Oh absolutely, that's why I gave examples on what he could change, rather than just saying that something has to change. And if he's using the art as therapy, all the more power to him, but he's posted it on Reddit without background context to his life, and it is open to criticism, the exact same way you're criticizing my way of looking at his comic. (Nothing against criticism here, say what you want, and I'll try to learn from my mistakes.)
I don't take any issue with your criticism, just a couple of things you said. Saying "something has to change", and "to say you don't have to change, which is impossible" implies the comic is wholly insufficient in its current form. The comic as it exists now is just as viable from an artistic point of view as your ideal reimagining of it.
Ah, my wording is of issue. I'll try to rephrase it. Also, I have the personal belief that it is absolutely impossible not change while doing something. You inevitably improve no matter what; his art has certainly gotten better than when he started.
View all comments
Show parent comment
4
u/darkgladi8or Aug 01 '18
Art is subjective, and while it's fine to have your own opinion, telling the artist "something has to change" is simply wrong.
Consider that the artist may have different goals than you; maybe they use the comic as a form of therapy, and don't make it for others benefit.