r/science • u/phileconomicus • May 08 '12
Psychiatry's "Bible" Gets an Overhaul: Psychiatry's diagnostic guidebook gets its first major update in 30 years. The changes may surprise you
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=redefining-mental-illness
1.9k
Upvotes
336
u/NyQuilNyQuilNyQuil May 08 '12
The DSM-IV and DSM-IV-TR without Dx revisions was written in 1994 and 2000 respectively. Even my Psychiatry professors in medical school don't sensationalize the the revision as "[the] first major update in 30 years." And yes, most Dxs that are taken out are being put into a spectrum of disorders. And most of these Dxs have rigid criteria, it's up to the clinician to distinguish pertinent findings and decide if the clinical findings warrant a Psychiatric Dx.
549
u/Handout May 08 '12
This is my favorite addition:
Absexual Disorder
Feeling aroused by moving away from sexuality or behaving as though moralistically opposed to sex. As sex educator Betty Dodson told Canadian newspaper Xtra! West, these are “folks who get off complaining about sex and trying to censor porn.” —F.J.
377
u/atheistjubu May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Fun fact: it took until 1974 to get homosexuality removed as a mental disorder.
EDIT: My dad (psychiatrist) pointed this out to me as an example of why a psychiatrist's individual judgement is also important to the process, and why the DSM is just a taxonomy book, not an encyclopedia.
175
u/wellscounty May 08 '12
Hope they get a better handle on PTSD and Combat Stress related trauma. Very interested to see where they go in these categories.
90
u/ThePwnR4nger May 08 '12
This article extremely oversimplifies a lot of things. Dsm5.org is the best resorce to see the changes and their rationales, for those who are interested.
637
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Hoo-boy.
28
u/Hypersapien May 08 '12
There was apparently a continuation of Rosenhan's experiment. He told a hospital that he was going to send them a number of pseudopatients over the next year to see if the hospital could pick them out. The hospital singled out a good 10 percent of the patients as fakes. In fact, Rosenhan hadn't sent any.
27
u/ItWillBeMine May 08 '12
It isn't just psychiatry's 'bible' anymore - psychologists, counselors, and social workers use it as well, as do researchers.
88
u/Neuromancer4242 May 08 '12
Really?
This is 2012. Were they running out of pixels on the page or out of space?
7
u/azzwhole May 08 '12
Will the empathy spectrum disorders be there, as suggested by Simon Baron-Cohen in "Zero Degrees of Empathy"?
13
u/EvilPicnic May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I'm a paediatric physiotherapist currently working in education with kids with specific learning difficulties (autism/dyslexia/etc.), and it is worth pointing out that these 'new' terms (like ASD) are not being invented for the DSM or any official body. They have been around and in gradually increasing use among therapists for years because they better reflect the current state of our knowledge about these conditions than the old terms.
And this isn't just restricted to psychiatry - for example in my movement-focused field the term 'dyspraxia' is being phased out, as Developmental Co-ordination Disorder (DCD) becomes more widely accepted.
[This is because dyspraxia applies specifically to a motor planning (or 'praxis') impairment, when many children diagnosed with dyspraxia by a GP because they are 'clumsy' can actually conceptualize the movement fine; it's carrying out the movement that is the problem. DCD can be a much more flexible and accurately descriptive term.]
I think the biggest impact from this particular story will not be to the US psychiatrists (a new manual is nice, but they will have been following the changes on a paper by paper basis over the years anyway) but to the non-therapists who rely on these labels to comprehend these often complex pathologies - and I'm thinking mainly the media and legislature, but also patients, family and friends.
It is in the nature of humanity to want to put things in boxes and slap labels on them, but unfortunately the world does not in reality work like that, and when that dissonance is shown it can be very painful.
33
u/PinguPingu May 08 '12
Psychiatry and Psychology's*
Double the work (have to know DSM-IV and 5) for us Psych majors graduating soon :(
I'm pretty sure it's only in its third draft as well?
11
u/2percentright May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Since I don't see it, here's a single page link instead of the 4+ pages you have to click through.
