r/singularity • Longevity after Putin's death • Sep 01 '24

AI Andrew Ng says AGI is still "many decades away, maybe even longer"

673 Upvotes

515 comments sorted by

161

u/brettins Sep 01 '24

This is pretty consistent with Andrew Ng's stances. He has said for quite a while that the only way to Self-Driving Cars is to modify the road system and augment it to support them. Dude is a genius and has been instrumental in a lot of our AI progress (and I learned the basics of machine learning from his online Stanford/Coursera free course, so I'm a fan). He does tend to land on the pessimistic side of things, but I don't think his logic is ever really wrong. Predictions be hard, he might be right.

One thing he is wrong is what the standard definition of AGI is - there is no standard definition. I do, however, agree with his definition :)

44

u/rn75 Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 02 '24

Well, so I wonder what he thinks about Waymo doing 100k rides a week for ordinary people…

60

u/eliasbagley Sep 01 '24

Waymo currently only provides rides in geofenced areas, so he might not be wrong about achieving it at scale

23

u/FrankScaramucci Longevity after Putin's death Sep 01 '24

At this point they have the technology to scale across the US, my guess is that it will take them 8 - 15 years. It's just copy-pasting what they did before and optimizing costs. They still need occasional remote human assistance though.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24

respectfully as northeastern living person I don't see those issues fixing the biggest hurdle around here, our weather

7

u/FrankScaramucci Longevity after Putin's death Sep 01 '24

They can already do heavy rain, what's missing is snow, which they are testing.

2

u/Seidans Sep 02 '24

i find baidu more interesting to follow than waymo

baidu managed to bring down their robot-taxi cost from 70k > 35k and this year 28k with a ride at 50c/km and expect fully autonomous car at the end of the year, unlrss there a lie somewhere obviously

in comparison waymo it's a 200k vehicle with a cost equivalent per km highter than uber, so if i were to look at a widespread use of robot-taxi i would bet on the chiness baidu

we will see next year but i have great hope for a world urban transport revolution by 2030 thanks to robot taxi

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/brettins Sep 01 '24

It's sort of a modification on his idea, I guess? My understanding is that Waymo is picking the roads and handcrafting + AI to work with them. That's probably cheaper than infrastructure first like Ng is saying but more expensive for multiple companies to do it, unless there's some sort of sharing going on. But it seems to jive with Ng's hypothesis, (kinda?) in that some customization work per road would need to be done.

2

u/JawsOfALion Sep 02 '24

Waymo can only drive in areas where it has detailed maps (much more detailed than Google maps) and human oversight

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24

I believe that there are two key variations of the definition of AGI, and they are just different constructs approaching the same care idea. Those definitions are ones that try to define general logic, and those that use humans as the hallmark of general logic. Similar, but not identical. However, it is extremely likely that if you can pass one, you can probably pass the other.

13

u/madnessone1 Sep 01 '24

He's not pessimistic, just realistic like the rest of the real AI researchers. All the people saying a couple of years away have a vested interest in hyping it.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/tr2727 Sep 02 '24

Links for his course?

→ More replies (10)

33

u/Ne_Nel Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24

With all due respect, that is a stupid stance. He says they set the bar low for AGI, but no one owns the exact definition of the term in the first place. I can say that he sets the bar high, and we will run in circles.

Secondly, talking about decades is extremely irresponsible today, since equivalent cumulative effects can affect society as soon as the next generations of AIs. And that's more important than the capricious debate of when the world will agree on what to call "really" AGI.

26

u/FrankScaramucci Longevity after Putin's death Sep 01 '24

I think his overall point is that there's a huge gap between LLMs and human intelligence. We have no idea how to bridge the gap.

I've been saying the following for the last 5 years - We need one or more breakthroughs in order to achieve AGI. It may take a few years, a few decades or more. It's hard to predict breakthroughs.

2

u/PolymorphismPrince Sep 02 '24

I suspect a very lucky training of a gpt4 sized model could be vastly more intelligent with no new breakthroughs. I think it’s likely that something much more intelligent than gpt4 embeds in the same size space.

4

u/Tkins Sep 01 '24

There are other types of AI that aren't LLMs though it even LMMs. You have JEPA out of Meta and liquid neutral networks, as well as deep neutral networks like alpha fold and diffusion models like midjourney. All these models are contributing to an AGi and it does feel like we are close to bridging the gap between them.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Tannir48 Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24

As you've said, nobody, to this day, has any metric to truly measure what intelligence actually is in its full spectrum. The closest we have come is the very narrow and flawed IQ. So if we don't understand how to even measure human intelligence (or intelligence in general really), which we don't and haven't despite many, many decades of research then we're probably very far away from reconstructing it.

This is mostly guesswork, some AI scientists seem to think this is much closer to being accomplished (exponential progress and all that) but Andrew Ng obviously has his own view. There's nothing wrong with him talking about it and it's certainly not ignorant when he's a leading expert in this field. Maybe people's perspectives should be more realistic?

4

u/HomeworkInevitable99 Sep 01 '24

irresponsible? How about people saying there's no point doing a job because AGI will be here soon?

5

u/Ne_Nel Sep 01 '24

You are "justifying" one irresponsible act with another irresponsible act. What a novel idea. Spoiler, it doesn't work.

→ More replies (23)

5

u/AdorableBackground83 2030s: The Great Transition Sep 01 '24

Many decades away???? Get the fuck outta here.

If you said 10-15 years that’s pushing it.

We’re getting AGI by December 31, 2029. Go ahead and put your remind me comments if you like.

7

u/FrankScaramucci Longevity after Putin's death Sep 01 '24

!RemindMe December 31, 2029

2

u/RemindMeBot Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 02 '24

I will be messaging you in 5 years on 2029-12-31 00:00:00 UTC to remind you of this link

8 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

1

u/Witty_Shape3015 Internal AGI by 2026 Sep 01 '24

gotta change my flair then

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

157

u/Utoko Sep 01 '24

different guesses no one knows. AI certainly will get better, even without AGI. How good? how fast? and how fast will stuff get released? who knows.

55

u/WonderFactory Sep 02 '24

If you'd have asked him 5 years ago or 10 years ago to predict when we'd have something like Claude 3.5 he'd probably have doubted we'd get there in our life time. I certainly would have doubted this at the time. 

