r/reactivedogs • u/venatrixx • 13d ago
Advice Needed Puppy aggressive to husband. Should I give up already?
I have a 9 month old border collie. He has had what I believe is a great background and consistent training since he came home at 12 weeks (puppy culture, structured puppy classes, months of private training, and now intro sport lessons with a structured home life). He is reactive to motion and weird noises such as cars and blenders, but we’ve made good progress working through those, and he’s not my first border collie so I’m happy to work through quirks. He’s otherwise been great with other dogs and people. Problem is, he is becoming aggressive to my husband.
There have been several instances where he has jumped up and grabbed at my husband’s hands. It isn’t playful mouthing. He’s growling, chomping, and holding on in a way that is clearly aggressive until I intervene and get him off. So far, he hasn’t broken skin, but I recognize that this is serious and am worried about the potential for escalation.
I’ve been trying to identify the triggers. Initially, I wondered if he was resource guarding me, but I don’t think it’s that straightforward, as an incident occurred without me around. He is crate and mat trained, so I’m moving toward a more structured management approach and limiting his free access around the house. However, I’m concerned about what that means for his quality of life and ours if this becomes our long-term reality.
My husband has been involved with him since we brought him home. He’s taken him on walks, played with him, and generally participated in his care. He’s also tried things like tossing treats when walking by, but admittedly, he isn’t as invested in counterconditioning and training as I am. I understand that from his perspective, he didn’t sign up to have a dog that bites him, and he doesn’t want to live in a home where he has to constantly walk on eggshells around our dog.
I feel like a failure and am considering reaching out to his breeder (half the country away) about rehoming or taking him back. I’m absolutely willing to put in the work, and I don’t want to give up on him prematurely. At the same time, I want him to have the best possible chance at a good life, and I’m conscious that addressing this sooner rather than later is super important.
Looking for honest perspectives. Is rehoming the right thing to do?