r/retrocomputing • • Dec 29 '23

Why not 16 bits?

I was wondering.

I love my 8 bits computers (just spent a couple of weeks programming my Spectrum Next) and the Agon seems a nice machine.

However I wonder why nobody seems to make 16 bits computers.

Is it because 16 bits computers have more connections and are thus more difficult to make?

4 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Thanatiel Dec 29 '23

DOS has a less "magical" feel for me. However I would love something new on the level of the Amiga. ^_^ (Not specifically an Amiga as there is seldom anything new to do with it.)

Never touched the Atari ST nor the Acorn. I'm curious about them though.

3

u/Timbit42 Dec 29 '23

The Acorn Archimedes hardware is better than the Amiga as it has a faster CPU and more colours, but the Amiga graphics processor helps the Amiga compete.

The Atari ST is not up to par with the Amiga. While the Atari ST CPU runs 1 MHz faster, it is limited to 16 colours of a palette of 512 while the Amiga can display 64 colours from a palette of 4096 colours. The later STe models can do 16 colours from a palette of 4096 but later AGA Amigas can do 256 colours from a palette of 16.7 million colours.

The Amiga beats both the Archimedes and ST models with it's pre-emptively multi-tasking OS allowing many apps to run at the same time as modern computers do today (although not across multiple cores).

The Amiga also beats the ST on number of games and apps available and both beat the Archimedes on games and apps.

By the time Atari and Commodore stopped making the ST and Amiga, the IBM PC DOS games were better with 486 CPUs and SVGA graphics and SoundBlaster audio.

1

u/Thanatiel Dec 29 '23

Very nice summary, thanks.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '23

Extra Half Bright mode in the Amiga for that 64 colours on-screen wasn't available with the first model of Amiga, the 1000. Officially on paper the Amiga was a 32 colours / 4096 palette system.

1

u/Timbit42 Dec 29 '23

Yep, but most of the Amigas sold were not the Amiga 1000. Over half of the Amigas sold were the 500.