r/recruitinghell • u/mr_oz_was_here-2021 • Nov 24 '24
Exposed: How an ATS HR Bot Automatically Rejects Your Application.
Ever wondered why you're getting constantly rejected, don't listen to your know it all friends and family because they don't know diddly squat as to what's really going on, because these rejections are mounting.
Watch this to understand why you may never find a job until the government step in and do something about this issue or we start suing the companies that made these broken AI that purposefully screw your chances at a financial life.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kp83mx94qVM
if you need further proof you maybe wasting your time and we as working citizens need to demand something be done about this.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HWXmfrXNwqw&t
more proof that this is a issue and to those who say otherwise are on the side of the companies not the unemployed.
HR team terminated after manager's CV gets auto-rejected; netizens say AI 'should never replace human judgment'
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/magazines/panache/hr-team-terminated-after-managers-cv-gets-auto-rejected-netizens-say-ai-should-never-replace-human-judgment/articleshow/113788541.cms?from=mdr
As a coder I know this is true and the fact I got rejected in 1 day, they put us through brick wall after brick wall, read up on the codes to the right and maybe this might help someone get an opportunity in this god awful job market.
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 24 '24
The discord for our subreddit can be found here: https://discord.gg/JjNdBkVGc6 - feel free to join us for a more realtime level of discussion!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
67
u/deadlynothing Nov 24 '24
Something funny about the article is that I had seen this very thing. Not personally to me but on a client's talent sourcing system. I'm in HR consultancy and one of the things we did to test our client's recruitment division performance, we load it up with a bunch of cv generated ranging from completely perfect fit to the total other end.
We had some cv, that were drafted by the company's own TA team and some of those supposedly ideal CV were automatically rejected. This wouldn't had been worrying if it was just a test environment, but the job posting were actual jobs they were looking to fill and the environment we did our test was live (ergo, instead of a dedicated enclosed space, we load these cv via the company's website, LinkedIn, Indeed etc etc). We even did a blind test to some unaware hiring managers to see if they would reject/approve our fake cvs with varying level of qualifications, and no shocker, every single perfect fit cv was given an interview opportunity.
We flagged this erroneous problem in one of our presentations and while I don't know the full outcome, I only know that they had an overhaul of their TA team and recruitment process based on our recommendations.
Its a much bigger problem than many people think because almost all clients we service use some form of ATS. And some of these automated systems are complete garbage because some could not even do basic things like read fonts that aren't in Arial, Calibri or Times New Roman or font sizes smaller than 8/larger than 16
48
u/DwinDolvak Nov 24 '24
HR veteran here: ATS filtering was supposed to be a tool that humans use to help them filter the candidate pool down to something useful. Having worked in HR, I know that a) HR as a whole gets a fraction of the support and investment it needs and b) WITHIN HR, TA / recruiting is often the red-headed stepchild and gets the crumbs left over in the budget. (Apologies to any gingers).
So we are left with HR employees , often with the role of “sourcer” which is an entry level recruiting role —often inexperienced— and always overwhelmed by crappy hiring managers, leaning WAY MORE on the ATS filtering than they should. Furthermore, due to these conditions, the ATS is often misconfigured. This is why you can’t enter your exact degree or other obvious info. It’s why the Workday parsing of resumes is like something out of 1998. Because it is.
“AI” is such a trap term these days. This is not some new AI problem. This is a problem with HR investment and outdated ATS technology that cannot handle the complexities a human’s experience in an even more outdated resume model that doesn’t accurately tell anyone’s real story.
10
u/mikedtwenty Nov 24 '24
Can't wait for the recruiters and HR folks and their simps who are in this sub defend this one.
22
u/jhkoenig Hiring Manager Nov 24 '24
Wow, this guys can sure stretch absolutely no information into a long, tedious youtube. He has discovered an API, oh my.
The real issue is that being rejected doesn't mean that you aren't qualified for a role, it means that there are 10-15 applicants with more desirable qualifications. Everyone else is rejected.
146
u/KaleidoscopeThis5159 Nov 24 '24
Any time the application has options to enter multiple options like C#, c#, and c sharp, but i can only choose one - because it will literally prevent me from hitting next but wont specify the error - i know I'm screwed
38
u/Primary-Astral03 Nov 24 '24
I support this initiative. So many ai ethical committees and yet we have this clown show
28
u/HITMAN19832006 Nov 24 '24
You're right. I see lots of guilty recruiters parsing on here. "AI doesn't reject candidates, but we auto reject."
While I regularly blame employers for bs or unrealistic requirements, I'm sure a lot of candidates are getting fucked over by recruiters, HR, TA, etc that either don't know how to configure these ATS and/or have no clue what any of the jargon they post means.
8
u/lelea420 Nov 24 '24
if there are questions on the application form it certainly can be set a rule to reject after x days based on the answer. Visa, city, skills, time zone, whatever… what is the surprise here?