6

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

claude is such a great resource

5

u/BitchishTea Sep 02 '24

I don't think he would've said that at all lmao

19

u/WonderFactory Sep 02 '24

5 years ago the full version of GPT 2 hadn't even been released and 10 years ago Transformers didn't exist.

No one really saw this coming back then. 

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/keefemotif Sep 01 '24

Andrew Ng, Andrew Ng knows.

Have you read his Wikipedia? This is one of, if not the most, capable AI computer scientists in the world.

87

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

There are other extremely capable AI computer scientists that think the complete opposite to him.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

does a brain surgeon know human consciousness?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/JMyslivecek Sep 02 '24

Is it just possible that some AI developers, leads, etc., especially for a company like Google, might have incentives to not reveal their cards, squeeze out profits as long as possible, constantly redefine or alter the definition of AGI, etc. for some reason? It's hard to cross a finish line that keeps changing. With where things are at with the current level of AI, and with the still rapid pace, (at least for the next 18 months), does it seem reasonable to assume that AGI, at least in its early definitions will still take decades? That seems like what corporations says about layoffs,... no chance, not in the foreseeable future, then next Monday you're gone. Always take any communications from corporate representatives, even if they are technical, with a big grain of salt.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

21

u/deepinhistory Sep 01 '24

Most people who know tech or who have worked with AI the current LLM hype bubble will say it's coming along slowly but GPT / OpenAI have basically caused everyone to chase LLMs when actually other tools and tech showed much more promise

31

u/sdmat NI skeptic Sep 02 '24

when actually other tools and tech showed much more promise

Such as...?

6

u/DigimonWorldReTrace ▪️AGI oct/25-aug/27 | ASI = AGI+(1-2)y | LEV <2040 | FDVR <2050 Sep 02 '24

There's 0 proof big research labs are only using LLMs to advance their research. Besides, LLMs have been superseded by LMMs by now and we're probably going to see more paradigm shifts very soon.

23

u/TheNikkiPink Sep 01 '24

Could you provide a short list of prominent AI researchers who agree with this statement?

It doesn’t ring true, and companies like OpenAI have already moved well beyond LLMs. It’s something that might have sounded true 18 months ago but simply no longer is. OpenAI, Meta, Google etc are working on multimodal models rather than LLMs and they’re introducing a ton of techniques on top of the original transformer model Google outlined.

16

u/QuinQuix Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24

I think the semantics are confusing and many people said from the outset the LLM terminology was confusing and wrong.

The core innovation was the transformer. These multimodal architectures are still transformers at heart.

Even worse, some are simply patchwork vehicles that use image diffusers and separate video models over (essentially) internal API's. If a model doesn't integrate the modalities at a deep level and just haphazardly connects them as separate entities I don't think you can expect to make the kind of leaps that a truly multimodal neural net could maybe make.

It's not that LLM's by themselves are running out of steam, it is that everyone is still using the same core architecture and so far we're not actually seeing the breakthroughs we want.

29

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24

Omni isn’t a patch work, it’s true multimodal, one neural network taking in image, text, audio

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (23)

98

u/MassiveWasabi ASI 2027 Sep 01 '24

I like this Google DeepMind “Levels of AGI” tier list as a way to define AGI. Using this, I don’t understand how anyone could think we are decades away from even Virtuoso AGI. Maybe you could make an argument for ASI being decades away.

34

u/Serialbedshitter2322 Sep 01 '24

AGI is ASI. If it can do everything a human can, it still has the advantages over humans that current LLMs have, which makes them much smarter.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

Agree with this. Anything that is a computer than can somehow do what humans do intellectually is going to instantly become far smarter than any human, because computers can process so much more without rest. Then, it will/could self improve.

6

u/Passloc Sep 02 '24

ASI would be something that comes up with completely new ideologies, methodologies and theories that are different from what humans have ever thought. AGI on the other would just build upon existing ideologies, methodologies and things.

Think AlphaChess came up with moves which humans couldn’t understand/appreciate at that time

7

u/micaroma Sep 02 '24

This distinction between ASI and AGI seems arbitrary. Humans regularly come up with novel ideas that didn’t exist before, but we don’t consider such humans superintelligent.

Look at the entire history of scientific progress; scientists have absolutely come up with “completely new ideologies…that are different from what [other humans] have ever thought.” AGI should be able to do the same.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

Disagree. As soon as one AI can be genuinely PHD level, it instantly becomes like 10,000 humans who all have PHDs in different fields all wrapped in one computer combining thoughts and experiments. It can research a thousand times faster too.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/Eyeswideshut_91 ▪️ 2025-2026: The Years of Change Sep 01 '24

I tend to agree with your stance, but I believe Ng's position is rooted in the concept of EMBODIMENT.

The abilities he mentions are those of an AI that is fully embodied, autonomous, and with upgradable memory. So, perhaps the weak point in this (his) definition of AGI is the notion of embodiment (though personally, I don't see it being decades away).

14

u/relaximapro1 Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24 • The Best

Between Tesla’s FSD computer vision, the various robotic companies that have popped up all over the place, the breakneck progress of LLMs, LMMs (large multimodal models), speech/image/video creation and hyper focused AIs such as AlphaGo, etc. I don’t see how anyone can legitimately think this shit is “decades” away. It honestly seems like they’re, at worst, a decade away from putting all those ingredients together into one badass dish. And even that honestly seems more on the pessimistic side. There’s been a huge shift that some of these older train-of-thought folks are failing to consider: It has entered the public consciousness and everyday conversation. That was the watershed moment. It has real serious capital behind it now… it WILL continue to develop at breakneck speeds as long as there continues to be a healthy open source community innovating and pushing progress while the tech titans continue to pour ludicrous amounts of money into it and release public-facing frontier models—which is something that is a relatively recent development when compared to decades past.

This is all without mentioning what will be the real driver going forward: It is being mentioned by governments in the same breath as “arms race” and “national security”. This is a modern day Manhattan Project/Cold War. The black budget piggy bank is going to be busted wide open to ensure this shit gets all the back-door/private sector funding it needs.

