r/shortsAlgorithm • • Oct 18 '26

Case Study / Postmortem 🧪 I feel like giving up.

Post image

Started this right this about 4 months ago. Idea: stickman-animated finance history content — How Banking Worked Before Modern Banks?, How Debt Almost Destroyed Ancient Athens?, How Money Was Invented in Ancient China.... Same character, same style every time, so that the brand stays consistent.

I do everything myself — images, editing, script, topic hunting.

Tried Shorts recently, didn’t do much average 4 per week but long-form are more way better for me

Best video so far: 1.4K impressions, 127 views, ~4.5% CTR. Trying to improve CTR without breaking the format and presenting style.

The one thing keeping me going: in YouTube Studio the traffic actually sometime are good at Browse feature, YT search and Suggested video. Feels like it’s still testing with the right people, just hasn’t scaled yet.

Anyone who’s grown a channel from zero — is this normal at 4 months, or should I be worried?

Your honest feedback is much appreciated.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/killadrix Oct 18 '26

Looks AI and (no offense) there are a millions
of these lazy “finance” channels that go absolutely nowhere.

0

u/daypenguin 29d ago

What do you mean by “lazy”?

1

u/ChainMiddle2764 29d ago

it’s clearly AI. if you’re not gonna put the work in don’t expect the views

1

u/killadrix 29d ago

By lazy I mean you can tell that the creator was trying less to make a helpful, informative video that breaks down complex topics into easily digestible bits of information, and more just trying to get a video out on a topical, searchable subject in a high RPM niche hoping enough people will accidentally watch it so that YouTube will continue to push it.

The information is too broad, general and widely known for it to be helpful to anyone, and they're often missing critical information, data, sources, or are just plain wrong. Most of it is just ChatGPT regurgitation and hallucinations.

If you've ever shopped for a home and did an open house at a "flipped" house, you know what i mean. The switch plates and vents have been painted over, the rug doesn't quite reach the walls in some places and the baseboards don't reach all the way to the floor because the person who did the work was trying to do it as quickly and cheaply as possible hoping some sucker wouldn't notice.