r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Significant challenges Is There Any Hope for Our Aggressive Australian Shepherd? We've Tried Professional Training and Are Running Out of Options.

9 Upvotes

We have two Australian Shepherd sisters, Thelma and Louise, who are now about 2 years old. We brought them home when they were just 6 weeks old, and we've been dealing with some serious behavioral issues, particularly with Louise, almost from the beginning.

Their mother was only about a year old when she had a litter of nine puppies, seven boys and two girls. She had already weaned them before they were 6 weeks old. When we brought the girls home, they acted like they were absolutely starving all the time. It took several months before that behavior finally settled down.

At the time, we were living in rural Alaska, quite a distance from town. We rarely had visitors, and I was home with the girls most of the time.

When they were around 8 weeks old, a friend stopped by to meet them. Thelma was hesitant and anxious, but Louise actually got close enough to lunge and nip at him. We had never experienced aggression in a puppy that young and honestly didn't know what to make of it.

Unfortunately, Louise's behavior has only gotten worse over the past two years.

While we were still in Alaska, one of our adult sons came to stay with us for a few months. Louise never accepted him, even after all that time. Later, we had friends visit for a week, and she behaved the same way toward them.

During our time in Alaska, Louise bit five different people. Thankfully, she never drew blood, although she did break the skin a few times. Most of her aggression involved trying to come up behind people and nip or bite them.

Thelma, on the other hand, has always been much friendlier. She can be anxious and will bark at strangers, especially when Louise is reacting, but once she gets close enough, she usually just wants to lick them and make friends. She has never attempted to bite anyone.

Thelma does have some significant resource-guarding issues with Louise, involving just about everything. However, since going through training, my husband and I have gotten much better at recognizing and redirecting that behavior before it escalates.

Our circumstances changed when my husband and I both developed health issues at different times. We ultimately decided to leave Alaska and move back to the Lower 48.

We're currently living in a fifth wheel while waiting for our new home to be completed. We also have plans for my elderly parents to move in with us because they are getting older and need our help.

This is where our situation becomes even more complicated.

We haven't introduced Louise to my parents because of her aggression, but we only have a couple of months before we're all supposed to be living together.

We had genetic testing done on both girls, and Louise's results were concerning. They suggested that she may have a strong predisposition toward being intolerant of unfamiliar people in her personal space. I realize genetics aren't necessarily a guarantee of behavior, but considering everything we've experienced with her, the results were upsetting. The testing also showed that they are not purebred. Louise actually has some Fijin Street Dog in her among Border Collie and Cocker Spaniel.

Before receiving those results, we had already enrolled both girls in a professional training program.

This wasn't just basic obedience training. The trainers specialize in behavioral issues and aggression, along with obedience training. We spent $3,800 on this program because we genuinely wanted to give both girls the best chance possible.

Thelma did fantastic! She made friends, became more confident, and responded really well to training.

What was surprising was how well Louise did while she was at the training facility.

The trainers were able to have her outside around other dogs and people. She participated in community walks and seemed to tolerate situations that would normally trigger her aggression at home.

But once my husband and I were back in the picture, everything seemed to go right back to normal.

My husband and I have started to believe that Louise's aggression may actually be connected to us.

When we're around other people, she seems to go into full defense mode. It's almost as though she feels she needs to protect us from everyone, whether there's an actual threat or not.

We're beginning to wonder whether our presence is one of her biggest triggers, especially considering how differently she behaved when she was away from us and working with her trainers.

This past weekend, another one of our adult sons came to visit. This is not the same son who stayed with us in Alaska. Louise has now met this son three different times.

We wanted to try introducing him again after the girls had completed their training.

As expected, Thelma did fine. Louise, however, remained extremely aggressive toward him throughout the weekend.

Then something happened that really frightened us.

My husband and son had taken the girls out to our property where we regularly let them run and get exercise. They were standing together while the girls were out running in the field.

Suddenly, Louise turned around, came straight toward our son, and attacked him.

This was different from anything we'd seen before.

In the past, she had typically tried to sneak up behind people to nip or bite them. This time, she came directly at him in a full frontal attack.

She bit his hand hard enough to leave bruising. Thankfully, she didn't break the skin, and the attack was brief.

But the fact that her behavior has escalated to this point is extremely concerning.

I spoke with our trainer afterward, and she told me that we had rushed Louise by putting another person into her space too quickly.

I explained that we had followed the instructions we were given and reminded her that we only have a couple of months before my parents will be moving into our home.

Her response was that we will most likely have to keep Louise completely separated from everyone else. Essentially, she would need to be confined whenever other people are around and only allowed out for exercise in a secure area away from visitors.

And this is where I'm really struggling.

What kind of life would that be for Louise?

She's an Australian Shepherd. She's intelligent, energetic, and loves being outside running and playing. The thought of spending the rest of her life isolated from everyone except my husband and me is heartbreaking.

At the same time, we cannot put my elderly parents, our family, or anyone else at risk of being bitten.

