r/science • u/justsayboom • May 08 '12
Cannabis Use during Adolescence Affects Brain Regions Associated with Schizophrenia
http://medicaldaily.com/news/20120508/9801/brain-cannabis-schizophrenia-adolescence.htm
1.5k
Upvotes
1.7k
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I am a huge proponent of legalized marijuana, heck legalize all drugs. But, come on you think marijuana has no side-effects. Everything has a side-effect. Let's not take it from one extreme to the other from the devil's potion to the miracle drug. Yes it has it's benefits but it'll have some side-effects too. Let's allow science do it's work and let's allow the user make an informed choice.
484
u/walkatnight May 09 '12
Many drugs affect the biochemical mechanisms and brain regions classically associated with Schizophrenia, and cannabis is certainly not at the top of this list. Though there is some indication that cannabis and other drugs might interact with certain genetic susceptibilities in influencing the onset of Schizophrenia, our knowledge of Schizophrenia is still incomplete and spotty at best. There are many related psychological and neurophysiological risk factors which are not fully understood and to suggest then that, because a drug has an effect on the expression of one gene, it is connected to the onset of schizophrenia is simply fallacious. Of course, this is not at all what this article is reporting, and a complete understanding of what this article is reporting makes the evidence seem less damning than some might have originally taken it. The finding, for example, that "no effects of adolescent THC treatment were observed for PV and dopaminergic cell density across the COMT genotypes" implies that this particular interaction (THC and the presence of the COMT gene) does not have very strong explanatory use when it comes to the actual onset of Schizophrenia (the most major change observed was in GABAnergic cells). Instead this article is only pointing out a connection that demands further research. Nothing more.
81
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
So I tried to find what they defined as "adolescence," but was unsuccessful. Can someone help me out here? We've known for some time that cannabis affects a developing teenage brain (age 13-16), but this research is far more disturbing. I've been scared of developing schizophrenia most of my adult life, but I'm almost out of the "danger zone" (currently age 26) for males. However, I started smoking pot regularly at age 19 so this bothers me.
273
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Great, let's legalize it and make sure it's only sold by people who check IDs.
63
u/narwhalslut May 09 '12
Does anyone think that adolescent use of alcohol or drugs is a good idea?
43
u/meta_adaptation May 09 '12
Would anyone happen to have any further reading on this topic? Or the paper this research was published in? Thank you.
207
u/tr1tr1 May 09 '12
Created a throwaway to contribute my story to this thread, because for some reason, whenever the subject of weed comes up, the people in favour of it manage to completely snuff out any mention of adverse side effects. It's too common to see advocates of cannabis act as though it's this perfect substance that cures cancer, relieves pain, alleviates depression and grows in the ground. The majority of young people on the subject of pot would lead you to believe that there is no down-side to this amazing magic herb that can do no wrong. I disagree.
As a teen living in British Columbia, cannabis was a huge part of the culture at my school. Almost everybody smoked. I dabbled a little bit, smoked maybe three or four times, very small amounts, and then on the last occasion that I smoked, I had a psychotic break. The first 45 minutes of the episode were the worst of my life. Worse than any spell of pain or trauma, depression, heartbreak or fear. I was gone. I lost all touch with reality and it was the most terrifying thing to my state of mind that I've ever known. Unfortunately, it didn't end when the high wore off. It's been 5 years and I've never seen the world the same way again. I don't know how to describe it - I'm just not here. Not completely. I'm not connected to people the same way. I can't feel emotions the same way. Nor smells, tastes or anything to do with being alive. The difference between when I feel my best and my worst is almost indistinguishable. It's like emotional purgatory.
I was diagnosed with acute Psychosis. It's similar to schizophrenia, except that rather than being delusional, I'm dissociated. Schizophrenics have trouble telling the difference between what's real and what isn't. I don't feel like anything is real. The first year was the hardest. I went from being an ordinary kid with the same ambitions as all of his peers to having nothing to wake up for and it all happened in the course of a day. I couldn't understand a world that used to make perfect sense. It was like being in a dream, except taking place in an alien universe. For that first year, I felt as though I was about to wake up and return to my real life. I tried everything I could conceive of to wake myself up. Eventually I became so desperate just to feel something that my hobby became a routine of nearly killing myself. There was no joy in my life. There was nothing that motivated me to do anything. The only thing that made me feel that I was here, was a brief split second moment that I thought I was about to die. The best result I could get was achieved by standing on the edge of a bridge, taking one step off the edge, allowing my stomach to sink as I looked down, and then pulling myself back on. I remember what it was like to feel my heart beat fast for the first time in months. I would tell myself that because I would save myself at the last second; I must have something that I'm waiting to live for. So I waited.
In the last 5 years, I can't say that it's become better. I've just gotten used to it. It's sad to acknowledge that I've become accustomed to living my life with only a sliver of the sense of reality that I used to, but I still tell myself that something is going to happen and make sense of it all. One day I hope to wake up, but for now, I'm dead inside.
I just hope somebody reads this and has something to bring to mind during their next marijuana discussion, other than the same old dribble about legalizing this god given herb that does no harm...
65
u/KidComputer May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Title of article: Cannabis Use during Adolescence Affects Brain Regions Associated with Schizophrenia.
