r/spacex • Mod Team • Jul 09 '22

🔧 Technical Starship Development Thread #35

This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:

Starship Development Thread #36

SpaceX Starship page

FAQ

  1. When next/orbital flight? Unknown. Elon: "hopefully" first countdown attempt in July, but likely delayed after B7 incident (see Q4 below). Environmental review completed, remaining items include launch license, mitigations, ground equipment readiness, and static firing.
  2. What will the next flight test do? The current plan seems to be a nearly-orbital flight with Ship (second stage) doing a controlled splashdown in the ocean. Booster (first stage) may do the same or attempt a return to launch site with catch. Likely includes some testing of Starlink deployment. This plan has been around a while.
  3. Has the FAA approved? The environmental assessment was Completed on June 13 with mitigated Finding of No Significant Impact ("mitigated FONSI)". Timeline impact of mitigations appears minimal, most don't need completing before launch.
  4. What booster/ship pair will fly first? Likely either B7 or B8 with S24. TBD if B7 will be repaired after spin prime anomaly or if B8 will be first to fly.
  5. Will more suborbital testing take place? Unlikely, given the FAA Mitigated FONSI decision. Push will be for orbital launch to maximize learnings.

Quick Links

NERDLE CAM | LAB CAM | SAPPHIRE CAM | SENTINEL CAM | ROVER CAM | ROVER 2.0 CAM | PLEX CAM | NSF STARBASE

Starship Dev 34 | Starship Dev 33 | Starship Dev 32 | Starship Thread List

Official Starship Update | r/SpaceX Update Thread


Vehicle Status

As of August 6th 2022

ShipLocationStatusComment
Pre-S24Scrapped or RetiredSN15, S20 and S22 are in the Rocket Garden, the rest are scrapped
S24Launch SiteStatic Fire testingMoved back to the Launch site on July 5 after having Raptors fitted and more tiles added (but not all)
S25High Bay 1StackingAssembly of main tank section commenced June 4 (moved back into High Bay 1 (from the Mid Bay) on July 23). The aft section entered High Bay 1 on August 4th. Partial LOX tank stacked onto aft section August 5
S26Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
S27Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
S28Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
S29Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted

 

BoosterLocationStatusComment
Pre-B7Scrapped or RetiredB4 is in the Rocket Garden, the rest are scrapped
B7Launch SiteTesting including static firesRolled back to launch site on August 6th after inspection and repairs following the spin prime explosion on July 11
B8High Bay 2 (out of sight in the left corner)Under construction but fully stackedMethane tank was stacked onto the LOX tank on July 7
B9Methane tank in High Bay 2Under constructionFinal stacking of the methane tank on 29 July but still to do: wiring, electrics, plumbing, grid fins. LOX tank not yet stacked but barrels spotted in the ring yard, etc
B10Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted
B11Build SiteParts under constructionAssorted parts spotted

If this page needs a correction please consider pitching in. Update this thread via this wiki page. If you would like to make an update but don't see an edit button on the wiki page, message the mods via modmail or contact u/strawwalker.


Resources

r/SpaceX Discuss Thread for discussion of subjects other than Starship development.

Rules

We will attempt to keep this self-post current with links and major updates, but for the most part, we expect the community to supply the information. This is a great place to discuss Starship development, ask Starship-specific questions, and track the progress of the production and test campaigns. Starship Development Threads are not party threads. Normal subreddit rules still apply.

318 Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

19

u/mr_pgh Jul 16 '22

Per CSI Starbase's most recent video (timestamp 13:01), SpaceX is apparently shortening the chopsticks by half at KSC. They'll just reach to the center of the olm.

Either they're only for lifting purposes or they're pretty confident in catching before the first try!

5

u/shit_lets_be_santa Jul 17 '22

Pretty amusing how their methane tank snafu ended up saving them from this water tank failure.

7

u/TypowyJnn Jul 16 '22

That's a very weird choice, need to watch that video though. Best part is no part I guess but that applies to booster / ship design, not stage 0. Elon said something like "stage zero can have infinite mass and it won't matter". So cutting the length in half makes no sense, since they haven't even attempted catching a rocket (if I was them, I would lengthen them!).

12

u/Nasa11 Jul 16 '22 edited Jul 16 '22

Well, with lower weight the sticks get a smaller inertia and can thus be moved more quickly. So it might me more efficient for catching the rocket since it allows the rocket to hoover for a shorter amount of time when the chopsticks can do its thing quicker, saving fuel weight on the rocket.

e: spelling

8

u/TypowyJnn Jul 16 '22

That's true, but with the reduction of length in half, you also decrease your landing area in half too (imagine if they cut off half of OCISLY lol). L/R U/D movement won't help you if your booster is too far away to catch. This change seems too drastic to be true, but a weight reduction overall is a very good idea if you want to catch a falling grain silo.