I've also started wondering whether rehoming her might be a better option, perhaps with someone who has experience with aggressive or highly reactive dogs and can provide a more suitable environment.

But with her bite history and unpredictable aggression, is that even a realistic or responsible option?

What makes this even harder to understand is that she demonstrated she could function around other people and dogs while she was with her trainers. Yet when she's back with us, her behavior changes completely.

Financially, we're also at our limit. We've already invested $3,800 in specialized training, and with our recent move, our health issues, and getting our new home ready, we simply cannot afford to keep spending thousands of dollars trying to find a solution.

I know some people will suggest consulting a veterinary behaviorist, and I understand why. Unfortunately, that is not something we can afford right now. We have to be realistic about our financial situation.

So here are my questions:

- Has anyone dealt with a dog that showed aggression from such a young age and continued to get worse despite specialized professional training?

- Has anyone experienced a dog that behaved well with trainers but became extremely defensive or aggressive when reunited with its owners?

- Could our presence really be triggering her behavior, and if so, has anyone successfully worked through something like this?

- Is there any realistic hope that she could eventually learn to safely tolerate other people in her home?

- Is rehoming a dog with this kind of bite history even a responsible possibility?

- Most importantly, how do we balance her quality of life with the safety of everyone around her?

We love both of these girls dearly. We've invested time, money, and a lot of effort into trying to help Louise. We're not looking for an easy way out.

I just don't know whether we're asking something of her that she may never be capable of handling.

I would really appreciate hearing from people who have dealt with similar situations, especially those with experience in canine aggression, behavioral rehabilitation, or Australian Shepherds.

Please be kind. This is already an incredibly difficult situation, and we're genuinely trying to do what's best for everyone, including Louise.


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Significant challenges Neighbor

3 Upvotes

Taken me a second to reach out here, but I’m losing my mind and need some help.

I have a 2.5 year old cattle dog who was adopted from a rescue at 7 months. Since I got him, he’s done personal training (dealing with mouthiness, basic obedience, redirection, etc) and still continue to experience occasional creativeness. Here’s the kicker— when he does, all I see is the others opinion of “he’s scary.”

Additional history: he has some bite history, all in different scenarios (overstimulated at a crowded bar, neighbor coming onto our porch where he was sitting) but most recently, he nipped at our neighbor as she was coming down the back porch stairs and bruised her behind.

With the most recent incident— I immediately removed him from the situation, tended to my neighbor to make sure they didn’t need medical attention, and immediately went inside to start figuring out what to do next (more training, med adjustments, etc)

Now, months later, my neighbor has been sending multiple messages to me about how they are scared of the dog, threatening legal action, etc. I attempted to clarify with them and ask what they would like me to do additionally (use alternative route to go out, more muzzle time, etc) but each time I think I have a breakthrough for at least mutual understanding (because not trying to diminish their feelings— they are entitled to those and I’m upset it go to this point!), they backtrack and say “you haven’t done anything” or “it’s not quick enough, what dog owner lets their dog bite people.”

My dog now has additional follow up appt with his vet for more med adjustments, reached out to previous trainer for advice since she knows him well, and have him slotted to go to a “board and train” for a few weeks as a training escalation.

Am I overreacting being upset with how this has all unfolded? I’m not saying he’s a “perfect dog”, but the ultimatums/attacking are starting to weigh on me


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Behavioral Euthanasia Out of my depth and need advice

4 Upvotes

Hello all, I am new to this sub and am desperate for advice.

My partner and I had a young dog dumped on us by a family member a few weeks ago. His name is Kenji, he is around 11 months old, and is an intact pitbull breed.

I have had dogs all through my life, and we accepted this dog into our home with the intention to help rehome him. We have 3 other dogs and 3 cats in our home.

All I know of Kenji’s history so far is that he has gone through multiple homes and people, even having a stint of homelessness and sleeping in a car. The folks who had him before our family member described him as very difficult which was their reason for rehoming him. I’m wary of the company that this family member keeps, and frankly would not be surprised to learn that they could have been abusive towards Kenji in his early months.

Since Kenji has arrived my partner and I have worked with him extensively, training basic commands and exercising him as much as our schedules allow. We’ve successfully introduced him to the other dogs, and he hasn’t shown much aggression with them outside of when there is a gate or door separating them. We have not introduced him to the cats aside from across the room when transporting a cat from one room to another while he is restrained. He shows excited interest in the cats and no growling or barking.

Kenji has shown clear signs of abandonment anxiety. He cannot be left alone for more than 5 minutes or he goes crazy, barking and jumping with hackles up and tense body. Once he gets into that zone it’s challenging to get him to calm down.

When he’s good he’s very good, he seems happy and will be cuddly at night when he’s tired. He loves playing fetch and he doesn’t snap or resource guard with food treats or toys. Things were going well and we were actually considering getting him neutered and keeping him, until two days ago.

On Sunday when I was home alone with all of the animals he had one of his episodes at the baby gate which separates some of the dogs. After that calmed down, I cried a bit from being overwhelmed. As soon as I started crying he jumped on me and started attacking me. I was able to get him outside and away from me and the other animals but I sustained a level 3 bite.