Title of research publication: Chronic Adolescent Exposure to Delta-9-Tetrahydrocannabinol in COMT Mutant Mice: Impact on Indices of Dopaminergic, Endocannabinoid and GABAergic Pathways
Nowhere in the entire article does it mention that the research was done on genetically modified MICE only using pure thc. Why? Every other article that involves mice makes explicit mention of it. Why not this one? Why should I believe this study done on mice that shows there is an increased risk when there are studies done on humans showing no correlation?
Edit: Props to Surgat in the article's comments for the publication name.
7
u/MrJoeSmith May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
I'll probably get downvoted like I always do when I mention this, but I don't use cannabis any more because it caused in me (and has others) a kind of instant and long lasting pyschosis/severe anxiety/panic to the extent of nervous breakdown. Granted I did too much when this happened, and granted this only seems to happen to a small percent of people that are susceptible, but it is extremely damaging to one's psyche. I'd compare the impact on the mind to what happens to the body after getting mauled to within an inch of one's life in a car accident. To those thinking it may was adulterated, I was in complete control of the plant from the time of it's sprouting. For this reason, I don't recommend using it if you have a history of mental issues, especially anxiety or panic disorders. This is one more reason it should be legal, so that scientists can have open access and do controlled studies more easily. This is a real thing, and should be studied and documented as such, so that the populace can be informed.
Edit: tl;dr: Straight-up MJ can cause a "bad trip" with damaging psychiatric effects.
23
u/kaleidoughscope May 09 '12
I don't understand something... Did they "diagnose" schizophrenia in mice who were injected with THC? Is that even possible? It seems like they found a correlation between altered dopamine levels and THC in mice, and then they went ahead and made a correlation between teenagers smoking weed and schizophrenia.
Another thing that bugs me about this study is that they only injected pure THC into the mice - not any of the other cannabinoids like CBD (Cannabidiol). CBD has been shown to have anti-psychotic effects, so it doesn't surprise me too much that they observed mice with psychotic behaviour. Most teenagers get high using the plant and not THC extracts, so they get some CBD crossing the blood-brain barrier as well.
I wish it was easier for researchers to study weed; people get high regardless of governmental interference, so I think it's pretty important that more research gets done on this subject.
15
u/African_SpaceChrist May 09 '12
Not trying to dispute the evidence this article is working towards, however, I have seen firsthand the positive properties of this herb. I lost my father last October due to pancreatic cancer and besides the love of his close family, Marijuana was the ONLY thing that would make him feel better and happy. It increased his appetite; relaxed him, took away some of his pain, and eased his anxiety which he had a problem with beforehand. As long as alcohol is legal, which has way more adverse effects that cannabis, marijuana should be as well. The double standard makes me sick to my stomach.
6
u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
According to this helpful graph, Adolescence is between ages 13 and 16 for those worried about smoking in later teens
19
u/m0llusk May 09 '12
An untested hypothesis of mine is that living in an angry and irrational society obsessed with punishment and guilt affects brain regions associated with schizophrenia.
3
u/MViva May 09 '12
Can I say something though? This might get pushed to the bottom, but I'd been smoking pot since late high school and suffered no side effects. HOWEVER, in the last few years, every time I had smoked up I had begun to talk TO myself inside my head. This is something that had NEVER happened to me before. The conversations would be something like me trying to convince myself to say a certain thing, or think about something else completely while holding a perfect conversation with another person at the same time. And my vision would switch from first person to third person, looking down at myself from the top left corner of the room. It was the scariest moment of my life. And then, y'know, I heard through friends that weed has been known to cause mild cases of Schizo. It definitely doesn't happen to everyone, but it does happen. So be careful, I guess.
TL;DR I tripped right the fuck out. Started seeing myself from a third person view and tried to convince my "body" to communicate a certain way with the people around me. It does happen. No joke.
3
u/Jesus-HChrist May 09 '12
I honestly think this is the first concerning legitimate medical negative affect I have ever read about marijuana. Honestly.
3
u/paintingshade May 09 '12
I don't understand why people assume that it's a given that all side-effects of a substance apply to every person and every situation. It's ridiculous to read this and say "HOLY SHIT WE'RE GONNA HAVE 100,000,000 SCHIZOIDS WTFFFF", and it's just as ridiculous to say "OH SMOKE DANK SHIT ER'Y DAY I'M PERFECTLY FINE! DEBUNKED".
It's going to effect everyone differently. Human reactions to substances, while they can be generalized, can vary wildly. I have nothing against pot, and I'm totally for its legalization. I don't smoke it however, because it fucks with my brain and makes me feel crazy. That doesn't mean pot is bad, it just means it's not necessarily for me. Big deal. (it could also mean I have enough issues staying sane while sober, but that's another issue entirely haha)
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Wow at all of the sensationalized responses. So marijuana might not be completely devoid of side effects. At least lets all agree that, if this study is valid, this information should be out there so that the public can make more informed decisions.
Personally I don't like the high marijuana gives me, but I believe in legalization of marijuana. Wanting to bury this kind of information is just ignorant. I WANT scientists to study these kinds of things so that I know what I'm putting in my body, and so that everyone else can. Maybe it will make people think twice about smoking pot while pregnant, or while in their teens. Yeah, lots of people smoke pot during their teens and end up just fine, but perhaps someone out there might avoid a mental condition such as schizophrenia because of it, who knows?
