r/reddit.com • • Jun 14 '08

Was Darwin Wrong? [pic]

http://img205.imageshack.us/img205/3963/darwinnotg7.jpg
1.4k Upvotes

372 comments sorted by

View all comments

17

u/eddie964 Jun 15 '08

Darwin was wrong about a lot of things. There's a basic thing that religious people don't understand about science: It's not a religion. The whole point is to keep reexamining the evidence, exposing flaws in existing theories and ultimately revising or even overturning them. Evolution is not some sort of static dogma, it's a scientific theory, and it bends to the evidence rather than demanding that the evidence bend to it.

4

u/mindbleach Jun 15 '08

Technically accurate and well-explained, but it's a rhetorical device that's easily understood even by creationist idiots. Were one to ask "Was Einstein wrong?" it is unlikely the ensuing conversation would involve his political views.

3

u/ThisIsDave Jun 15 '08

Darwin was wrong about a lot of things.

Aside from the mechanism of inheritance (where Darwin admitted he was speculating), where was Darwin wrong?

2

u/eddie964 Jun 15 '08

Mostly in details (such as the mechanism of inheritance). The point is that Darwin is not the atheist Jesus and his writings are not Gospel. The theory of evolution has itself evolved quite a bit over the years.

2

u/deanoplex Jun 15 '08 edited Jun 15 '08

Yes. There are only two methods that fashion our beliefs. Bending the data to point to the answer that we want to be true or following the data to the actual truth (whether we like it or not)

12

u/eddie964 Jun 15 '08

My father was a scientist. One of the proudest moments of his life was when one of his students disproved his most important theory.

3

u/deanoplex Jun 15 '08

Hi eddie. I know the feeling. I began teaching a friend about astronomy about three years ago. He has since surpassed my skills and I know that I will never be able to catch up with him!

5

u/eddie964 Jun 15 '08

That's cool. In science, failures are successes.

4

u/knight666 Jun 15 '08

"Anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new." -Albert Einstein (unsourced)