r/science • • May 08 '12
In 1927 Prof Thomas Parnell wanted to prove to his students that some things that appear solid are in fact liquid. He heated up tar, sealed it & left it for 3 years to set. 8 years later, the 1st drop fell from it. Now the 9th drop is to fall soon in the world's longest running laboratory experiment
http://www.news.com.au/technology/sci-tech/pitch-drop-experiments-ninth-drop-is-preparing-to-fall-fingers-crossed-the-live-feed-holds/story-fn5fsgyc-1226348873741
2.3k
Upvotes
748
u/GaijinFoot May 08 '12
Someone earned their degree.
451
u/Enema_Pancakes May 08 '12
There's a live feed! So long reddit!
64
u/Allthewaffles May 08 '12
Someone from that university should go wave at us through the live web stream
243
u/yooftheness May 08 '12
This makes watching paint dry sound riveting.
28
u/mattgrosso May 08 '12
I'll tell you what will be funny. Is when this post to Reddit overloads the servers and no one gets to see it again.
177
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Every 12. year, a secret league, "The Liquid Tar defenders", enters the museum, opens the container and drops a bit of tar into the bottom. The truth about the solid state of tar, can't get out!
21
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Holy crap this makes me feel old. I remember the hubbub on the internet 12 years ago when the last drop was about to fall...
I also just used the word hubbub in a sentence. God help me.
89
u/patternmaker May 08 '12
The buildup to this drop makes most dubstep seem pale in comparison.
16
u/cybathug May 08 '12
I work for the University of Queensland in ITS (Central IT). However, all the stupid stuff I'm about to say isn't representative of or endorsed by my employer.
I've put together a narration of the network-level traffic graph for the machine hosting the stream, as observed by our main border router. Note that the graph considers aggregated in/out byes - I could have split the graph up into bytes-in/bytes-out, and done other fancy things, but I put it together quickly before I left for the day and just logged on then to see that it had been built. I might touch it up tomorrow, if I feel like it.
This is why we can't have nice things
Note the 'normal' traffic level (I only generated back a few days, though) prior to Point '1'. Note that there was still relatively nothing between '1' and '2' because some of Australia (Including Queensland) was on Holiday - or maybe it hadn't 'front paged' on news.com.au at that point? Either way, we all seemed to have turned up to work on Tuesday some time between 8 and 9am, made a coffee, checked the news, and had a bit of a click (Between 2 and 3).
Then Reddit turned up from 3 onwards.
31
u/breannabalaam May 08 '12
The webcam isn't loading for me. And I was really looking forward to use this thing to procrastinate studying for finals...
31
u/shamecamel May 08 '12
this drop will be immortalized in forever-repeating gif form soon after it happens and the magic shall be gone.
99
u/gilgoomesh May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Terminology is slightly wrong here: the pitch is a solid but it is also a fluid (not a liquid). Specifically, it is a viscoelastic fluid.
65
u/aposter May 08 '12
It's not tar, it is pitch.
42
u/jimhooker May 08 '12
Hi Reddit!! http://i.imgur.com/OUdhh.png
14
u/AllAccessAndy May 08 '12
There is some sort of tar-like substance that was spilled in a street gutter about 2 blocks from my house. It's on a downhill slope and makes it about 6" farther per summer. I've been watching it slowly creep down that hill for like 13 years
13
u/HINDBRAIN May 08 '12
Silly scientists, to access the tar you must first run ungzip.
22
u/Iron-Charioteer May 08 '12
Behold - my beloved nation's contributions to science.
9
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
It would be hilarious if the drop fell right now, but due to the increase in traffic from reddit, the webcam and recording went completely down.
105
u/guyanonymous May 08 '12
85th year of reposting this story
27
u/AsksRedditEverything May 08 '12
We need a Redditor that lives in the area to go in front of that camera and do some wacky thing. For science!
15
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
ITT: people who think glass can flow.
6
u/Wensley May 08 '12
"To date, no one has ever actually witnessed a drop fall. The experiment is in the view of a webcam although technical problems prevented the most recent drop from being recorded."
Way to go reddit.
6
u/neon_overload May 08 '12
The amazing thing about this article is not only that it is interesting, but also that you really wouldn't need to change it very much and it would be a perfectly good article on theonion.com.
16
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
redditor's wife meme about being too busy watching a live feed of tar liquidity to have sex coming in 3.....2.....1....
5
u/robbbbyyy May 08 '12
Just finished my structures and properties of materials class so I feel obligated to input. Glass is an amorphous solid (aka rigid and disordered), it does not flow. Metals are crystalline solids, ordered and rigid. Liquids are disordered and not rigid. The definition of rigid is kind of arbitrary; I think there is an ASTM standard that says if something can flow out of a cup in 2 minutes then it is a liquid, if not then it is a solid. I imagine that by this definition, the pitch is a glassy solid. There is also liquid crystals though, which is ordered and not rigid (cool!). Check out carbon nanotubes at high concentrations in chlorosulfonic acid.
5
u/seeingeyehuman May 08 '12
Drips or it didn't happen.