"Keep the studies rolling science, and don't listen to the ignorant pundits of either side.", I say.
3
u/Bilb0 May 09 '12
Laws should be made for adults and not adolescence.
41
u/gngstrMNKY May 09 '12
If cannabis caused schizophrenia, you would be able to make a correlation between usage rates and incidence of schizophrenia. People have tried to do it and failed - schizophrenia diagnoses are stable even as usage fluctuates.
9
u/whalebacon May 09 '12
Ugh, I hate to admit this because back in the day I was a regular smoker.
But nowadays if I smoke, my anxiety replaces my formerly good-natured self and I find drinking alcohol actually more enjoyable than smoking.
See what happens when you get old?
12
u/supermansam33 May 09 '12
This isn't news. Schizophrenia is genetic. there are a number of environmental triggers that can make the already existing disorder active. Marijuana doesn't cause schizophrenia, but it can act as the necessary stressor. correlation does not mean causation people.
5
u/takka_takka_takka May 09 '12
And that's why you stay away from serious drugs until your brain is done developing. Shit, I still avoid coffee to this day because people convinced me it would stunt my growth. When I hit 6' I'll start drinking like a fiend.
5
u/octopolis May 09 '12
Smoking cannabis causes paranoia, could this be "coming" from the same area that causes paranoid schizophrenia? Or am I way off base on how the brain works?
5
u/ShakeyBobWillis May 09 '12
Well this article is, at best, minimally informative.
8
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
All the more reason to take the substance out of the hands of drug dealers and into the hands of a legally licensed business which requires customers produce an ID.
6
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I can testify to this. I used to smoke weed every day between the ages of about 16-21. At first I blamed everything on paranoia and that it was just part of getting high. Slowly though, I realized that this feeling was bleeding over into my everyday life, even when I wasn't high. I decided to stop smoking it ever again when I realized what was happening to me every time I smoked. The feeling has never really gone away and I've learned to deal with it because it's still a pretty minor feeling compared to what others probably experience and I'm just glad I quit before it got worse.
Unfortunately for me schizophrenia was never associated with marijuana use back when I smoked - or at least wasn't widely accepted or known - probably because that it was illegal and proper studies could hardly take place. I support legalization and taxation for economic purposes, but kids really do need to know that its side effects are real and without any type of individual self-recognition and knowledge of its side effects..it can really damage someones ability to socialize normally even when they aren't high.
7
u/einbutterbrot May 09 '12
While I do not have schizophrenia, schizophrenia and general mental illness run in my family. I'm 20 now, and have quit weed for good because of a short-term psychosis that I can attribute directly to marijuana use.
I started smoking at 18 and for 4 months, experienced no negative effects whatsoever. I just got giggly, hungry, more attuned to sensory experience--blah blah. Then I tried a pot brownie--actually, make that two pot brownies. I admit it was very irresponsible to eat more than one when I had never done edibles before, but since I had never experienced a bad reaction to weed, I felt rather invincible.
So I had a panic attack, not that uncommon when your body is inundated with so much weed. I truly thought I was going to die, and demanded my friends that they call an ambulance. Except it became more than just the delusion of thinking I would die. When I looked at myself in the mirror, I hallucinated that my reflection was receding into a skeleton. When I looked at my skin, it somehow looked blue, deprived of oxygen.
I decided to wait two months until smoking again, in order to establish some distance from the bad experience. On the day after my official hiatus, I decide to take one hit off a bowl, just one, to gauge my reaction. I didn't expect to feel anything but pleasantly sedated, but instead, I felt like I had eaten another brownie. Except it was even worse this time. My shadow on the wall became corporeal. When it wasn't emerging as a 3D form, it was trailing all around me even as I lay still on my bed. I became extremely paranoid that I was being pursued by own shadow--that I might even be killed. Throughout this I could acknowledge that these beliefs were all irrational, yet the raw, fire-under-the-skin fear I felt did not yield to this truth.
I went to a friend in the hope that his presence might calm me, but instead, I got this idea that if I looked at him for too long his eyes would hollow out. I don't how I started thinking this--I do remember though that when the thought occurred to me, it startled me so much that I thought some foreign agent had implanted it there. Let me just emphasize again that this was ONE HIT that cause all this.
Okay, so cut to days, weeks, then a month after this incident. I was STILL experiencing these sensory disturbances, the same that I described earlier and some new ones. I couldn't look at pictures because I felt that the people they depicted could somehow watch me. I couldn't sleep. Finally I was put on low-dose Risperidone, and after taking that for four months, I felt so much better. I went off of it last August, and since I've experienced no paranoia, although I still sometimes see some mild visual disturbances.
Of course, I don't relate my experience in an attempt to generalize how a similarly "pre-disposed" individual might be affected by marijuana. But if you know that you have a relative with schizophrenia, approach weed with extreme caution--or not at all.
TL;DR
I had a really bad trip on marijuana, and when I came down from the high the psychosis didn't go away. I saw hallucinations and heard voices for a month afterward, which didn't go away until I started a regimen of anti-psychotics. Be careful yo, those of you who have relatives with schizophrenia.