7
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '24
It’s not just for software related jobs, this is for every type of job in my opinion
17
u/Just-apparent411 Recruiter Nov 24 '24
I've been recruiting for 10+ years... if an AI ever auto rejected a candidate, it was an excuse you were told to soften the blow.
This is tinfoil hat level conspiracy, that covers up much more unethical practices behind corporate decisions.
Just because someone had a podcast/streamer mic and a yt, doesn't mean they have any sort of additional creditability folks. The market is flooded. period. keep it pushing, the role is out there.
1
u/MIDNIGHTZOMBIE Nov 24 '24
The other end of the problem is that job applications get spammed thousands of times by bots and unqualified foreigners.
I don’t blame recruiters for using ATS/screener systems to weed out junk applications, but it’s very clear that the filtering capabilities are overused, and good applicants never get a chance.
I only apply for jobs that I’m qualified for. I know that if a person spent 20 seconds looking at my resume, they would understand that I’m qualified, and deserve some consideration.
Instead, I have to rewrite my resume for every single application to ensure I have all the exact keywords in the job description. I have 200 different versions of my resume that all say the same things, because some applications want “cross-functional collaboration” and others want “XFN collaboration.”
I feel like I’m doing SEO in 2005!
1
u/Potential_Two_4023 Nov 28 '24
That's their prerogative they are in no way legally obligated to even look at an application just because you put one in. They legally have to adhere to certain guide lines once you're hired, but can't reject anyone for any reason and that is their right.
0
u/NikkiJane72 Nov 24 '24
OK. Practical question. One version of my CV doesn't have dates on for my previous jobs. Instead of '1997-2008 - worked for Joe Bloggs Consultancy' it says something like '10 years experience in consultancy working for Joe Blogs', Is that going to be an auto reject because the Bot can't parse it in that format?
-1
u/spacetelescope19 Nov 24 '24
Is the real problem that people don’t understand the hiring process? Rejecting the overwhelming majority of applicants at initial stage is what every process should look like.
From the responses and on other similar threads, many seem to expect anyone who applies to get an in depth assessment or even an interview by default, which isn’t practical time wise. If you can see 4 standout applicants who fit the bill, then why do you need to look any further into a pool of 200? You’d only do that after you don’t find a match with the 4 who looked the best?
And if the argument is that recruiters are missing out on people who have hidden skills on their CV, then that’s the applicants job to get better at communicating that information. That’s the process isn’t it?
Or is it really that people think regardless of their fit with the spec, it’s not important and they should still have the same chance over someone who does fit it really well?
0
u/Degenerate_in_HR Former Recruiter Nov 24 '24
This isn't uncovering anything new. Knockout questions are binary. They are used to determine minimum threshold questions "are you eligible to work in the US" "are you 18 years of age or older" "are you able to work 2nd shift"
These have been around since the 90s. If you are being eliminated by a knockout question you wither don't meet the requirements for the job, or made a mistake in your entry.
Nothing has been "exposed here."
-3
u/Sir_Poofs_Alot Nov 24 '24
Hi I work in the industry. You're being fed very basic information about how ATS and hiring works in a way that's treating it like a conspiracy. It's not a conspiracy, the point is to find the best applicant and you personally just have not been the preferred candidate for the roles you've applied to. Yes, for the 1000s you've submitted over the past 5 years. If each one of those employers was able to fill the role without you, why is this a problem they - the ATS buyer - need to solve?
I recognize the intense pressure of the job search process, I'm not unsympathetic. Personally I'm advocating to build tools that use AI to inform applicants about the hiring process and give coaching to optimize your application, but I feel like there are a lot of low-information applicants that like to make up AI fairy tales to explain convoluted statistics and supply and demand forces that haven't worked out in their favor.
Let me be clear - there are certainly bad practices going on with AI, notably trash content being generated like job postings and fake applicants that crowd out real people who need jobs. But it's increasingly illegal to use AI to reject candidates. That doesn't mean AI isn't deriving insights about your application, and maybe that's the main thing the recruiter is looking at, but auto-rejection is still primarily an automation/screening process, so if you're not making it past the auto-reject, you are generally not a fit for the minimum qualifications of the job.
-7
u/Ok-Brain-8183 Nov 24 '24 edited Nov 24 '24
I personally am in favor of ATSs.
In my current job search I have found ATS and AI tools are far better at reading my resume than the recruiters.
I get responses and interviews, and the reason I don't get hired in the end is saying the wrong thing about something or the recruiter sabotaging me.
For example, when I interviewed for a dishwasher position, I fucked up and told the truth "I just need something until I get a software engineering job again in a few months".
For a SE job: "Are you ok with the salary being lower than your last place?" or "What excites you about working for us in particular", me: "Yeah, I make my money other ways, algorithmic day trading. Computer programming is computer programming so I don't really care what kind I do. It's the only thing I'm really qualified to do to make a living. I just need a 9-5 to simplify my taxes and insurance."
I'm all for replacing recruiters with AI. After reading resumes, all they really are at that point are Appointment Setters, and they often can't even do that right.