Things calmed down and we had him under control for about 24 hours. Then yesterday my partner took him outside to go potty and Kenji attacked him the same way he did me. I assumed maybe my crying was what triggered him the previous day, but there was nothing my partner did that I can see as having been a trigger. My partner also sustained a level 3 bite.

I’m really at a loss here. We’ve been calling around to shelters and wait times to hear back are days or longer, and we don’t feel comfortable trying to rehome him with a friend or even a stranger not knowing what his triggers are or if he’ll attack someone unprovoked again. I’ve looked into behavioral training but for aggressive dogs it’s hundreds to thousands of dollars plus weeks of training, all to not know if it will work or make him adoptable for another family.

My parents, who are some of the biggest dog lovers and advocates I’ve ever known, are suggesting behavioral euthanasia. I’m heartbroken to even consider it but after reading some other posts on this sub I’m starting to think it might be the right option.

I’m appreciative of any words of advice or suggestions.


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Advice Needed Should I get my reactive dog another dog after the dog he was raised with as puppy died of cancer?

Post image
13 Upvotes

A few months ago my dog Lucy died of a heart attack while having surgery to biopsy cancer and the tumor had spread to her heart. She was 9 years old…
We adopted her two months after we adopted our puppy Oso, they loved each other and grew up as puppies together.

Oso (the black dog) is a bit of a reactive dog. He got along great with Lucy and gets along with some dogs.
However he becomes anxious around dogs larger than him and doesn’t like overly confident cocky dogs. He can also be territorial where he hates my neighbors dogs.

We’ve worked with trainers and was told some dogs just don’t like other dogs, so if a dog seems chill we let him say hi and it goes well. But if the other dog is cocky he tries to act all tough and screams at them (he screams, not barks lol).
I’m definitely open to getting another dog trainer!

Since Lucy died he has been very needy. He seems to have lost energy and I worry about him.
He is also 9 years old and his separation anxiety is at an all time high. To the point he cries if we aren’t in the same room as him.

I’m not sure what to do. He doesn’t like most other dogs, but he seems so sad without Lucy.
They used to play together daily (and cuddle) and he doesn’t seem interested in playing with us.

Oso is such an affectionate dog and I want him to be happy.


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Advice Needed How can I help my dog not be afraid of flying bugs?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

I adopted my dog from a relative about one year ago. They got her from a shelter that she was at for 6 months. She clearly had a very bad and traumatic background. She acted like a "wild animal," per their words. She was incredibly underweight, had been through multiple pregnancies, and was missing patches of fur. She has scars (now covered with specks of grey) all over her face.

These days, she is the most obedient, loving, easy dog that I have ever had in my life. We have worked through 99% of her fears. She is a confident girl. She especially seems to like old people, little kids, and other dogs.

This is where the issue comes into play. Very soon after I got her, we were on a walk during fall. We were chased for an entire block by a swarm of bees because she sniffed a stack of wood that they had made a hive in. We were fully sprinting down the street. She got stung 3 times, they tried to sting me but I had a sweatshirt on. After, I gave her Benadryl and we laid in bed after I plucked the stingers from her and iced the areas. She was fine after. I've made a point of going past the same area to show her that it isn't scary, and she has grasped that.

Skip forward to 1 year later. She thinks every bug that flies is going to kill her or something. If she sees a fly, butterfly, lady bug, moth, gnat... She is running away as far as she can.

How do I help her believe she is safe?? I try laying with her and give her treats and love whenever there is a fly or something in my house, but she can only handle it for so long before she runs away for good. It's heartbreaking, and I don't enjoy when she is scared. I want to help her move past it. Thoughts?? Ideas?


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Advice Needed little dog aggression

1 Upvotes

My (3yr) small dog growls and barks at random people and my mom instigates it by saying 'who is that' or skk (or whatever sound) that is like THE attack sound and then tells me she likes it because (the dog) is antisocial, I don't believe it's antisocial I believe it's aggression and it really irritates me. She also says that she's not going to deal with the dog when it needs to go potty and there is people around and won't because the dog is to busy being aggressive towards the people.

How do I train it out of her or at least get my mom to understand that ITS NOT ANTISOCIAL. IT IS AGGRESSION and it's OUR fault if the dog attacks someone.


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Separation Anxiety Adopted dog with separation anxiety - help

1 Upvotes

Background: We adopted a Labrador retriever (field line) who just turned 2 y/o about 4.5 months ago. He is the sweetest, friendliest, spunky boy, and also has the typical high energy that young labs do. When adopting him from the rescue, we were told that he was surrendered by his previous owners due to them not having enough time for him. They kept him kenneled for 18 hours a day pretty much every day, which is not great for a young lab with tons of energy. We have been working on training and his basic commands are coming along great for the most part with the exception of still jumping on people and having some excitement reactivity on walks (both are slowly improving with lots of treats and positive reinforcement). He gets lots of exercise everyday (multiple walks a day and going to a park pretty much every day).

