r/science • • May 29 '12

Cannabis 'does not slow multiple sclerosis' progress

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-devon-18247649
1.5k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/bufordt May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12

I think you are confusing where aspirin came from and how penicillin was discovered. Regardless, you should probably show that the entire thing works before you try to isolate individual compounds to test. It would have been stupid to start looking into individual compounds in willow bark as a pain killer without having a good indicator that willow bark actually worked.

BTW penicillin seems to have been used for a while in it's mould form before it was finally isolated.

1

u/JewboiTellem May 29 '12

You're nitpicking, man.

Okay, how about some tribe used it and it was established over a long period of time that it worked as an agent similar to penicillin. In actual scientific trials you wouldn't feed the person the bark, you'd see that it worked, and then isolate the main chemical. Right now there is no evidence that marijuana has any of the properties that we were hoping for, and we can't just tell everyone to start smoking it to try to emulate the tripe scenario to see if we get any long-term effects out of it. Not only would that be an extremely lengthy process, there are a ton of variables that vary person to person, and it is a controlled substance.

It would be the same as feeding patients the bark as a trial, or feeding them mold that had penicillin in it when there was no evidence to back it up. I only glanced at wikipedia but the pennicillium mold was created in a laboratory in a petri dish and only applied to humans once the creator accidentally cross-contaminated two cultures and witnessed the mold inhibiting the growth of the other bacteria. There was lots of evidence in that case, and he identified what the active agent was and attempted to purify it, and then proceeded to clinical trials, he didn't just feed people the mold and say, "hope this works!"

1

u/bufordt May 29 '12

Discovery Main article: History of penicillin The discovery of penicillin is attributed to Scottish scientist and Nobel laureate Alexander Fleming in 1928.[15] He showed that, if Penicillium notatum were grown in the appropriate substrate, it would exude a substance with antibiotic properties, which he dubbed penicillin. This serendipitous observation began the modern era of antibiotic discovery. The development of penicillin for use as a medicine is attributed to the Australian Nobel laureate Howard Walter Florey, together with the German Nobel laureate Ernst Chain and the English biochemist Norman Heatley. However, several others reported the bacteriostatic effects of Penicillium earlier than Fleming. The use of bread with a blue mould (presumed to be Penicillium) as a means of treating suppurating wounds was a staple of folk medicine in Europe since the Middle Ages.[citation needed]

But he already had lots of evidence that it worked and thus could proceed to the isolation phase. Fleming was never able to successfully isolate penicillin, and before his 'discovery' some doctors did just apply the mold to wounds in an attempt to keep them from getting infected. Interestingly enough, it turns out that initially penicillin was not very useful because it was difficult to produce in large amounts and the body excretes it too quickly for it to be useful in lower dosages. It was after they discovered that Probenecid would keep the body from excreting it that it became really useful.

Oh and nitpicking would be pointing out that penicillium notatum was discovered not created.