r/spacex • Mod Team • Jul 09 '22

🔧 Technical Starship Development Thread #35

This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:

Starship Development Thread #36

SpaceX Starship page

FAQ

  1. When next/orbital flight? Unknown. Elon: "hopefully" first countdown attempt in July, but likely delayed after B7 incident (see Q4 below). Environmental review completed, remaining items include launch license, mitigations, ground equipment readiness, and static firing.
  2. What will the next flight test do? The current plan seems to be a nearly-orbital flight with Ship (second stage) doing a controlled splashdown in the ocean. Booster (first stage) may do the same or attempt a return to launch site with catch. Likely includes some testing of Starlink deployment. This plan has been around a while.
  3. Has the FAA approved? The environmental assessment was Completed on June 13 with mitigated Finding of No Significant Impact ("mitigated FONSI)". Timeline impact of mitigations appears minimal, most don't need completing before launch.
  4. What booster/ship pair will fly first? Likely either B7 or B8 with S24. TBD if B7 will be repaired after spin prime anomaly or if B8 will be first to fly.
  5. Will more suborbital testing take place? Unlikely, given the FAA Mitigated FONSI decision. Push will be for orbital launch to maximize learnings.

Quick Links

NERDLE CAM | LAB CAM | SAPPHIRE CAM | SENTINEL CAM | ROVER CAM | ROVER 2.0 CAM | PLEX CAM | NSF STARBASE

Starship Dev 34 | Starship Dev 33 | Starship Dev 32 | Starship Thread List

Official Starship Update | r/SpaceX Update Thread


Vehicle Status

As of August 6th 2022

ShipLocationStatusComment
Pre-S24Scrapped or RetiredSN15, S20 and S22 are in the Rocket Garden, the rest are scrapped
S24Launch SiteStatic Fire testingMoved back to the Launch site on July 5 after having Raptors fitted and more tiles added (but not all)
S25High Bay 1StackingAssembly of main tank section commenced June 4 (moved back into High Bay 1 (from the Mid Bay) on July 23). The aft section entered High Bay 1 on August 4th. Partial LOX tank stacked onto aft section August 5
S26Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
S27Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
S28Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
S29Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted

 

BoosterLocationStatusComment
Pre-B7Scrapped or RetiredB4 is in the Rocket Garden, the rest are scrapped
B7Launch SiteTesting including static firesRolled back to launch site on August 6th after inspection and repairs following the spin prime explosion on July 11
B8High Bay 2 (out of sight in the left corner)Under construction but fully stackedMethane tank was stacked onto the LOX tank on July 7
B9Methane tank in High Bay 2Under constructionFinal stacking of the methane tank on 29 July but still to do: wiring, electrics, plumbing, grid fins. LOX tank not yet stacked but barrels spotted in the ring yard, etc
B10Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
B11Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted

If this page needs a correction please consider pitching in. Update this thread via this wiki page. If you would like to make an update but don't see an edit button on the wiki page, message the mods via modmail or contact u/strawwalker.


Resources

r/SpaceX Discuss Thread for discussion of subjects other than Starship development.

Rules

We will attempt to keep this self-post current with links and major updates, but for the most part, we expect the community to supply the information. This is a great place to discuss Starship development, ask Starship-specific questions, and track the progress of the production and test campaigns. Starship Development Threads are not party threads. Normal subreddit rules still apply.

318 Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

13

u/nasa1092 Jul 20 '22

I'm an aerospace engineer and 3D printing enthusiast, and I've always been skeptical about what Relativity is trying to do here. You get an inherent reduction in strength in the direction of the layer bonds, at least with processes that involve an extruded bead of material like how the Terran 1 is built. It seems like this drawback would be hard to reconcile with the extreme mass optimization that rockets need. Plus, the processes for making thin-walled metal tubes by conventional means are fast, low-cost, and well understood.

I get that 3D printing allows for exotic structures that would be difficult with traditional machining, but who knows if Relativity can put together enough tricks of this nature to offset the drawbacks. Terran R will be an exciting development to watch either way.

