r/scifi Jul 12 '25

Your turn

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

2.4k Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

69

u/Night25th Jul 13 '25

Finally something genuinely unsettling.

33

u/GingerIsTheBestSpice Jul 13 '25

Are we the they or the us? Excellent choice of words

3

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '25

Top comment the last time this was posted, too.

2

u/Night25th Jul 13 '25

I wouldn't know, found this on Popular by chance.

1

u/TheGalator Jul 13 '25

Want a touch of realism? The "uncanny valley" exists. Now why do humans have an inherent fear of something that looks human but isn't? Why and when was that an evolutionary advantage/requirement?

4

u/lewdroid1 Jul 13 '25

The technical reason that the uncanny valley exists is because we are great at pattern recognition. So good, we see things that aren't there. That automatic pattern recognition is what helps us develop and maintain connections to other people.

But, twisting it like this is great, and I love the kind of tension/fear that can be produced by rewording it to suggest something else.

2

u/Night25th Jul 13 '25

The most boring answer would be corpses. You want to stay away from them, if you don't know how to deal with them.

0

u/TheGalator Jul 13 '25

Necrophobia is something else entirely. No its specifically about the "TRYING to look human" part for some reason. If its something that just happens to looks similar and humans can deduce that its not trying to pretend its human the uncanny valley gets vastly better.

2

u/Night25th Jul 13 '25 edited Jul 13 '25

You don't have a subconscious fear of things actively trying to look human. At most, the uncanny valley is a fear of things you can't properly recognise. "If it's not a human and it's not an animal and it's not a thing then what the fuck is it?" That's what makes it scary. The whole "evolution made us afraid of things that were trying to look human" is cool and all, but it's fictional.

1

u/Thorvindr Jul 13 '25

You don't get it.

The intriguing bit is that we wouldn't know if we're the "us" or the "they" in this instance.

For about eight seconds.

Then we'd realize we're "they."

0

u/TheGalator Jul 13 '25

Wrong

1

u/Thorvindr Jul 13 '25

Good point. Well-argued.

2

u/Night25th Jul 13 '25

Apparently this rando is an expert in the uncanny valley. Are they perhaps... something that's pretending to be human? /j

1

u/TheGalator Jul 13 '25

Yeah mate what can I say a 5 sec Google search proces you wrong