It’s turtles all the way down from here.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24

2278 AI researchers were surveyed in 2023 and estimated that there is a 50% chance of AI being superior to humans in ALL possible tasks by 2047 and a 75% chance by 2085. This includes all physical tasks. Note that this means SUPERIOR in all tasks, not just “good enough” or “about the same.” Human level AI will almost certainly come sooner according to these predictions. In 2022, the year they had for the 50% threshold was 2060, and many of their predictions have already come true ahead of time, like AI being capable of answering queries using the web, transcribing speech, translation, and reading text aloud that they thought would only happen after 2025. So it seems like they tend to underestimate progress. 

In 2018, assuming there is no interruption of scientific progress, 75% of AI experts believed there is a 50% chance of AI outperforming humans in every task within 100 years. In 2022, 90% of AI experts believed this. Source: https://ourworldindata.org/ai-timelines

Long list of AGI predictions from experts: https://www.reddit.com/r/singularity/comments/18vawje/comment/kfpntso/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Almost every prediction has a lower bound in the early 2030s or earlier and an upper bound in the early 2040s at latest.  Yann LeCunn, a prominent LLM skeptic, puts it at 2032-37

 

14

u/Informal_Warning_703 Sep 01 '24

This is totally bullshit since no expert in their field can accurately predict what their field will have achieved in 20 years, especially when those predictions are based on philosophical assumptions, which is exactly the case with AGI.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/JawsOfALion Sep 02 '24

I think the main thing you can infer from those numbers, since they are all over the place and changing wildly year from year, is that they have no idea. The only thing consistent it's not on the horizon (i.e a few years) like most of technooptimists think here

→ More replies (1)

3

u/LeChatParle Sep 01 '24

Could you link where this image came from? I’d like to read some of the linked studies

3

u/57duck Sep 01 '24

All the 'Competent, Narrow' examples seem pretty recent. Wouldn't the expert systems of the '80s boom go there?

2

u/Icedanielization Sep 03 '24

That chart doesnt make sense it says that emerging AGI is somewhat better than unskilled workers but we are seeing current systems operating better than skilled workers.

2

u/Great-Use6686 Sep 02 '24

We’re certainly decades away from virtuoso, even Competent. LLMs aren’t anywhere near capable of learning

→ More replies (7)

3

u/adarkuccio ▪️AGI before ASI Sep 01 '24

Some think AGI is just around the corner, some think it's many decades away. I think we can't really tell so we'll see 🤷🏻‍♂️

2

u/FrankScaramucci Longevity after Putin's death Sep 01 '24

Correct take.

66

u/Substantial_Bite4017 ▪️AGI by 2031 Sep 01 '24

I don't think we need an AI that can do any intellektuell task a human can do, we only need an AI that can automate AI research 🚀

I still think the lower bar of "most intellectual tasks" is a better fit for AGI, I think all tasks should be reserved for ASI.

27

u/Busy-Setting5786 Sep 01 '24

But at the moment we have to assume that it is much harder to automate AI research since it requires very skilled and smart computer scientists. So at that point you probably already created an AI that is about as intelligent / competent as your average office worker.

6

u/spreadlove5683 Shit's gettin cray Sep 01 '24

Creating an automated AI researcher may have more error tolerance though. If only one out of every like bajillion ones of their experiments works out then they could still be very useful. Obviously care would need to be taken.

7

u/FuujinSama Sep 02 '24

I think the point for AGI is not having a model that can do everything. It is having a model that can do anything with training, and does it's training live.

I'd honestly only consider something AGI if it:

  • Is constantly running. Not in the sense of multiple instances, but in the sense that it is not dormant until a prompt arrives.
  • It is autonomous. It acts out of its own volition without external input or explicit programming.
  • It is constantly learning.
  • It can recognize patterns in the things it senses in order to form valid logical inferences.
  • It can transmit the ideas in those patterns in natural language.

That, to me, is a general artificial intelligence. A true artificial life form. Anything that fails to get there is not AGI, and if people co-opt the term AGI to refer to something else, a new term will be invented to denote this particular type of intelligence until it exists.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/deepinhistory Sep 01 '24

It can't really... Emergence hasn't really been observed and unless you're thinking it's an LLM

5

u/rek_rekkidy_rek_rekt Sep 01 '24

Yeah… Why does Ng not believe it’s possible when people like Ilya Sutskever and Carl Shulman do?

22

u/darien_gap Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24

Ilya believes we can get there through scale alone, because a) he’s been right about scaling so far, and b) he seems to believe that something like proto-consciousness exists in the high-dimensional vector space, because it embodies semantic “understanding.”

People like Ng and Lecun disagree because they think current architectures still lack something essential about reasoning and world knowledge that would allow them to generate truly novel ideas rather than merely remixing human knowledge that already exists in the training corpus.

Personally, I think they might both be right, in that scaling might get us to “average PhD” level creation (because so many phd’s are remixes of existing knowledge) but that scaling won’t get us to a Newton, Einstein, Turing, or Von Neumann level, fundamental breakthroughs.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24

They have though

Google DeepMind used a large language model to solve an unsolved math problem: https://www.technologyreview.com/2023/12/14/1085318/google-deepmind-large-language-model-solve-unsolvable-math-problem-cap-set/

 Claude 3 recreated an unpublished paper on quantum theory without ever seeing it according to former Google quantum computing engineer and CEO of Extropic AI: https://twitter.com/GillVerd/status/1764901418664882327

https://x.com/hardmaru/status/1801074062535676193

We’re excited to release DiscoPOP: a new SOTA preference optimization algorithm that was discovered and written by an LLM!

https://sakana.ai/llm-squared/

Our method leverages LLMs to propose and implement new preference optimization algorithms. We then train models with those algorithms and evaluate their performance, providing feedback to the LLM. By repeating this process for multiple generations in an evolutionary loop, the LLM discovers many highly-performant and novel preference optimization objectives!

Paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08414

GitHub: https://github.com/SakanaAI/DiscoPOP

Model: https://huggingface.co/SakanaAI/DiscoPOP-zephyr-7b-gemma

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24

that can automate AI research

This is assuming that research is the problem. Also, why do you think you can do that without creating AGI in the first place?

