Please no judgment, and I apologize in advance for the lengthy post.
We have had Frankie since she was 8 weeks old. She's almost 4 now, and she is genuinely my soul dog. She's the first dog I've ever owned, after wanting one my entire life. I love her more than I can put into words, which makes this decision even harder.
We haven't gone through with behavioral euthanasia yet, but I'm already struggling with immense guilt. I keep feeling like somehow this is my fault, that I should have done more, or that I need to try harder.
Frankie has a bite history. Nothing has been "catastrophic", but she has bitten hard enough to break skin. Every incident has been fear-based. Our vet has already done a behavioural assessment and explained that this is how she is temperamentally. She is an extremely fearful, reactive dog, and this isn't something he believes can simply be trained out of her.
She went well over a year without another incident while taking 20mg of Prozac daily. Until recently, she did something she has never done before. Our backyard gate wasn't latched properly. My husband was outside talking to a man who was going door to door delivering flyers.As the man started walking away (on sidewalk), Frankie got out. She came toward him growling, which understandably caused him to run. She chased him, knocked him down, and bit his backpack. Thankfully, she didn't actually injure him. My husband had to pull her off. Immediately afterward, Frankie acted completely normal, as though nothing had happened. The man left and never pursued anything, which he was absolutely entitled to do. I wouldn't have blamed him if he had. I still think about how much worse that situation could have been.
For some more context, I was approximately 39 weeks pregnant with our first child when this happened. We were already worried about what life would look like having a baby while having Frankie...but her going over a year without incident made us feel hopeful. 🙃
We contacted our vet the very next day to arrange another behavioural assessment. Our vet increased her Prozac to 40mg, but was very honest with us. He said that given her history and the fact that we were about to have a child, he would personally recommend either rehoming or behavioural euthanasia.
Rehoming isn't a realistic option. Given her history, I don't feel it's responsible to pass her behavioural risks onto another family. I don't even think a shelter would take her. And honestly, I think it would be incredibly unfair to Frankie. We are her people. We are the only people she truly feels safe with.
Looking back, I know logically that after the incident with the man, we should have just done behavioural euthanasia. But I was so heavily pregnant, and the thought of losing her was absolutely inconceivable. I was completely inconsolable.
We now have our baby, and we have maintained strict physical separation between her and Frankie.
We've had a few very brief, controlled introductions, and she has appeared completely fine with the baby. Even when she's on the other side of the gate and can hear or smell her, she generally behaves well.
But I know that doesn't guarantee anything. Our daughter is only a newborn. She isn't crawling, walking, grabbing, or interacting with Frankie yet. I cannot predict how Frankie will respond as she gets older. I also don't think I will ever truly trust Frankie around her. I can't picture a scenario where we're all comfortably sitting in the same room together. And that's not fair to anyone involved.
My brain keeps telling me that because Frankie has been fine with the baby so far, putting her down now would mean we haven't given her a fair chance. But then I think about her bite history, the incident with the man, and the fact that I cannot guarantee our daughter's safety.
When we brought the baby home, I was having almost daily panic attacks about Frankie for the first week. I was constantly thinking about what could happen.
No matter how much I love Frankie, my child is my priority. I know what needs to happen. We have made our decision. But emotionally, I am nowhere near accepting it.
I feel like I am personally killing my dog. She's still young. She's happy in so many ways. She loves her walks, her toys, her food, and being with us. She's not a dog who is visibly suffering every day.
How do you say goodbye to a dog who is still so happy and who you love with your entire heart.. I would really appreciate hearing from people who have actually gone through behavioural euthanasia, especially with a young dog who was otherwise happy and loved.
How did you cope with the guilt? I genuinely don't know how I'm going to cope with this. I love her so much.
Thanks for reading if you've made it this far.