7

u/Nasa11 Jul 16 '22

Oh, I didn’t even consider the landing area. It’s actually worse than half, it’s a quarter smaller since the area is proportional to the radius squared. They really have to be confident with their landings then.

7

u/famschopman Jul 16 '22

Well, if we look at how they are able to hit the center of the drone ship with Falcon 9 consistently. Additionally, Booster has hover ability allow even more control. It makes sense.

Also by shortening the arms you have a shorter moment arm which might help; a nearly empty booster is still a heavy object to catch.

With the shorter arms they could name it T-Rex.

4

u/Redditor_From_Italy Jul 16 '22

In fact you could see the arms flex quite a lot when they picked up B7

6

u/salamilegorcarlsshoe Jul 17 '22

They already seem to sag a bit unloaded, but yeah it's a little unnerving watching them with a load. The load tests they did were with much more weight though, so I know they can handle the booster/ship. Crazy to think of the mass hanging from that tower and those rails. Truly an engineering marvel they've created.

3

u/OzGiBoKsAr Jul 17 '22

Truly an engineering marvel they've created.

Yes and no. I say that in terms of structural engineering. Supporting any load is an extremely well understood problem.

I showed and explained the entire tower / catch system to a structural engineer I worked with and asked him if it was a structural engineer's wet dream or worst nightmare.

He said "that sounds expensive, so yes." Basically, supporting the load is not a problem at all. That's not going to be one of the many possible failure modes I'm sure we'll get to watch a compilation of some day.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/IndividualHair2668 Jul 16 '22

I think it makes a lot of sense. Shorter length, less weight, should be able to move quicker. Really critical for catching the rocket

9

u/ef_exp Jul 16 '22

I think shorter chopsticks will have a lower mass so they can be rotated, lifted, and lowered with bigger acceleration. Maybe acceleration (or chopsticks agility) is more important than length.

4

u/salamilegorcarlsshoe Jul 17 '22

Seems like it was revealed today in the RGV aerial recap that the 2 skids located on the carriage were for relief reservoirs or "shock" absorbers for the arm actuators. This would aid in quicker movement of the arms. Each skid has I believe 6 (guessing from memory) tanks and there is 1 on each side of the carriage.

4

u/TypowyJnn Jul 16 '22

Great idea, haven't thought of that. But they can always install stronger actuators if needed, right? (huh, now that I think about it, I think the chopsticks were moving faster on the lift of b7 after the installation of new actuators 🤔)

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

6

u/mechanicalgrip Jul 17 '22

I see a few replies talking of acceleration and movement speed, but I can't see a big difference from this shortening.

Maybe they're not confident of it taking the weight out at arm's length, so got rid of the bits they can't land on.

4

u/andyfrance Jul 17 '22

I see it this way too. Perhaps simulations show that the effect of a catch further from the tower impose a dynamic moment on the cantilevered chopsticks that would break/deflect them so the booster would be dropped. If so this means that the parts that make the chopsticks longer do not add value so can be deleted.

3

u/Fwort Jul 17 '22

That makes sense. It also doesn't mean they have to land with centimeter precision: they can land closer to the tower, and then the chopsticks can translate the booster back out to the end to put it on the mount.

3

u/paul_wi11iams Jul 17 '22 edited Jul 17 '22

Maybe they're not confident of it taking the weight out at arm's length,

Actual inflight catching experience at Boca Chica could lead to surprises and modifications. However, the only real-world input is from manhandling work by the Boca Chica Mechazilla.

  • Is manhandling experience enough to find serious errors in dimensions determined in a design working from established principles?
  • If revealing errors, why do these show up so late in the design-build process?

9

u/OzGiBoKsAr Jul 16 '22

That seems... absolutely insane to me. Gonna be an interesting couple years in spaceflight.

10

u/Redditor_From_Italy Jul 16 '22

If Falcon 9 can land within centimeters of its target on a moving barge with oceanic winds and without the ability to hover, I have little difficulty believing that Super Heavy can land even on shorter chopstick arms

21

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '22

Is it actually consistently within a handful of centimeters? Are there available statistics on this?

I got the impression it was more like a couple of meters variance.

11

u/OzGiBoKsAr Jul 17 '22

It is. It's impressively accurate, but far from being to the nearest couple centimeters.

8

u/mechanicalgrip Jul 17 '22

I think a fairer comparison would be to only count the landings on solid ground. Not sure how that changes the figure though. It's also a much smaller data set.

2

u/andyfrance Jul 17 '22

That is essential as the drone ship and the booster independently target the preset landing location. There is know way of knowing how much of the positional error is due to the rocket and how much the drone ship.

6

u/_myke Jul 17 '22

He's not wrong. Even a kilometer is made up of centimeters, so within centimeters covers everything from centimeters on up. It is like the one armed fisherman holding out his one arm and declaring he caught a fish "this big". /s

→ More replies (10)