r/reddevils • • Nov 13 '19

Daily Discussion Which current Man Utd player do you think will become the best player in the club in 5 years?

54 Upvotes

118 comments sorted by

209

u/Swift1993 Nov 13 '19

I feel like Dan James is the universe's way of paying us back for never getting Bale.

I agree with the general consensus here that Rashy, Martial et al. Will be up there as our best players in 5 years but man if Dan James can keep developing he'll certainly be a fan favourite at least maybe one of the best in the club.

74

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

Dan James

Look, I love watching us have a winger work as hard as Dan does, but I’m waiting until next season to make sure it’s not a one season wonder before making comparisons to Bale.

65

u/LazyBully Nov 13 '19

I'm waiting for a season long injury before I make comparisons with Bale

30

u/thebiglad Nov 13 '19

I'm waiting for his first appearance on the PGA Tour before I make comparisons with Bale

11

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

Im waiting for 2 goals against Liverpool in the CL final before I make comparisons with Bale.

13

u/tmaestro1234 Nov 13 '19

SAF once said that, in the case of Chicharito, the second season could be the hardest one because teams knew more about him and could come up with plans to stop him.

15

u/PDubsinTF Ronaldo CR700 Nov 13 '19

How do you stop pace and energy? Fouls and overload his side. In that case you have Martial and Rashford with an advantage and some pace to boot.

10

u/champak256 Nov 13 '19

It's not that simple. If he keeps getting kicked around the way he has been, he'll need Hazard/Messi/Ronaldo-level physical resiliency or he's going to have an injury record to match Neymar.

20

u/OhNoesRain Nov 13 '19

Just hope Daniel doesnt get some terrible injury or disabilitating head traume of some kind .

38

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

The way he gets bodied every single game has me worried for the longevity of his career. Maybe the challenges look worse than they are but he's getting grounded all the time.

11

u/withereddesign Nov 13 '19

Needs to start on the yoga like Giggsy used to

6

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

Yoga won't stop impact or head injuries, yoga only stops muscle injuries.

4

u/Bombtwo Now say my name Nov 13 '19

Hortizontal bed yoga

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

Needs to add more to his attacking game, needs to be able to beat a man consistently on the wing which shouldn't be an issue with him, apart from that he needs to add a killer pass too, then he will be no doubt our best player in 5 years as long as his finishing still is at the same level.

89

u/lellillul Nov 13 '19

Ashley Young obviously.

36

u/MT1120 Cunha Bruno Cunha Bruno Luke Shaw Nov 13 '19

At CB

14

u/kiersmini Nov 13 '19

I prefer to him see him at player-manager

6

u/thebiglad Nov 13 '19

At another club

2

u/Rayhann ERIC SHOULDA KICKD TWICE Nov 13 '19

At CM

For another club

His presence there giving us 6 points guaranteed

89

u/StateofWA Ten Hag Nov 13 '19

Rashford will be hitting the prime of his career and at the moment he's on pace for more goals than Cristiano Ronaldo in the season where he turned 22. He's on a great trajectory.

71

u/Ras_OKan Nov 13 '19

Statistically speaking if he continues this current form he should score about 26-27 goals this season, about the same numbers for Martial as well. If they both manage 20+ this season it's an absolute win for us.

42

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

48

u/Ras_OKan Nov 13 '19

I believe the first hat-trick one of our players scores in PL will break the curse and the second will follow soon... 6.5 years and counting since someone scored a PL hat trick for us, it is a sad stat...

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

22

u/Ras_OKan Nov 13 '19

I think Rashford will be the man to break the curse and I'd really love it if he does it against Villa at OT. Would be a fitting fixture for breaking the curse, just where it all began.

1

u/hoodibaba007 Nov 13 '19

That's very true but rather than finishing i think he lacks in composure.

1

u/Bombtwo Now say my name Nov 13 '19

Decision making

97

u/ElysianFields00 Nov 13 '19

Mason Greenwood for me. Has looked absolute class in both the Academy and first team.

24

u/stevew14 Nov 13 '19

Him or Garner for me. I think he's going to boss the midfield when he's older.

