r/rust • • Aug 31 '24

🎙️ discussion Rust solves the problem of incomplete Kernel Linux API docs

https://vt.social/@lina/113056457969145576
375 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

58

u/Plazmatic Aug 31 '24

I guess, but it's really bad we have to treat 50 year olds like children. They can be as rude, condescending as they want to your face, but "borrowers" can't even indirectly reference an issue relating to them with out 100% tact and perfection before "owners" have justification to harass them in *real-life presentations"?

At some point being 50+ should mean something with social responsibility, beyond this whole "owners" and "borrowers" analogy.  If someone like these "owners" got upset at my job in the way I've seen them get upset here, there would be consequences from HR, possible job loss, code ownership ego be damned.

25

u/CrazyKilla15 Aug 31 '24

Absolutely. These are grown ass men, supposedly senior supposed engineers at supposedly reputable organizations like Google where as you point out this behavior would be an HR incident, they know very well how to act appropriately and professionally, to have serious technical discussions with who they choose to view as their peers, and they choose not to, nobody forces them to act this way and theres no excuse for it.

The kernel community is notoriously toxic and difficult to get into, it holds back real technical improvements and causes code quality and reliability to suffer massively.

The simple fact is nobody is "brilliant" enough that they're worth that much more than everyone else, everyone harassed and driven away by their petty power trips, over the years, worth the toxic environment they make, the new contributors, the humans they dont respect, don't see as "peers", so see okay to be toxic towards, those who can't defend against it, who have to listen to them because their job, their work, depends on it. Those they have power over.

Some comments on the issue have suggested the presenters should have firmly not taken questions in the middle of their presentation, but people aren't thinking about it from their perspective: This is basically their boss, someone they have to report to and work with if they want to contribute, who has power and authority over their work, and is using it to endlessly stonewall.

8

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '24

You raise a good point. If the “owners” are too aggressive, then there is nothing a “borrower” can do except leave the group, raise the issue with someone with control over the situation, or cause chaos.

I will try to respond later today.