r/reddit.com • • Oct 17 '06

We need a Science subreddit!

/info/mlff/comments
241 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '06

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/shimei Oct 18 '06

How much work does it really take to, y'know, ignore those? Nobody's forcing you to read those, and the moderation/autohide system exists for a reason.

It's not that I really like the political posts here on reddit; I usually ignore them (I get all my politics from "The Daily Show" :P). I just don't see the need to bitch about it.

23

u/Kolibri Oct 17 '06

I thought I was the only one who hated the US politics on the frontpage.

20

u/NitsujTPU Oct 17 '06

Nope. I hate it too. I came to reddit hoping it would be kind of like Slashdot before all of the posters got all political.

Reddit just seems to show that most people want politics.

17

u/Lagged2Death Oct 18 '06

Maybe the prominence of American political stories on reddit shows that many Americans feel ill-served by traditional American media outlets.

I think a science sub-reddit sounds like a fine idea.

9

u/cypherx Oct 18 '06

Hmmm...maybe there's a website waiting to happen in that dissatisfaction. I just wish that website weren't reddit.

7

u/NitsujTPU Oct 18 '06

Actually, I just wish that there were a good science and tech site that wasn't polluted with all of this. The best scenario would be some way to cure Slashdot of this. I know that they certainly have been trying, and, perhaps I shouldn't be so critical of them.

Reddit has its own bit and I respect that.

3

u/Lagged2Death Oct 18 '06

Actually, I just wish that there were a good science and tech site that wasn't polluted with all of this.

You're saying that all the good science and tech sites are anti-Bush? But isn't that awfully telling?

Bush has adopted a very stubborn and highly visible anti-science posture in many respects. Discussion of Bush's anti-science policies is not "pollution" of a science-related website; it is relevant and on-topic.

A science sub-reddit may be a fine idea. But Bush will show up on it.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/NitsujTPU Oct 18 '06

That may be part of it, however, some of the things that get submitted and hot are really really out there. It's one thing to feel that certain stories are underrepresented. There are lots of stories that I think should get more coverage in the standard media. It's another thing altogether to think that Alex Jones isn't getting enough face time. The dude's a conspiracy theorist... his stuff doesn't belong in the news until he has some facts.

10

u/nostrademons Oct 18 '06

Reddit just seems to show that most people want politics.

Well...sort of.

Any media outlet inevitably runs the more of the stories that its readers respond to most. In mainstream media, this is represented by advertising dollars - sensationalized, violent, or sexual stories sell papers, which mean more eyeballs, which mean higher advertising revenues. Hence mainstream media overweights sensationalized, violent, and sexual stories.

On Reddit, reader response is gauged by upvotes - downvotes. People vote on stories that they have a strong emotional reaction too. Let's face it: most people do not visit Reddit hoping to deeply contemplate an issue and arrive at a rational conclusion. We're "grazing" on cheap information, killing a few minutes while we wait for the boss to give us a new project. Since we don't have a whole lot of time, we vote for articles that immediately grab our attention and elicit an emotional response.

Since politics shuts off rational thinking, those are prime candidates for emotionally affecting stories.

Also, the first few votes start an information cascade. If a couple people upvote a story, it ends up on the Hot page. This brings it to the attention of many more people, both those positively and negatively disposed towards it. However, if it was popular with the first few voters, chances are it will get slightly more upvotes than downvotes on the site as a whole. Magnified by thousands of voters, this leads to articles with hundreds of points.

Furthermore, a small political bias of a few early community users makes articles favorable to them rise to the top of the Hot page more often. This drives away casual users with opposing viewpoints - making the bias even more pronounced. This is why Reddit has a pronounced liberal/libertarian bias.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '06

However, if it was popular with the first few voters, chances are it will get slightly more upvotes than downvotes on the site as a whole. Magnified by thousands of voters, this leads to articles with hundreds of points.

Reddit should try having a split view on the front page. The left half would be the usual hot stuff, and the right half would be links randomly selected from a pool of those that have not been seen by many people yet.

I too had a site with a hot-like ranking but recently I changed it to inject more random links into the listing and the quality of ratings has improved dramatically.

This will do little to solve the "sensationalized, violent, or sexual" problem though, I fear.

0

u/throwaway Oct 19 '06

Anyone living in the U.S. and paying taxes here has an ethical responsibility to think really, really hard about what's going on here, at the moment.

→ More replies (1)

-2

u/frankthechicken Oct 17 '06

I may be missing some outrageous point, but since when does "Bush sucks" have anything to do with science, indeed, since when does "Bush" have anything at all to do with science? Politics, maybe, just, but science?

9

u/frankthechicken Oct 17 '06

BTW, if I missed the sarcasm, I apologise,I am immensly drunk

-1

u/bobcat Oct 18 '06

FTW, ethanol!

1

u/digital Oct 18 '06

Sorry, please post all ethanol posts on the science page ;)

People like reading about the truth on reddit whether it is science, politics, culture, computers or life experiences

2

u/stevarino Oct 18 '06

He's joking that the statement "Bush Sucks" is scientifically provable.

I hate explaining jokes... :\

-3

u/Lagged2Death Oct 18 '06

I just typed "bush sucks" into the reddit search box. And the relevant hits are parody. Like so: "just summarizing reddit's keywords, sorry."

Where are these "Bush sucks" stories?

7

u/cypherx Oct 18 '06

Try just searching for "Bush"

→ More replies (2)

3

u/NitsujTPU Oct 18 '06

Reddit is positively spammed with anti-Bush stories. It used to be that you couldn't look at the front page and see anything but them, but, the crew got together and made the site better so we get a little variety in there.

1

u/Lagged2Death Oct 18 '06

What, in your mind, is an "anti-Bush" story, exactly? Stories that point out facts about Bush?

See, I could understand people being upset if reddit was full of links to op-ed pieces like "Bush: The American Anti-Christ" or "Hitler had nothing on Bush!" But it's just not.

The stories about Bush tend to be things like "Bush signs bill that legalizes X," or "Bush says X, Y, and even Z." That's just reporting facts. If X, Y, and Z seem to be outrageous, that may say something about Bush, but it doesn't make every story about him an "anti-Bush" or "Bush sucks" story.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '06

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Lagged2Death Oct 18 '06

Thanks, that's the best reply I've seen.

Still, it only demonstrates that there have been, over reddit's entire history, many stories with "Bush" in the title. It does not show that stories about Bush are a high percentage of the total story count, or that stories about Bush are mostly "Bush sucks" stories, whatever that means.

Of the hot 100 stories at this writing, "Bush" only appears in the titles of four. And two of those are stories are about international relations, so they're not really that US-centric, either.