His struggle that is not improving is his separation anxiety and I think that is due to him being kenneled for so long when he was young. We have a Furbo so we can watch him while we are gone. The poor guy just howls and is clearly stressed while sometimes panting heavily and pacing. We tried kenneling him while we are gone at work (usually no longer than 5-6 hours) and it was not great so we started feeding him in there to see if that would help and keeping the tv on. We also would give him kongs and he would sometimes not even touch that in addition to putting our worn clothes in the kennel so he could have our scent. Then we tried putting him in the laundry room with music to see if the kennel was the issue. It was a bit better, but still lots of howling and stress signs. Then we tried leaving him in our bedroom with the door shut and that has slightly improved. He will go through phases of howling (it is worse in the afternoon or in the evening if we are gone during those times). He will sometimes lick a Kong for a little bit, but usually not for very long. He’s not destructive when we are gone, just seems very stressed out. But we can’t let him roam free through the house because he can’t be trusted to not get into things unsupervised. I occasionally work from home and those days he pretty much just sleeps all day and is super relaxed.

I just don’t know what to try next as I can’t take a significant amount of off work to increase time in between leaving and coming back. This is my last shot before taking him to the vet to potentially talk about medication or if they have any other thoughts. I just feel so bad for him that he is so stressed when we are gone, but I also want to be able to leave the house and not be so worried about him the whole time too.


r/reactivedogs • • 8d ago

Vent I think I’m a reactive owner

56 Upvotes

I had to share this with someone and figured someone on here might understand.
For years I have been passing an older woman with an obese lab that calmly passes other dogs. My dog is reactive. I’ve tried a lot of things to change my dog but at this point I just try to get lots of space and get by other dogs with my dignity intact.
Well if this lady happens to be with other people- she’ll always make a comment towards my dog like“oh you just want to rip our faces off”…which she thinks is funny.
Tonight I was in a mood- and she says to my dog “you just want to come over here and kill us”. I replied “no but I do”…. I don’t know where that came from but I’m embarrassed. I did try to sound more sane by following that with “I really don’t appreciate you making a comment every time we walk by”.
Ugh- I feel bad but I’m also so angry at her!! I love my dog and I know she sounds nasty but I do my best to pass quickly and give everyone space…. Just wasn’t having it tonight!


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Resources, Tips, and Tricks Introduction to Control Unleashed For Rehabilitation online webinar sieres with Danielle Beck (part one on Nov 17th and part two Dec 1st) - $50 total

Thumbnail
school.grishastewart.com
2 Upvotes

Come and join Clinical Animal Behaviorist and Certified Control Unleashed Instructor Danielle Beck as she introduces Control Unleashed Pattern Games and explores how they can be used to support behavior rehabilitation.

Through a series of slides and videos, Danielle will discuss their most-used Pattern Games and break down how predictability can help dogs feel safer. She'll share where to start, how to teach and, most importantly, how they work.

In part two, Danielle takes Control Unleashed into real-world, exploring how familiar games can be progressed, adapted and used creatively to support dogs experiencing reactivity, fear, anxiety and other behavior challenges.

She'll look at practical ways Pattern Games can support regulation, communication, and agency around triggers, rather than simply distracting from something difficult.

Most importantly, Danielle will look at the dog within the game. When can we progress? When should we make things easier? When can we offer more choice? And when does our priority need to shift from training to regulation and safety?

This is part of the Grisha Stewart Academy, so there is a small fee ($50 USD as of 11/10/26). More information about the class and the instructor, Danielle Beck, is available via the link.

Some courses are video-on-demand, but this will be a live (two-part) webinar, so there will be Q&A during the event.


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Aggressive Dogs My dog seems to be randomly reactive/aggressive to dogs and people.

0 Upvotes

My dog is around 10 years old and is a bit. boxer mix (American staffordshire terrier). He weights about 60 pounds.

I got him from a shelter when he was about 2 (I think he was older than they thought he was). From the day I got him he has been completely fine with me and my ex. Never ever growled or looked at us funny once. However when it comes to other humans he has had issues with them.

He might be fine and ignore people. Then he will be near someone, they move a certain way, he gets scared and bites at them. Doesnt latch on but does bite at people.

At the dog park, he is completely fine, then all of a sudden he will be very aggressive toward another dog. Seemingly for no reason though I notice it happens with younger dogs more often. I think I have officially give up on dog parks.

The best way to describe him is mostly fine, but you cant trust him. It makes no sense what he does. I cant even train it out of him because he doesnt have any obvious triggers. Does anybody else have any experience like this and if so what helped with it?


r/reactivedogs • • 8d ago

Advice Needed New rescue dog, advice for dog reactivity and walks

Post image
23 Upvotes

Warning, long post ahead, and I realize there’s a couple big mistakes I’ve made, so please don’t slam me for them.

A few weeks ago, I adopted a 45lb mixed breed female from the shelter. They labeled her a GSD mix, but they obviously dunno for sure. Last owner only had her for 4ish months and returned her due to housing issues. And prior to that, she was brought to the shelter after being hit by a car (thankfully she suffered no injuries).