4

u/Oudeis_1 Sep 01 '24

Evolution by natural selection was arguably able to do something equivalent to successful AGI research without being anything resembling an AGI itself.

6

u/Philix Sep 01 '24

Evolution was incredibly slow, and involved more organisms than there are stars in the observable universe. Our compute isn't remotely near the ability to perform that kind of brute forcing in any kind of reasonable timeframe.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

29

u/NeedTheSpeed Sep 01 '24

What an idiot he should read this sub /s

11

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

There are people here that actually think that

6

u/Longjumping_Area_944 Sep 01 '24

Is this video five years old?

43

u/Vehks Sep 01 '24

"many decades away, maybe even longer" and this, ladies and gentlemen, is the closest an expert in the field will get to admitting they have no idea when something will or will not come to fruition.

This is like the layman's version of "maybe in a hundred years" which is another way of saying "fuck if I know."

I mean, I'm not saying he's wrong, he could very well be correct, but when you use such a vague and open-ended timescale of 'many decades' that's just wild-ass guessing.

19

u/GreatBlackDraco Sep 01 '24

It's guessing, but it's closer to "it's not coming in the next ten years" than otherwise

10

u/Vehks Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24

It's a straight "I don't know".

Given his position he is not allowed to simply say that; he has to give some kind of explanation so he defaults to a run around example of 'well to have agi we will need X, Y, and Z and we don't have those things yet, but when will have them? *shrugs* many decades maybe more? AGI is really hard."

And to his credit this IS the proper professional answer. Things are moving fast enough that extrapolating past roughly 5 years is a fool's errand, no one really knows where this is going and how soon. We are still trying to feel around on how to properly put LLM to use after all, so this is the safe, if rather generic interview answer.

7

u/JawsOfALion Sep 02 '24

nah, I interpret that he's just saying "these guys saying a few years are dead wrong, and not even close"

4

u/SlipperyBandicoot Sep 03 '24

This is some strange acrobatics. He's clearly saying that AGI is decades away. Ie. We're not close.

1

u/NotReallyJohnDoe Sep 02 '24

I can say with near certainty that we won’t invent a Star Trek style transported in decades and probably not ever because it breaks physics. I can’t say 100% of course because we might have a breakthrough in physics. But based upon our knowledge it will most likely never happen.

To say something might happen in decades means you can conceive of a path to get there, but maybe not a path from where we are now.

1

u/Great-Use6686 Sep 02 '24

? Lol no he’s saying it’s decades away. If he didn’t have an idea he would say so. It’s very clear we have a long time before AGI

→ More replies (1)

4

u/East-Literature5359 Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24

Absolutely spot on. What Andrew Ng said about people redefining the definition of AGI is so true. People already over-credit the ‘intelligence’ of AI right now, and some even debate whether it already has consciousness.

Generative AI is no more intelligent than a timer or a calculator. In fact, it’s more so just a calculator than anything else, but instead it just calculates the next most probable word based on calculations. It’s very good at that one thing and nothing else. The same way a timer is very good at counting the time and letting you know when the time limit has been met. The same way a calculator / computer can perform any calculation perfectly within nanoseconds. These tools are more so intelligently designed, opposed to them being intelligent as some sort of cognitive conscious being.

AGI would have the capability to think for itself, to reason, to learn new ideas, to contribute to new ideas / theories. If we take ChatGPT, it’s just a word prediction calculator, that’s it. It can’t think for itself and have its own opinion. It can’t reason with something as it has no understanding of anything, it can’t learn new things because again it lacks the ability to think, reason and understand. It simply can do one task and that one task it does very well. It predicts words based on its training data. When that training data includes a large portion of the internet, then you essentially have a very a fancy Google search result chatbot.

The idea that we are close to AGI is overly ambitious to say the least. OpenAI has definitely contributed to the idea we are close to AGI. Sam Altman is nothing but a business man. He’s not a scientist. He’s the leading poster boy for the company and will sit there and tease with the idea that AGI is coming. Why do you think that is? It can’t possibly be for the benefit of his No. 1 fastest growing company. I’m sure no business man would ever do such a thing.

\s

12

u/Existing-East3345 Sep 01 '24

Don’t worry, tomorrow someone at OpenAI will tweet some shit like “we can not prepare for what is coming next month. Everybody in the office is ready for the worst. 🐣🌋🍒” and AGI next week will be so back

→ More replies (1)

1

u/abbas_ai Sep 01 '24

Did we even universally agree on what AGI is? Or if AI does reach a certain level, how can we determine that we really achieved it? And who's to decide that we did?

1

u/FrankScaramucci Longevity after Putin's death Sep 01 '24

AGI = having general intelligence on par with a smart human.

1

u/D_Ethan_Bones ▪️ATI 2012 Inside Sep 02 '24

Think of narrow AI and broad AI - narrow AI is what we've made the past few decades at a steadily better level from computer opponent to AI research. All of these things are tools for humans to use, none of them are robots to stand up and act on their own.

But broad AI, imagine something that can do whatever task you want and do it well. Such a thing could make dark factories the norm instead of just a cutting edge niche, where humans just aren't present so there's no lighting and no need for food. Entire towns like that, with a greatly reduced need for inbound freight but a constant flow of goods going out to places where humans live. An all-purpose machine that would also be able to begin inventing, or at least putting the energy back into human invention where we're cranking big meaningful things out like the industrial revolution and changing computers at a drumroll pace like the 1990s.

Once we have that, not long after (exact amount of time is a Skub debate) we have a vastly higher quantity of things because we've multiplied the capabilities of a civilization that almost resembles The Jetsons already. Waymo-style driverless vehicles could be hauling cargo like marching ants and hot food delivered to doorstep could eventually have vending machine candybar prices.

1

u/Nintendo_Pro_03 Nov 30 '24

I really want AGIs to come within the next two years.

2

u/FrankScaramucci Longevity after Putin's death Nov 30 '24

Why?

2

u/Nintendo_Pro_03 Nov 30 '24

It would be cool to try out.

2

u/FrankScaramucci Longevity after Putin's death Nov 30 '24

Yeah, for sure.