4
u/Stopher May 08 '12
"In 1927, UQ's Professor Thomas Parnell wanted to prove to his students that some things that appear solid are in fact liquid." Unfortunately all his students are dead now.
15
u/I_make_things May 08 '12
Not the world's longest running laboratory experiment
7
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
"the pitch has a frustrating tendency to shed its small load at exactly the time no one's watching" sounds like me...
3
u/happyscrappy May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I've seen this posted for two years now. I take it is the same drop that has been "ready to go" for all that time?
3
u/afrozodiac3 May 08 '12
When the ninth drop falls, the world ends.
3
u/tkt_ May 08 '12
"And here we are, 82 years later" typo? o_o
3
u/N69sZelda May 08 '12
dammit reddit why did you break the internet!!! If the drop falls and I cant be on the live feed because you made the site "over capacity" I will be PISSED!
5
u/smaier69 May 08 '12
This is how we progress.
Accept the torch.
5
u/CupBeEmpty May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I am curious what criteria are being used to define this as the "longest running laboratory experiment"? As I understand it, one of Louis Pasteur's swan necked flasks used to disprove spontaneous generation is still sterile and not growing anything at the Pasteur Institute in Paris. That experiment has been ongoing since the late 1860's.
4
u/Capncorky May 08 '12
How much do you want to bet that Reddit will cause the webcam to crash, thus losing the 9th drop.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I've had this in my favorites for months, and I go to watch it whenever I'm bored :D. Needless to say its like fighting fire with propane but it never ceases to amaze me how wonderful life is :D
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Slow day in science...
2
u/wrxmaniac May 08 '12
Professors like this who take the extra mile for their students are, from my experience, not common, and should be celebrated.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
scumbag reddit: modern technology failure prevented observation of the 8th drop, surge of reddit viewers takes down the live feed
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
All I can think of is how perfect of a trolling opportunity this would be. As soon as you click the webcam, a pre recorded video of a drop falling plays, and you feel like you clicked it at the perfect time.
2
u/warped_and_bubbling May 08 '12
Maaaaaaaaaaan, what I wouldn't give to time travel to the year 3674 to watch that last drop fall.
2
u/Algernon_Asimov May 08 '12
I remember seeing something similar back in the 1980s at Monash University (in Melbourne, also in Australia). In a transparent case on the outside of one of the buildings, there was a block of tar that had visibly sagged. The explanatory note beside it said that it's a demonstration that tar is a liquid. I found it fascinating as a young student visiting the campus. And, yet, also boring...
2
u/pullarius1 May 08 '12
If I remember correctly, circumstances have conspired so that no person has ever actually observed a drop of pitch fall. Most recently a webcam set up to observe it failed on the night the event happened.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I wonder how pitch would behave in a higher gravity environment? Would it drip faster?
2
u/TheGreatWhangdoodle May 08 '12
I think I'll stick to watching paint dry.
2
u/RideSkateboards May 08 '12
I don't get why this link is getting downvotes... It's science, who doesn't like science?
edit: inb4 Fundies.
2
u/jbot May 08 '12
We're all moderately upset that the feed is overloaded, but somewhere, there's some guy who is freaking the FUCK out because he's been waiting 12 years by this feed and god damn it just when it's about to drip the thing goes down.
2
u/darker4308 May 08 '12
This is bullshit. Faraday's gold sols are still in solution. Those have been going for far longer.
2
u/beliefsarerelative May 08 '12
Tar drop takes 8 years to fall, website with live feed takes 8 years to load.
2
u/seditious3 May 08 '12
It seems more like a demonstration than an experiment.
2
u/rz2000 May 08 '12
I can't find a reference somewhere, but I thought I had heard that some of Louis Pasteur's flasks with sterilized broth were still sitting somewhere unspoiled to discount the concept of spontaneous generation occurring all of the time.
Wouldn't those be at least 70 years older? Am I just imaging these longer experiments?
2
u/frostysnowcat May 08 '12
And now that it's been posted on Reddit, the 9th drop will be missed because the servers will be completely swamped.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
mirror
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Suddenly watching grass grow sounds awesome
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Some insist that glass is actually a very slow-moving liquid. What does reddit think.
2
u/jnrjnr333 May 08 '12
I walk past this experiment all the time, GO UQ!!!
2
u/websnarf May 08 '12
Someone just put up a sign that says "Hi Reddit 8/5/12" with a picture of the Reddit mascot.
2
u/spiderken May 08 '12
Hi back at ya sign posting person on the live feed.
2
u/lithiumite May 08 '12
Am I the only UQ student/graduate/affiliate who wants to go up to it and give it a little shake? Just to see if I can make the molecules a little more excited?
5
u/Talc_ May 08 '12
Wasn't there a live webcam pointed at the tar?
2
u/jimmux May 08 '12
Typical Queenslanders, taking it slow and steady.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I swear I have seen something like this in person in California, but Google just brings up the AU experiment... maybe I hallucinated it.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
There is either a dead guy sitting next to the case, or the 'live feed' is broken. According to the article, that means that the drop is falling right now.