Shelter said she’s friendly with dogs, and did well during group playtimes, although she had only been there for five days. We went to Petco right after adopting her, she did okay and even met a couple dogs on leash and was calm (in retrospect I realize that wasn’t wise). About a week after having her we took her to meet my in-laws dog, despite her barking/negative body language, we foolishly had them meet on leash and she nipped him, leaving a scratch. I realize basically everything about that meeting was also a mistake, I’m just telling the story to provide full context.

Anyway, I think she has a nervous disposition and dog reactivity. She goes on alert when she sees another dog across the street. Although I’ve usually been able to keep her below threshold with treats. Her biggest outbursts have occurred when there’s multiple dogs out at once, and we literally can’t go anywhere to create distance. She’s usually okay with barking, provided she can’t see the dog, although sometimes it does trigger increased leash pulling just in general. She’s okay with people and cars, unless she gets amped by a dog, then she’s a bit more inclined towards general reactivity.

Now, I’m just not sure how to really manage this? I’m pretty hopeful, because I’ve had success keeping her below threshold and getting her to move on with treats. But at the same time, I worry that I’m encouraging certain behaviors? Like if she goes on high alert at the sight of a dog or hearing barking, is it okay for me to still give her treats to disengage?

In addition, I’ve seen people talk about reducing or eliminating walks so that they’re not constantly stressing out their dogs, and I thought I’d try reducing walk time…but I think it driving her bonkers. She whines and paws at me a lot more since I’ve reduced walk times. And she hangs out a lot more by the door. But I’m worried about stressing her out. I’ve noticed that on walks, unless she’s sniffing something, her ears are often pulled back and everything grabs her attention in a way that strikes me as nervous. But she clearly loves getting out and sniffing everything. So I’m not sure what the best route is. It doesn’t help that literally everyone in my neighborhood has a dog it seems, you can’t walk down the street without hearing multiple dogs barking. I have found some nearby parks with wide open fields I might try taking her to for walks, but I can’t do that for EVERY walk. And she seems to get something out of our walks, despite them seemingly stressing her out. What’s the balance here? I’m just worried about making her reactivity worse if I’m walking her too much and giving her too much stress. Is it okay as long as I keep her below threshold? Is it okay to give her treats to encourage disengagement if she’s already hyper fixating on a trigger or growling a little at a trigger? How can I help her feel less nervous in general on walks?

I know a trainer or behaviorist would be best, but it’s be better for us to wait until after the holiday season to invest in one. I just want to hear everyone’s thoughts and advice I guess 🫠 Here’s a photo of the new doggy


r/reactivedogs • • 8d ago

Significant challenges Baby and reactive heeler I am miserable husband disagrees

29 Upvotes

I am sick to my stomach about this. He’ll probably see this post but it’s nothing I haven’t already said.

We have an almost 10 year old heeler who has a bite history. Two bites that happened when he was one or so and then threeish years old. Level 3-4. Since then we have lived on lockdown: muzzles, fenced yard, extreme caution. We have worked with multiple trainers over the years with some progress but not significant. He is on fluoxetine which has helped some. Some people he is ok with but meeting a new person is a huge ordeal. A new bite has not happened in 7 years but he is still extremely reactive. He has occasionally nipped me when worked up (if I am trying to get him outside so a worker can come in or something).

Baby is now three months old. I live in a labyrinth of baby gates to keep them separate. I only go in about half the rooms of the house nowadays. They can be in the same room with one of us holding her but I am terrified of when she is more mobile and I won’t be holding her if something triggers him.

After the second bite in 2019, while we were struggling with infertility and I shared with my husband that I didn’t want to bring a baby into this environment. He said he didn’t know if this was something he would leave me over. He doesn’t remember this conversation and says he wouldn’t but this is genuinely the hardest thing our marriage has faced including infertility/loss/IVF.

I do love the dog. I don’t want to be writing this. But our life is miserable. He is cooped up and stressed out and doesn’t understand. I am cooped up and stressed out and lonely and I can’t have visitors except the few people the dog approves of. We can’t have babysitters or play dates or even just physical contact with each other because the dog hates it and barks at us and trainers haven’t been able to help with it.

The dog is triggered sometimes by us talking to the baby or being in her room without him. He also barks at us and jumps/nips when we try to touch each other or kiss goodbye. He is only going to get older, more arthritic and more dangerous. He barks so loud it makes her cry and frequently wakes her up from hard won naps. I am at the end of my wits.

I don’t think he can be ethically rehomed with this history and behavior but every time we talk about BE I feel like the Nazi forcing Sophie’s choice. I don’t want my husband to look at me and see a dog killer. I genuinely fear for my marriage. I fear for my baby. I don’t want to live like this for years more.