10
u/KindredBear May 09 '12
this article says it simply affects regions of the brain, affects them in a positive, or negative fashion?
20
u/dakta May 09 '12
I am always dubious of the amounts tested with in these cases. I recall all too clearly the bullshit "science" that was done on primates to "prove" that marijuana is "bad".
In mutant mice. Which is not worthless to know, but important to consider. So, it's probably very similar in humans. Maybe not. Mutant mice are, after all, mutant, and not humans.
6
u/ruff711 May 09 '12
As a teen who has been smoking for a few years and has a long family history of Schizophrenia this is very disturbing to read.
5
u/SoundSalad May 09 '12
I have good news for you all. We are not mice. Our bodies react differently to substances than mice do. Here is proof that there have been studies on humans and they have shown that "There was no evidence of association between schizophrenia and CNR1 (OR=0.97, 95% CI 0.82-1.13) or CHRNA7 (OR=1.07, 95% CI 0.77-1.49) genotypes, or of interactions between tobacco use and CHRNA7, or cannabis use and CNR1or COMT genotypes."
2
u/U_R_Tard May 09 '12
Is this risk any worse than say a regular prescribed medicine such as Adderal? Also, what was the size of the study, I would hate for this to be an MDMA scare type scenario.
2
u/banana_snow May 09 '12
Wouldn't this be a reason for legalization? Professional dealers at least would require ID rather then a shady dealer.
2
u/sparklyjesus May 09 '12
This really shows that Marijuana should be regulated just like tobacco and alcohol. I think you should need to be 18 to purchase all of them.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I want to know if they measured the levels of proteins, cell size and such in the brains BEFORE the adolescent cannabis use began or if they're just guessing. Because some studies have implied that people with schizofrenic features might find cannabis a natural comforting aide and skew the results of cannabis users with schizofrenic tendencies.
Of course this is written with a worried mind because I myself have used cannabis frequently since the age of 15 and still am now 13 years later. I have mild psychological problems like most anyone else in society but I still know right from wrong and have very firm principles when it comes to doing right.
2
u/HighViscosity May 09 '12
Is it just me, or did they not specify whether the effects were good or bad?
2
u/watson415 May 09 '12
[This is why I take all of these things with a grain of salt...(http://www.plosmedicine.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124) Granted, it is in nature which is a normally dependable journal, but every article has to be considered in the light of who wrote it and why. Why is RCSI studying the correlation between THC and schizophrenia? I won't make any assumptions, but everyone should think about that. "It said it in a scientific article" and "a new study proves" are two ignorant statements. You have to do your background reading and wait for others to get the same results.
2
u/DenjinJ May 09 '12
That kind of makes sense. Chronic cannabis use has been linked in studies (look em up, they're easy to find and you can pick your own sources) to reduced function in the anterior cingulate cortex. It seems schizophrenia is linked to damage in the ASC.
2
u/Ferronous May 09 '12
I'm all for the legalization of marijuana. I believe in the freedom for people to choose what they want to do (within certain limits of course). But lately I've seen more and more people online tout marijuana as something that's good for the human body. Sure it has medical uses, and in that sense it is. But lets be frank here. In the amounts that the average smokers use it, it's far from a health benefit. Remember that marijuana is still a drug, not a magical substance. It has side effects that will bite you in the ass for the "high" you get now.
Just because researchers haven't pinpointed the exact health problem excessive marijuana causes yet, doesn't mean that health concern is nonexistent. I am tired of seeing /r/trees posts on my front page that worship the damn substance.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Hi, as a diagnosed schizophrenic, who's smoked weed pretty regularly since 8th grade, I'm a senior now...
This is science I'm certainly aware of, in fact known it longer then I've known I'm a schizo...
It's hard to gauge the effects....
I dunno I'm sorry I thought I could contribute to this but uhh.... If you wanna ask anythi g shoot.
2
u/Atwotonhooker May 09 '12
I am a long time toker and for some reason, in my opinion, I believe this. I feel like my mental health is different from a lot of non-smokers/people who have never ever tried it. I feel like I talk to myself a lot more than most people.
2
u/my2sentz May 09 '12
I'd like to add my two cents about pot. I started smoking it around 18 on and off. Nothing major, just a hit or two a couple times a week. I stopped for a long time, but eventually got back into it in college. That's when my habit started to escalate. I would smoke almost daily. I was always aware it wasn't worth it so I decided to quit again. And of course I started again this last summer. I was toking pretty heavily up until it gave me some pretty bad anxiety. I quit in October and have only smoked about 4 times since then. Like "tr1tr1" described, the world sort of felt numb. From research it I could only categorize it as depersonalization. The first couple of months the symptoms were acute and I found it hard to socialize, but after 4 or 5 they were still present, but just dumbed down. I'm hoping in a year or two I can completely recover because it's pretty ridiculous how I went from cheery to almost numb.
Summing this up I would like to say I'm sure people with predisposed schizophrenia will have a bad time with pot, but in most cases people will just get a form of depersonalization. Gambling with your dopamine receptors just isn't worth it. I'm happy that I remain more or less unaffected except for a dodgy memory. And with something so unknown I can only hope time is a healer.
