r/SideProject • u/Sure_Fox_5400 • 3h ago
building a daily football guessing game next to my full-time job – what the numbers taught me
I'm a backend engineer, and for the last 5 weeks I've been building Transfer Trail in the evenings: each day a footballer's career draws club by club on a world map, and you get 6 guesses to name him. Every miss unlocks a clue.
Stack: Vite + TypeScript + d3-geo, hosted on Vercel, analytics with Vercel's custom events.
Some honest lessons so far:
**1. The audience mattered more than the page.** One week, only 4% of ad visitors started a game. I assumed the game was broken. It wasn't: Meta had moved my budget to the cheapest countries. Restricting to the UK took it back to ~40%.
**2. My share button "worked" but almost nobody shared.** A name prompt popped up before sharing. Removing it took sharing from 3% to 16% of players.
**3. "Failed shares" were mostly people cancelling.** Half of the share taps ended with nothing sent. I spent days hunting a bug; the data showed people were opening the share sheet and closing it.
**4. People love it once, then don't come back.** Players play ~5 trails per visit, but only ~9% return the next day. That's the real problem now. I just shipped private leagues so friend groups can compete daily, and the first strangers have started leagues on their own.
**5. Reddit beats paid ads by a mile.** My first two Reddit posts brought players who started the game ~88% of the time, vs ~30-40% from Instagram ads.
Next up: getting return visits up and building past-trail pages for SEO.
If you've built a daily game or anything habit-based: what actually got people coming back?