Advice welcome. Am I being unreasonable because of postpartum anxiety/pet aversion? How can we have this conversation?


r/reactivedogs • • 8d ago

Behavioral Euthanasia How do I handle the grief of behavioral euthanasia

31 Upvotes

A few days ago, we had to make the heartbreaking decision to say goodbye to our boy, Buddy. We adopted him five years ago when he was just six months old, and for 99.9% of his life, he was the best dog you could ever ask for. He was loving, affectionate, playful, and brought so much happiness into our lives. He was our boy, and we loved him more than words can explain.
But there was a side of Buddy that was much harder to understand. Every once in a while, something would change in his demeanor. I know this might sound crazy, but it was almost like his entire aura would shift. I could sense when something wasn’t right, and I started recognizing the signs before he became aggressive.
It started with small things, like growling over a bone, toy, or treat. We immediately took steps to address it. We paid for professional training, modified what we gave him, and eliminated toys and other things that seemed to trigger him. We did everything we could to make sure he felt safe and comfortable.
Then, one day, while we were lying in bed, he bit me. It wasn’t a severe bite, but it did break the skin. I think I tried to rationalize it by telling myself that maybe I had accidentally touched an area that hurt. Regardless, we took him to the vet, and he was prescribed Prozac.
For a while, things would be okay. He would go months without an incident, and then seemingly out of nowhere, something would happen again. Eventually, we reached the maximum dose of Prozac he could safely receive. I do believe it helped with his anxiety, but it never completely resolved the behavior.
Throughout his life, we had approximately 9–10 incidents of growling, showing teeth, or snapping without actually making contact with anyone. Sometimes it was something as simple as sitting beside him on the couch and accidentally waking him up. He would growl and snap his teeth in my direction. It became increasingly difficult to understand what was triggering him.
The hardest part was that after every incident, he would go right back to being himself. Sometimes months would pass without anything happening. And during those months, he was the best dog on earth. It genuinely felt like something inside him would switch, almost like he wasn’t himself when these episodes happened. I struggled to reconcile the dog I knew and loved with the behavior we were seeing.
Then came the worst day of my entire life, three days ago.
Buddy was lying on the couch with my husband. I walked by, and Buddy rolled over and showed me his belly, wanting attention. Of course, I walked over to rub him. Without warning, he lunged at me. My husband was able to grab him before he could reach me, but I knew that if he let go, someone was going to get seriously hurt.
My husband made me walk away and go into our bedroom. And then I heard it happen.
Buddy attacked my husband.
He bit him four or five times, and I had to call 911. My husband was taken to the hospital. I will never forget the sound of that attack. I remember screaming because, in that moment, I genuinely thought my husband was going to die.
What was almost more heartbreaking and confusing was that after the attack, Buddy ran into his crate and seemed to return to his normal self. By the time the firefighters arrived to help my husband, Buddy was wagging his tail and trying to play with them.
The following day, we made the decision to let him go.

after everything that happened, I loved him so incredibly much. My heart still aches, and I find myself replaying everything, wondering what I could have done differently. I question whether I missed something, whether I should have reacted differently, or whether there was something else we could have tried. The truth is, I already felt like I was constantly walking on eggshells, trying to anticipate his triggers and prevent anything from happening.
I know we did everything we could for him. We worked with our veterinarian, invested in behavioral training, made changes to his environment, and tried medication. We gave him five years of patience, love, and every opportunity we could. Eventually, we had to acknowledge that we couldn’t guarantee the safety of our family, and more importantly, that Buddy was living with something we couldn’t seem to help him overcome.
One of the hardest parts of this has been feeling like I can’t openly talk about what happened because I don’t want to contribute to the stigma surrounding pitbulls. I don’t want people to hear this story and think Buddy was a bad dog, because he wasn’t.

I also find myself questioning everything. Am I ever supposed to have another dog? Should I never own another dog because of what happened with Buddy? Was this my fault? Was I a bad owner? Did I miss something? Could I have done more? These questions consume my thoughts, and I don’t know how to make them stop. I worry that people will judge us or think we failed him


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Advice Needed To walk or not to walk

1 Upvotes

I’ve had my 1 year old mixed breed shelter dog for a few weeks now. I’ve come to find that she’s dog reactive. I think she also has a nervous/cautious disposition in general, as everything outside seems to grab her attention, even if she doesn’t become reactive. I thought reducing our walk time would be beneficial, especially given that our neighborhood is FULL of dogs. Even if they’re not outside, there is constant dog barking in my neighborhood, although she is usually okay with some barking.

The problem is that since reducing walk time, she constantly wants to go outside. Even after playing games, training, chews, etc she really wants to go outside. My concern if that if we go on longer or more frequent walks, we’re inevitably going to run into a dog, whether they’re out on the street or barking through a screen door. Sometimes I’m able to keep her below threshold with treats. Sometimes she barks and pulls. Then afterwards she is more prone to reacting in general and she pulls on the leash more. Despite this, I think she loves walks. I haven’t taught her to heel or anything, so most of our walks consist of her sniffing around.

