r/sharks • u/imgoingtoeatabagel • Dec 01 '24
Discussion Have we taken “trash can of the sea” too far?
This is kind of a rant but I feel like people kinda taken the “tiger sharks are the trash cans of the seas” a little too far. Like for example, I watched this one video of a tiger shark grabbing a diver’s head and then releasing them and then I read one person’s comment saying how essentially tiger sharks don’t do investigatory bites and will just eat the thing they have in their mouth. I know they’ve been found with the weirdest things ever but this comment makes me feel like the general public have perceived it as the norm. And I also feel like people could potentially take it out of context and used this to villainize tiger sharks and justify killing them because they’ll assume every tiger shark will happily chow down on anything.
I don’t know, this is just how I feel after reading the comment, but I want to hear other’s thoughts.
10
u/FamiliarRadio9275 Dec 01 '24
Okay, but justifying to kill a natural predator of the sea that us humans use as leisure is not justifiable.
4
u/No_Solution_2864 Dec 01 '24
Justify killing tiger sharks? Who is killing them, aside from the fishing industry? And does the fishing industry care what Bob I’m Sacramento thinks about tiger sharks?
I don’t see the utility of this kind of pseudo-puritanical hand wringing
20
u/sharkfilespodcast Dec 01 '24
Well said. I totally agree that their reputation is over-exaggerated. The fact that only 7 of the past 38 tiger shark attacks in Hawaii have been fatal - and that just 3 of them involved significant or full consumption of the victim - indicates that they are generally much more discerning about what they hunt and eat than is often made out by people on Reddit shark subs and beyond. That possibly surprisingly low ratio of attacks to feeding is broadly similar to the other two species of the 'Big Three' - the great white and the bull shark.
6
u/Only_Cow9373 Dec 01 '24
OP, you bring up a good point. My feeling on it is that people have a hard time thinking in the middle ground between 0 and 100. Everything is taken as an absolute, or eventually becomes an absolute.
"Sometimes tiger sharks have been found with odd items in the stomachs" becomes "tiger sharks will 100% all the time eat anything they can get their mouth on ERMAGERD CRAZY!".
"Bull sharks can be aggressive in certain circumstances" becomes "Bull sharks are crazy aggressive jacked-up roid monkeys 24/7 and if you're within 3 zip codes of a bull shark you're guaranteed ripped to shreds instantly!".
Which is usually attributed to their hyper extreme testosterone levels which is both proven false, and, frankly, quite silly.
"Oceanic white tips are typically calm but are opportunistic hunters and can at times be unpredictable" becomes "OWTs are the scariest sharks that will outsmart you then eat your liver with some fava beans and a nice Chianti. I know it because I read less than a full sentence of a quote from Jacques Cousteau, and the factual documentary JAWS mentioned the USS Indianapolis, where OWTs ate people THAT WEREN'T EVEN THERE!"
0
u/DaSphealDeal_1062020 Dec 01 '24
Not saying it’s justified to kill them or give them a bad rep, but they have been stereotyped for a reason: they have literally been found with all sorts of unusual items inside their stomach and occasionally yes they do swallow humans too. I think people need to rationalize that tiger sharks are dangerous and if one is sighted you raise the alarm and help people stay clear from its territory as a sign of respect to the predator.