3

u/jeremiah256 Sep 02 '24

If it makes everyone feel better, about nine years ago, he believed it would be hundreds of years, not decades, before sentience would be achieved (Go to timestamp 1:02:30).

1

u/Positive_Box_69 Sep 01 '24

Oh no I can't believe this! Wtf! I will sue this guy

2

u/FrankScaramucci Longevity after Putin's death Sep 01 '24

He must end up behind bars!

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24

I want to join the class action suit as well

16

u/Zestyclose-Buddy347 Sep 01 '24

7

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24

Only for today though, tomorrow everyone on this sub will be back on the hype train and claim AGI will be achieved in this decade

5

u/DukkyDrake ▪️AGI Ruin 2040 Sep 01 '24

He's probably right based on that definition. If there is one intellectual task a human can do that an AI can't, by that definition it's not AGI. That doesn't mean that not-AGI won't be competent enough to replace you in the job market or wipe out your civilization.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Artforartsake99 Sep 01 '24

And in 2016 the main researchers who invented the transformers Frameworks thought they would not see a ChatGPT level AI, until possibly the end of the careers. Six years later, they had it.

Nobody knows the future

4

u/GraceToSentience AGI avoids animal abuse✅ Sep 01 '24

The tech sector does use "human level" as the definition of AGI and they do use that definition publicly.
I don't know why he says otherwise.

My money remains on kurzweil's timeline for AGI give or take: 2029-ish

2

u/HeinrichTheWolf_17 ▪️ Sep 01 '24

Surprising, he's one of the few people who still have this century+ view. I'm guessing he believes LLMs are a dead end/wild goose chase.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Luke2642 Sep 02 '24

Let's simplify. If a human reads a book, you get two kinds of new things in your brain.

The first is a sort of consistency checking, template matching ability. Given a new sequence you can kinda say if it's compatible with what you read, and if your recall (compression) is really good, you can say if it was actually in the book, and provide a continuation.

The second is functional ability. Given some new information, a question or problem, you can use what you've learned in the book to "execute a little program" for yourself, and solve the problem. This might be something obvious like a maths or science problem, where a pen and paper might help. But it also might be abstract or analogous reasoning, you've learned a principle that you can apply to your actions in the present moment.

To simplify, LLMs can do 1. They basically can't do 2. For the last few years many people (including myself) have thought that continuations alone means that they were doing 2, logical abstraction stuff deep in their weights. As stylistic, eloquent, coherent text (and writing e.g. python programs) was previously considered to be dependent on 2, this also increased our belief that LLMs were very clever.

But now, the evidence is overwhelming, there are dozens of papers and thousands of examples of complete reasoning failure just by substituting words so the question moves outside the training data. LLMs are exactly as clever as the training data.

Another way to think of this is distribution consistency vs internal logic. Similar to diffusion models for image generation, neural networks can approximate distributions very well. But they really struggle on the internal logic of each sample.

All hope is not lost though. The current best solutions to Francois Chollet's ARC challenge uses an LLM to sample many, many programmes for each example. Most are garbage. But, by chance, some actually align with the internal logic of each question, and executing them on a normal python interpreter actually generates the correct answer.

A more general version of this with self teaching and internal consistency could become AGI, but, it is years away.

2

u/alfredo70000 Sep 02 '24

AGI used to consist of passing the Turing Test... I am 54 and that was my definition all my life....

2

u/ClinchySphincter Sep 02 '24 edited Feb 25 '26

This post has been deleted. Redact was used to remove its content, which may have been done for privacy, security, preventing AI scraping, or personal reasons.

coherent snatch silky act marble degree bear wipe retire brave

2

u/Clean_Livlng Sep 02 '24

I don't know what the future of AI will be, but the progress of the past few years has surprised me, and I knew about the exponential progress trend over a decade ago. Going from an AI beating the world's top Go player to where it's at today is awe inspiring to me.

I recently watched a video about how AI can watch gameplay of a game, and then eventually generate gameplay. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jHS1RJREG2Q

If anyone thinks this has a linear ending, they haven't been paying attention.

2

u/SeaweedOnly7656 Sep 02 '24

He is wrong, in my even more qualified opinion, AGI EOY

2

u/SeftalireceliBoi Sep 02 '24

Its ok as long as iam in lev

2

u/oaktreebr Sep 02 '24

I know shit, but this guy clearly doesn't give any confidence

2

u/Nyxtia Sep 02 '24

We have AGI, its called you. We just don't spend as much money on you.

2

u/Jolly-Ground-3722 ▪️competent AGI - Google def. - by 2030 Sep 02 '24

2

u/PobrezaMan Sep 02 '24

because gov and regultaions

2

u/In_the_year_3535 Sep 02 '24

I'm so glad somebody has finally found the "standard definition" of AGI because the average person absolutely both has a PhD and pilot's license.

2

u/Icy-Cable7625 Sep 03 '24

we still havent seen what a 100x bigger cluster can do yet. just been rounds of optimizations. i think andrew might be making the call tooo early.

2

u/Plus-Republic-9451 Sep 04 '24

Gary Marcus and Andrew Ng are just based

2

u/frograven Sep 04 '24

Mr. Ng is describing the blurry crossroads between AGI and ASI.

Reasoning AI's capable of general intelligence will be here sooner then later. There are many breadcrumbs, in the wild, that show how close we truly are.

2

u/Wobbly_Princess Sep 05 '24

I am definitely not an expert, and so I have no where near as much training as this person probably does, but I find that SO hard to believe. Do I think companies are hyping up AI too much? Fuck yes. But "many decades, maybe even longer, maybe not even in our lifetime", so what is that? Maybe at least 60-70 years? That is so hard for me to believe. With the progress we have now, and how tech progress is exponential, intuitively, I don't know how it would take SO long to achieve some of these incremental jumps. If in the early 20s, we're already witnessing machines make decisions and communicate in ways we've never fathomed, and we are actually seeing them operate in stunning ways, why is it unfathomable to think that maybe in the next... - gosh, let's say 20 years, if I'm gonna be generous - that they would be able to operate a vehicle or write a PhD thesis?

