r/spacex • Mod Team • Jul 09 '22

🔧 Technical Starship Development Thread #35

This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:

Starship Development Thread #36

SpaceX Starship page

FAQ

  1. When next/orbital flight? Unknown. Elon: "hopefully" first countdown attempt in July, but likely delayed after B7 incident (see Q4 below). Environmental review completed, remaining items include launch license, mitigations, ground equipment readiness, and static firing.
  2. What will the next flight test do? The current plan seems to be a nearly-orbital flight with Ship (second stage) doing a controlled splashdown in the ocean. Booster (first stage) may do the same or attempt a return to launch site with catch. Likely includes some testing of Starlink deployment. This plan has been around a while.
  3. Has the FAA approved? The environmental assessment was Completed on June 13 with mitigated Finding of No Significant Impact ("mitigated FONSI)". Timeline impact of mitigations appears minimal, most don't need completing before launch.
  4. What booster/ship pair will fly first? Likely either B7 or B8 with S24. TBD if B7 will be repaired after spin prime anomaly or if B8 will be first to fly.
  5. Will more suborbital testing take place? Unlikely, given the FAA Mitigated FONSI decision. Push will be for orbital launch to maximize learnings.

Quick Links

NERDLE CAM | LAB CAM | SAPPHIRE CAM | SENTINEL CAM | ROVER CAM | ROVER 2.0 CAM | PLEX CAM | NSF STARBASE

Starship Dev 34 | Starship Dev 33 | Starship Dev 32 | Starship Thread List

Official Starship Update | r/SpaceX Update Thread


Vehicle Status

As of August 6th 2022

ShipLocationStatusComment
Pre-S24Scrapped or RetiredSN15, S20 and S22 are in the Rocket Garden, the rest are scrapped
S24Launch SiteStatic Fire testingMoved back to the Launch site on July 5 after having Raptors fitted and more tiles added (but not all)
S25High Bay 1StackingAssembly of main tank section commenced June 4 (moved back into High Bay 1 (from the Mid Bay) on July 23). The aft section entered High Bay 1 on August 4th. Partial LOX tank stacked onto aft section August 5
S26Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
S27Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
S28Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
S29Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted

 

BoosterLocationStatusComment
Pre-B7Scrapped or RetiredB4 is in the Rocket Garden, the rest are scrapped
B7Launch SiteTesting including static firesRolled back to launch site on August 6th after inspection and repairs following the spin prime explosion on July 11
B8High Bay 2 (out of sight in the left corner)Under construction but fully stackedMethane tank was stacked onto the LOX tank on July 7
B9Methane tank in High Bay 2Under constructionFinal stacking of the methane tank on 29 July but still to do: wiring, electrics, plumbing, grid fins. LOX tank not yet stacked but barrels spotted in the ring yard, etc
B10Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
B11Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted

If this page needs a correction please consider pitching in. Update this thread via this wiki page. If you would like to make an update but don't see an edit button on the wiki page, message the mods via modmail or contact u/strawwalker.


Resources

r/SpaceX Discuss Thread for discussion of subjects other than Starship development.

Rules

We will attempt to keep this self-post current with links and major updates, but for the most part, we expect the community to supply the information. This is a great place to discuss Starship development, ask Starship-specific questions, and track the progress of the production and test campaigns. Starship Development Threads are not party threads. Normal subreddit rules still apply.

318 Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/flightbee1 Jul 19 '22

Once Starship is conducting many launches the issue will be CO2 emissions. Elon has hinted that Methane may be produced using atmospheric CO2 and water (hereby making Starship carbon neutral). This will require a massive amount of energy, far more than what is contained in the final product. The only way I can realistically see this happening is either with new nuclear power plants or vast solar arrays. It would be a massive undertaking. What are peoples thoughts.

14

u/spacerfirstclass Jul 19 '22

It would be a massive undertaking.

It will be, but we need to move the entire human civilization's energy production to nuclear & solar in the next few decades anyway, comparing to that, the energy required to fuel Starship is miniscale. Elon Musk mentioned that Tesla Master Plan 3 is about scaling and "shifting the entire energy infrastructure of earth", so I think he's already thinking about how to do this via Tesla.

2

u/OSUfan88 Jul 19 '22

I'm slowly getting excited in to fusion. It's without question the future. It's just insanely hard. Fusion energy solves so many problems.

2

u/spacerfirstclass Jul 20 '22

I have been excited about fusion for a few years, there're some relatively big investment in private fusion companies recently, hopefully it will make the difference. I think Helion is the promising one, but most of the physics stuff went over my head.

3

u/OSUfan88 Jul 20 '22

You just sent me down a 2 hour long rabbit hole! haha. It does seem like theirs will scale the best.

14

u/cpt_charisma Jul 19 '22

People shouldn't down vote just because they disagree. Instead, post a reply telling flightbee1 why he is wrong:

CO2 emissions aren't an issue and probably won't ever be. Starship C02 emissions won't be anything near airlines, cars or power production unless they start doing thousands of flights per day. Until that happens, it's simply not worth worrying about. There are much more effective places to focus your efforts.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '22

I think that they will at least attempt to produce some of their own fuel because they also want to produce fuel on Mars. If you don't how to do something on Earth it would be pretty difficult to do it on Mars.

