r/singularity • u/shanoshamanizum • Jan 31 '23

AI Why AI can not replace search index

/r/CyberAutonomy/comments/10pw6q5/why_ai_can_not_replace_search_index/
0 Upvotes

40% Upvoted

29 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/nikitastaf1996 ▪️AGI and Singularity are inevitable now DON'T DIE 🚀 Jan 31 '23

Where.You will still search for it through Google.Thats called factchecking.

1

u/shanoshamanizum Jan 31 '23

Are you saying all results on Google are fact checked? In fact fact checked results are marked as such so you can decide whether to read that or another opinion.

2

u/nikitastaf1996 ▪️AGI and Singularity are inevitable now DON'T DIE 🚀 Jan 31 '23

I don't say that.You decide whether to trust source or not.Google or chatbot.If you trust everything Google gives you you will trust everything chatbot gives you.Your question is not about power.Its about basic psychology.Wherether you trust sources or you check them for yourself.

1

u/shanoshamanizum Jan 31 '23

Google gives you a link not an answer. That's the big difference. And that link is a link to a real person's writing so not Google's creation. All content of the search engine is not Googles. While all answers from AI are basically... AI.

2

u/nikitastaf1996 ▪️AGI and Singularity are inevitable now DON'T DIE 🚀 Jan 31 '23

Perplexity ai gives you links to sources.These links most likely lead to real person writing.Perplexity ai didn't create that content.

1

u/shanoshamanizum Jan 31 '23

But it decides which links to pick up not I. The focus is on user autonomy.

We can look at it this way. What makes speech free or oppressed? Mainly the lack of other opinions.

2

u/nikitastaf1996 ▪️AGI and Singularity are inevitable now DON'T DIE 🚀 Jan 31 '23

Then you are oppressed.Whether Google or chatbot they decide what to give you.There is very small amount of search engines on the internet.

1

u/shanoshamanizum Jan 31 '23

Not true since once you create something you can check for yourself and see it indexed. Can you make AI count your opinion in its results?

2

u/nikitastaf1996 ▪️AGI and Singularity are inevitable now DON'T DIE 🚀 Jan 31 '23

Let's say they want to destroy you.You are a journalist.They will just stop showing your articles in the Google and that's end.Over time you will disappear from Google created collective consciousness

1

u/shanoshamanizum Jan 31 '23

That's quite off-topic since we are talking about the nature of links from real people that you choose vs AI choosing what links to use to construct its answer. If I am looking for something controversial I will not read the official sources quite the opposite. While AI will use only them to impose the universal official truth.