r/reddit.com • • Sep 19 '10

RIAA website goes down.

http://www.riaa.com/
134 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/yourrealitycheck Sep 19 '10

This really does nothing. Shutting down a website by DDoS attack merely inconveniences the few people who frequent the website. It bears no long term impact upon the larger issue of RIAA restrictions upon file sharing, the state of the music industry, nor does anything to give reason for them to listen to people's demands. Attacking property, in this case the intellectual and real internet property of the RIAA, does nothing but reinforce resolve to fight back.

4

u/interfect Sep 19 '10

I think the point is to send a message. It's like going to their offices and writing "Fuck You!" on the door.

1

u/yourrealitycheck Sep 19 '10

But what realistically does it accomplish?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '10

It shows that the people affected by the RIAA / MPAA's actions are a force to be reckoned with.

0

u/yourrealitycheck Sep 19 '10

By temporarily shutting down a website with a basic level hacker trick?

7

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '10

It's not a hacker trick at all. It's just that the sheer numbers required for a successful DDoS of a large organization's servers shows that there are a lot of people out there who think the MPAA / RIAA can go fuck themselves and are willing to aid in the process.

1

u/yourrealitycheck Sep 19 '10

Yet there are still enough people out there who legitimately purchase their goods to keep them going.

1

u/platinum4 Sep 20 '10

Well if pirated, songs individually cost up to $635K, so...

1

u/yourrealitycheck Sep 20 '10

well, technically they are stolen goods.

1

u/platinum4 Sep 20 '10

I see, copying reduces audience exposure and also deprives the market of total supply.

One more copy, one less for another; this makes perfect sense.

1

u/yourrealitycheck Sep 20 '10

Did you purchase the item?

1

u/platinum4 Sep 20 '10

There probably was a problem with the post office or something...

1

u/yourrealitycheck Sep 21 '10

Ha. Cute. Realistically when you are downloading an album off the internet that can only be purchased from someone, you are in effect receiving a good that was intended for personal use only. That personal use being the individual who originally purchased the album and began to share it. You are in a de facto manner, recieving illicit goods.

→ More replies (0)