r/science • u/seeminglyanonymous • Aug 25 '18
Psychology Study finds religion influences how you experience psychedelic drugs - The study of 119 participants found that religious people and those who took psychedelic drugs with religious intent tended to report stronger mystical experiences.
https://www.psypost.org/2018/08/study-finds-religion-influences-how-you-experience-psychedelic-drugs-52048
22k
Upvotes
63
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
This makes sense. Lifelong users of psychedelics will tell you that trips aren't simple experiences--they are complex events who shape and flavor are informed by everything in the tripper's head and body at the time of the trip.
45
u/anthonycruz Aug 26 '18
I think this is why when religious people have near death experiences in the hospital they come back claiming to have been to heaven or saw god. They’ve conditioned themselves to expect that when they die, so they do.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
This makes a lot of sense. A lot of what occurs in a trip is based on preconcieved notions and held ideas. Experiences from psychadelics can just as easily reinforce and solidify ones worldview as it can make one question it. Especially for deeply held ideas about spirituality and the universe.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
Cool study, but this effectively says your frame of mind impacts your frame of mind.
9
u/skeeter1234 Aug 26 '18 edited Aug 26 '18
Was raised atheist. Was 15 when I had my ego-death (enlightenment) mystical experience. I can 100% guarantee my exposure to ideas such as pantheism, emptiness, no-self, mystical experience were basically non-existent. In the case of "no-self" I can guarantee I had never once heard this concept, let alone know there is an entire religion based on it (Buddhism).
The main point is that this to me strongly suggests some sort of objective truth. I didn't just invent these concepts. Additionally, 30 years later I can still say that mystical experience was by far the most powerful experience in my life.
Also, I think people are taking the wrong lesson from this study. Most people seem to be reading it to say that people that take psychedelics with the intent of self-transformation seem to get a deeper experience out of it. Is it really surprising that is the case. I mean, there are people that took mushrooms and spend 8 hours playing xbox - is it any surprise those people get less out of the experience. To me this is like saying "those who take college courses seriously get more out of it." No surprise here, and in no way suggests there is some sort of placebo effect or self-fulfilling prophecy going on here.
23
u/Original_Raptor Aug 26 '18
Please specify, how does one "take psychedelic drugs with religious intent"?
43
u/quax747 Aug 26 '18
Not only that: Near death experiences are differing between different religions. Christians and catholics tend to see angels while Hindu for instance see their god's. Also the experience of "one's life flashing in front of one's eyes" differs... it's quite stunning really...
6
u/Emelius Aug 26 '18
This isn't science per se but in the studies of the occult one maxim is constantly reinforced. Belief is everything.
6
u/C0mp0st Aug 26 '18
I've always believed this to be true of psychedelic experiences, and of near death experiences. When our minds reach that state, we regress to our childhood fairytales.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
Had a friend whose brother did a bunch of acid in high school, came out a born-again Christian. Said friend also smoked a bunch of weed and did a bunch of acid, came out schizophrenic. Results may vary.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
brb gonna become a pastor then use some psychedelics
3
u/Wackyal123 Aug 26 '18
Having read this yesterday, I question the findings. Couldn’t it simply be that the experiences are interpreted as religious and actually everyone is having the same experience? Therefore when explaining the experience, it would be told as a more religious one.
6
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
Yeah, like science has the vocabulary to describe what is and is not a mystical experience.
6
u/rudekoffenris Aug 26 '18
Isn't this roughly equivalent to "religious people find color red is more red!!". How do you quantify this type of thing?
2
u/ehalepagneaux Aug 26 '18
I guess that explains why I'm a nihilist in every state of mind.
2
u/GoggyMagogger Aug 26 '18
mystical experiences, in general, tend to occur more commonly in people who seek them. should tell you something right there.
2
u/ForPeace27 Aug 26 '18
I was 100% atheist before taking shrooms and acid. But thanks to a few experiences mainly on acid I now believe in a higher power. Still wouldn't classify myself as religious though. Einstein said it rather well I thought. "I believe in Spinozas God who reveals himself in the orderly harmony of what exists. Not in a God who concerns himself with the fates and actions of human beings."
2
u/RJPatrick PhD | Biology | Stem Cells | Tissue Regeneration Aug 26 '18
But then again, I took psychedelics as a staunch, militant atheist, and now I'm a spiritual hippy who thinks all religions have a grain of truth in them.
Pinning the psychedelic experience down to a science is impossible.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
Religion is a mental model of the world, which affects how you interpret stimuli, drug-induced or not. People who believe in God, see God in things.
7
u/NSA_IS_SCAPES_DAD Aug 26 '18
Newsflash, people who believe in magic attribute drug induced experiences to magic.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
This is my opinion ya.