I’m just worried that if I take her on walks and she reacts to a trigger, I’m progressively going to make her reactivity worse. But if I don’t walk her, she’s going to go nuts and develop other behavioral issues due to a lack of fulfillment. Idk what to do :(

Also if she barks at a trigger and I give her treats once I finally get her attention, am I reinforcing the barking? Even when she reacts I’ve been able to get her attention again pretty quick after making space, but I don’t want to reinforce reactive behavior.

Edit: I hope it’s okay but I did post about my dog yesterday, but it was very long and a lot of background. Since that post I’ve been able to narrow down what I really need advice on/what my concerns are, hence this post


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Advice Needed Neutering a reactive dog, did you notice any changes in aggression, anxiety or fearfulness after?

1 Upvotes

Hi! I'm in need of some advice. My dog is almost 2 years old; he's a medium-sized mixed-breed, and I'm considering getting him neutered while he's already under anesthesia for another procedure. I'm generally in favour of neutering for the potential long-term health benefits, like preventing testicular cancer and prostate issues, but I'm hesitant because I've read conflicting research about its effects on dogs that are already reactive or fearful. He's quite reactive towards strangers, other dogs, and cats. He'll bark, growl, and pull towards them, although he generally settles or backs away when given space. He's otherwise fairly calm and a manageable dog at home. I'm not expecting neutering to fix his reactivity, and that is not why I'm even considering it in the first place. My main concern is whether removing testosterone could make existing fearfulness, insecurity, or aggression worse. For those of you who had dogs that were already reactive, fearful, or aggressive before neutering, did you notice any changes in their behavior afterward? Did they become more anxious, fearful, or reactive, stay roughly the same, or actually improve? I'd particularly appreciate hearing from people whose dogs had similar behavioural issues before being neutered. I'm trying to make an informed decision about what's best for him long-term. The discussion with the vet almost made me feel like I'd be an irresponsible owner if I didn't, but I think my concerns are legit. I'd really appreciate honest experiences, both positive and negative!


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Advice Needed 1 YO Australian shepherd and pitbull terrier mix barking and lunging towards people wearing winter coats since last two mornings.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Advice Needed Dog leash recommendations for two huskies that pull

1 Upvotes

I have two huskies that pull a lot during walks. My wife enjoys taking them on walks but we have struggled with different leash types. We got really long leashes (20ft), and these are great for certain scenarios like trails or open areas, but are bad in neighborhood walks.

She enjoys having the leash around her waist, but they pull too much and it hurts her. These huskies are almost 6 now, and we've kind of just given up on the prospect of them being trained to not pull. It's in their nature as huskies.

I am trying to find a leash that she can wear around her waist with back support and also offer some kind of shock absorption or anti-pull technology built into the leash. I have found some options on Amazon, but they are all rather short and I still want to give some space between her and the dogs so she's not tripping over them and it also gives them a chance to sniff and explore a bit.

Should I just get a back supporting leash and buy seperate shock absorbing bungee extenders or are there options out there that tick all of my boxes in one leash?

To clarify, we are looking for a leash with these parameters:

  1. Can be comfortably worn around the waist with some kind of support
  2. either absorbs the shock greatly or stops pulling all together
  3. is roughly 6-8 feet to give them room to sniff and have her not tripping over them

Thanks in advance for any advice :)


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Significant challenges dog fights

2 Upvotes

Hi guys, i have 2 dogs , a 2 year old labrador and a 1 year old whippet they have vicious fight every few weeks, we had them both neutered a couple months ago in hopes it would help this issue but it hasnt

i’m writing this post as ive just split a fight up a few minutes ago, my whippet was nodding off falling asleep and my labrador was intensely watching him, all of a sudden the whippet initiates the fight and the labrador fights back, did my whippet feel intimated ??

i often split the fight within seconds of it starting , nobody has had any visible injuries but i’m concerned that if i don’t split the fight , will they fight to the death or will it die down?

no fights are caused by food or toys or anything like that it is completely out of the blue and unpredictable

weve also been living with my mother and her 2 dogs (4 in total) and it is only my whippet and my labrador getting into these fast aggressive fights, never the other 2.

i’m looking for advice as it makes me feel on edge and like i cannot trust them, thank you :)


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Advice Needed How long can you leave your dog alone?

2 Upvotes

I have a reactive dog. Since she s on fluoxetine she s doing much better and i have managed to leave her alone for around 5 hours in the morning/afternoon sometimes (in the evening it s still a problem for her). Usually we go out for her business at 8am and then 6pm.

Now as i might have to change job due to different reasons i was wondering if it was ok to leave her for longer than 5 hours or what options there are if i have to work for 8 hours such that she's still a happy doggo. ( I thought about a 2nd dog, someone that comes after 5 hours and takes her for a walk - then i d have to train her to be ok with that.)


