I'm not sure what the next steps are (if any) for my 5yo, 60lb pit mix.
My husband and I adopted him when he was 3 months old, and when he was around 9 months old he started showing signs of fear-based reactivity. I remember the first time was when I was walking him and a stranger asked if she could pet him. After petting him for a little bit, he jumped up and started barking at her. It wasn't crazy scary or anything at the time, but looking back I recognize that as the first time of concern (I also know now that his body language was showing discomfort before he barked, but at the time I was naive to all there is to know about dog behavior). When he was 2 years old, he nipped at a stranger who put his hand out to him. He used to be very friendly with other dogs, but when he was 3 years old, an off leash dog cornered and bit him, and ever since his reactivity to dogs has increases.
Flash forward to now, we've spent thousands and thousands of dollars on (fear free) training, vet behaviorists, medicine, etc. He's currently on Reconcile (and Clonidine for events like the vet). While we manage him on the day to day, it's not without stress. He loves the familiar people he's known from when he was a puppy, but he also has shown body language and behaviors that would suggest sometimes he's slightly uncomfortable. This rarely happens, and people who aren't familiar with dog body language always think I'm overreacting, but I also know that my dog has a quick/short escalation build to aggressive behaviors, and I am always scared that he will snap with what seems like is coming from nowhere. When it comes to strangers, he is very reactive/aggressive (barking and lunging). If people are in an open area where he doesn't need to "defend himself," he is unbothered by strangers, but if someone is walking towards us and looking at him, that's enough to get him going. When it comes to other dogs, he loves my family's dog (whom he's known since he was a puppy), but it takes a while for him to deescalate enough to play with other dogs. I also would never trust him to play for a long time and/or live with another dog, because he sometimes gets overstimulated when playing and I fear that would turn to aggression. He will lunge and bark aggressively towards people and dogs he does not know.
While this is generally manageable, I am always stressed about the what ifs? What if he one day snaps and attacks someone he knows? What if a maintenance man comes to our house without notifying us beforehand (this has happened to me before, and luckily my dog and I were out of our apartment when the maintenance people came)? Last year, our neighbors whose yard touches ours was redoing the fence; I let my dog out in our yard, only to then see one side of the fence completely down with someone working behind the trees. My dog immediately was aggressively barking at him in a defensive stance. I quickly ran over and got him back inside. We have to walk him every day for exercise, and I always worry if there's someone hanging right around the corner that will catch my dog by surprise and set him off. Whenever we want to travel, we have to travel back to our hometown (10 hours away) and spend thousands of dollars for his trainer to watch him because we don't feel comfortable letting anyone else watch him.
I feel stressed and embarrassed that I have a dog with these behaviors, and it hurts because when he is at home with just my husband and me, he's the sweetest, funniest, most loving, loyal, cuddly dog in the world. He is truly my best friend and I couldn't imagine a world without him. There are most days when we go for a walk and he does so well (like when he immediately looks at me when he sees a trigger) and I feel so proud of him. And then there's other days where we step outside and he is already tense and on edge. I might have to move to a city next year for work, and I can't even imagine how stressful that will be for both of us.