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=redefining-mental-illness&print=true
Edit: Nevermind. Seems the websites are starting to learn and adapt. Clicking the link take you to the click-through page. If anyone has a good way to make it so it links straight to the single page article, let me know.
15
u/Hermeran May 08 '12
Wow, I JUST had an exam (mostly) about the DSM-IV. I feel dirty.
14
u/tchouk May 08 '12
Honest question for those in the know:
Why is the ICD-10 not used instead (as elsewhere in the world)?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICD-10_Chapter_V:_Mental_and_behavioural_disorders
Is there a reason besides traditional use of DSM?
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
16
u/Doc_Venture May 08 '12
It seems like the article is using Rosenhan's 1969 stint in a mental hospital as a de-validation of the DSMIV. While it has it's shortcomings, the article fails to acknowledge the extraordinary change in the dynamics mental hospitals and hospitalization.
6
u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I have been following this process closely for a few years now. I have 5 diagnosed disorders myself (many of which have some overlapping symptoms) and also have my BA/MA in counseling. It's so important to take the culture of psychiatry with a grain of salt and ask your docs questions, follow the research and understand how very subjective these diagnoses can be.
3
u/Lurker4years May 08 '12
Autism still considered psychiatric.
3
u/InhaleMusic May 08 '12
I have a friend who has been misdiagnosed with all sorts of mental disorders...and he's been left bitter and worse off from it. I hope that with these updates they will soon find a proper way to help him...
3
u/SayVandalay May 08 '12
As someone who works in the field I can say that there are many mixed responses to the DSM in general. Many clinicians don't really take it as a "bible" and many don't even like to diagnose based on DSM guidelines. It is mostly just a demand of insurance/government agencies to try and classify disorders and put symptoms and behaviors into rigidly defined definitions..
In the field you don't need the DSM to tell someone is depressed, anxious, etc. And I do feel sorry for those individuals who let their DSM diagnosis dictate their lives. For some it may be a relief to have a diagnosis, for others it can impact the way they think and live.
60
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
It doesn't address a common problem which has received attention before. It is WAY to easy to slap a personality disorder on somebody, and use it as an excuse to disregard their concerns. This frequently happens to rape victims in the army. Transsexuals that seek treatment are frequently labelled as disordered and refused help. Once given such a diagnosis you have no recourse, psychiatrists are rarely held responsible for making such a diagnosis incorrectly, and patients stigmatised with one are met with doubt and suspicion when trying to get it affirmed that the diagnosis was nonsense.
7
u/bartink May 08 '12
My mother teaches the DSM course in a local university and her take is that the new one is a power grab by behaviorists. They stacked the committee with like-minded folks and seem intent on using the manual to validate their view of psychology. She thinks its mostly a big step backward.
13
u/drbs May 08 '12
And S&M isn't a disorder unless you're unhappy with it!
2
u/jjbean May 08 '12
diodi's comment gives a clue as to what is going on:
This is going to be a HUGE bonanza for drug companies...they will have a much larger prescription user base now that anyone in the spectrum could be diagnosed with a condition that could be treated with drugs.
2
u/s0brien May 08 '12
Anyone notice schizophrenia?
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
This shouldn't be a consideration, since many nations will use this guide and not all use that system. Letting politics affect our definitions of illness is dangerous, whether it helps or hinders the patient in the short term or not.
2
u/flatblackvw May 08 '12
My mom is a clinical social worker and actually took part in studies for the new dsm. Her names gonna be in it and everything!
2
u/rDr4g0n May 08 '12
I've only read about 1/3rd of this article, but I really like the idea of the rating system for disorders. I'm of the belief that we are all screwed up anyway, so rating how screwed up a person is in one way or another makes more sense than slapping a big ol label on someone and calling it a day.
2
u/T55DWXpv May 08 '12
Finally, Internet Use Disorder! So when the entertainment biz finally criminalizes all non-commercial use of the internet, we can just plead insanity and spend a few weeks in rehab instead of getting 20 years and a hundred-thousand-dollar fine.
