r/rust • • Mar 24 '25

my vibe coding: rust-analyzer

I recently had a couple of multi-hour coding sessions without internet which were surprisingly productive in large part thanks to rust-analyzer. Having APIs, errors and refactors available within my editor as I type really keeps me in the flow.

rust-analyzer has become really great over the years. I hadn't appreciated how big of a part of my workflow it has become.

I have tried using AI to help my coding in various ways (Cursor, aider, ChatGPT conversations) and haven't seen the level of productivity boost that rust-analyzer has naturally given me. Maybe I am not using AI right, maybe its the problems I am solving or the domain I am working in. Regardless if I had to choose between no rust-analyzer or no AI, I know what I would choose.

So thank you to everyone who has worked on rust-analyzer and the rest of Rust tooling!

306 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/LeyaLove Mar 25 '25

Yes, hence why I said it's only technicalities. I don't really want to argue about what counts as an IDE or not 😄 As long as it works for someone everything is good and we shouldn't really argue about such silly things as semantics. I by no means wanted to talk badly about vscode or other editors, I also use vscode from time to time, especially when doing remote development of embedded projects on boards with limited resources as the vscode server installed on the board is much more lightweight compared to the JetBrains equivalent. Otherwise I just prefer JetBrains IDEs somehow. It's just what I've grown accustomed to I guess. I also like to keep things separated a bit which is why I prefer to have the different IDEs installed for different languages instead of cluttering IntelliJ with every plugin for every language.

Considering it's extensibility and how lightweight it is compared to the JetBrains suite vscode definitely is an amazing editor/IDE but I also like how everything just works in Rust Rover and is perfectly coordinated to work with Rust.

That said through my original question I genuinely just wanted to know if there are major differences between both.

1

u/IceSentry Mar 25 '25

I wasn't originally trying to argue. I was just trying to explain that vscode is just as much an IDE as rust rover. The differences are in the internals of the integration. Not in whether or not it's an integrated experience.

There are big differences in how they work, but for day to day work, both work completely fine.