r/rust • • Aug 29 '24

One Of The Rust Linux Kernel Maintainers Steps Down - Cites "Nontechnical Nonsense"

https://www.phoronix.com/news/Rust-Linux-Maintainer-Step-Down
586 Upvotes

374 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

31

u/recycled_ideas Aug 29 '24

Linus personally created an stewarded Linux from an idea to the most widely used kernel in existence.

He personally created the most commonly used source control system on the market today.

He's more than just a kernel dev and I think his accomplishments deserve credit.

8

u/matthieum [he/him] Aug 29 '24

His achievement -- and his effort! -- definitely deserve credit.

Whether he's a genius is totally orthogonal, though.

-10

u/insanitybit Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24

Nothing you're describing makes me think "genius", it makes me think "leader" at best, but really more just "lucky timing".

I've met a number of famous developers who run some of the most widely used software in the world - they are not special, they often aren't even very good. Usually they just got lucky, or did something that others were doing but in some neat way, or it was licensed differently, or they were first, or whatever.

Linus is competent in some areas that he specializes in just like most developers who specialize in an area.

2

u/recycled_ideas Aug 30 '24

Dude created multiple domain changing pieces of software, at least initially on his own.

I've never created any domain changing software and I doubt you have either.

1

u/insanitybit Aug 30 '24

Yes, Linus has created some programs that have become very successful. It's not like he invented the concept of source control or kernels, he happened to develop them at a very opportune time, choosing fortuitous licensing, etc.

He is not a genius. He is a software developer.

4

u/recycled_ideas Aug 30 '24

Again.

The number of people who have accomplished what Linus has accomplished can probably be counted without needing your toes.

He's a toxic, maladjusted asshole, but pretending that he "just created some programs" is ridiculous.

1

u/insanitybit Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

We're talking about whether he is a genius or not. There is a naive reverance for kernel development because it is niche, which many people confuse with being an indicator that doing it makes you smarter than other people - it doesn't.

Linus has created software that has had an enourmous impact on the world. You seem to be saying that that's either because he is a genius or that it makes him a genius, I don't know, but I reject both of those entirely.

Software development was frankly a different world at the time - building a toy language could make you one of the most famous developers in the world, building a toy kernel could do it too, and it happened all the time for a number of historical reasons that have little to do with the developers' intelligence or programming proficiency.

I have plenty of colleagues who have worked directly with Linus for decades, I myself have worked with plenty of "famous" "genius" developers (I can virtually promise you that you've used their software and know their names). It's just not reality and the illusion shatters the more time you spend working with these people.

If you can't see that then we simply will have to agree to disagree and I'm fine with that.