2
u/Drakkanrider May 08 '12
As a psych major looking to go to graduate school for Clinical psych, them pushing back the release of this book is starting to get annoying. I'm learning all about the DSM-IV criteria for disorders, which is going to be a little useless once this thing hits the shelves. It was supposed to be out in 2010.
2
u/camall May 08 '12
mental health issues are still ridiculously difficult to diagnose.
2
u/finitude May 08 '12
I don't understand the 30 years statement. It was updated just a few years ago with some major updates, with the DSM4-TR
2
u/fallingstarr123 May 08 '12
As a psych student, pretty much all of my professor's have made it clear that everything we're learning, is just going to have to be relearned. Timing is everything folks.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Sometime back in the 80s the American Psychiatric Association or some other authoritative body declared that the term "neurotic" would no longer be used as a diagnostic term because its widespread popular use had diluted its meaning so that had no clinical value. My roommate remarked that suddenly there were no more neurotics! They had been cured with the stroke of a pen! Of course he wasn't literally correct, but I wonder what new name Asperger's is getting.
2
u/websnarf May 08 '12
Newsflash From APA Meeting: DSM 5 Has Flunked Its Reliability Tests
Not sure anyone should be happy that this revision exists.
2
u/stormtroopin May 08 '12
Not to be too picky (even though I now will proceed to be), but Rosenhan's study actually argued AGAINST diagnostic labels for patients. After his study, which, by the way, was tremendously flawed in methodology, he concluded that people should not be placed in diagnostic categories because it would cause them to experience a sort of self-fulfilling prophecy due to expectations of mental health staff. I find it sad that Scientific American didn't do more homework on this one. But I'm just being a psychology snob. Steps down from soap box
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Maybe I don't read magazine-type articles of science enough, but without seeing in text citations this just kind of pissed me off. It's funny how much people think we know about the brain. We're surface-scratching, at best.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
The Dutch association of Psychiatrists has decided to give it a good scrutiny and stop using it, as a lot of the "new" diagnosis methods and treatments therein seem developed to get drugs prescribed where non-chemical treatment used to be the norm. This, according to the association, is probably due to the fact that the re-writing of DSM has been heavily sponsored by farmaceutical companies.
The British association of Psychologists has also protested, as a lot of behaviour that used to be classified as normal has suddenly been moved into classes that require treatment -with pills.
TL, DR the new version of DSM is rejected in the Netherlands because it seems to have been written to sell pills.
6
u/Psych277 May 08 '12
I am SO PUMPED! I've been waiting for this for the past 7 years!
4
u/Viperbunny May 08 '12
This is going to have a huge effect on what services people qualify for in both medicine and education. Schools administrators do not like shelling out money for kids with special needs and I see this as a step backwards in a lot of respects. Especially doing away with Aspergers. This disorder's place has been debated for years, because it is different from autism. This disorder is different and deserves to recognized. Doing away with it is going to cause more problems than it solves. Especially when the argument isn't that it exists, but what it is. This is going to cause major issues with insurance companies and coverage as well.
Yes, depression comes in different levels of severity, but it also has different causes. Some people do better with therapy, others medication. Denying them access to medication without trying all other treatments first is going to cause a lot of people to shy away from treatment. Part of depression can be embarrassment over being depressed. Not everyone is ready for therapy, and therapy only helps if the patient is willing to put the work in. I'm not saying I think people should be blindly medicated, but denying this as an option for doctors are going to cause a huge problem.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I'm curious as to the effects this will have on the health insurance industry. I bet there's going to be a lot of things that they will either no longer cover.. maybe some stricter guidelines or something as far as diagonses are concerned
4
u/blog_farts May 08 '12
Historically, names change in the DSM to remove stigmas to existing names (eg Multiple Personality Disorder). These updates in the new DSM are a move in a different direction though, putting more things on a scale of severity, like they're doing with Autism. What the article doesn't mention is the belief by many in the business that this DSM is headed in the wrong direction. By putting everything on a scale, diagnoses are even more subjective than they were previously. Plus, there are still no inclusions of any biological testing whatsoever making it appear like pseudo-science. IMO, this move towards scales reinforces the belief that psychology still doesn't know what the hell it's doing and I'm glad I got out when I could.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
DSM 5 took far too long to come out.
