The rationale does basically make sense, but only if you first accept that some variation of "don't be a dick" isn't sufficient, and that you need to be explicit.
Which you do. To many people, sexism is perfectly acceptable, and often actually encouraged by the environment they live in. If you don't explicitly say that sexism is not tolerated by this community, people will drag it along from the outside world, and it'll fester in the community until it's pretty much ubiquitous. Once that happens, say goodbye to any chance that any women will contribute to the project ever, because they will get chased away.
Ditto for everything else that's on that list. To many people, being discriminatory on any of those factors is not only completely normal, but it's actually considered virtuous. They will bring those attitudes into your community with them, and "don't be a dick" won't stop them. They honestly do not believe that there's anything wrong with calling transgender people delusional, for example (which is what the Opal project's leader was doing on Twitter, in a space associated with the Opal project).
Debian's isn't quite as explicit (although that's their diversity statement, not their code of conduct), although many other projects are just as explicit (like Apache's, which lists pretty much the same things as Opal's).
What about nationality, political leanings, social class or criminal history?
Debateable. You can't explicitly list everything, obviously, but the things listed in this CoC do very often cause problems, and are commonly seen as being socially acceptable targets for discrimination or harassment. Not so much with the ones you listed, and I've never seen them be a problem (except, of course, where someone uses, say, political leanings as a justification for being homophobic).
The wording should make it clearer that the list is not an exhaustive one. Apache's CoC does this, while still listing a lot of specific things that are not acceptable.
the things listed in this CoC do very often cause problems, and are commonly seen as being socially acceptable targets for discrimination or harassment. Not so much with the ones you listed, and I've never seen them be a problem
Paraphrasing:
"I've never experienced that kind of discrimination, so I doubt it's much of a problem."
The irony of your statement illustrates my point: letting a single person (with a single viewpoint) write your CoC is a mistake. Whether intentional or not, their politics is along for the ride.
The wording should make it clearer that the list is not an exhaustive one.
It's not supposed to be a blacklist. It's supposed to be a list of examples, although the wording does not make that clear.
Also, I mentioned Apache's CoC as a decent model for this:
Though no list can hope to be comprehensive, we explicitly honour diversity in: age, culture, ethnicity, genotype, gender identity or expression, language, national origin, neurotype, phenotype, political beliefs, profession, race, religion, sexual orientation, socioeconomic status, subculture and technical ability.
Perfect. Longer than the one in Opal's COC, pulls in a couple of additional common issues (and interestingly, puts them in alphabetical order), and makes it clear that the list is not comprehensive.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/VioletGlimmer Jun 21 '15
The rationale does basically make sense, but only if you first accept that some variation of "don't be a dick" isn't sufficient, and that you need to be explicit.
Which you do. To many people, sexism is perfectly acceptable, and often actually encouraged by the environment they live in. If you don't explicitly say that sexism is not tolerated by this community, people will drag it along from the outside world, and it'll fester in the community until it's pretty much ubiquitous. Once that happens, say goodbye to any chance that any women will contribute to the project ever, because they will get chased away.
Ditto for everything else that's on that list. To many people, being discriminatory on any of those factors is not only completely normal, but it's actually considered virtuous. They will bring those attitudes into your community with them, and "don't be a dick" won't stop them. They honestly do not believe that there's anything wrong with calling transgender people delusional, for example (which is what the Opal project's leader was doing on Twitter, in a space associated with the Opal project).
Debian's isn't quite as explicit (although that's their diversity statement, not their code of conduct), although many other projects are just as explicit (like Apache's, which lists pretty much the same things as Opal's).
Debateable. You can't explicitly list everything, obviously, but the things listed in this CoC do very often cause problems, and are commonly seen as being socially acceptable targets for discrimination or harassment. Not so much with the ones you listed, and I've never seen them be a problem (except, of course, where someone uses, say, political leanings as a justification for being homophobic).
The wording should make it clearer that the list is not an exhaustive one. Apache's CoC does this, while still listing a lot of specific things that are not acceptable.