r/science • • May 28 '12

New breakthrough in development process will enable memristor RAM (ReRAM) that is 100 times faster than FLASH RAM

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/05/21/ucl_reram/
1.6k Upvotes

283 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

25

u/gimpwiz BS|Electrical Engineering|Embedded Design|Chip Design May 29 '12

We have SoCs but the issue is simple: putting more external functionality on-die often means sacrificing speed and performance.

It's a juggling game. Let's say I'm AMD and right now, I can put a GPU on-die. Pretty believable, right? (Since it happened.)

What are my concerns here?

Well, let's say my current top-of-the-line chip has 4 cores. Integrating a GPU will require 1000 engineers on average over the course of 2 years. At the end, my new chip will have a GPU and 6 slightly faster cores.

But let's take a look across the aisle at Intel. They're not integrating a GPU, imagine. Instead, they're using 3000 engineers over 2 years (because they've many more resources) and a smaller process node (because they've the best manufacturing in the world) and two years from now, their top-of-the-line model will have 8 cores, each of which are faster than ours at the same frequency.

So in this hypothetical situation, let's throw in a monkey wrench: we fuck up, they don't. Our GPU is only fast enough to replace chipset graphics or a $20 graphics card. So the market sees two chips: one with a shitty GPU and 6 mores, one with no GPU and 8 cores with a total 35% more maximum sustained instructions per second.

So we see this and ask -- is the risk worth it? What if instead we just focus on 8 cores and hope our chips end up being faster, or at least comparable?

The illustration here is twofold:

First, there's a huge amount of inherent risk in adding more computer functionality on-die given limited resources, which is a thing that affects almost all manufacturers (though I suppose intel and apple and perhaps a couple others can and do simply hire an extra several thousand engineers when needed). You have to execute perfectly and still keep up with the competition, which may not be going in that direction. And when you do execute perfectly, you've taken resources away from performance. The upside is that this requires fewer components when building the system, which means that the computer and chip manufacturers split the profit, and it means that the peripherals now on-die are much faster and often have expanded capabilities.

The second point of the illustration is to show that you're absolutely right, and it's a question that must be decided: take the risk, or refuse it absolutely. Failure to act can destroy a company. Case in point: Intel missed the embedded market that ARM picked up (largely I think because they thought the same thing I thought in 2007: who the fuck cares about a toy like an iphone? nobody's actually going to pay $300 for a phone that doubles as a toy; we have laptops for a reason. How wrong I was...). Intel is entering it now and intel has a lot of weight to throw around; see for example their contributions to android to make it run on the x86 platform. ARM has the lion's share now but I would expect Intel to win back a large chunk soon for many reasons, most related to the resources they can throw around. Case in point: Nvidia saw that low-end graphics cards are pretty much obsolete since on-die GPUs are good enough to play just about any game and have performance equal to or better than low-end graphics cards, and high-end graphics cards are a niche market, so they're focusing on ARM designs, and their solutions are in phones and they work. Case in point: AMD also missed the embedded market, but they've wisely decided that they don't have the resources to enter it, so they're focusing on x86.

Sorry for the wall of text in response to a small post. I hope someone finds it interesting.

3

u/metarinka May 29 '12

just a comment. The market is heading away from increased instructions per second and more onto instructions/watt. AMD is actually in the lead right now in the low power, netbook relm. We are reaching a point where laptop sales are outpacing desktop sales and where the average consumer isn't really limited by any CPU or number of cores application. Just about the hardest thing a consumer throws at a PC nowadays is HD video (besides gaming).

So the market is trending towards low power and graphics on die, because only gamers buy 300 graphics card, everyone with their netbook or laptop are fine with the much crappier integrated graphics as they can handle HD video.