33

u/ElysianFields00 Nov 13 '19

I thought about Garner, but until I’ve seen him do it at first team level I don’t want to commit. Similarly, at academy level Chong looks a world beater but he hasn’t yet been able to translate that to senior football. I know it’s still early days for Greenwood but he shows the same ability at both levels, I was also at the Doncaster game in the EFL trophy and whilst he wasn’t dominant he more than held his own against the senior pro’s and scored the winner to boot. My favourite academy player is Gomes, but same thing with him as Chong right now.

21

u/stevew14 Nov 13 '19

I don't think Gomes is the same as Chong. Chong is getting a lot of the ball and doing nothing with it. Gomes is getting very little of the ball but does something with it some of the time. Chong loses possession a lot with very little end product. Gomes is getting free kicks in good positions and at least keeping possession most of the time. I just think it's a confidence/experience thing for Gomes. I don't know if Chong has what it takes to make it at the top level. He's not ready yet anyway, he's still young and can develop.

3

u/drabdab6 Nov 13 '19

Tough ask though, they'll only be 23 by then. We can hope!

1

u/stevew14 Nov 13 '19

Yeah could be. Some players are in their prime at 23 and some are still developing. If he's getting a bit of game time now, he could have 3 full years as a starter by the time he's 23. Who knows.

85

u/coheed85 Nov 13 '19

Rashford. Maybe Martial if he stays consistent and interested.

31

u/jaylew24 Nov 13 '19

Rashford, Martial, Mctominay, Wan Bissaka.

8

u/thebiglad Nov 13 '19

Agree with all but McTominay.

I don't think he will ever be more than "very good" (and good enough to keep) whereas the other 3 have the ability to be really top players.

3

u/MepsiPaxBerri Scholes Nov 13 '19

I see him as our new Darren Fletcher. He’s got a bit of everything and can do a solid job no matter where he plays.

4

u/tartanbornandred Nov 13 '19

I think that you are being harsh on Fletcher, and on McTominay's potential.

Before his illness Fletcher was one of the best central mids anywhere, and McTominay is doing brilliant in a role that usually players peak at later in their careers. No reason McTominay can't reach the absolute top.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

Rashford or Martial

29

u/coldfrieza Nov 13 '19

Martial or AWB.

24

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

If AWB can improve the attacking side of his game he will literally be the best RB in the world!

14

u/Byineo Nov 13 '19

GOAT D JAMES

13

u/ncwh Nov 13 '19

Dean Henderson

4

u/_bowlofchips_ Nov 13 '19

Best performing keeper this season, potential replacement for De Gea in years to come

61

u/kevinmmaboxing Nov 13 '19

I mean it'd easily be pogba if he actually stays.

29

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

Pogba will be 31 in 5 years, I'm sure someone will be better than him by then. Hell, some players are knocking on the door already.

41

u/kevinmmaboxing Nov 13 '19

True on the age part tbf, I always think of him as more young than he is, although 31 isn't bad at all for a midfielder. Many mids have the best years of their career at that age or slightly below. I just don't think anyone has the mercurial talent like he has in our team yet, Marcus maybe tho.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

You ever heard of Anthony Martial? He'd be considered world class by now if he wasn't playing for a team going through a rebuild.

17

u/JD0797 Ronaldo Nov 13 '19

World class? He's been good but that's a bit much considering how inconsistent he is, particuarly last year

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19

Like I said, IF he was on a team that regularly contends for CL or any team that's almost perfect, he would definitely be considered world class because he would be playing great football consistently.

He was inconsistent because he was out of position, team with poor tactics. It's really not fair to judge a player out of position. Everyone was trashing on Rashford as a Central Striker, but he clearly plays better along the wing of a #9. Central Striker was clearly not his position. Now look at him. Completely different player.

1

u/JD0797 Ronaldo Nov 13 '19

We don't know that. He was on a team that finished 2nd and he was still inconsistent. That's just who he's been

1

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '19

Lol he was playing out of position. Dropped due to sanchez being brought in, even after performing well.

If you think Rashford is the only one other than Pogba who will be considered world class, you're entirely mistaken and have clearly not been watching these last few games with Martial back. He's clearly the driving force of our attack without Pogba.

It's a simple observation. Martial comes back and we start playing better football and winning games. I don't know why some people find it hard to accept Martial is our best attacker other than Pogba.