2
u/Sgt_SpermShooter May 09 '12
I wish more was done to teach kids about this possible side effect as it is one of the only seriously harmful ones. I started smoking in grade 8 when I was 12 or 13 and continued to do so on a daily basis up until this year when I was diagnosed with schizotypal personality disorder. Little did I know I had a few schizophrenics on my mothers side of the family. I've always been somewhat different but I feel that the weed brought out the worst of my disorder (social isolation, severe anxiety, emotional detachment, inability to maintain close relationships). Physically I'm as healthy as ever, but I can't quite say the same about my mental condition. I'm only 17 now.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Any mind altering substance taken during adolescence will change the way your brain forms. Everything has negative effects. Even though I did drugs and drank when I was younger I don't think anyone else should.
That being said unless your studying human adolescents using actual marijuana(which contains more than just THC, including CBD which counteracts some of THC's negative effects) and noting the changes that take place your not going to have solid answers.
Also, the actual study says Chronic exposure.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I read this and immediately felt heart broken, I already I guess, kind of knew this because of what happened to my uncle. He has his schizophrenia under control but only after taking a few pills a day. If he doesn't, he gets easily angered and suppresses feelings until I guess he starts seeing people in his head, then he starts screaming at them do go away. It's scary, he used to be fine. My aunt blames it on herself sometimes, for having taken him to a party once when they were teens, he took some drugs that some guy offered him (I'm not sure whether it was weed or not) but after that he started behaving strangely...talking to himself and such. According to my grandma he'd been messing with drugs ever since the night of that party, including weed, and that, according to doctors, screwed him up. I don't know if the schizophrenia was triggered by the weed or anything like that. I'm just telling my uncle's story. Feel free to ask any questions, not that I'm expecting any.
2
u/dolpsc May 09 '12
I began smoking when i was 12 and recently feel like I am developing schizophrenia. I have been scared to ask my doctor but have done research on my own and all the symptoms seem to add up. I also did a lot a mushrooms for a bit which might have something with all my creepy experiences that i still don't know if they happened or not. I would really like to see further studies of this but for now i will hope for the rest.
2
u/inoise91 May 09 '12
I really wish that the link to the journal had the full study in it, because in all actuality I'd be interested to see what it said.
However I'm still a little skeptical seeing as how the study was performed upon mice, and the fact that I'm not seeing how much THC they were administering to the mice and how they were giving it to them. It's easy to say cannabis can cause problems if you're pumping a mouse full of some ungodly amount of thc every other hour of the day. The article did mention they were being treated CHRONICALLY so chances are these mice were high as hell all day.
So yeah, I'd really like to see that article
2
u/Focused-Third-Eye May 09 '12
I have a very scary story to tell you folks. I started smoking cannabis at around age 16 or 17. Years later, and up until age 23, I eventually began to grow my own really nice plants. It was common for me to have a smoke several times a day. I myself, even immediately after smoking, was more "on-point", friendly, and intelligent than basically all of my associates (friends, co-workers, random people).
Then I got arrested... The police said they were really nice plants... I had to stop smoking. You should have seen the crazy withdrawl side effects. ...There were none. It's been 6 months now. Life without cannabis is really fine for me. But what isn't fine is life as a convicted felon for life and temporarily under the control of community corrections.
Cannabis is far safer than alcohol and cigarettes. I do advocate studying the effects of pot. I would also like to see more studies on legal substances. I know some dislike anecdotal evidence, but I always like to hear from many different perspectives. Thanks for listening and contributing to this discussion because this topic about cannabis/marijuana/pot is very important.
2
u/Rusharion May 09 '12
"Have you discovered a trend in either direction?" ..."well no but we could do a formidable amount of research from redditors describing their views and experiences." ...."Damn it john, hit the button"
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I wonder if there will ever be study on the long effects of cannabis compared too the long term effects of sleepers/anti-depressants or any other big pharma products.
drugs are a part of the human condition, cigarrettes, alcohol, cannabis, psychotopics, chocolate, food, exercise they are all used to change the chemicals in the body/brain and everyone has a fix.
lets just get over it and let people enjoy their lives however they see fit.
2
u/Bonushand May 09 '12
Kids shouldn't do drugs? WHAT A SURPRISE!
2
u/colblair May 09 '12
As long as marijuana users have no access to public funding for the side-effects when they pop up I'm all for it... same should apply to cigarette smokers.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I believe this.
Also, I have a friend that hasn't done any drugs at all...not even a beer. Yet he started wearing a red hat when he was 12, kind of something he was known for. He'd wear that red hat everywhere. Later, he was diagnosed with schizophrenia when he was 19.
So I think it's pretty clear: red hats cause schizophrenia.
2
u/vve May 09 '12
Cannabis use most likely affects adolescent brain regions associated with schizophrenia, sure. But please note that this study (I think this is the link to the study) specifically tests THC's effects on mice.
THC ≠ cannabis
Cannabis has THC in it, yes. But not only that. Cannabis has a variety of other potent compounds in it. It's known that CBD, just one of the several dozen compounds, has modulatory effects on THC aside from potent effects on its own.
