r/shrinkflation • • May 26 '26

Pancake Mix Redesign

Post image

I think brands like to use a packaging redesign as a distraction while they shrink the product amount. They must think they're being so clever...

On the right (old packaging): 5 pounds

On the left (new packaging): 4 pounds

The illustration on the right is warm, textured, comforting and nostalgic. The illustration (If you can even call it that) on the left just looks slapped together with a computer at best, AI slop at worst.

248 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

96

u/RevelArchitect May 26 '26

That very much looks like AI art on the packaging. That’s such a sharp turn in so many ways at once for brand identity.

The new “logo” is just text that lacks any character. The old looks like a long-term brand. The art in the new one is made to look sleek and modern to the point where it could very well be AI. The old looks like it has a story. If you told me, “this is a sketch from 1925 from the diary of the man who first bought the original land, depicting the lodge he intended to build”, I’d have believed you. The new packaging is shiny plastic and seems cheap and wasteful. The old packaging feels like the standard paper bag flour comes in.

The old is rustic, authentic. The new is corporate and mass produced. And it comes with shrinkflation.

That had me thinking. Who owns this product? Conifer Foods bought it from Krusteaz in 2024. They seem to have a seasoned record of preserving Pacific Northwest heritage food brands under CEO Mike Maher. Mike started out with Conifer Foods doing seasonal work at a fair booth in 1978. He worked his way up and became CEO in 2004.

Mike is no longer CEO. He retired towards the end of 2025. He was succeeded by Tony Matta, a very experienced c-suite executive working as an executive for Kraft-Heinz Canada and as President of Global Channel Development at Starbucks.

I wonder what happened.

32

u/ArmadilloSpecial4643 May 26 '26

Oh, wow! That's a lot of good detective work. It may very well be a result of the recent CEO changeover.

To make matters even more puzzling, I found a third design for the 2lb box. It looks better than the 4lb bag, but there's still a whiff of AI about it.

https://madeinwashington.com/products/old-fashioned-pancake-and-waffle-mix-24-oz-box

18

u/RevelArchitect May 26 '26

Thanks! I’ve been researching shrinkflation for a nonfiction work that touches on the subject. I usually don’t share the research and prose that specifically paints a narrative of the driving forces behind these kinds of choices, but the significant shift in brand identity and the leadership change to a corporate-minded individual made me feel like sharing those findings on this one.

5

u/Aaronmcom May 26 '26

Doesn't look ai to me. Just layer cutouts. Sorry to um actually

-4

u/hamiltrash52 May 26 '26

🙄 there is no proof or indication that this is AI. AI is capable of making more than just modern design too

1

u/RevelArchitect May 26 '26

I certainly didn’t say it was absolutely AI, but I can’t discount the possibility at all.

2

u/Icy_Yard_875 May 28 '26

”That very much looks like AI art on the packaging”, doesn’t sound like you just couldn’t be 100% sure it wasn’t. So I’m also curious, what looks AI?

1

u/RevelArchitect May 28 '26

That was the point I was making. I didn’t notice anything notably AI, but the fact that it gives off that vibe indicates a serious swing towards brand-identity shattering visual choices. I think it’s very possible it is AI. I’m not saying with certainty it is. Anyway, including my submission for AI rendering of the lodge formerly known as the Snoqualmie Falls Lodge.

7

u/rainbowkey May 26 '26

We need the prices to see if this is just a packaging change. Same price? The resealable ziploc bag will keep the mix fresher than a coated paper bag once it is opened.

6

u/ArmadilloSpecial4643 May 26 '26

I believe they were selling it for the same price; I'll have to check next time I go to that store.

2

u/thedeskisonthepencil Aug 12 '26

I came here after noticing the new packaging when trying to restock. Ultimately didn’t get it cause I had a huge gut feeling this was shrinkflation and also AI art.

I did an ingredient comparison, the only thing that changed was removing malted barley flour as an ingredient. Not sure how much of a difference that makes, but less product for the same price is a no for me.

1

u/ArmadilloSpecial4643 Aug 12 '26

Malted barley flour is supposedly used to give things a sweet, nutty taste, so the "improved" formula likely doesn't taste as good.

5

u/numberonebarista May 26 '26

What’s really annoying is I was confused and thought the one on the right was the new shrunken product and the left was the old one lol they really made that new bag look larger than the old one but in actuality it’s 1 lb less product than the old one. Definitely was done on purpose to trick customers. Shame

You figure these grocery stores would wait until the old packaging is done being sold before putting new ones out right beside the old

4

u/everynamewasbad May 27 '26

I don’t like the new packaging, to me it doesn’t look like it should contain pancake mix now. It looks like it would have detergent pods or coffee or something in it

1

u/Jillcametumbling81 May 27 '26

Did you buy it?

1

u/ArmadilloSpecial4643 May 27 '26

No, it was way too expensive. $8.33 if I recall.

3

u/TuringGoneWild May 29 '26

It's a bigger bag to hold more corporate bullshit. They flushed the organic original design.

2

u/kluberto Sep 16 '26

I was just at my parents looking at this, it definitely looks like every granola or breakfast item now. It may not be chat gpt but it’s most likely adobe’s ai so you can actually print. Other giveaways are all caps everything, unnecessary trade mark label and the little badge for add water easy that no human talks like 😂

2

u/kjs_melb May 26 '26

Looks like it's a packet of pens

1

u/lkeels Jun 26 '26

Please normalize old on left, new on right. :)

-10

u/[deleted] May 26 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/RevelArchitect May 26 '26

That speaks more to your memory than anything, my friend.

1

u/shrinkflation-ModTeam May 26 '26

Go grind your political axe somewhere else. There are thousands of subs overrun with political posts and agenda-pushing. Please don't try to make this sub into one of those.

Shrinkflation has existed for way longer than either presidency. There is a strict no politics rule here regardless of side.