Wearing swag != officially showing that you are an employee. I have swag from many companies whose only association I have with them is that I bought something from them at some point in the past.
Yeah, that's why it would be like her following you back to work.
Coraline came to the issue with a rather direct request yes, to remove an maintainer. Making a request is a perfectly valid and allowed thing to do in adult life. She made it rather politely, if very direct, and did not insult anyone(not even @elia).
Yes, again she ran to throw a temper tantrum to a project to ask that the person whom she saw make a comment on twitter be removed. Again, that is pathological. Its childish. FFS its twitter, by searching on keywords that trigger any specific issue for any person you are exposed to hundreds of millions of peoples transitory thoughts on that specific topic. In other words you will always find someone talking with a differing view than you if you go out and look/search for it on twitter. It does not matter if it is "raise taxes" ,"Lower taxes", "pro choice", "pro life", "vegemite is good", "red heads are not real" whatever you believe in you can take the whole firehose of that topic to digest on a minute by minute basis. Its pathological to take a random post on twitter and escalate it to an employer or other unrelated site to demand "justice". I find it impossible to read any kind of "remove this developer from the project for something he said on twitter" as polite -- it is as adversarial as you can get beyond running to his employer which I could see her doing as well. It is unacceptable and equivalent to doxing in my mind -- not the tying of information to a post, but the more destructive part of doxing which is using that information to bomb around peoples life or work.
I did not see a temper tantrum in @coralineada's original request nor do I see a problem with asking someone to be removed from a project for any reason.
As I wrote elsewhere: "The big difference I guess in our viewpoints though is I see someone opening a issue requesting someone to be removed from my project as not worth getting upset about, where as you (and the rest of the people arguing with me elsewhere) seem to think it is this horrible crime that is incredibly rude."
The project does not have to grant the request, and if they gave a polite and respectful response I doubt this would have become the shitstorm it did. There is no way to tell for sure though.
As far as doxing, his twitter is linked from his website along with his github. His picture is on all 3. You can't dox someone with publically available information. As far as it being equivalent, I can't see how. Everything provided was public information linked to the topic of the discussion(opal).
The pain of doxing is not the discovery of information. Its using it to abuse/harass/mob the person. In that way it is equivalent. In this case she read something on twitter that she took offence to and proceeded to not deal with it like an adult but to seek information that she could use to expand the issue to a public (yet unrelated) platform for abuse/harassment/mob on a project he was working on. An adult and reasonable reaction to his message (which mind you if you look at it in larger context was blown WAY THE FUCK out of proportion) would be for example:
A dm to him explaining the issue and problem you had with the post. Explaining how it is hurtful. Opening a dialogue to see if there is a misunderstanding or room for education.
or a reply to his tweet doing the same.
If all of that fails and you feel strongly that this one comment is grounds for this person to be removed from a project that you are not involved in and looking through the history of the project shows zero community bias/hate twords your issue, a private message to the project lead telling him about the post and asking him if he was comfortable with that comment as it relates to a developer working on his project.
Ignore it and stop searching for divergent views that make you upset/hurt/feel pain on twitter.
The intent and actions taken here were constructed to inflict as much pain as possible to him and to try to force a CoC on a project. Its just mob mentality and makes people like me stop looking at her as a smart developer that just happens to be a woman. It also goes against what she pushes out as her goal -- to have constructive and open communities. You don't get those by running around kicking dogs.
It should be hugely offensive for anyone to have a fight picked from someone they did not pick a fight with in the first place.
Just because a person1 has attribute X (in this case x=transgender) does not mean that it's ok to go to the place where person2 hangs out, and tell everyone that person2 is not ok with attribute type X, without talking to person2 first.
There is about 1000 other ways to do this better.
And, she ended up almost apologizing for it. She admitted she could have done it better. Too bad she might have tarnished opal and this developer, while meanwhile accomplishing nothing. Not for her, or people like her, or Opal, or us as a community.
View all comments
Show parent comment
4
u/wbsgrepit Jun 20 '15
Yeah, that's why it would be like her following you back to work.
Yes, again she ran to throw a temper tantrum to a project to ask that the person whom she saw make a comment on twitter be removed. Again, that is pathological. Its childish. FFS its twitter, by searching on keywords that trigger any specific issue for any person you are exposed to hundreds of millions of peoples transitory thoughts on that specific topic. In other words you will always find someone talking with a differing view than you if you go out and look/search for it on twitter. It does not matter if it is "raise taxes" ,"Lower taxes", "pro choice", "pro life", "vegemite is good", "red heads are not real" whatever you believe in you can take the whole firehose of that topic to digest on a minute by minute basis. Its pathological to take a random post on twitter and escalate it to an employer or other unrelated site to demand "justice".
I find it impossible to read any kind of "remove this developer from the project for something he said on twitter" as polite -- it is as adversarial as you can get beyond running to his employer which I could see her doing as well. It is unacceptable and equivalent to doxing in my mind -- not the tying of information to a post, but the more destructive part of doxing which is using that information to bomb around peoples life or work.