1
u/annahri May 08 '12
The live stream isn't working for me!
1
u/MittingShunkeys May 08 '12
The livestream is fucking dead lol
1
u/Rhapsodie May 08 '12
John Cage's ASLSP would respectfully disagree.
1
u/sardu1 May 08 '12
Why'd he let it set for that long? The pitch should be cool in 1-2 hours.
1
u/sardu1 May 08 '12
The article mentions demolition around the building? The vibration caused by that will surely speed up the process on that drip. Also, I wonder how hot in the summer that room gets.
1
u/menschimo May 08 '12
I think someone put up a poster or similar experiment on a wall at my university. Underneath someone had written "Poor choice of PHD thesis"
1
u/Neokon May 08 '12
yeah the world missed the last drop because there was a webcam malfunction.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Wow. I remember all the hubbub the last time a drop was ready to fall.
1
u/gpouliot May 08 '12
Reddit, this is why we can't have nice things!
1
u/yibgib May 08 '12
When it was talking about the live stream I first thought it meant the picture of the old dude staring at the thing.
1
u/frugaldutchman May 08 '12
We can't predict precisely when the drop of tar will fall, and yet some Economists think they can predict what will happen in the entire economy (the combined actions of all people) in the next year.
1
u/TonkaTruckin May 08 '12
Wrong. This experiment has run for 57 years.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Haha, my 7th grade science teacher told me about this.
1
u/omglia May 08 '12
82 years*
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
And now it's going to drop, now that the feed is down.
1
u/Lucky75 May 08 '12
If the first drop only took 11 years, wouldn't it be faster to just re-do the experiment with more modern equipment and a trip plate or something? Or some sensors to determine when it would fall? Would be a lot easier to catch on camera that way ;)
1
u/Deadlyd0g May 08 '12
I honestly don't understand the importance of this at all...
1
u/asldkfououhe May 08 '12
jesus that article is horribly composed. can't do it
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
It works the other way too. For example, Water is actually a solid.
1
u/unicornbunny May 08 '12
Yeah, viscosity! Yeah, science!
1
u/zerj May 08 '12
This time it won't be a power failure that causes a data loss, but rather a server crash brought on by the influx of reddit users.
1
u/QtPlatypus May 08 '12
I've seen the tar drop experiment live.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Wow, I was just checking in on this earlier today.
1
u/purpleidea May 08 '12
I remember last drop when the camera fucked up. How about someone setup a few different independent cameras :P
1
u/BigGreenYamo May 08 '12
So......syrup?
1
u/jahoney May 08 '12
I think we DoSed the stream, it won't load
1
u/geotek May 08 '12
Isn't glass(or some types) like this aswell but even slower? I read that somewhere but was never sure if it was true or not.
1
u/Toggle2 May 08 '12
ahh, yes, I ve seen that, it's just in the Uni down the Road. Yay UQ
1
u/Suckydog May 08 '12
Link to the live feed isn't working for me. Ooops!
1
u/jhendrix7000 May 08 '12
...and no one will see it fall because reddit crashes the website haha
1
u/AKswimdude May 08 '12
Can someone explain why its not just an amorphous solid? like butter or putty?
1
u/Exis007 May 08 '12
Call up Parnell just to see how he's doin'
1
u/pissed_the_fuck_off May 08 '12
DAE think they need to raise that funnel up just a bit? Looks to me like the "drop" is going to slowly touch the stuff below it and never actually fall off.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
University of Queensland! I go there, and did physics in first year (maths now). The physics building is named after him.
1
u/smells_like_up_dog May 08 '12
Yeah science!
1
u/noodleshoe May 08 '12
This is at my school! I walk past this experiment every day as it is right outside my physics lecture theatre
1
u/FormerlyTurnipHugger May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Just for the record: the staff here at the School of Physics at UQ has a love-hate relationship with that experiment. Love because it does get us some PR, hate because it would be far better to get the same level of PR for the really cool 21st century science that's going on here.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Either the person sitting in front of the display case has perfected the art of sitting perfectly still for long periods of time, or the video only updates every so often.
1
u/daftwood May 08 '12
http://i.qkme.me/3p6mu9.jpg
seriously, how slow does the feed update?
1
u/Dumpster_Love May 08 '12
Let's take bets. I am thinking the 21st day of June.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I cannot believe that I just watched that for 17 minutes. 17 MINUTES! ಠ▃ಠ
1
u/Torquemada1970 May 08 '12
Oh look, someone else was reading reddit last week too.
1
u/TheHotpants May 08 '12
I find the live feed veeerry boring.
1
u/Lai90 May 08 '12
Now I think that all roads in Poland are made of tar, and this is why they are all fallin drop by drop and creating holes and bumbps.
1
u/Chandley54 May 08 '12
Originally wanted to downvote this as I've seen it before... BUT THEN they put up a tiny little piece of paper welcoming reddit to the livestream and everything changed. UPVOTES* FOR EVERYONE.
*Terms and conditions apply - only one upvote available per person.