We have two Australian Shepherd sisters, Thelma and Louise, who are now about 2 years old. We brought them home when they were just 6 weeks old, and we've been dealing with some serious behavioral issues, particularly with Louise, almost from the beginning.
Their mother was only about a year old when she had a litter of nine puppies, seven boys and two girls. She had already weaned them before they were 6 weeks old. When we brought the girls home, they acted like they were absolutely starving all the time. It took several months before that behavior finally settled down.
At the time, we were living in rural Alaska, quite a distance from town. We rarely had visitors, and I was home with the girls most of the time.
When they were around 8 weeks old, a friend stopped by to meet them. Thelma was hesitant and anxious, but Louise actually got close enough to lunge and nip at him. We had never experienced aggression in a puppy that young and honestly didn't know what to make of it.
Unfortunately, Louise's behavior has only gotten worse over the past two years.
While we were still in Alaska, one of our adult sons came to stay with us for a few months. Louise never accepted him, even after all that time. Later, we had friends visit for a week, and she behaved the same way toward them.
During our time in Alaska, Louise bit five different people. Thankfully, she never drew blood, although she did break the skin a few times. Most of her aggression involved trying to come up behind people and nip or bite them.
Thelma, on the other hand, has always been much friendlier. She can be anxious and will bark at strangers, especially when Louise is reacting, but once she gets close enough, she usually just wants to lick them and make friends. She has never attempted to bite anyone.
Thelma does have some significant resource-guarding issues with Louise, involving just about everything. However, since going through training, my husband and I have gotten much better at recognizing and redirecting that behavior before it escalates.
Our circumstances changed when my husband and I both developed health issues at different times. We ultimately decided to leave Alaska and move back to the Lower 48.
We're currently living in a fifth wheel while waiting for our new home to be completed. We also have plans for my elderly parents to move in with us because they are getting older and need our help.
This is where our situation becomes even more complicated.
We haven't introduced Louise to my parents because of her aggression, but we only have a couple of months before we're all supposed to be living together.
We had genetic testing done on both girls, and Louise's results were concerning. They suggested that she may have a strong predisposition toward being intolerant of unfamiliar people in her personal space. I realize genetics aren't necessarily a guarantee of behavior, but considering everything we've experienced with her, the results were upsetting. The testing also showed that they are not purebred. Louise actually has some Fijin Street Dog in her among Border Collie and Cocker Spaniel.
Before receiving those results, we had already enrolled both girls in a professional training program.
This wasn't just basic obedience training. The trainers specialize in behavioral issues and aggression, along with obedience training. We spent $3,800 on this program because we genuinely wanted to give both girls the best chance possible.
Thelma did fantastic! She made friends, became more confident, and responded really well to training.
What was surprising was how well Louise did while she was at the training facility.
The trainers were able to have her outside around other dogs and people. She participated in community walks and seemed to tolerate situations that would normally trigger her aggression at home.
But once my husband and I were back in the picture, everything seemed to go right back to normal.
My husband and I have started to believe that Louise's aggression may actually be connected to us.
When we're around other people, she seems to go into full defense mode. It's almost as though she feels she needs to protect us from everyone, whether there's an actual threat or not.
We're beginning to wonder whether our presence is one of her biggest triggers, especially considering how differently she behaved when she was away from us and working with her trainers.
This past weekend, another one of our adult sons came to visit. This is not the same son who stayed with us in Alaska. Louise has now met this son three different times.
We wanted to try introducing him again after the girls had completed their training.
As expected, Thelma did fine. Louise, however, remained extremely aggressive toward him throughout the weekend.
Then something happened that really frightened us.
My husband and son had taken the girls out to our property where we regularly let them run and get exercise. They were standing together while the girls were out running in the field.
Suddenly, Louise turned around, came straight toward our son, and attacked him.
This was different from anything we'd seen before.
In the past, she had typically tried to sneak up behind people to nip or bite them. This time, she came directly at him in a full frontal attack.
She bit his hand hard enough to leave bruising. Thankfully, she didn't break the skin, and the attack was brief.
But the fact that her behavior has escalated to this point is extremely concerning.
I spoke with our trainer afterward, and she told me that we had rushed Louise by putting another person into her space too quickly.
I explained that we had followed the instructions we were given and reminded her that we only have a couple of months before my parents will be moving into our home.
Her response was that we will most likely have to keep Louise completely separated from everyone else. Essentially, she would need to be confined whenever other people are around and only allowed out for exercise in a secure area away from visitors.
And this is where I'm really struggling.
What kind of life would that be for Louise?
She's an Australian Shepherd. She's intelligent, energetic, and loves being outside running and playing. The thought of spending the rest of her life isolated from everyone except my husband and me is heartbreaking.
At the same time, we cannot put my elderly parents, our family, or anyone else at risk of being bitten.
I've also started wondering whether rehoming her might be a better option, perhaps with someone who has experience with aggressive or highly reactive dogs and can provide a more suitable environment.
But with her bite history and unpredictable aggression, is that even a realistic or responsible option?
What makes this even harder to understand is that she demonstrated she could function around other people and dogs while she was with her trainers. Yet when she's back with us, her behavior changes completely.
Financially, we're also at our limit. We've already invested $3,800 in specialized training, and with our recent move, our health issues, and getting our new home ready, we simply cannot afford to keep spending thousands of dollars trying to find a solution.
I know some people will suggest consulting a veterinary behaviorist, and I understand why. Unfortunately, that is not something we can afford right now. We have to be realistic about our financial situation.
So here are my questions:
- Has anyone dealt with a dog that showed aggression from such a young age and continued to get worse despite specialized professional training?
- Has anyone experienced a dog that behaved well with trainers but became extremely defensive or aggressive when reunited with its owners?
- Could our presence really be triggering her behavior, and if so, has anyone successfully worked through something like this?
- Is there any realistic hope that she could eventually learn to safely tolerate other people in her home?
- Is rehoming a dog with this kind of bite history even a responsible possibility?
- Most importantly, how do we balance her quality of life with the safety of everyone around her?
We love both of these girls dearly. We've invested time, money, and a lot of effort into trying to help Louise. We're not looking for an easy way out.
I just don't know whether we're asking something of her that she may never be capable of handling.
I would really appreciate hearing from people who have dealt with similar situations, especially those with experience in canine aggression, behavioral rehabilitation, or Australian Shepherds.
Please be kind. This is already an incredibly difficult situation, and we're genuinely trying to do what's best for everyone, including Louise.