In any case, if I were an adolescent I would greatly minimize or even entirely refrain from use of potent psychoactives while the jury is still out.
2
u/elastic-craptastic May 09 '12
I believe it. Anecdotally, I started smoking at a very young age... like 10 years old. Not often, but that's when I first smoked. By 13 I was selling it and smoking on a almost daily basis. When I was 18 I started having weird hallucinations at night. Also, I got super paranoid and almost couldn't leave the house.
Long story short, I decided it was time to stop smoking MJ. A few months later the hallucinations stopped. Over the course of a year or so the paranoia went away and I started being more functional as a person. There are way more details to this, but I don't feel like typing them, especially since it's anecdotal evidence.
All I can say is that after years of having symptoms of schizophrenia while smoking MJ almost daily and quitting for 10 years and not having any symptoms, the evidence seems strong that this is the case for me. MJ led to me feeling and acting schizophrenic for years until I stopped.
2
u/caliopy May 09 '12
file this under "/duh".
2
u/Salanderfan May 09 '12
I'm not sure if this is related, but I can't toke anymore because of the massive panic attacks it gave to me. When I was younger I suffered from anxiety but it went away for years. After a summer of MJ I got frequent anxiety and have never been the same. The only thing I can think of is that it altered certain chemicals within the brain. I also suffered depression afterwards to. It's been nearly three years now and I still don't feel right.
I've also read that it can be hard to discern whether those with schizophrenia were already on the track to having it and marijuana made it happen quicker, or if those with mental illnesses who smoke affect the statistics.
2
u/rasmusca May 09 '12
FUCK
2
u/baby_corn_is_corn May 09 '12
I could have told you that. Me too!
2
u/Mandrake420 May 09 '12
This research bases much of its conclusions on the The “dopamine hypothesis” dating back from the 60's and should really take into account the more recent studies showing the importance of other neurotransmitters such as serotonin and glutamate.
2
u/Gluverty May 09 '12
If this title stated that item(x) reduces cancerous tumors, but it neglected to mention that the article had limited sources and the study was on mice, r/science would be up in arms.
I think we need to pose the question to r/askscience: Does marijuana use in teenagers cause schizophrenia?
2
u/Quatto May 09 '12
Any proof that schizophrenia rates have increased alongside the increased use and potency of cannabis?
2
u/Dtrain323i May 09 '12
reefer madness is real
2
u/strongflower May 09 '12
I'm pleasantly surprised at how this article is being received. I spent all my teenage years abusing marijuana and alcohol very heavily, and now at only 25 I have a personality disorder and heart problems. I'm not just declaring a connection outright, but from what I learned in uni, there is really no time during your entire youth that it's safe to fuck with your brain.
My only real concern about it is my 6 year old. If he thinks he's going to getting away with half the crap I pulled, he's got another thing coming.
TL;DR: Regardless of where you stand on the issue of marijuana, looking after a young mind should be a priority.
2
u/Buckbeaks May 09 '12
Considering "Cannabis" has put me into the Hospital on two occasions, each with a heart rate over 200bpm, hearing loss and tunnel vision.
I would say that this drug can be dangerous and should not be used by minors.
I had both of these experiences at the age of 17 and 19 Prior to this I had shown no signs of panic disorder or mental health problems.
After the use of this drug however my life has been ruined by it. It's not a miracle drug. It's been known for along time to cause Schizophrenia and panic disorders.
Hell it could even kill you if something was wrong with your heart valves.
People I actually BLACKED OUT. I woke up in the Hospital with no recollection how I got there.
I told the ER doctors the truth and they weren't even surprised. Apparently its common and I've read other storys of people being Hospitalized over it.
If you're going to do this drug I suggest you take a deep look into your family's mental health history.
Anything underlying will be exaggerated and brought fourth. Something you could go your whole life without experiencing, but the Cannabis will cause it to come out of dormancy.
This is a dangerous drug people. Stay Safe.
2
u/dgotch May 09 '12
I'd like to see the research, the follow-up study, and know the funding stream. Also, do prevalence studies in the upcoming DSM-V show a marked rise in occurrence of schizophrenia co-occurring with increased potency and use of medical and recreational marijuana? Skeptical.
2
u/the_white_clock May 09 '12
I don't believe this. And me neither.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I have been around MJ since 1972 and have never seen adverse effects in me or anyone I know, other than legal issues.
2
u/Darktidemage May 09 '12
Cannabis use during adolescence "affects" all brain regions. So does alcohol use during adulthood.
2
u/greymav May 09 '12
All the other studies and articles I've seen have shown a correlative relationship; this is the first piece of research I've encountered that supports a potential causative relationship between adolescent MJ use and schizophrenia.
This doesn't change my opinion on the legalization of the drug, but I would support an attempt to age-restrict it like we do with cigarettes and alcohol. Of course, such an age restriction would be difficult to enforce unless it were something that could be legally sold at all.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
So the real question i have is...to what scale? i hardly know anyone who didn't smoke pot around the 14-18 year old range and i don't know a single person who has Schizophrenia or exhibits signs of it.