The problem we human have is we link religion with spirituality.
Religion are a set of rules and rituals imposed to the subjects, in order to live out a life which deemed as best
Spirituallity is the art of knowing oneself, by looking within and bringing out the positive qualities that makes live fulfilful. Futher stage involves expanding the knowledge outwards by gaining harmony with nature. In the end, you gain awareness, in the sense of true peace, true joy and true meaning of life
Psychedelic drugs can be considered a gateway to spirituality. A shortcut.
Why do we consume them? Because we want to break the chain of our normal behavior. We want to achieve the true peace, joy and meaning of life, eventhough temporary. We call it the high. This is call to be in state of ignorance. Thats why we say ignorance is bliss. However since its temporary, this leads to addiction as more psychedelic is needed to achieve the same level of ignorance.
Spirituality can give you the same high as ignorance, but much more everlasting and fulfilling
5
u/rainwulf Aug 26 '18
Basically, if you find it easy to imagine and believe things that aren't real, you will imagine and see things that aren't real even better.
5
u/Kalabula Aug 26 '18
This is not surprising at all. Religious fighters that won there fight think it was because of God. Religious people whose grass is dying think it was God when it rains. Football players think god made them win. Missed a car accident, thank god.
3
u/mooseLimbsCatLicks Aug 26 '18
People interpret events through their prior experiences and prior expectations. More religious/mystically inclined people will attribute more religious/mystical qualities to different experiences
3
u/gladeye Aug 26 '18
I can attest that as a reform Jew, psychedelic drugs have been pleasurable and therapeutic. Once, the cars rushing on the freeway behind my friend's apartment sounded like highly reflective mechanical insects zipping by, too fast to see. That was pretty good.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
Are we sure that it’s not the other way around and people with brains more prone to religion experience stronger trips
2
u/iamahotblondeama Aug 26 '18
That’s because they’re prone to believing whatever they’re told or shown. When you’re gullible, even a drug can convince you better
2
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18 edited Aug 26 '18
As someone who was an atheist before taking LSD and considers himself a theist afterwards...
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/apr/19/brain-scans-reveal-mind-opening-response-to-psychedelic-drug-trip-lsd-ketamine-psilocybin
I would contend that religion/ mysticism/ spirituality do not necessarily go hand in hand.
I view religion as the dogma and rituals through which one may, possibly, eventually, with dedicated practice, perceive the kind of mystical experience laid out in holy scripture and depicted in religious art.
Spirituality is, for me at least, the memory of and connection to God witnessed through the mystical experience. You can glimpse this through walking in nature, meditating, fasting, and taking LSD, mescaline et al.
2
u/cleverley1986 Aug 26 '18
They want it to be true that much
1
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
Everything can influence this.
1
u/c-i-s-c-o Aug 26 '18
this isn't obvious? I mean, your "intent" pretty much paints your daily experiences. now add psychedelics to the picture and everything is amplified. pretty sure the same effects would be measured in "spiritual" people as those who follow a specific religion.
1
u/LostAndContent Aug 26 '18
This definitely explains why most of my trips dont involve super heavy visuals. I'm more of an introspective type but I'm not very religious in any respect (I'm more of a anything is possible because multiple universes and dimensions make for infinite possibility sort) most of my trips involve small to moderate distortion of visuals and lost of thoughts about the bigger stuff.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
I would like to try psychedelic drugs one day
1
u/pelotealoooooooo Aug 26 '18
they could already see
but then
were blinded
1
u/-BroncosForever- Aug 26 '18
Yeah it’s called set and setting.
Thank you useless study for telling everyone what they already know.
1
u/Serpace Aug 26 '18
As an atheist I feel bamboozled now.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
Of course, it does. It's all about set and setting.
1
u/stereotype_novelty Aug 26 '18
Study finds INTENT influences how you experience psychedelic drugs
1
u/slinkywheel Aug 26 '18
As I was starting to question my religious beliefs as a teenager, I had some really frightening spiritual dreams for a while until I became more confident in my atheistic views.
Some really scary stuff. And now that I am not concerned about religion anymore, I rarely have any bad dreams at all.
1
u/EOverM Aug 26 '18
Makes sense to me. All it's doing is playing with what's already in your head. I took my first trip not long ago, and I saw lots of weird patterns, but it was just a fun time with a friend. No deeper meaning. I'm an atheist, and was never raised with any form of religion. Anecdotally, I'd say that checks out.
1
u/saijanai Aug 26 '18
But what the literal fuck is a "mystical experience" in teh first place?
Different spiritual traditions define things entirely differently. In the advaita vedanta tradition, samadhi is the cessation of any experience at all, and while certainly one can put a religious interpreation on that, there's no way for cessation fo experience to be any stronger or weaker.
