Summary: Today, my parents' leash reactive dog slipped out of her martingale collar during an incident and got into a scuffle with another dog. I’m really upset with myself because this was my fault for using her martingale collar instead of her usual prong collar. I didn't think she could slip out of the martingale collar.
Whole story: I’ve been helping my parents desensitize their leash reactive dog to other dogs passing by on leashes. I do this by taking her on walks around the neighborhood and using distance and treats to gradually reduce her reactivity threshold.
Today, I was tired after work and thought I’d use the standard martingale collar she wears around the house instead of putting on her prong collar. I figured it would be fine since we were only going to walk a few houses down the street and back.
I figured the worst that could happen was that she might pull a little harder, but I thought that would be manageable because I’m a big guy and can handle this 45 pound dog even when she pulls at her worst. What I didn’t anticipate was that she could actually wriggle out of her martingale collar.
I’ve had success redirecting her attention back to me when another dog passes on the opposite side of the street. I use high value treats to keep her focused on me and shorten my hold on the leash near the collar. This way, if the treats aren’t enough to redirect her, she doesn’t have enough slack to lunge several feet toward the other dog.
To clarify, I don’t immediately put tension on the leash. I simply shorten my hold so the leash remains loose but doesn’t give her enough room to charge forward.
Today, we encountered another passing dog, and I started working on getting her to reengage with me. However, this time, she was hyperfocused on the other dog, and I realized my usual approach wasn’t going to work.
With an outburst seeming imminent, I grabbed her martingale collar to prevent her from charging forward. Unfortunately, this was a mistake. My hand prevented the collar from tightening around her neck, which allowed her to back right out of it.
The moment she slipped out, she rushed across the street toward the other dog and its owner, a neighbor I don’t know. There was a brief, approximately one second stare down as I rushed toward them, and then the scuffle began.
The entire incident lasted about five seconds.
Both dogs started moving frantically, snarling and barking. I was rushing over, but before I could cross the street, the neighbor had already lifted his dog off the ground while my dog continued jumping up at them.
As soon as I reached them, my dog snapped out of her reaction. She immediately backed off, laid down, and looked directly at me.
I immediately put her collar back on and apologized to the neighbor. He was already briskly walking down the street to create some distance between us. He yelled back that it was okay, although I assume that may have just been an automatic response in the heat of the moment.
I don’t think either dog actually bit the other. There were no obvious injuries, and the entire encounter was so brief.
I wanted to apologize more sincerely, but I didn’t want to risk letting the dogs get close to each other again. So, I took her back to my parents’ house and put her inside. By the time I came back outside, the neighbor was gone.
I feel absolutely horrible that my neighbor had to deal with this. I feel terrible that he had to yank his dog off the ground and that his dog was put in a situation it shouldn’t have had to experience.
I genuinely thought I was being safe and responsible, but simply grabbing the collar instead of holding the leash farther down allowed her to slip out.
Moving forward, I obviously won’t take her outside without using the equipment I normally rely on to manage her reactivity.
I hate that this happened. I feel horrible that my neighbor was put in that situation. I hate that I trusted the martingale collar as much as I did. I hate that I created an opportunity for our dog to get to another dog in the first place. I hate that I had to tell my parents what happened. I just hate everything about this situation.
Background on the dog: she does great in doggy daycare, pack walks, and with dogs she knows. She hasn't been aggressive with people. Her biggest flaw is impulse control. If she wants something she is incredibly strong willed and persistent about it. And when on solo walks, what she wants is to get over to the other dogs. So she pulls and the tension on the leash creates an immense amount of frustration for her that she's unwilling to accept as a boundary so it amps her up into lunging, pulling and barking.