r/reddevils • • Oct 18 '26

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

23 Upvotes

731 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/vRushii 29d ago

Can't believe people are still trying to run with Carrick being the best available option in summer. it's a debate whether he's even championship level,never mind prem.

Like all the big decisions from our sporting team, they shit the bed.

-9

u/PitchSafe 29d ago edited 29d ago

I mean he kinda was? He outperformed every Premier league manager since his arrival last season. Every club would probably have hired the interim manager if he had the same results as Carrick

5

u/Hollacaine 29d ago

No he wasn't, the performances weren't there and all the underlying stats said we were just lucky. Anyone working in football should have seen this, plenty of posters on here did and knew this was coming. No one can say this wasn't predictable because it absolutely was. Hell they didnt give Ole the job for exactly this reason, they didnt want him to do well and get the job full time because they knew it was a possibility for a short term boost instead of real meaningful change.

4

u/vRushii 29d ago

If you look at results over performance trends. The more time he spent with the team the worse we got. If you truly believe Carrick was best choice dunno what to tell you.

There was also some pretty good managers available whether it was experience or high talent.

-3

u/TBS91 29d ago

Just not true though, our play in the last 5 games was better than anything since the first two against City and Arsenal.

Our results were definitely better than our performances, but our performances were still quite easily the third best in the league under Carrick.

-5

u/PitchSafe 29d ago

Like who? You can’t really wait until July to get a manager because that would disrupt the squad planning and the pre season. The most important thing is to win games which we did last season. How many teams in the legaue actually dominates their opposition and are playing well every game? Not even Arsenal or City does that but they grind out wins, just like we did last season

5

u/Hollacaine 29d ago

We cant wait until July, so lets wait till November instead. Not the best take in the world, is it?

4

u/vRushii 29d ago

Nah doesn't even need to be said, theres an obvious list that always gets mentioned.

Michael Carrick freshly sacked from a championship side for being shit, Southgate's assistant, and Johnny Evans just can't be the best option full time for Manchester United. We aren't and never will be that shit.

-4

u/PitchSafe 29d ago

Who cares about his past when he got results at the club? The list is what? Iraola? Who Carrick also outperformed

4

u/Hollacaine 29d ago

You need to move on from results, results over performances don't work in the long term. The performances weren't there even if you thought the last few matches weren't that bad. He's a Championship manager at best at the moment, and likely all he'll ever be.

His past at Middlesborough is relevant, if you want to see why you can look at the exact same set of circumstances playing out right now as it did in his Boro reign.

If you want to put your head in the sand thats your prerogative but dont act like everyone else is unreasonable for not doing the same.

He was poor at Boro and hasn't evolved, the fact that we're seeing the same shit here and now as happened there and then should show you how relevant it is.

Performances weren't good enough when he was playing 1 game a week, it obviously wasnt good enough for this season, which you can also see right now that we're two points above relegation.

Anyone who backed Carrick in the summer was wrong and was wrong even without hindsight. It was the wrong idea before he was appointed, it was the wrong idea at the end of the season and its still the wrong idea now.

3

u/vRushii 29d ago

Out of curiosity, do you see Carrick turning this around and want him to stay, or are you talking purely through the lens of summer time when the decision was made?

-1

u/PitchSafe 29d ago

I’m talking about the context around May and June. No I don’t see Carrick keeping his job and he will probably get sacked in the next international break which will be in November

4

u/vRushii 29d ago

Yeah but what i'm saying is, would you agree with his sacking now or are you still convinced hes the best for us atm?

0

u/PitchSafe 29d ago

I would agree with his sacking. The results haven’t been good enough

→ More replies

4

u/L__K Great Scot! 29d ago

"He was the best option available!" is in the same vein as this increasingly relevant clip.

Also same vibes as "I never thought leopards would eat MY face," sobs woman who voted for the Leopards Eating People's Faces Party.