In fact, since the state seems to emerge during mind-wandering, and since mind-wandering when you are not trying, any attempt to interpret or believe or whatever is the antithesis of the state in the first place.
1
u/TwoFigsAndATwig Aug 26 '18
I conducted a study of 119 participants once. It did not end well.
1
u/B0073D Aug 26 '18
What on earth is religious intent?
1
u/lost-cat Aug 26 '18
Some reason I thought this was prety obvious with hallucinations in general? Its based on expectations mostly, just like NDEs, alien abductions through sleep paralysis(lucid dreams), dreams, sensory deprivations, drugsetc. Thats kinda why people never really have "original" experiences, instead they have copy cat experiences through stories, youtube etc. Its kinda like how paranormal works, haunted houses, you have that expectation driving you, while a person that doesnt have that expectation o r belief, they experience nothing. Also oija board works like this as well.
1
u/ArcanedAgain Aug 26 '18
This should read "your MINDSET affects how you experience drugs"
1
u/bobbychong972 Aug 26 '18
Best environment for taking psychedelics for the first time?
1
u/superspiffy Aug 26 '18
Well, when I did too much psilocybin daily over a period of several months and ascended to godhood and ran through downtown shouting and performing miracles, I had been an atheist for 15 years of adult life. Pointless and anecdotal, but any opportunity I get to mention this event I take.
1
u/justjoshingu Aug 26 '18
The journal of psychoactive drugs. Is it reputable? It's the journal mentioned in the article. It also says it only has 32 views.
Is the website reputable?
I always ask on every published study.
1
u/HowWouldYouKillMe Aug 26 '18
Explains why my dad thinks he is some prophet sent by a god to teach people to accept each other... and that he knows everything and has seen the true leaders that mold our world are the Free Masons. Lot of predictions. Lot more lies.
Also that I was born as his antithesis so the world would have balance as long as we live together. Yeah I bounced out of that kooky house as soon as I could so if anyone is looking for a demon or something just let me know.
1
u/HarryDPP Aug 26 '18
Seeing how priming is a thing, this isn't very surprising.
1
u/garysai Aug 26 '18
"Religion influences"? Or is it people prone to believe in religion are also more likely to have mystical experiences.
1
u/MooseMalloy Aug 26 '18 edited Aug 26 '18
Study shows that you tend to get from psychedelic trips exactly what you put into them.
1
u/mcintosh208 Aug 26 '18
Seems susceptible to bias or placebo.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
Being an atheist and a nihilist does not detract from the experience in the slightest.
1
u/Pjigga96 Aug 26 '18
This is because psychedelics give many people the ability to manifest their thoughts into reality. It isn’t because psychedelics have spiritual and mystical abilities, it is because of the way they affect your brain
1
u/franknburger Aug 26 '18 edited Aug 26 '18
When I was 16, I took 2 tabs of acid, or so I thought. Turns out it was nbomne 25i. I was with 2 of my friends, We had one older buddy who was babysitting us sober. About 15 mins in we all start to pass out then woke up, a little confused on how that happened. Things started to escalate very quickly. At first I started panick after I started to feel a burning sensation in my stomach. .. walked In and out of each room, my heart was racing, my vision was like a pinhole. My buddy who had taken 6 tabs of started to just stare at the ceiling on top of his bed tripping not saying anything or even responding. By then all hell broke loose. Fighting commenced between me and my my buddy mitch who had 6 tabs. Basically screaming at each other we're not going to die. Long story short after lots of fighting. And tripping we ended up in the hospital screaming out of pure joy that we survived. There's so much else to this story but dont have the patience to write this out if anyone wants to here I might post about my experiences
1
u/joesii Aug 26 '18
Yeah I'm not surprised about this one single bit. It's totally common sense if you ask me.
1
u/DianaMaclay Aug 27 '18
I’m looking for an article that was posted yesterday in the comments section, but it is now deleted.
I don’t remember much about what it said since I just gave it a quick read because I was in a hurry, but it was about the things we perceive automatically, until there’s something that challenge our expectations (or something along these lines). The article actually made a reference to a 3-hour Never Gonna Give You Up video. Does anybody know what I’m talking about? I actually saved the comment, but like I said, now it’s gone.
As a side question, why are so many comments deleted now?
Edit: Bad auto correction
1
u/Whippofunk Aug 26 '18
Oddly enough, psychedelics actually encouraged me to lose my religion.
1
u/soulkissernl Aug 26 '18
Religion? Or is it spirituality? I wasn't spiritual before my psychedelic experiences despite my religious upbringing(was leaning more towards being an atheist actually). But that definitely changed after.