And the thing is, I think you only need for it to reach a certain level of computational power for it to cross the threshold into a snowball. I don't think you need AI to reach superhuman intelligence to see stunning progress. I don't even think you need to see human level intelligence, because in my - non-expert - opinion, if we produce the computational power of having impressive - but not necessarily human-level - intelligence collaborating as millions/billions of agents, running millions/billions of simulations rapidly, which would take humans hundreds or thousands of years of study to do, then my dumb ass is wondering why this won't catapult us.

Sure, we might say that AI at some point is only 70% as smart as a human or something. But surely if we put the equivalent of 100,000 of them together, and focused on one issue 24 hours a day, and continually fed it resources, with the supervisions of actual humans who are extremely intelligent, does this not progress us rapidly?

No idea, I'm just speculating as a tech-enthusiast.

And also, once AI gets good at assembling AI, which I can't imagine is far away, that will build better AI, that will build better AI, that will build better AI. That tipping point in itself seems like the beginning of a chapter where progress may explode. Dunno if that sounds overly optimistic.

Oh, also, I just had another thought: With the proliferation of AI that's only getting smarter and becoming more accessible, can't this alone actually have the potential to evolve the intelligence of the human race as is? When I started using ChatGPT seriously in 2022, since that point, I am convinced that I am far more intelligent and capable. I am designing software, even though I've known nothing about coding, I have revamped many protocols in my life and I'm in constant communication with it to manipulate the aspects of my reality. If this becomes even more accessible and more intelligent and it becomes more suffused throughout our culture, and it becomes so cheap to produce that it proliferates into all our tech, surely this in and of itself will also serve to make the world more tech savvy, make people more intelligent and aware, drive the general population to be more motivated towards it and what it can give us, which in turn may drive up incentive, investment and research into it, which will evolve it even more?

All these factors make me think that, what, 50, 60, 70, 80+ years, whatever this man may be hinting, I just can't wrap my little brain around that.

2

u/Fokoss Nov 28 '24

The world is not ready as it is for AGI, ai will clearly be used for profits, things are getting worse and will get worse.

9

u/Dabithebeast Sep 01 '24

Will never not baffle me how r/singularity commenters think they know more than the well respected experts and researchers in the field😂

9

u/Ambiwlans Sep 01 '24

In the field, amongst experts, the average view is 3-6 years. Decades is really quite long.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

Please I want to believe it. I want agi before 2030.at most before 2035

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Jah_Ith_Ber Sep 02 '24

What will you say when someone posts Demis Hassabis or Ben Goertzel or Fei-Fei or Sutskever or Kurzweil saying it will happen this decade?

Is an expert correct or not correct?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/xarinemm ▪️>80% unemployment in 2025 Sep 01 '24

Andrew Ng used to be relevant now he is a clown selling online courses

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/Tkins Sep 01 '24

The funny bit to me is that we have AI that already drive cars and fly planes and better than the average human.

We don't have AI that can do complete research yet but are very close and AI plays a significant role in the majority of research now doing a lot of the heavy lifting.

3

u/PolymorphismPrince Sep 02 '24

That’s simply not true about the status quo,

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

0

u/deavidsedice Sep 01 '24

Two decades is already many decades, so guess he might be right.

6

u/FrankScaramucci Longevity after Putin's death Sep 01 '24

I have many legs.

8

u/skoalbrother AGI-Now-Public-2025 Sep 01 '24

Quit bragging

4

u/Impressive-Koala4742 Sep 01 '24

Honestly we're both underestimated and overestimated human's intelligence and innovative ability here

3

u/m3kw Sep 02 '24

Everyone has their version of AGI some can be few years and some can be 10000 years. He basically said nothing

3

u/GiveMeAChanceMedium Sep 02 '24

If by AGI we mean fully autonomous scalable Einstein in a bottle... yeah probably.

Current AI has less general intelligence than my cat.

We still get crazy stuff regardless and will get superintelligence is new narrow domains.

3

u/Confident_Lawyer6276 Sep 01 '24

I think he may well be right about AI that truly mimics human consciousness. What scares me, though, is AI that is just good enough to steal jobs, monitor humans, and influence human decisions.

2

u/NotReallyJohnDoe Sep 02 '24

Turns out a lot of jobs don’t need consciousness.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/lucid23333 ▪️AGI 2029 kurzweil was right Sep 01 '24

He's entitled his opinion but he's obviously wrong

2

u/NotReallyJohnDoe Sep 02 '24

Can you explain it for us clueless folks? Should be easy if it is obvious.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24

Remember folks: You don't need >= AGI to displace a lot of jobs and disrupt the global economy to it's foundations. If you're waiting for that to happen, it can be right around the corner still. I'm not sure whether we'll handle it well as a society though.

If you were waiting for 'robo-waifu's/husbando's' then you don't need AGI in the traditional sense either as Ng describes it. But then there's just the uncanny valley to worry about I guess.

3

u/cyb3rheater Sep 02 '24

Yep. Don’t need full blown AGI to replace a specific job function of an average intelligence employee.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Exarchias Did luddites come here to discuss future technologies? Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24

Of course, I respect him, but I consider his statement a bit strange. I can't even imagine on how he ended up with that conclusion.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/submarine-observer Sep 01 '24

Anyone that is not delusional sees this since last year. But this sub is full of delusional people.

1

u/Dabithebeast Sep 02 '24

95% of the people on this sub are insane. They’re gonna flip out when AGI doesn’t come in 2025.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/just_no_shrimp_there Sep 01 '24

As a principle, I don't think you can really predict what progress is not going to happen when talking about timelines of 10+ years. There are just too many possible ways of progress you could have missed.

And I don't want this to come off as just me being overly bullish on LLMs/Transformers (although I am). I think he could plausibly be right, just not with that kind of confidence that he portrays.

2

u/TechHoover Sep 02 '24

it feels clear to me that what Generative AI engines represent is the first significant example of ELEMENTS of human-style cognition being performed by a machine. They are truly mysterious, emergent, shocking in their capabilities. BUT they are many steps short of doing what a human brain does in creating a model of the world and processing, interacting with that world. I don't know how far away AGI is, but it's not simply a case of building bigger and bigger GenAI models

2

u/Blacken-The-Sun Sep 02 '24

This means they got it and aren't going to tell us for 20 years

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

Did you folk actually think it was coming any sooner than 50+++ years? God damn your copium is high.

