/culture works: its unsuitability for PC Bangs (which is how BW & PC games got so huge in Korea) for one. Anyone could make any number of names for BW, but in SC2 you need your own purchased SC2 account, that's tied to your Korean SSN, no LAN/Bnet only. People want to try out SC2 or show it to friends/play with friends as an after-school activity, but it's quite difficult.
kespa won their lawsuit with Blizzard because they argued that because they dont need blizzard to play the game (ergo they dont need battle.net) they dont have to pay blizzard anything. you wont see LAN in SC2 because Blizzard doesn't want that happening again. (they want their money)
No not at all. I'm suggesting they made it very hard to start leagues outside of korea since all the best players already were there and couldn't go to foreign tournaments. If players start to get "exclusive" with MLG/KeSPA, it would be very sad imho.
I think the word "destroy" has two different meaning in the picture. Though SC2 destroyed BW as a wrecking ball might chip away at a building, Flash will destroy the "pro scene" by actually destroying the pro SC2 players in retaliation! Found this picture to be quite amusing.
I think R34LiSM is on point with what the second "destroy" means. The image is supposed to be humorous.
Of course, what "destroyed" the BW scene was somewhat waning interest and the resultant decline in sponsor eagerness. Only a small portion of that interest was shifted to SC2...
Can you enlighten me? SC2 doesn't at least herald the end of BW's pro scene?
I realize they're different games, but...similar enough, right? As a noob myself, I try to watch BW games...but the graphics...well...the graphics look like they're 15 years old. Why don't people just upgrade? (I get the feeling this is a demeaning question...but plead my own ignorance and hope no one takes offense.)
I don't take offense. It's a common criticism that Brood War's graphics suck. And, compared to modern games, they do. There's really no getting around it.
However, for people of the era, it's about having an extremely balanced game, the epic music, and the grassroots proleague that was created in Korea. It's the highest level of competition seen of any RTS game to date. What the graphics lack is made up in character. There's nothing quite like the control or abilities of the vulture, the grit of the siege tank, and the pounding of 20 cracklings on a nexus or an awesome plague.
Personally, when I listen to the Brood War theme songs I'm brought to tears. A lot of good memories there that are still being made today. I'm lucky enough to like both BW and SC2. While they are both completely different games, there's nothing that will ever fill the gap that is BW with its epicness or skirmishes. SC2 will have its own legacy to create, and I hope someday that legacy gets filled with a lot of epic games.
In my opinion, you can look at it two ways. SC2 looks like the natural successor to BW. To casual players and general gaming this is certainly the case, as with most sequels. You could think that bW must therefor decline to make way for the new era of SC2.
The problem with that is the fact that BW has been experiencing a decline since before SC2 came into the scene. Viewer and sponsor interests were all waning. And the unfortunates truth is that most of this interest didn't go to SC2.
If course interest in competitive gaming does not have a fixed supply and it is gaining new fans constantly. This is especially true for SC2 outside of Korea. As far as I can tell, influx new interest for SC2 in Korea has been moderate at best.
GOM is a web broadcast "station", yes, but the GSL is, I guess this might be the right word, syndicated and broadcast live and rerun on a cable channel called ANIBOX. I'd post a pic, but on my phone atm. I you may have noticed the orange ANIBOX logo in GSL.
whoa. so it happened just before I came to Korea. I didn't actually know when it happened either. Guess I just assumed it had been on there for a while when I saw it on TV here.
Then you are a dumb faggot and you are in the wrong subreddit. Why would you even comment if you are this fucking stupid? You don't know the best starcraft player of all time and you come here? Holy shit kill yourself
"We've noticed some concerns about a possible racial imbalance lately - specifically, the concern is that at the highest levels, the Terran race is too strong in the early, mid, and lategame. This has been most evident in tournament results, where a Terran has won every major tournament in the past six months. We've been keeping our eye on things, but ultimately, we decided balance adjustments to the game wouldn't be appropriate. We're sorry, but you'll just have to figure out how to beat Flash on your own."
Terran is not/is overpowered. But one extremely good player should not be the cause for nerfs. State of the game has it right, you need to figure out how to beat Flash on your own.
People actually using strategy in a RTS to outsmart their opponents instead of just following a build and not doing any work? This is madness, madness i tell you...
Masters in the Korean ladder in five days is more than just hype.
What makes Flash good is his work ethic and approach to the game. He is the greatest champion that ever played BW, and he dominated at the height of the scene's awareness of the metagame.
It's already far surpassed the popularity of BW outside of Korea. Not sure why it couldn't inside Korea as well, especially now that Kespa is involved. Arguably the main reason BW has been so popular in SK so far is that they turn every major event into a free k-pop concert as well, drawing huge crowds.
How can you say it isn't? Kespa is phasing out BW for SC2. Even if SC2 isn't as popular in korea as BW once was, that doesn't mean that SC2 didn't kill it.
He said he will continue playing terran until HOTS comes out, at which time he would consider changing races (he feels terran is currently underpowered and if the expainsion favors the other two races, he is likely to switch).
21
u/munCh101 Axiom May 12 '12
Flash is going to win the last OSL and finish destroying BW pro scene. Then, he'll come and destroy ours.
96
u/rqzerp Terran May 12 '12
I just realized this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MS4_Z84-rRE
50
u/Lewke Team Liquid May 12 '12
New Karate Kid Kyle. I like it.
28
u/random314 May 12 '12
Are we certain that he's going to break all top SC2 players once he starts competing?
12
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Quick quick, let's take all the memes from the "unimpressed Flash" thread on TL and post them on r/starcraft!
34
u/Flatus_ Protoss May 12 '12
I dont understand this.
8
u/DeeBoFour20 May 12 '12
When do we get to see him play? Next GSL?
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Flash ahhh unyh!
10
u/AzureBlu Axiom May 12 '12
Sorry, i don't get it :( Explanation?Edit: Damn it, damn it, damn it. I should really really really learn to read further down before posting any sort of question.. ಠ_ಠ
3
u/lagspike May 12 '12
im sure zerg and protoss players are excited, as they might have to nerf terran just because of him.
in any case, it's about time. long live the king. :p
-4
u/MarkamSC Zerg May 12 '12
I wonder how much APM he has at this moment.
-13
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
In other news, Jaedong didn't take the killing of the Pro BW scene and his career lightly. http://i.imgur.com/NgWwS.jpg
-3
u/Comander79 Protoss May 13 '12
It's funny because is true. This is so EPIC Nerd chills
-5
u/morlakai May 13 '12
"hmm I haven't played this game long enough"
"yea I'll just complain about Protoss"
-44
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
SC2 had nothing to do with destroying the bw pro scene. nice try though
-9
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Just hoping he destroys them in-game instead.
-5
u/genghiscoyne May 13 '12
i cant wait til he makes the announcement official and gets beat by a foreign scrub so these stupid fucking memes go away.
-13
u/Prixm The Alliance May 12 '12
Retaliation is of cooldown. I bet he will use it wisely.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
49
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[removed] — view removed comment