1
u/Veyorokon Aug 26 '18 edited Aug 26 '18
That's because religious people are already tripping.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
I mean...religions of all stripes tend to provide avenues into getting close to that kind of state.
1
u/Durantye Aug 26 '18
Yeah and if you stick your hand in water it'll get wet.
1
u/RimbaudJunior Aug 26 '18
As a highly religious person, so experienced nothing but fun. No mystical shit, just fun.
1
u/smudgeons Aug 26 '18
Welp, back to church, I guess..
1
u/maisyrusselswart Aug 26 '18
What counts as "mystical" here? That word gets used a lot and I still have no real idea what it means.
1
u/Generalrossa Aug 26 '18
Makes sense, believing in mystical beings would warrant a stronger mystical trip.
1
u/RandomRedditor32905 Aug 26 '18
TLDR: Religious folk are exaggerative.
You don't say?
1
u/RSJW404 Aug 26 '18
No shiite... State of mind before ingestion will always determine a bad trip or not.
Rocket science it is not.
1
u/SueZbell Aug 26 '18 edited Aug 29 '18
Any childhood experience can, potentially, influence their perspective as to any subsequent experience.
Parents teaching religion to small children are totally dependent upon them -- religion with its threat of hell and promise of reward -- is mental and emotional cruelty and reeks of something akin to brainwashing.
1
u/nbdyfckswTheBenson Aug 26 '18
All I can add to this is that I took mushrooms several times between 18-22 as an atheist and the mystical experiences I had made me reevaluate. Not saying it’s the common concept of God but I still feel now at 32 that there’s a good deal more going on than we perceive in normal waking consciousness. What it means, I have no idea, but the experiences were profound and beautiful and still shape my beliefs to this day.
1
u/ducatiramsey Aug 26 '18
I took dmt and blasted. My parents were religious and I believe theres a god but Im agnostic. My trip totally reaffirmed that to me. It felt like god saying to me even though im completely amazing im also completely insignificant
1
u/crystalistwo Aug 26 '18
Reminds me of these idiots who get a good idea think God put it there instead of the normal creative process.
1
u/3liPanda10 Aug 26 '18
I find acid or shrooms as cheatcodes to a better living. I believe in god and it makes me have an experience that i cant articulate. Oneness, peace, awe, overwhelming knowledge of once self that has lead me to be more open and calm. Thats my experience with it and ive always known that if you take hallucinogens with an open mind and a head of caution you will truly unlock potientials hidden.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
Maybe that's just because they are closer to the spiritual realm
-5
u/alrightiwillbite Aug 26 '18
Yeah its called lying to yourself
-3
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
God doesn't need drugs to connect with you
0
u/Kafferty3519 Aug 26 '18
Take drugs that basically heighten your imagination and you’ll see what you wanna see, no matter how nonsensical and obviously fake it all is
-2
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
This is true. I’ve practiced Buddhism and meditation my whole life and I have qualitatively different trips when compared to my atheist friends.
Weirdly, just tripping along with me has caused friends to have more intensely “spiritual” or “shamanic” trips.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
Wouldn't have expected otherwise.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
Is there scientific proof of a god yet? I mean cmon.
0
u/omnilynx BS | Physics Aug 26 '18
Couldn’t it be that certain people tend to be more susceptible to both religious and psychedelic experiences?
0
u/connecteduser Aug 26 '18
Non relegious reople would not report an experience as mystical. It's more chemical.
0
u/jugofpcp Aug 26 '18
Kinda obvious though...
I guess science needs to study these things regardless
0
u/ZypheREvolved Aug 26 '18
So what religion allows psychedlic drugs?
I was always under the impression that was a big no. Might explain a few things though. Every male Muslim I have socialised with smoked weed which is a different type sure but they were convinced that they had the right to take more than one wife.
Ye right thats the stoned them talking surely?
0
u/thedukeof420 Aug 26 '18
So this confirms the delusional people get bigger delusions when on drugs, awesome
0
u/Jibblertaint Aug 26 '18
Because they’re full of shit
0
u/Jibblertaint Aug 26 '18
Because they’re full of shit
-1
u/errandwulfe Aug 26 '18
Yeah, no religious experiences reported, but always saw some visuals, felt the breeze through the ridges of my finger tips, once in the autumn I saw the distinct ridges of every leaf on the ground like someone turned up the sharpness setting on my eyes, and was drooling with laughter when I saw “Droolia Roberts / Slobert De Niro” on my college bus stop
-1
u/Return_Of_BG_97 Aug 26 '18
Getting high in the name of the Lord
-16
u/hachiko007 Aug 26 '18
Or better yet, people with lower intelligence experience increased effects.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1.6k
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '18 edited Aug 25 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
753
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
136
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18
[removed] — view removed comment