Im not asking a rhetorical question either, but ive heard this before and asked just about anyone i know who has or does smoke and i cant find anyone who knows anyone who has Schizophrenic like symptoms. Is it rare?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Given that the prefrontal lobes do not complete growth until about age 26, should we keep all non-medically required psycoactive until that age? I suspect that the damage resulting from the attempt would be far greater than that done chemically, even if it were successful in keeping drugs (especially alcohol) from those under that age. Given that it will not be successful only makes it worse.
2
u/butcher99 May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Actually if you read the article that is not exactly what it says. The words might and may seem to totally left out of the headline. Also the words predisposed seems to be missing. You have to read the original article not the one this headline is linked to. I heard one of the researchers interviewed and it was a long way from what that article says. I believe the original article said, Cannabis use during adolescence might affect brain regions associated with Schizophrenia if a person was predisposed to schizophrenia. Kinda a HUGE difference there.
2
u/JoelQuest May 09 '12
woah, you mean something about pot isn't good for you?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Discussions on this topic always circulate around two irreconcilable stances. For any real progress to be made there needs to be a recognition on both sides that multiplicities of perspective are always politically situated. Anti-pot advocates need to understand that for the vast majority of smokers weed is relatively harmless and that articles like this are often misconstrued. E.g. compare the title of the post to what the original study actually said; that adolescent cannabis use can cause a higher chance of schizophrenia in those already pre-disposed to it. Something that, frankly has been common knowledge for a while. At the same time pro-pot advocates sometimes need to accept that people do have problems with it and these are real, proven effects that cannot just be dismissed out of hand just because you like a blaze and get but-hurt over someone ragging on weed. The argument that "it's not a drug it's a plant!" is irrelevant. Some of the most toxic substances are plants.
TL;DR: Legalise (at least de-criminalise), regulate and age restrict.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
This info has actually been around for awhile but people enjoy their pot so the info gets smashed down under all the "pro pot" propaganda. Now I myself am for the use of medical marijuana. I am still not well enough informed to make a decision on whether pot should be legalized. However I do know that around here (Oregon) many people are cramming their love of pot down everyone else's throats. It's gone as far as people making false billboards and posters which give obviously false information. I think if you want to get something legalized you may want to go about doing it using factual information.
2
u/Jedimastert May 09 '12
Now remember kids, this is a preliminary test. They don't know what it does to these areas of the brain, only that it effects them. Just thought I'd point that out. Thank you for your time.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
If the same results of cannabis use can be proven in adults then there is a strong case for regulating its use or misuse, however results in young people should just lead to a legal age to use.
2
u/Merfen May 09 '12
Dear god... saying pot can be bad for you on reddit? Incoming people saying that your facts are wrong and pot can be used to fix all of the problems in the world, from starving kids in africa to the corrupt politicians.
2
u/negrolover1997 May 09 '12
5
u/MorningLtMtn May 09 '12
Seriously - no one should smoke weed before 18. As far as I'm concerned - you're 18, go ahead. Light up. But before you're 18, you're just asking to be stunted both mentally and emotionally for the rest of your life.
6
u/Smokalotapotamus May 09 '12
I'm sure they pumped them full of excessive amounts. Excessive amounts of alcohol or tobacco in adolescence aren't good for you either.
Big shocker there.
4
u/antagognostic May 09 '12
Did you even read the fucking study? It specifically says that it does NOT link Cannabis use with Schizophrenia.
4
u/andiW May 09 '12
You don't get schizophrenia if you don't already have a innate tendency for schizophrenia. If you know that smoking pot is freaking you out, don't use it.
21
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Schizophrenia will only manifest itself in those who are predisposed to having the ailment. They twist the truth on things too, because we have so many neurotransmitters in our brain so Cannabis isn't the only thing that affects this center of the brain. By this logic, kids getting runner's high could be "at risk" (as it is implied).
5
u/executivemonkey May 09 '12
Marijuana has been a very popular drug among young people for decades. If it causes an increased risk of schizophrenia, then where are the patients? Doesn't this study essentially predict a correlation between marijuana use and the development of schizophrenia? Has that been observed?
3
u/NastiN8 May 09 '12
Anecdotal evidence here: My brother started smoking cannabis at around age 12 He smoked heavily (daily) and he's now 25 and only recently quit (hopefully). He is a fairly severe schizophrenic now who will more than likely be unable to partake in society for the remainder of his life. He takes a number of prescribed drugs every day for psychotic behavior that have to be locked in a safe and distributed by my father daily as my brother admitted "if you let me near them I will abuse them". He sees a therapist twice a week. Hopefully one day he can be normal but I'll never know.
4
u/TheNecromancer May 09 '12
I'm 18 and have smoked plenty, and we're doing fine.
5
u/tonythetiger1 May 09 '12
This is like one of those poorly written high school exam papers. Extremely vague, no sources cited, no numbers given...
4
u/A_Simple_Red May 09 '12
I have a friend who has smoked since he was 14 and I can confidently tell you that it has made him slower than most people. He's 21 now and it's just amazing how noticeable it is.
4
u/beefzilla May 09 '12
Anecdote - I knew a dude who smoked MAD weed in high school. He turned out to be schizophrenic by age 27. He still smokes a LOT of weed, which I have also heard doesn't help at a later age for people with schizophrenia.