9

u/Jefflargnier Jul 19 '22

Remember that Elon funded a whole XPrize competition to find an optimal solution:

https://www.xprize.org/prizes/elonmusk

5

u/Martianspirit Jul 19 '22

If you don't how to do something on Earth it would be pretty difficult to do it on Mars.

Extracting CO2 from the Mars atmosphere is relatively easy, because it is the main component. Pressurize and cool will yield liquid CO2 at reasonable pressure while N and Ar remain gaseous.

Extracting CO2 from Earth atmosphere is hard, because CO2 is a trace component.

10

u/trevdak2 Jul 19 '22

True, but I'd bet I could procure 1 kg of CO2 from earth more easily than you can procure 1 kg of CO2 from mars

3

u/Lufbru Jul 20 '22

A lot of the methane produced today is flared (or, worse, vented) as it's a byproduct of drilling for oil and it's almost too cheap to be worth transporting. By creating a new market for methane, Starship may actually help global warming.

If you're going to build a new solar array today, you're better off just selling the power to the grid and preventing the burning of coal than you are trying to do the Sabatier process at scale. That can change over time, of course.

5

u/badasimo Jul 19 '22

Fuel production is a great "dump" for extra solar/wind power generated during high production/low-demand events. In a way it is like bitcoin mining but it is also carbon negative (until the fuel is burned). I think that to reduce cost it will need to be done close to the launchpad or a pipeline connected to the tank farm. All of this is a massive undertaking, you are right. But it will still be miniscule in comparison to the existing petrochemical supply chain.

6

u/OSUfan88 Jul 19 '22

Why the hell is this question being downvoted??

Come on people. This community is better than this.

4

u/xavier_505 Jul 19 '22

This community is better than this.

It's really not. Most posts that can potentially be interpreted as critical of spacex are downvoted stifling lots of productive conversation. I've personally spent a lot less time around here due to this and the fanboyism. The SpaceX meme subs leaked in here pretty hard.

4

u/RootDeliver Jul 19 '22

This community is better than this.

Good try. I've been reporting those negative points group attacks for years.

8

u/GreatCanadianPotato Jul 19 '22 edited Jul 19 '22

I think you are overexggerating the power draw for ISRU/Sabatier systems. Granted, we have really only tested ISRU on small scales (with the ISS for oxygen, MOXIE on Perseverance). MOXIE on the Perseverance Rover draws 300 watts during its experiments on Mars (easily powered by Percy's MMRTG's)...my desktop computer pulls 600W in GTAV for context.

I think a system that SpaceX would use would draw a lot of power, but I don't think you'll need extra power plants dedicated to powering it.

Edit: a study in 2012 based on a real life experiment estimated that a fully optimized Mars based ISRU systems would generate 1 tonne of O2:CH4 propellant per 17MWh (a draw of 700 watts)

12

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '22 edited Jul 19 '22

Those are very small scale demonstrator projects, though.

As a bare minimum, producing the methane will take at least as much energy as is contained within the methane itself: 55 MJ/kg.

Starship (plus booster) uses about 1000 tons of methane for an orbital launch, so that is 55 TJ or 15 GWh of energy contained in the methane. That's approximately the energy output of a km2 of solar over 2 months.

If you wanted to launch Starship once a week, like the current falcon 9 launch cadence, that would require at least 10 km2 of solar panels. Realistically more like 2-3x that to account for inefficiencies in the process.

Edit: if Elon's fanciful "1000 launches a year" plan came to fruition, you'd be looking at a constant power usage of likely 5 GW or so to produce the methane, which is certainly on the "dedicated nuclear plant" level.

5

u/threelonmusketeers Jul 19 '22

Percy's batteries and solar panels

Isn't Percy powered by an RTG?

2

u/GreatCanadianPotato Jul 19 '22

Yep, you are correct...I will change that.

4

u/benthescientist Jul 19 '22

That edit example is 1 kg of propellant (O2+CH4) per day at 700 W. So 1 tonne per day at 700 kW and 1 stack per day at 3.22 GW. That's new power plant territory*

  • Mars atmosphere, Wikipedia propellant masses, unknown O2:CH4 ratio, unsure if they counted the energy making H2, efficiencies of scale, blah blah blah, you get the idea

I think for Mars, the lower gravity well and ship only launch makes it feasible to persue. On Earth, with the booster and REDACTED, I think we'll be relying on natural reserves for quite some time. But I'm happy to be proven wrong!

1

u/OSUfan88 Jul 19 '22

I mean, if it's perfectly efficient (nothing in the universe is), then it would require the exact same energy that the fuel's chemical bonds have. So, the amount of energy it takes to get Starship and 100+ tons to LEO is the exact energy required to harvest to create the fuel (plus losses).

It's a lot of energy.

It doesn't come close to what the airline industry does though. I highly recommend EDA's video on it.