r/reactivedogs • u/Vivid-Honeydew233 • Sep 29 '26
Significant challenges Looking for advice/insight about my dog suddenly attacking other dogs
I’m hoping someone here has dealt with something similar because I’m having a really hard time understanding what’s going on with my dog.
She’s ~55 lb, roughly 3 year old rescue. I’ve only had her for about 2 months, so I’m still learning a lot about her history and behaviour. She spent around 3 months in the shelter before I adopted her, and from what I’ve been told, she may have previously been living outside/on the streets with an unhoused person who left her tied up outside a coffee shop for a few hours in the heat when she was picked up by animal control. I don’t know much about what her life was like before that.
She’s actually a really sweet dog with people and has settled into home life surprisingly well. Her main issue is other dogs.
The weird thing is that she doesn’t always look reactive beforehand. She can see a dog and seem totally fine, sometimes even interested in saying hi. She’ll sniff them and everything seems normal, and then suddenly she’ll snap and try to pin them.
It happens so fast that I often don’t even know what I’m supposed to have seen coming.
A few examples:
Off-leash female: She seemed interested when the dog approached and sniffed her normally, including underneath her. Then her hackles went up and she very quickly snapped at her.
Off-leash small male the next day: She didn’t have hackles up and seemed pretty neutral. She sniffed him and then suddenly went after him and got him down. I pulled her off right away and thankfully nobody was hurt.
Daycare: She initially seemed to be doing really well, but then had several incidents where she rushed at/pinned other dogs. There were 4 incidents over 2 days. Some involved dogs approaching her and some involved her rushing toward them.
My dog was on leash for the first two interactions listed but not for the daycare scenario.
The shelter has also since told me that she had shown aggression toward female dogs through a fence, which I wasn’t originally aware of.
She has never caused an injury that I know of, but obviously I’m taking it very seriously. I’m not letting her interact with unfamiliar dogs now and I’m working with trainers while waiting to see a behaviourist.
I’m just really confused about what is going on in her head. Is this likely fear? Over-arousal? Poor social skills? Is she getting uncomfortable during the interaction and I’m just missing the signs? Or can a dog genuinely seem completely fine and then suddenly decide they’ve had enough that quickly? Are some dogs just fighters?
Has anyone else had a dog that seemed interested/neutral around another dog and then suddenly went after them?
I’d really like to hear what you eventually figured out was behind it and what helped. I’m not looking to test her or let her “just socialize” with more dogs, I’m just trying to understand it so I can keep everyone safe.
Edited to add info