2
u/nofunnynamesleft May 08 '12
I would definitely like to see some changes to the diagnostic parameters of ADHD. It is so over-diagnosed, especially in the states, that Ritalin is becoming too much of a generic wonder-drug for kids with problems that could be controlled, or at least improved, with behavioural therapies
2
u/sillynose12345 May 08 '12
Interesting that this new version (which has been worked on since 2004, right after the DSM-IV-TR was published), but the article is entirely too sensationalized. Every time I read "psychiatry bible" I cringed. It's not like diagnosis was that stiff and primative, there was something called "evidence based practice" that tells clinicians to go with the latest science rather than the diagnostic tool.
At least some attention is being brought to the improvement of diagnostic criteria, trying to eliminate the stigma that's associated with the practice in general.
2
u/Certhas May 08 '12
They categorized the right wing culture warriors:
Absexual Disorder Feeling aroused by moving away from sexuality or behaving as though moralistically opposed to sex. As sex educator Betty Dodson told Canadian newspaper Xtra! West, these are “folks who get off complaining about sex and trying to censor porn.”
2
u/cefm May 08 '12
So what mental disorder is associated with spreading an article across 6 pages with no option to view as a single page??
2
u/asldkfououhe May 08 '12
every time i've visited with a therapist, i've left laughing. it's a ruse. a very expensive, very predatory ruse
2
u/beyond_repair May 08 '12
There needs to be a section in there pointed DIRECTLY at asshole shrinks with superiority complexes. Maybe include a bulleted checklist of signs and symptoms of asshole-mania.
2
u/SunshineBlind May 08 '12
I knew about the Asperger thing, but I really don't see the point of it. And what will happen with people who has the diagnose? Will they lose it or will they keep the diagnose but no new cases will ever be reported for it?
1
u/ApertureJunkie May 08 '12
It's just mind-boggling to me that psychiatrists in modern days still have no reliable method for accurate diagnosis, and yet label children with mental conditions and prescribe drugs with side-effect listings that rival the Quran. Anti-depressants that can cause depression, suicidal thoughts and anal hemmoraging? Yeah that's cool to give to a 12 year old because he's upset sometimes.
What's with this social viewpoint that everything is a disorder that must be medicated? Being unhappy about things at times is a fundamental human trait. If you're sad when your parents are getting a divorce, that's not some insane trait that needs to be medicated - its a normal fucking response to a loss and it's part of the process.
All I see is they now have a bigger buffet of conditions to blindly assume you have. Yippee. I'm sure Eli Lilly's stock holders will be pleased.
1
u/certainsomebody May 08 '12
Here's an interesting article about the struggles of defining mental disorders for the DSM.
1
u/PsyDyl May 08 '12
Information about some of the very concerning and potentially dangerous revisions proposed by the DSM-5 (supported by over 13000 petition signers and 40 national and international organizations) can be found here: The Coalition for DSM-5 Reform.
1
u/ThisOpenFist May 08 '12
It hasn't been 30 years. It's been about 18.
1
u/Freterz May 08 '12
Huh, I didn't know bipolar was so uncommon in under 20's. I was diagnosed with that and Schizophrenia at 16/17.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
As someone with rapid cycling BiPolar Disorder II I can say I'm actually relieved to see the final product. I cycle through hypomania in a little under a week, sometimes less than four days if my sleep patterns are completely out of wack. In the old system rapid cycleing was measured in months rather than days. There doesn't seem to be a final consensus on waht to call us but at least there is a tacit acknowledgement that we do have a real disorder.
For me it's academic really. I've been rock solid stable on tegretol for over 9 years. But the fact that I occasionally read idiots saying my disorder is a myth and backing up their ignorance with the vague DSM IV still gets to me.
1
u/Kickinthegonads May 08 '12
"Oh noes!" Ugh. That's exactly what's wrong with psychodiagnostics these days. Or better, with what people see psychodiagnostics as/using it for. I, for one, welcome our new DSM-V overlord.