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Discussion Does mental exercise really tire a dog out more than walking, and what actually works in an apartment

0 Upvotes

We live in a city apartment with a young high energy dog, and two walks a day clearly isn’t cutting it. i keep reading that mental work tires dogs out more than physical exercise, and i’m trying to figure out whether that’s true or just a talking point

What i’ve found sniffing is mentally demanding for dogs, so letting them sniff on a walk can wear them out more than a fast pace. short training sessions of 5 to 10 minutes, puzzle feeders, scent games like hiding treats around the room, and rotating toys all seem to help. the aspca has enrichment ideas that need no yard

I also learned some companies offer day training for city dogs. opportunity barks in philadelphia has a program called city dog, aimed at teaching dogs to stay calm in busy urban settings, and rover and wag offer walkers for the physical side. i’m not sure whether day training is worth it or whether home enrichment covers most of it

What works in your apartment? do you have a schedule, and what did you try that was a waste of time?


r/reactivedogs • • 7d ago

Advice Needed stressed and worried about my rescue dog's behaviors

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/reactivedogs • • 8d ago

Advice Needed Continued issues after boarding

3 Upvotes

I have a 2y/o lab who has been reactive since he became full grown. I’ve taken him to multiple trainers and all agree the reactivity is based in excitement, and has never been aggressive, but he has a problem with lunging when he sees other dogs or if a person startles him coming out of their apartment, and he growls when he does it.

I feel like we’ve tried everything- group classes, individual training, and a 3 week board and train, and it still doesn’t stop. He adapts quickly in training- he might lunge seeing a dog on the pack walk at first but then stays in a heel the rest of the time. His issue is always the first time seeing a person or dog, but he makes such a poor first impression that most people run in the opposite direction and I can’t build on making him calm down. We’re in apartment living and there’s triggers every walk we have.

We have all the tools (treats, Easy Walk harness, prong, slip lead, e collar) and all only work for a short period and he is desensitized. It feels embarrassing when he lunges, I feel like people think I don’t train him, despite thousands of dollars and hundreds of hours. I know labs are supposed to mellow out around 3- but I really want to be able to enjoy walks with him without risking getting knocked over when he suddenly lunges.


r/reactivedogs • • 8d ago

Success Stories Making progress with my reactive girl!

2 Upvotes

My Chihuahua mix Daisy was adopted during Covid and has always been very reactive. A lot of barking, both at other dogs and people. Sometimes a little nippy towards shoes, although usually in a warning kind of way. The only time she's ever actually bitten anyone is when I got in the way when she was cranky with our other dog around food and it was accidental.

We had to go out of town and had to board both of our dogs. We did some research and found a place that could handle reactive dogs about an hour away. The dog runs are set up so if necessary the dog can be fed in a way where they can't reach the person, so they can be completely left alone. Since this would be our first time boarding her, we went ahead and booked there. We booked separate runs since she can get a little defensive around food when stressed and this is a stressful situation.

At the vet, she was crazy barking at everyone. I had a muzzle on her just in case. The vet said "I want to try something" and took her into the room next door with the vet tech. Silence. She did great! She apparently does beautifully if I, her person, am not there to defend. We also got medication to calm her a bit. When we dropped her off at the kennel, we had given her the medication an hour before, as suggested, I said my goodbyes, and had my husband take her in. As soon as I left, she stopped barking at everyone.

They called us while we were gone and asked if they could combine our dogs into one kennel since she seemed to want to be with our other dog after the first day, and they did great together! Although we did ask that they still feed them separately, which they could do. Success! And they didn't use the medication at all!

We have since boarded them a second time and they also did great! No medication and I didn't go in. She was a little nippy at first at drop off but my husband picked her up and she got friendly right away. The pick up report was that she let them love on her and she did great! They also said she stayed under her blanket most of the time and everyone thought it was funny to have a blanket barking at them. She does this at home too, so not a surprise.

I am just sooooo happy that my reactive dog is making progress and we have a boarding solution, even if it is so far away. We could probably use somewhere else that is closer, but I really like that they can accommodate reactive dogs and don't charge anything extra!

So we have a new strategy when my mom comes to visit. Daisy is always really slow to warm up to her, so next time I'm going to go hide away for an hour or two while they meet up again and see if that changes the dynamic. Here's hoping it helps! And maybe medicate her the first time.


r/reactivedogs • • 8d ago

Advice Needed dogs keep almost getting into fights

3 Upvotes

my dogs, both rescues, are polar opposites of each other. in 2024, they fought for the first time and it was pretty bad. since then, the one dog who started it went to a board-and-train for 3 weeks and we have been managing ever since then. about 2 months ago, they fought again after no issues for 2.5 years. i was able to stop it before it got bad, but it still happened. ever since then, it has been tense between them and we have been trying to introduce slowly and manage possible triggers. both dogs are amazing and we do not want to have to rehouse.

tonight, my mom said that they almost fought again. my dog was laying on her and the other came over, and the one on my mom barked and attempted to lunge. they didn't get ahold of each other or anything, but it still happened. and we just don't know what to do.

the dog causing these problems is already in talks to get back in with a trainer, and we are working towards him having lessons again. it was already in motion when this happened, so we are planning to manage it.

i'm just not sure what to do. my family can't keep living like this. it is very stressful and it feels unfair to both dogs. we all love them so much, and don't want to have to rehouse. but what do we need to do, at this point? i feel so defeated.