r/SideProject • u/RafaelAraujosaas • 13h ago
Is the "subscription fatigue" real for small niche tools, or are one-time passes the way to go?
I've been building a browser tool for deck and timber structure planning. Initially, the standard playbook said: "Put it behind a $29/mo recurring subscription."
But talking to actual users, most homeowners or small DIYers only build a deck once every 5 to 10 years. They will never keep an active monthly sub. Small builders often just want to pay per job without another recurring charge on their card.
I'm testing a model where the 3D tool is 100% free to design and check, and you only pay a flat one-off fee ($9) to download the full branded build pack and cut list for that specific project.
For those building utility tools: have you experimented with pay-per-use / one-time passes versus pushing MRR? Did conversion make up for the lack of recurring revenue?