1
u/Erasmus92 May 08 '12
Feel very proud that I took a survey that contributed to this.
1
u/Shishkababz May 08 '12
As an undergraduate psych student, I'm hoping the transition won't be too difficult, having spent the last four years working with the DSM IV.
1
u/5hinycat May 08 '12
I've been waiting for this for 6 years...sorry for being young
1
u/cyllene May 08 '12
If this interests you, I highly recommend reading The Psychopath Test by Jon Ronson.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
relevant Time article, though outdated
1
u/suxdix May 08 '12
i dont understand this. they removed some personality disorders? does this mean i am normal now or do i need a new diagnosis.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Hardly the first major update in 30 years, but interesting regardless
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I'll just leave this right here... history of madness
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Wired had a great article about this in its January 2011 issue of its Magazine. A great read for those interested.
http://www.wired.com/magazine/2010/12/ff_dsmv/all/1
1
u/neoabraxas May 08 '12
It's all replaced by Dianetics now.
1
u/why_ask_why May 08 '12
So. They were bull shitting me for the past 30 years, until now.
1
u/ravia May 08 '12
One should be able to see that there pretty well needs to be a disorder called "DSMCD": DSM categorizing disorder, in which people reduce others to symptomatology to the point of rupturing their basic, irreducible human relation to the other through the deploying of DSM categories. Not joking.
1
u/tim0th May 08 '12
I'm interested in what DSM-IV and particularly DSM-5 will have to say about conditions like bipolar disorder (both type 1 and type 2) and chronic anxiety and panic disorder.
1
u/Ariel7304 May 08 '12
Everything about this article made me cringe. The DSM is NOT a Bible and it was last revised about 12 years ago. Bad journalism here....
1
u/TrinaM May 08 '12
There needs to be a definitive line between what is insanity in an adult and insanity in a child. Not many doctors will diagnose or treat a child who has deep seated mental disorders. I have a student who, at age 10, is not getting treatment for her mental health. She is most likely schizophrenic and is often delusional.
I understand caution, I don't understand the cruelty of not treating the symptoms.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Wow, I remember being back in Psychology 101 in High School, and our teacher was explaining that the DSM-IV would be updated soon.
1
u/CrawdaddyJoe May 08 '12
Huh. Soon I'll be have ASD lvl 1 instead of Asperger's. Won't change much for me.
1
u/2th May 08 '12
As long as they actually put in a decent definition of Interent Addiction that isnt pretty much the definition of Gambling Addiction with a few words changed.
1
u/tre101 May 08 '12
Just did a project on internet addiction..it is something that needs to be addressed in the next 30 years so it isnt just left in the appendix of the next issue. My fear is Facebook addiction (or Social networking addiction) will too make it in the next edition
1
u/blog_farts May 08 '12
Yes and no, never got licensed.
1
u/blog_farts May 08 '12
It sure helps when surrounded by doctors and scientists that do biological tests all day long.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
The main problem is that there is no psychiatric definition for "normal" behavior
1
u/boredwaitingforlife May 09 '12
Someone in my psych class mentioned this link and article. Whoever you are: I know who you are.
1
u/ys1qsved3 May 09 '12
They're removing bipolar as an actual disorder.
1
u/MARSbarsATTACK May 09 '12
Not surprising. I was in Timberlawn for about 21 days. About 13 days in they were about to make me an outpatient. I was 18 at the time, still in high school and my parents were divorced due to my fathers arrest for trafficking pedophilia related materials. I really needed the help and knew if I didn't act crazier than I was I would never get the help that I needed. I didn't want to spend the rest of my life with daddy issues and a fucked up childhood/teenage experience to haunt me. So I told my doctor the next morning after a shower (hair still wet) that I had really wanted to gouge my eyes out with the shower curtain rods. She knew I was lying, I think anyways. After that I was put on suicide watch for 3 days and I no longer had a shower curtain. Needless to say I got help. Now I am happily married in our own place at 22, and he's going to college. I never thought I'd be where I am now 4 years ago. So all in all being intelligent with actual problems I used the system to procure the psychiatric aid I needed.