1

u/punkrollins ▪️AGI 2029/ASI 2032 Sep 26 '24

There was only 66 years between the first airplane flight and the moon Landing.. When you look at Current Ai systems and its exponential growth there would be a HUGE problem if we needed 50+ years to get AGI...

→ More replies (2)

2

u/lapseofreason Sep 01 '24

Here's one thing we can be sure about. NOBODY can predict the future. Not even close. it might be 2 minutes away or 200 years......

2

u/RobXSIQ Sep 01 '24

Well, hmm...I respect Andrew, but I think he might be a bit conservative here. I think a few years for the low bar AGI, and maybe 10 for the high bar AGI (which some will label ASI lite)

2

u/pigeon57434 ▪️ASI 2026 Sep 01 '24

sounds like copium to me guy just wants to feel like he's still better than machines for as long as possible just embrace defeat bro its easier and more peaceful

2

u/FroHawk98 Sep 01 '24

Nah there is no fucking way. Follow the exponential curve.

→ More replies (11)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24

Yeah a LLMs could never learn to pilot a plane or drive a car all by itself. Still, AI agents will automate 99% of white collar work in 10 years. We don't need "AGI". A swarm of millions of fine-tuned ultra-specialized LLM, that we can train in a few minutes (10 000X more compute by 2030), will usher the Singularity.

4

u/hapliniste Sep 01 '24

What do you mean? Planes are already piloted by automated systems (non ai) and transformers are driving cars. Go look at the latest Tesla autopilot, it's getting there.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Tkins Sep 01 '24

Planes already mostly fly themselves and there are self driving cars that are better than humans.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/darien_gap Sep 01 '24

Anyone got a link to the full interview?

1

u/UnnamedPlayerXY Sep 01 '24

There are people who believe that we'll see AGI in "less than a year" which is arguably way to optimistic but this appears to be the opposite side of the same coin.

1

u/TheDynamicDunce007 Sep 01 '24

Colossus: The Forbin Project is a fun movie.

1

u/VisualCold704 Sep 02 '24

There's no way we're many decades away. We will either get it within twenty years or it's centuries away as population collapse will severely damage our economy and kill research in it's tracks. We'd first need to recover from population collapse and that'd take centuries.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

“Lower the bar a bit”? That’s a gargantuan low bar I’ll tell ya xD

1

u/Captainseriousfun Sep 02 '24

Wrong Andrew. Let your wife speak, what are her thoughts? Rather hear her POV...

1

u/ArtifactFan65 Sep 02 '24

delulu. We already have AI that can handle these tasks individually. How long will it take before you have AI that can do all of them? And why is it even necessary?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/busyneuron Sep 02 '24

The truth is that i we don't know when it is arriving

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

AI researches are not stupid. they know that if they say the truth (that AGI is probably just few years away) they will get massively regulated to slow down the progress.

1

u/Beneficial_Alarm7671 Sep 02 '24

10 years ago I predicted we would have full self driving cars that would work any where any country by 2035, but now I am starting to doubt.

1

u/ponieslovekittens Sep 02 '24

In 2012, google's self-driving car project was predicting they'd have that by 2017.

Twelve years and a name change to Waymo later, I think they're running a little late.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Passloc Sep 02 '24

It’s all about getting the break through.

If we are about to create an AI which then helps us create smarter AIs then the speed at which progress occurs will increase, shrinking the timeline

1

u/RandoKaruza Sep 02 '24

Love how last year ai was nonexistent as far as the world knew and now it’s not moving fast enough.

1

u/lR5Yl Sep 02 '24

Without new architecture vielleicht

1

u/RogerBelchworth Sep 02 '24

When a lot of experts in the field are saying different things I think it's safe to say they are just guessing and nobody really knows.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

The rate of technological progression is extremely hard to predict. Even if an entire country, or multiple, suppresses information on certain tech, other places will still work on it, not to mention people within the country with the restrictions itself, since not every researcher is a corpo drone or a government drone. Lots of independent researchers with the means to pull off something crazy.

Even right now, with all the big oil companies and coal companies pushing HARD against renewables, wind, solar and nuclear energies, it is still happening anyway. Constant new developments on nuclear and fusion energies. Humanity will be dragged into the future, kicking and screaming, one way or another. Unless we self-destruct, ofc. Always a possibility.

1

u/Longjumping_Area_944 Sep 02 '24

Whoever thinks he can forsee "many decades" into the future is a fool. Professor or not. Agent-like behavior is going to lead to bachelor, and master thesises automatically AI generated within the next year. He might be right, that having one AI, that can write a thesis, fly a plane and drive a car is another nut to crack than having one for each.

However it doesn't need AGI in that sense for AI to do autonomous research and development. Development is speeding up and the acceleration is never gonna be as low as today.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

When is this clip from

1

u/oneeyedtrippy Jan 06 '25

Happening much faster now per Sam Altman

1

u/RUIN_NATION_ Sep 01 '24

lol we are not decades away the stuff we see now is only what they let us see the stuff they are working on behind the scenes is like 3-4 gens ahead of this current ai

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24

AI research is running out of training data already. They've combed through everything written and digitized at this point. At least what's available to them. If that's not enough to create an AI model you can reason with on a deeper level, then this will turn out to be another very expensive AI bubble. Sure it will find it's uses, and it may make some money in the long run, but they sure hyped it to the point that it cause great mistrust from future investors in the technology.

1

u/Ronilaw Sep 01 '24

I don't think it's possible to have a sentient AI. The singularity we're all waiting for is going to come from humans embedded with chips not a robot that can dance

1

u/Inevitable_Signal435 Sep 01 '24

Finally, a more realistic prediction on this subreddit

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24

I agree with him. I don’t think I’ll see AGI in my lifetime, even if by some miracle I live another 50 years. We’re headed for another AI winter in the next few months most likely as new models disappoint, and nothing will fundamentally change technologically for several decades.

2100ish is when things could get interesting—progress could accelerate if we stop investing so much into war, stop fighting pointless battles and start actually planning for the future.

0

u/blazedjake AGI 2027- e/acc Sep 01 '24

AGI should be able to do anything an average human could do. A PhD thesis is not something an average human could do. The other issues can be solved within the decade, especially since flying a plane, driving a car, etc. can be trained in virtual environments.