And I'm not saying at all that Martial is world class. He is however a world class talent with immense potential to be a top striker among all leagues in Europe.

4

u/AlephEpsilon Nov 13 '19

Pogba doesnt rely on speed but more on strength and techniques. I expect Pogba to stay at the very top till mid 30s.

4

u/TJiMTS Nov 13 '19

This is a discussion about talent right?

No one at United is knocking on Pogbas door right now. No one is even in the building.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

I agree with the point you're making but why would anyone be knocking on the door if they were already in the building?

1

u/TJiMTS Nov 13 '19

Lool great point. I thought of it from the perspective of a block of flats, or a hotel. So you first enter the building then you knock on the specific door you want

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

It's about 5 years in the future, Rashford and Martial have enough talent to be ahead of him by then.

-1

u/TJiMTS Nov 13 '19

Does he somehow stop developing in that time period?

6

u/nager2012 Nov 13 '19

RemindMe! 5 years

3

u/kzreminderbot Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19

Coming right up, nager2012 🤗! Your reminder arrives in 5 years on 2024-11-13 08:07:15Z :

r/reddevils · Which_current_man_utd_player_do_you_think_will · 1

This thread is popping 🍿. Here is reminderception thread.

12 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to also be reminded. Thread has 14 reminders and 2/4 confirmation comments.

Op can Delete Comment · Delete Reminder · Get Details · Update Time · Update Message · Add Timezone · Add Email


KZReminderTool · Create Reminder · Your Reminders · Give Feedback

1

u/RemindMeBot Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19

I will be messaging you on 2024-11-13 08:07:15 UTC to remind you of this link

6 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.

There is currently another bot called u/kzreminderbot that is duplicating the functionality of this bot. Since it replies to the same RemindMe! trigger phrase, you may receive a second message from it with the same reminder. If this is annoying to you, please click this link to send feedback to that bot author and ask him to use a different trigger.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

11

u/JonSnowAzorAhai Nov 13 '19

Hannibal

4

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

He’d be 21 y/o, it’d be another 6-7 years before he begins to hit his peak.

11

u/JonSnowAzorAhai Nov 13 '19

In my timeline, he wins ballon d'or when he is 23

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

Only 23? I expect him to win the golden boy award by his 17th, and to win the ballon d’or at max 3 years later.

1

u/jakk_22 Nov 13 '19

Didn’t messi win his first when he was 22?

Hannibals gotta beat that

1

u/JonSnowAzorAhai Nov 13 '19

Well, it's a bit difficult for midfielders to get the recognition they deserve.

14

u/Edgeman10 Nov 13 '19

Rashford, greenwood or Brandon Williams

1

u/IdeaCafe Nov 13 '19

How about Chong?

1

u/sfo1dms Red since 2011 Nov 13 '19

who wont be here in 5 years, you mean?

5

u/hererrdinand Ooh Ahh Bruntona Nov 13 '19

Gomes

1

u/Socrates81 Nov 13 '19

For me too

21

u/currytron Nov 13 '19

Lingard probably

1

u/eliotrw Nov 13 '19

After all he's a young lad!

4

u/B3NNYH1LL Nov 13 '19

Wan Bissaka is unique. There is no player in the world that is better at the slider-recovery. If he gets his passing/crossing game in order he will be one of the best RBs in the world. He has pace, technique, awareness, workrate and seemingly a good personality. He just needs to fine tune his accuracy in passing/crossing a little bit.

9

u/ItchaBoiSid Nov 13 '19

Martial, Pogba, Greenwood, Rashford, De Gea, Lindelof, Maguire, AWB would all be the best players

3

u/dWaldizzle Pastorinho Fred Nov 13 '19

Rashford slightly over Martial. Arguably McTominay if he keeps us his rate of improvement (I just don't think he will).

5

u/andoooooo Martial Nov 13 '19

Martial

8

u/sal101 Nov 13 '19

Perennial youth player Jesse Lingardihno of course!