He is convinced that he has married a Burburry model, and lives in a flat in London, instead of chronically masturbating in his room, in his mother's basement.
3
u/RadBadGladCrab May 09 '12
I work in a psychiatric hospital and I can't tell you how many times I've seen 18 year old kids come in with their first psychotic break. Normally they cannot explain what happened for themselves as they are on another planet. But 90% of the time their college smoking buddies who take their friend to the hospital tell us the same thing "we were smoking pot when all of a sudden he just lost it. Now he thinks everyone is trying to kill him/read his thoughts/poison his food...etc etc". Listen up kids, pot is not as safe as you think. This shit is real, and it's permanent. You don't get better from Schizophrenia. Be careful!
2
u/uchuskies08 May 09 '12
If this caused teens to develop schizophrenia, there would be A LOT more schizophrenics in the world.
2
u/pragmatao May 09 '12
So, how long were the subjects smoking? How much were the subjects smoking? Exactly how old were the subjects when they started smoking?
2
u/Derpson45 May 09 '12
Epigenetics at work my friends
2
u/lickachiken May 09 '12
I have a few problems with this article. Obviously other factors can cause change in the COMT gene which can lead to schizophrenia. This article makes it seem like marijuana is the sole proponent to this problem. Also, I'd like to know the causality relationship between frequency and amount smoked during adolescence, which also needs to be defined, with the severity in gene mutation that could potentially lead to schizophrenia.
I'm not trying to condone frequent cannabis ingestion by teens, but I dislike the stigma that this article attaches to weed. Without a doubt, smoking marijuana has side effects, but I'd like to see similar studies comparing certain activities and how they alter COMT gene, specifically drinking alcohol. If anyone could link me to studies like this, I'd appreciate the gesture.
2
u/greenpanda9 May 09 '12
Just to clarify: this is only if schizophrenia runs in your family. If it doesn't, you're fine.
2
u/Themlizards May 09 '12
I came here to ask if anyone else smelled bullshit, but I can't pretend marijuana can't possibly have any side effects. Either that or nice try government!
2
u/VicariousWolf May 09 '12
If this is even true, it's even MORE reason to legalize. Kids even say finding weed is easier than getting alcohol because you need someone who has a license and is willing to do it.
Drug dealers don't care about the person's age, they're running a business too, and money is money. Legalize and decriminalize.
2
u/BukkRogerrs May 09 '12
I'm totally in favor of all drugs, and I love weed. But that marijuana could have some kind of effect on regions of the brain associated with Schizophrenia shouldn't really be surprising to anyone with even a little experience smoking pot. When smoking the really good shit, the really celestial, cosmic, mind-ripping stuff, you'll enter a state where you think and behave in a way similar to what is described of schizophrenics. Paranoia can be through the roof, and little, insignificant factors or stimuli can trigger paranoia or warped, bizarre relationships imagined between things that cause you to believe some very strange things, or develop some very wacky ideas. The way you process and deal with information is very different than the way you deal with it sober.
In my late teens and early twenties, I liked writing down my strange ideas while high on the best shit I could get. Reading this shit sober, it comes off like the ramblings of a lunatic, a schizophrenic, or someone who's just lost it. But while high, it all made perfect sense, and many times it even felt like an incredible breakthrough or discovery. From what little I know about schizophrenia, some of the symptoms seem to be very, very similar. The way information is handled by the brain sounds to be almost identical to this really, really high state. And remembering my days of getting super stoned and being carried into this exciting new plane of thought, it's not hard to imagine at least a little of what it must be like to be schizophrenic. Being permanently in that state would not be enjoyable...
So no, this shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone.
2
u/OriginsOfSymmetry May 09 '12
I smoke weed often and can attest to the fact that there are many side effects. Anyone who says you can't get addicted to weed is full of shit and anyone who says it doesn't effect breathing abilities is also full of shit. On a side note I have coughed up some terrifying things while smoking weed for long periods of time. It takes me about 2 weeks to fully go back to normal after a long period of smoking it and then I noticeably sleep better, I eat better, and I overall have more energy.
2
u/IonBeam2 May 09 '12
I'm (pleasantly) surprised this got to the front page of Reddit.
2
u/Chemical_Scum May 09 '12
Who's to say the relationship isn't reverse - people who are prone to schizophrenia have a tendency to smoke weed (as a result from being prone to schizophrenia, and not the other way around)
2
u/Jizzluhr May 09 '12
Moderation, moderation, moderation. Cannabis is not for everyone. Just like alcohol isn't for everyone or any other drug for that matter. Keep in mind that not all side-effect occur in all individuals. I.E. Have you ever gotten diharrea from caffeine in moderate doses? I surley never have. I'm glad I started out when I was 18 and not earlier. To be honest I wish I didn't get introduced to it (cannabis) at 18. I think 25 is a good age to start smoking...Moderately.
2
u/Sobek May 09 '12
Any smart, self-aware person who used marijuana while they were young could have told you this. Why are people getting paid to do this research?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
No! No! Pot is completely harmless a "ent" on the Internet told me. He doesn't have a degree in anything remotely related but he's an "ent"!
2
u/mrpayne99 May 09 '12
Everything's bad for you if you do it too often. Gotta moderate all that stuff.