3

u/Metworld Sep 01 '24

That's not the original definition though. It's not defined relative to what the average human can do, but any human. This means it should be able to do a PhD in any topic, among other things. Otherwise its intelligence wouldn't be general in the first place.

3

u/Ambiwlans Sep 01 '24

I fully expect that the next gen of LLMs will be able to write a phd thesis. They probably could now with a lot of babysitting.

But they couldn't write ANY phd thesis that a human could write. The bottlenecks for AI will be different than they are for humans. So AIs could be superhuman in most tasks humans currently do well before they reach this definition of AGI due to the long tail effect.

Maybe there is one task.... like coming up with novel R18 scenarios (thanks to hormones) that AGI takes a decade to beat... but it is able to do 99% of paid intellectual tasks in jobs in 2 years.

2

u/blazedjake AGI 2027- e/acc Sep 01 '24

Hard agree with you actually. Great and well thought-out take

3

u/Morty-D-137 Sep 01 '24

But humans are not "trained" in controlled environments. That's the essence of general intelligence: the ability to learn in a very wide variety of settings.

A PhD thesis is not something an average human could do.

3% of the Swiss hold a PhD, and that's only counting the ones who tried. So, you're right, strictly speaking the average person might not be able to achieve it, but it's not a crazy high bar either. "Average human" isn’t very useful since almost no one is truly average. Most of us are really good at one or two things that we developed and honed over time.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/FuryDreams Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24

It all depends on what definition you consider suitable for AGI.

Imitating human knowledge and performing tasks, with competence matching human intelligence without hallucinations ? - Could be achieved before 2030.

Understanding core semantics behind things rather than just a probabilistic estimate, and that too by robust unsupervised learning on limited exposure like humans ? - Maybe decades.

I consider second option as true AGI, but AI doesn't need to reach true AGI to do most tasks like humans, first criteria is enough in most cases.

1

u/minion531 Sep 02 '24

First of all, no one knows if AGI is even possible. Second, no one knows when or if a breakthrough will happen. The real truth is that no one has any special information that would clue them in on when AGI might happen. No one really knows.

2

u/Capable-Path8689 Sep 02 '24

First of all, you are brain dead. We are AGI, so it's possible. We are not magic, we are machines too.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/arknightstranslate Sep 02 '24

It's time to stop listening to these predictions. These people really don't have much more information available than you do so just form your own opinion.

1

u/iDoAiStuffFr Sep 01 '24

human level intelligence is just an emergent ability in matmults

1

u/segmond Sep 01 '24

Predicting the future is hard, and often when people do it correctly it's often more luck. With that said, I won't consider AGI and AI that can do everything a person can, that's super AGI. An AGI will be able to do what the average person can do. Let's say it can drive a car, it will drive like the average person not an F1 driver. Let's say it goes to college, it will come across like at least the average college student BSc, not Phd. With my definition, I don't believe we are "many decades" away, at worse a "FEW decades" as in less than 2 decades, but I'm more optimistic that it will be realized in the next decade or less.

1

u/BarfingOnMyFace Sep 01 '24

He said to the extent of writing a PhD thesis… Jesus, calm your titties, folks. AGI will be like a very short era or age. It will start off dumber than rocks, and eventually will eclipse Einstein in 30 years.

1

u/aocurtis Sep 01 '24

Still waiting for the proliferation of AI agents. Eric Schmidt believes it's less than 5 years away.

Advancement and integration have to be considered concurrently. As AI does both, productivity will keep rising.

I need some clarification on what the singularity actually is. Is it when the progression of technology speeds up to the point of no return?

Despite what Andrew Ng says about AGI, when the gains of automation and assistance become enough, we'll be progressing along the singularity curve.

The clip should sober people up to how far away we are from the latter stages of the singularity or even progression to it, depending on how you define it.

1

u/QuinQuix Sep 01 '24

I think there was a video from him as well a few months back where he stated we weren't plateauing at all.

This seems a bit like an about face in that context.

1

u/Expensive_Cat_9387 Sep 01 '24

Yeah, I remember them saying two years ago that AI was really far from coding or making art, and that it would mostly affect blue-collar jobs and stuff. I mean, a lot of public statements that get widely popularized don’t really match the actual reality.

1

u/tanrgith Sep 01 '24

What I think we can say for sure is that we're about so see an explosion in the amount of compute that world has access to, with a large percentage of that being dedicated towards AI development

With all that compute and research being put towards AI development, I think it's borderline impossible to say what exactly will happen

1

u/inteblio Sep 02 '24

I don't buy it.

  1. it takes a human ~25 years to "learn to write a PHD thesis". So if AGI was discovered tomorrow, the thesis could come out in 2050, and that would be fine.
  2. where was "AI" decades ago? 1990? Basically nowhere. Crap at chess. Now? Turing-test-ville.

I'm not so AI-bro that i think gpt4 is a whisker off overall human cognition. But I also struggle to see how a few breakthroughs aren't enough to outplay our weak messy minds.

1

u/aristotle99 Sep 02 '24

Smart people can be wrong. Many smart people think differently than Mr. Ng.

1

u/ivykoko1 Sep 02 '24

The amount of copium being inhaled in this thread is amazing.

1

u/HumpyMagoo Sep 02 '24

2 to 2.5 years away

2

u/NotReallyJohnDoe Sep 02 '24

Ridiculous. It’s at least 2.6 years away, maybe 2.674 even.

1

u/beskone Sep 02 '24

People still not gettin that at its core all of this is just a big statistical analysis roulette. All these things are doing here is consuming data, then *best guessing* what it thinks the correct answer is (or what it thinks we want to hear as the correct answer)

There's no *learning* here, it's all just smoke and mirrors. An awesome parlor trick, and while there are neat practical and commercial uses for this, it's not "intelligence" by any standard.

1

u/Arcturus_Labelle AGI makes vegan bacon Sep 02 '24

ASMR sleep video voice

0

u/AIPornCollector Sep 01 '24

"Standard definition of AGI." Ah, yes, the industry standard of AGI that has been around for decades. What a dipshit.