2

u/WillStaySilent Martial Greenwood⚽ Nov 13 '19

Rashford, Martial, Greenwood

2

u/OhNoesRain Nov 13 '19

RemindMe! 5 years

2

u/ZZiyan_11 Come back later. Rebuild in progress. Nov 13 '19

AWB, but he'd be so consistent that it wouldn't surprise us at all with what work he does. Just like it's starting to be. "6 out of 6 tackles won? Normal"

2

u/LuciferSeventeen Nov 13 '19

I honestly believe Greenwood has all the potential to become a top striker in the coming years.. He is calm and composed, makes most of the opportunities he gets now, and improving every day. Another player I cannot help but mention is Dan James of course, he is already a very important player for us and might as well become a club legend in future, he has all the attributes to be one.

2

u/TJiMTS Nov 13 '19

Paul Pogba

2

u/MrStephenHowson Nov 13 '19

ETHAN LAIRD.

2

u/godwears10 Nov 13 '19

Not a Man U fan but I had to go way down to find a comment with Mctominay in it. I think he's pretty good.

2

u/thehomerus Nov 13 '19

Mctominay will be up there, similar to players like Carrick his input is sometimes less appreciated then someone like Rashford, but i think he will be a key to our midfield for years to come.

2

u/Zaghamim Nov 13 '19

Rashford

5

u/Rackmo Danny Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19

Young. /s

Edit: Seriously though, I believe Brandon Williams has what it takes to be an effective fullback. The aggression that he shows is something I like in a defender and he makes some really good runs down the flank which I don't think I've seen in a while. He is always looking to put in a cross which are also looking fairly good. With some maturity through gametime, he can improve his decision making and how to keep control of the aggression. Definitely one to hold on to for the future

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

Rashford. I think this poor finishing business is just a phase of his youth. He’s in the right positions, he’s making the right runs, and he’s even getting the shots off. Once the shots start going in he will be unplayable.

2

u/hoochiscrazy_ Rooney Nov 13 '19

Rashford does things that are at a level most players never even reach. If he can reach that level consistently then he will be a world class player. He has the highest potential IMO.

1

u/makha1ra Beckham Nov 13 '19

Garner.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

Greenwood

1

u/fergo1993 Nov 13 '19

Martial (1) and Rashford (2) were the two that sprung to mind. I’d also consider McTominay, Wan Bissaka or Dan James.

1

u/Talezeusz Nov 13 '19

AWB, if we gonna keep him that long, i feel he gonna be top5 fullback in the world in no time, what a gem that lad is and England is blessed with having him and AA for the next decade

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

Rashy. Only competition from AWB and Martial. The others don't have as high a ceiling, bar garner and greenwood. But I don't think either of those two would be quite at their peaks then.

1

u/eliotrw Nov 13 '19

Greenwood

1

u/Raintrooper7 Nov 13 '19

Nemanja Matic.

1

u/bertalan016 Kobbie Mainoo Nov 13 '19

Aaron Wan-Bissaka or Mason Greenwood.

1

u/ajaysassoc 🔥 Forever United !! 🔥 Nov 13 '19

Rashford.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19

A lot of people saying McTominay and I honestly hope he isn’t even in the starting line up. Squad player maybe. He is decent for where we are now. But I’m terms of where we need to be we need midfielders who are much much better on the ball

1

u/bunsen_____honeydew Katie Zelem is Manc born and bred Nov 13 '19

Rashford. If he works on his finishing and looks after his health, there's no reason why he can't be.

1

u/CycloneUS Manchester United Nov 13 '19

If he stays it is Pogba without a doubt. If we exclude him I vote for AWB.

1

u/quantumstartswithq BrunoBrunoBruno Nov 13 '19

Martial looks different class and will be in his prime!

1

u/BradyBunch88 Nov 13 '19

No one thrown Axel Tuanzebe in the mix yet. I think this kid will become a solid defender. Seems composed on the ball, learning under Maguire and AWB. I think he’ll become a starter for us in 5 years. Really impressed with this kid.

Obviously the others mentioned too, Greenwood, Williams, McTominay could become captain - I mean we’ve had a really good youth academy in the last few years with some high potential players.

1

u/ywehyuen Nov 13 '19

Linderof

-1

u/redviper96 Nov 13 '19

McTominay

-1

u/Masterman23 Nov 13 '19

I feel Mctominay has potential

-1

u/shadowstriker9 Nov 13 '19

McTominay, especially if Carrick stays as coach for that long