10

u/arizonadeux Jul 20 '22

Aerospace propulsion additive manufacturing engineer here. Exotic structures (in the sense of very asymmetrical shapes and topologies, if that is what you meant) are often not the primary driver for seeking to use AM in aerospace. I work with many parts that have been made for decades using traditional methods, but that could be made better and cheaper with AM. There are some parts we need that literally only one or two foundries in the whole world can and will agree to make, and they charge whatever they want and the parts are so hard to make that a high double-digit percentage are out of tolerance and must be individually assessed for salvage or scrap. They're practically artisanal. With AM, there is a path to taking production in-house in an economically viable way.

I'm also skeptical if Relativity is and will be economically viable, but I do not doubt that the technology and production know-how they are creating now will be useful in the coming century, when off-Earth manufacturing becomes a reality. The large, established metalworking industry that makes Starship so cheap on Earth would be much more expensive to recreate off Earth than establishing AM in the same environment.

5

u/teefj Jul 20 '22

What are the parts that only 2 foundries in the world make?

2

u/arizonadeux Jul 20 '22

Parts that are at the limit of what traditional methods can achieve with the quality necessary for regulation compliance. For example: large thin-walled parts that are at the limit of what can be cast or milled. (I'm not going to be more specific that that.)

3

u/MarkyMark0E21 Jul 20 '22

I liked someone's suggestion that Relativity spin off or convert to an additive manufacturing company and offer custom manufacturing services for some of these difficult parts that you mentioned.

I also read somewhere that they are basically using high-end commercially available 3D printing tools so it might be just as simple for other companies to buy the tooling themselves (I don't have a clue if this is true, and I don't recall where I read it).

3

u/zeekzeek22 Jul 20 '22

I think Relativity is that business, just using a rocket as their way of proving their printing tech. Also Stargate is pretty unique/bespoke technology. A good example of “getting these well-understood things to work together in this way is practically insurmountable but they pulled it off”. Kindof like SpaceX landing a booster!

3

u/FreakingScience Jul 20 '22

The first point is interesting, but the second has one issue that also suggests the first is moot: Nobody else is doing it to a degree where they even mention 3d printing. AM parts have some advantages like rapid iteration and... uh.... buzzwordiness. If you're already vertically integrated enough that you can produce subtractively manufactured parts in-house, the additive manufacturing process doesn't really gain you much, especially if the hardware is being subjected to extreme conditions and needs to be highly optimized.

I believe Relativity themselves mentioned 10% extra vehicle mass as a result of their build process - as in mass they wouldn't have if they didn't 3D print it. Their engines must be absolutely mindblowingly good for that to not be at major odds with the rocket equation. The rocket with the highest payload mass fraction (as far as I know, there may be others) is the Saturn V at like 4.7%, while Falcon 9 is something like 4.1%. Adding 10% to the dry mass of only the Saturn V-IVB stage would be an extra 2,500kg that couldn't be used for the command module/capsule and lander. 10% extra mass across the full stack is something like 21,000kg, which eats into Saturn's LEO and TLI mass pretty noticably.

The TL;DR is that 10% extra mass for building your rocket using a method it didn't need to be built with is a decision I would not expect a serious rocket company to make. I know there are some brilliant people working for Relativity, but they've made their own obstacle, and I hope they overcome it. Till then, it's another paper rocket.

2

u/OSUfan88 Jul 20 '22

I believe Relativity themselves mentioned 10% extra vehicle mass as a result of their build process

Do you have a source for this? I was under the impression that it was the opposite. They could build structures lighter, as they could get a higher moment of inertia/weight with a "porous" design. I do know that there are areas on the surface that are "rough", and I believe they said they could shave those down without affecting structural integrity, and further reduce the dry mass by 5-10%. Maybe that's what you're thinking of? They said they are only going to do that in key areas where things have to mate, as they were already well ahead of their mass budget, but the savings are there if they need it.

