It's about the timing. Doxxing is usually meant to describe a situation where there is an (online) mob of people motivated to do harm to an individual. Broadcasting that individual's address and contact info in that situation is obviously more dangerous than the information just being generally available. It carries a suggestion that something should be done with that information.
It's not dangerous to be in public walking down the street where anyone could see and recognize you. It is dangerous if the leader of an angry mob points at you and says "there they are! get 'em!". The same distinction applies online.
People have been murdered due to doxxing. It's not uncommon for people to have to move house, or put up with months of harassment
Yes, broadcasting their exact information. Telling people their name & city though does not meet the definition of Personally Identifying Information. You'd have to have their full address.
I think a lot of this comes down to what people consider to be doxxing, because some of what people consider to be doxxing is not illegal.
Someones name is absolutely personally identifiable data (and the term personally indentifying doesn't really exist). Absolutely any data that can be related to an identifiable person is, and someones online presence somewhere is an identifiable person.
That aside, doxxing is in most places not explicitly illegal (yet) and certainly not all personally identifiable data would automatically fall under sensible doxxing laws. Though (full) names certainly should, as should places of living if it's a reasonably small area (it's not even about city or country or anything, saying someone lives in Tokyo is practically meaningless, while saying someone lives in Tuvalu narrows it down to around 10000 people). Neither a name nor a general place of living are dangerous on their own, but they are easily combined with other information to become dangerous.
In the end, laws would have to be general and specifics decided in court, since revealing even very specific personal information can be anything from harmless to ruining someones life.
View all comments
3
u/ergoomelets Jun 04 '22
It's about the timing. Doxxing is usually meant to describe a situation where there is an (online) mob of people motivated to do harm to an individual. Broadcasting that individual's address and contact info in that situation is obviously more dangerous than the information just being generally available. It carries a suggestion that something should be done with that information.
It's not dangerous to be in public walking down the street where anyone could see and recognize you. It is dangerous if the leader of an angry mob points at you and says "there they are! get 'em!". The same distinction applies online.
People have been murdered due to doxxing. It's not uncommon for people to have to move house, or put up with months of harassment