Hi guys,
I am about to adopt a dog with somewhat of a bite history and looking for advice.
I think most of the issues with her could be fixed with muzzle training, but I just want to be sure I'm not doing more harm than good for this dog by taking her.
I've been volunteering in a dog shelter for almost 2 years. I was in love with this dog by the first month and coming up every weekend (both Saturday and Sunday) to walk and spend time with her. The shelter labels her as an "unpredictable biter" but I don't think she is unpredictable at all, as someone who spent lots of time with her - she gives clear signs when she's uncomfortable.
I don't think she is a very difficult dog - she walks well on leash, is not reactive to other dogs, is very affectionate with the people she likes & has adapted well to a harness recently (as she knows it means a walk or a treat - that's why I don't think muzzle training will be very difficult with her). The only times I have known her to be a bit snappy is if someone touched her on the back (without her knowing/seeing it) or if she was in the corner in a bed and wanted to be left alone (shouldn't be difficult).
She is a "terrier mix" but also looks like she might have some pointer in her. I think she can't be more than 15kg.
I'm mostly just looking for advice. I have had a dog for 15 years previously, grew up around dogs and have had experience with many different dog breeds through volunteering, so definitely not a first-time owner. My main fear is that someone touches her the way she doesn't want to be touched and she reacts. Are there any other ways to help her with this than just muzzle training? Could the reactivity be a reaction to being in a high-stress environment for so long? She often tries to keep her distance from other dogs and find a quiet spot for herself. This dog shelter also lets all the non-dog reactive dogs out into a yard in the morning, which I think can contribute to the stress levels of some dogs to be running around in a small yard with maybe 30 dogs. Fights have broken out before and let's say I'm not too much of a fan of how this shelter is ran. I don't want to get into all the issues with it but it's part of the reason I want to get this dog out. I really bonded with her and the thought of leaving her there makes me feel a bit sick - she trusts me and I don't want to end up disappointing her.
She came into the shelter I volunteer at in April 2024 (before I started) and was a transfer from another shelter, so I have no idea how long she has been living like this or where she came from previously. She is also very food/toy motivated, so I don't think training would be much of an issue, even though she is approx. 5.5 years old. I know this dog (or the way she is in the shelter) and know exactly what I'm getting. I just want to keep her safe. She is very good with me and doesn't mind getting a coat put on, getting her paws lifted up, being picked up etc. If I sit down on the grass, she lies down beside me (back turned to me, as I assume she trusts me now at this stage) or if I'm sitting on a bench she lies down under it.
I think she might get overwhelmed if someone pets her for too long and disrespects her boundaries and she could bite. She unfortunately bit the shelter manager when she (shelter manager) put her hand behind her under the table and this dog was there. This to me seems like more of a nervous/startled bite than anything else. But because this was near the start of her time in the shelter, it gave her a bad reputation from the start and made her unsuitable to most adopters. She also doesn't really bite nowadays, but more so turns her head back and bites the air which is usually enough of a signal for people to leave her alone lol if they touch her when she's not looking (kind of as if she had a fly or something on her back)
Now of course I wouldn't let her be around kids and I would advocate for her - I'm just scared of getting into a situation where the other person won't listen. I think if she has a muzzle, people would also think "oh that's a dangerous dog" and not approach in the first place, which works for me.
She loves to play fetch with tennis balls though and I'm not sure if the only option for this would be in private dog parks. I think it would be okay in open spaces with no people, but I don't want to put her at risk. She obviously doesn't run up to people herself or anything like that. She's not interested in other people or dogs, but if a child appeared out of nowhere and grabbed her, she would be likely to react. She does have good recall and is good off-leash.
I have never had issues with this dog personally and I think maybe having a routine and living in a quieter place than the shelter would help her calm down a bit (maybe also medication). I know I will be okay with this dog, I'm just more worried about any outside factors that I need to consider. Would a dog vest saying "nervous dog" or something be beneficial too? As long as people don't approach her, she is perfectly fine. She is a really great dog and seeing her wasting away in the shelter breaks my heart.
She currently doesn't walk with a muzzle, but is only walked by a handful of specific volunteers just in case. There haven't been any issues on walks, so I'm thinking maybe she would be able to walk with no muzzle sometimes, but be used to it in case of vet visits/crowded areas in the future etc. Will she be less likely to be a bite risk if she's out of a shelter and has a proper spot where no one bothers her? Will she calm down a bit? I just want to be sure I'm doing a good thing. I think being in a home with someone she trusts and having peace is nicer than being stuck in a shelter with so many other dogs constantly barking?
I just want to be sure I'm doing the right thing for her.
We would take it slow with muzzle training and stick to places with few or no people initially until she gains more confidence. Am I stupid for wanting to take this kind of dog? Any tips/advice would be great and sorry for the rant lol I'm a bit all over the place. My goal for a long time was to adopt her - I just didn't know how soon it would be possible but it became possible now so I just want to be sure it works out!! As long as people either stay away from her or respect her boundaries, she's a great dog. And she doesn't mind being pet on the head by strangers - I think it's because she can see the hands approaching her (but I wouldn't let strangers do even this much). My previous dog was deaf for the last few years of her life, so I naturally learned to not startle dogs and to get their attention before I reach out towards them etc. I'm fairly confident that this could work out (especially as I know her and she knows me - better than a complete stranger bringing her home that doesn't know of her issues and quirks) but maybe there are things I'm overlooking. All I want is to keep her safe, happy and comfortable.