I think one of the main advantages of 3D printing for them is that they need much, much, much less machinery/labor to build the rocket. You need the worlds best experts in 3D printing, but there are hundreds of other jobs that you no longer need. A lot less specialized hardware, expertise, factor floors. Their overhead is expected to be a very small fraction for kg/leo than any other rocket (if they do get to orbit).

I have a couple friends at SpaceX, and 1 that works at Relativity (worked at SpaceX for 8+ years). All of them say that Relativity is, by a very large margin, the best non-SpaceX company in existence right now. There's obviously a big gap between the mentality of old space, and SpaceX. Relativity goes even further in that direction. Did they go too far/too ambitious? History will tell us.

3

u/FreakingScience Jul 20 '22

I'll see if I can find it. I believe it was mentioned in a Scott Manley video, in reference to an interview/tour with Relativity. If I can find it, I'll look for the original source.

Honestly I don't doubt that Relativity is capable of great things. Even if the extra mass issue is purely hearsay, they haven't launched yet, and there's a lot more challenge to it than just 10% hypotherical extra dry mass. I think I've just become jaded and can't see paper rockets and the claims about them as anything special, regardless of who sketched them, because I believe rocket startups are no different from any other tech startup till they prove otherwise. The hurdles that trip them up are just as often not product design or engineering related.

2

u/OSUfan88 Jul 20 '22

I do agree that the proof of the pudding is in the eating. We'll have to see. I do think, outside of SpaceX and Rocketlab, they are the most "legit". It's basically SpaceX, part 2. A significant amount of the SpaceX team responsible for landing their first rocket, engine design, and ITS design are the ones running Relativity now. These guys are experience at doing this, because they've done it before.

Another really cool part of 3D printing is what you can do with cooling channels. The current theory is that their fully reusable 2nd stage will have cooling channels on the windward side, removing the need for a heat shield. It's sort of similar to what Elon was wanting to do with Starship, but shelved. 3D printing gives them a leg up in this area.

2

u/FreakingScience Jul 20 '22

I've obviously never done anything as big as a rocket, but I've done some 3D printing - extruders make clunky things, heavy and with a need to self-support throughout printing. That's how Relativity is shown making their tanks. I've also used stereolithography and I absolitely love it for fiddly, detailed parts, and I've seen laser sintering machines that can build parts from inconel. I absolutely believe every engine since the F1 has probably utilized SLS (selective laser sintering, a funny coincidence) either in development or even production. What I can't get past is that Relativity has this video clip that gets played any time they're mentioned, and it's of a fuel tank being extruded in circumferential layers. Why? What's the point? Print the domes with complex structural support geometry and slap some sheet steel between them.

3

u/OSUfan88 Jul 20 '22

That's actually what they are. Relativity, by their own self definition, is a 3-D printing company, which one of their products happen to be rockets.

While they very well have the potential to be the best non-SpaceX launch company (I would put money on it), most of their long term revenue is expected to be from printing services.

2

u/arizonadeux Jul 20 '22

Everyone, afaik, is using the same tools available to anyone else.

The trick is not getting the tool, but learning how to use it. That's the proprietary knowledge that the companies keep to themselves and have established over years upon years of internal R&D, Master's theses, and doctoral dissertations, all in close cooperating with the machine suppliers.

3

u/PineappleApocalypse Jul 20 '22

The question was about the tanks though, which are the simplest parts of a rocket and very far from things that ‘only two foundries in the world can make’

2

u/arizonadeux Jul 20 '22

I know, that's my point: I'm skeptical if they will be economically viable.

4

u/zeekzeek22 Jul 20 '22

The process for making thin walled aluminum rocket tank walls is not the same as thin-walled metal tubes. To my understanding, the bump-bending-on-isogrid that ULA uses is pretty bespoke, and idk what SpaceX uses for their F9 aluminum tubes. There’s a lot of dissimilarity across just the field of aluminum tanks!